Premium Essay

All Animals Are Equal

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By jtrotter329
Words 966
Pages 4
All Animals Are Equal
PHI103

I chose to do my argument over “All Animals Are Equal” by P. Singer. After reading this argument I have concluded that it is trying to take serious discrimination issues with humans and comparing them to discrimination issues with nonhumans (animals). The information begins by talking about all the discrimination issues we have faced and are facing as a country and how we have began to fight for equality. It states “We became familiar with liberation moverments for Spanish-Americans, gay people, and a variety of other minorities” (P. Singer, 1989).
Liberation movements changed the way society viewed discrimination and how we equally treat “minorities.” A liberation movement demands an expansion of our moral horizons and an extension or reinterpretation of the basic moral principle of equality. And it’s sad to say, but if we wish to avoid being numbered amongst the oppressors, we must be prepared to re-think even our most fundamental attitudes. As P. Singer states, “I am urging that we extend to other species (animals) the basic principle of equality that most of us recognize should be extended to all members of our own species” (1989).
Singer then focus’ on women’s rights and how fighting for women’s rights isn’t sound. He goes on to make the claim “if women’s rights are sound when applied to women, why should the argument not be applied to dogs, cats, and horses?” (P. Singer, 1989). One way which we might reply to this argument is by saying that the case for equality between men and women cannot validly be extended to nonhuman animals. It might be said men and women are similar beings and should have equal rights, while humans and nonhumans are different and should not have equal rights.
“The basic principle of equality, I shall argue, is equality of consideration: and equal consideration for different beings may lead…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Are Animals Equal to Humans?

...Women, Animals, Nature Third Writing Assignment Are animals equal to humans? Humans are the most successful evolutionary animals known to ever exist to this day. There are endless accomplishments of man; from learning to start a fire to survive the cold, to the ability to hunt game for food, to the discovery of the vaccine, to the invention of incredibly fast transportation, to the fabrication of Wi-Fi, to the ability to connect to others around the world with a simple device called the iPhone. Without doubt, no other species has come to rival our intelligence and ability to progress and adapt to new environments. The value of a human life is so extraordinary because of the potential of the human intellect. Furthermore, it is because our extensive spectrum of emotions including the ability to empathize for others. This is the ultimate evidence of the greatness of man. Yet the question remains: is it wrong to choose a baby’s life over the life of an animal? Undeniably, animals are not equal to humans however, this doesn’t justify the horrors of animal cruelty that go on in today’s world. In evolutionary terms, we are biologically programmed to choose human life over a life of another species. If we didn’t follow this instinct we never would have been able to evolve. None of the above accomplishments would ever have happened. Likewise, animals that are intelligent don’t consider themselves equal to humans. They also don’t consider their own species above humans. All......

Words: 709 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Animal

...Animal IntelligenceAnimals are smarter than people think they are. As animal studies keep on increasing, we find out that some animals are close to our level of thinking. Animals such as chimps, parrots, elephants, dolphins and monkeys have been studied and proved to us that they too have a good level of intelligence. Self recognition, social skills, language skills and the use of tools are all signs that scientist use to prove that these animals have a good capacity of smarts in their brain.Many people may think that only humans have the ability to recognize themselves or to be recognized. But the study of two animals has turned that statement to something new. In one study, an elephant was looking at its own appearance and saw some dirt on its face, and with its trunk it tried to take the smudges off its face. (Braden) Another study was done on bottlenose dolphins; to show that they too, have self recognition .Researchers took markers and started to draw on them. Some dolphins had black marks and some did not acquire any marks, but they all felt something touch their body and were eager to see themselves in the mirror. ( DeSeve) To have self recognition shows intelligence. The studies done on these animals show that they are aware of themselves and to be conscious of your self shows a great amount of intelligence.The social skills of animals are very similar to human social skills. Two studies were conducted on chimps to see if they had emotional ......

Words: 257 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Animals

...Respecting All Animals: There’s No Difference x x Prof. x x Respecting All Animals: There’s No Difference The majority of people in this world consider animals just creatures put here on earth to serve a purpose, even more so-most react to their slaughter ,simply with a shrug of the shoulder, unimportant, and more commonly “a way of life” Many consider living conditions that would not be suitable for a person, to be suitable for a living animal. These animals are subjected to heinous conditions and treatment, supposedly for good reason. Of course, it seems to be a common principle amongst certain people to think that animals are not capable of possessing feelings, so maybe this is why the cruelty seems tolerated? As once acknowledged by René Descartes in Understanding Philosophy, regarded animals as “simply physical bodies that lacked minds or souls; thus, animals were similar to organic machines.” (Mosser, 2014, chap. 6.4) I will be analyzing how each of these issues contributes to the unethical and disrespectful treatment of our fellow animals and why we should no longer tolerate it. First off, the most important thing to point out is the fact that animals are used for many things, in constant disregard for their feelings I might add. Just like the previously mentioned living conditions- animals are subjected to the most inhumane practices that would not ever be suitable for the treatment of people. I suppose this is the exact reasoning behind the......

Words: 1055 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Equal Pay for Equal Work

...American culture expected women to preserve the family values not become “money makers” or head of the household. Women were unable to enter the workforce, vote, or get an education until the 19th century and even after they had received rights their rights were not equal to a mans. Institutions refused to allow women in educational programs and since they were economically dependent upon men, women had a poor socioeconomic status. Until the World Wars, that demanded women’s help in all areas of the labor market did society start to accept women as more than Susie-Home-Makers. The role of women drastically changed after the World Wars yet pay for women remained unequal to that of men, this led to the equal rights movement were women demanded “equal pay for equal work” (4). Working women ranked equal pay as a top priority for Congress in 2001 and the issue reemerged under President Barack Obama when he signed an amendment to the Fair Pay Act last year. The consequences of not acting on this important issue is plummeting tax revenues and further widened income inequality during an already starving US economy. Personal income taxes, child care taxes, earned income tax credits, payroll taxes, and state and local taxes all have aspects that affect the majority of women. Most of the tax system was drafted during the 1930s, 1940s, and 1950s when most women were not in the workforce. Women’s Contribution to Labor In the 19th century primarily women’s work was “duties around......

Words: 1556 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Arent We All Equal?

...Natalie Peguero English 112 Section 45 Prof. Mayers November 20, 2013 Aren’t we all equal? One of the most controversial topics today in America is immigration. Should they be deported? Or should they be given a chance for a better future? Immigrants go through abuse daily, they are treated unequal and as minority. Some immigrants’ are given the chance to work; they work hard but are treated and paid miserably. Even the health care provided to immigrants is sometimes cruel because of where they come from. Undocumented immigrants are abused all the time and because of their illegal crime the mistreatment is thought to be acceptable, but they aren’t the only ones that are being mistreated. Documented immigrants also go through harm of the government and society. Legal immigrants are treated different because of their inability of speaking English, or speaking with an accent. Many Americans’ seem to believe that just because somebody doesn’t speak English as they do, they don’t deserve to be treated as equal. In “Aria: Memoir of a Bilingual Childhood” by Richard Rodriguez you can see how he as child was treated different. Rodriguez being raised in Sacramento, California by Mexican Immigrants had difficulty with the English language and growing up in the society he lived in. Immigrants are mistreated in the daily basis just because of where they come from. They are unequally paid, made fun of, looked down on, treated differently and even those services that should be...

Words: 740 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Not All Companies Are Values Equal

...Ethical Obligation of Tobacco Industry towards Consumers Ethics play very important and crucial role in the making an industry a failure or success. Some industries are now trying to create some ethical laws for their further practices. This is very important for industries which sell consumer products that are harmful for the consumers for example Tobacco industry. Like any other industry, Tobacco Industry also has an ethical obligation to its consumers. It is well known that satisfaction of the consumer is the essence of every industry. But besides profitability, every industry has an obligation towards the health and well being of the consumers and is also obliged to delivering quality products and services in that adhere to international code of conducts. In most cases, the production, processing and packaging is at the discretion of the producer in the industry. In many cases, there is information gap between the producer and the consumer thus exposing the latter to the unilateral decision making by producers in the market (Fox, 2015). In a free-economy, forces of demand and supply determines the prices of products and services, industries has to capitalize on strategies like quality of products and services to survive and outsmart competition and increase their competitive advantage in the market. The platform of Tobacco industry is monopolistic platform. Only basis for the success of any company is the customer satisfaction in the industry. Apart from......

Words: 591 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Not All Companies Are Viewed as Equal

...Not All Companies Are Viewed As Equal Strayer University Being a supporter of free trade, market, and capitalism I believe that soda companies are being unfairly targeted doing this time in which American is at war with obesity. There’s nothing wrong with the products from the large soda companies PepsiCo and Coca-Cola. They are responsible companies that are making a product that consumers demand. One reason I am defending the sodas companies is because I feel they are barring to much of the blame for our country obesity problem There is no doubt that drinking sodas irresponsibly can cause weight gain, but treating it as the sole cause of obesity and disease is unfair and want solve our health problems. Many Americans who over indulge in sodas also have diets that consists of foods with low nutritionally values. Also foods that we consider healthy play a factor in America obesity issues, Cardiologist and author Dr. William Davis state that two slices of whole grain wheat bread have the same impact on blood sugar as a can of soda. In no way am I saying sodas are great for diet or your health, but I believe soda companies are being demonized for America obesity problem. When there are other unhealthy products on the market that are not being held accountable for their contribution to America obesity and health situations. Also we has American need to evaluate all factors of the obesity epidemic and just don’t attach yourself to the most popular campaign which at the......

Words: 658 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Not All Companies Are Viewed as Equal

...chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Smoking is considered to be the leading cause of preventable deaths in the US. It is responsible for about 480,000 deaths, including 41,000 deaths resulting from secondhand smoke. According to the CDC, the United States spends $300 billion a year on smoking-related costs to include medical care, lost productivity, and premature deaths. By now we are all well aware of the harmful effects that smoking and other use of tobacco products have on use, but according to the CDC 3,200 people under the age of 18 smoked their first cigarette today. Choosing to smoke is a personal choose that affects many. If an employer is required to pay a higher insurance premium for those employees that smoke, who should be required to pay? Who should be responsible for children that develop respiratory problems such as bronchitis or pneumonia from secondhand smoke? With so many people affected by smoking I think it is well with the right an employer and even the government to regulate its use, or even penalize those who make the choice to smoke. With all the harm that smoking and other tobacco usage does, some may wonder how and why it is still around. For starters, 2010 the combined profits of the six leading tobacco companies in the U.S. was 35.1 billion dollars. With a product that kills so many of its customers, your only concern in this industry is to increase sales and make a profit. Definitely in the tobacco industry and most others, it......

Words: 594 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Equal

...Equal Have ever consider a world so huge and immeasurable can be so unjust. I mean Problems of the past still affect the future. Women have always been the scape goat in term of blame or in adequate of men. This shape power that if women were to have a good or great idea it would be dismissive In the following are some topics that regard gender and some refers from "killing us softly 4"from Jean Kilbourne. She talks about adverting ads that sexually women and make or trying to turn them in to object rather than a human being. I saw an old navy commercial about woman in pants by presence them in different size and made look appeal to the male audience. One can say that we live in a male dominate socially. I'm not trying to sound sexist but it is true. From history has told from the begin regard of era that woman were in to be homemaker and servants. In the world women working side by side with can make a difference but inequity such as wages, treatment, and having a say. Today people are define by sociality by gender and how they are act towards one another. First ads affect people perceptive on how to live and want to do. A quote from Kilbourne “saying that don't look like there prefect but are made from four different woman's parts”. In most to all advertisement woman look at these ads and fell insecure and try to imitate that way they look. To them an out ward appearance is a primary feature that is important to maintain “prefect” image they are going for. One of the...

Words: 1910 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Equal

...their families come from diverse environments. All families have needs that arise from their social and economic, race and cultural or religious backgrounds. Children grow up in different family situations that include two or one parent families; some children have two parents of the same sex. Some children have close links with grandparents, uncles, aunts and cousins while others may be more separated from close kin or may live with other relatives or adoptive carers. Some children have needs that arise from disability or deficiency or may have progenitors that have an incapacity. Some children come from classes who experience social rejection or severe poverty; some have to face discrimination and racism because of their ethnicity, the languages they speak, their religious or beliefs, their gender or their deficiency. These factors influence the well-being of children and can have and influence on their development. For these reasons, the early years setting ensure by a policy of equal opportunities a change for children fulfil their potential (MCI, undated a). As mentioned in the article 29 of The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC, 2008) “Education should develop each child’s personality and talents to the full.” The Early Years Foundation Stage (EYFS, 2012) sets the principles for the early years providers in England. Moreover, it defined equal opportunities as a promotion of equal access to education for all children, a non-discriminatory approach to......

Words: 283 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

All Animals

...All Animals Are Equal PETER SINGER In TOM REGAN & PETER SINGER (eds.), Animal Rights and Human Obligations. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, 1989, pp. 148-162 Available freely online at: http://www.animal-rights-library.com/texts-m/singer02.htm. In recent years a number of oppressed groups have campaigned vigorously for equality. The classic instance is the Black Liberation movement, which demands an end to the prejudice and discrimination that has made blacks second-class citizens. The immediate appeal of the black liberation movement and its initial, if limited, success made it a model for other oppressed groups to follow. We became familiar with liberation movements for Spanish-Americans, gay people, and a variety of other minorities. When a majority group— women—began their campaign, some thought we had come to the end of the road. Discrimination on the basis of sex, it has been said, is the last universally accepted form of discrimination, practiced without secrecy or pretense even in those liberal circles that have long prided themselves on their freedom from prejudice against racial minorities. One should always be wary of talking of "the last remaining form of discrimination." If we have learnt anything from the liberation movements, we should have learnt how difficult it is to be aware of latent prejudice in our attitudes to particular groups until this prejudice is forcefully pointed out. A liberation movement demands an expansion of our moral horizons......

Words: 7140 - Pages: 29

Free Essay

All Animals Are Equal

...All Animals are Equal The argument I’ll be addressing today is to decide if “All Animals are Equal” by Pete Singer. Singer’s essay “All Animals are Equal,” develops an emotional debate for how we view or treat animals as humans (Singer, P. 1989). He also stirs up an argument regarding the equal treatment of animals and the equality with how we treat human beings as a whole. “Singer calls for the beginning of a “liberation movement” similar to those that were sprouting up during the period in which he wrote his essay and focused on such issues as gay, women’s and African-American rights.” There has been a lot of media coverage of an American dentist whole killed a lion in another country, while ignoring some senseless killings in our own country. Has the time come for us as human beings, beginning to respect the rights of animal’s verses our own kind? Will we continue to enjoy that nice steak dinner, hamburger, or thanksgiving turkey? Is it fair to say the sport we call hunting, is inhumane as abortion, the death penalty, or sending our defenders of this country to war for some people? Could his message be subliminal in this essay by referring those animal to human beings that endured struggle? Are we born into this world to be vegetarians due to our teeth structure and development of our body composition? We very well be but that decision should be left to the individual to decide. Pete’s utilitarian direction, due to the theory of an animal that suffers, should be...

Words: 1250 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Not All Companies Are View as Equal

...Not All Companies Are Viewed as Equal Sidia Vasquez Strayer University BUS 309 Not All Companies Are Viewed As Equal In Free trade, the public views on a particular industry depending on the products brought to the market. The ability of the firm to understand the consumer needs and expectations will attract more attention than other industry (Shaw 2014). Each industry plays a vital role in one way or another in making the life of the public better or worse but what differentiates between them is the market expectations. It is entirely ethical to consider one company less important than the other if the reasons are objective. Issues like the tobacco industry help businesses earn favor from consumers but at the same time it help destroy their own lives. Industries are fairly targeted since a socially ethical industry will always attract customers even though the products or services are not quite essential in life. Not all industries are viewed equally, as some industries happen to be harmful to their consumers. The tobacco industry is one such industry and continues to be a menace to the populace with their addictive products on to which people get hooked and have difficulty getting off it. Even though there is argument that the consumer should be held responsible for their decisions, this would not be fair as far as the tobacco industry is concerned. The tobacco industry goes out of their way to entice people into the habit of using tobacco related......

Words: 612 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Not All Companies Are Viewed as Equal

...Not All Companies Are Viewed as Equal Strayer University: BUS309 Business Ethics Week 4 Assignment Not All Companies Are Viewed as Equal Speaking on the side of the consumer, I believe the consumer is responsible for him or herself. If you decide to partake in alcoholic beverages, you have a responsibility to yourself and those around you. We have all heard about drinking and driving. It affects everyone that it touches: the victim, the person responsible and each of the families. If both individuals involved are not killed they could be seriously injured. I support the consumer who decide to drink. It is their choice whether or not to partake in alcohol. As an individual, no other person can force you to drink. You are your own person and like the ad goes, you should do so responsibly. Alcohol can affect us, personality wise, in different ways. For example, some of us may react violently while others may become happier. However, it affects the body itself, the same. “Alcohol is absorbed through the stomach and travels straight to the bloodstream” (www.drugfreeworld.org). It only takes a few minutes to reach your brain. Hence, it affects your brain and slows a person’s actions/ reaction time. With that being said, you have to educate yourself about being responsible when it comes to drinking alcohol. Alcohol education it is good to know the facts, but there is so much more that you need to know. “There is the risk of disease, early death,......

Words: 611 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Animal

...Treatment of Animals in chemical testing Animal testing is an issue in today's society that, whether anyone realizes it, does affect each of us. Such as transplants, vaccines, and medicine. Nearly each and every one of us today have received vaccine shots. We have all used medications. We have all heard of transplant technology. This above example I have used is farfetched. Brain transplants are not an everyday occurrence. They are not yet, at least. However, kidney and heart transplants are beginning to become a more and more common every day. Who knows what is possible with the proper research. Today there are a great deal of people who oppose animal testing in laboratory research. This is limiting our medical capabilities . Could we be holding ourselves back from medical breakthroughs such as a cure for cancer or AIDS? Animal testing is already controlled to a great extent. Many cats and dogs are killed annually by shelters and pounds. Animal testing is not as cruel as it is portrayed and is an essential to reaching medical breakthroughs. Special controls on laboratory animals have been in place since 1876. These have been revised in 1986. These laws are now more commonly known as the revised Animals Act of 1986. This law allows for scientist to perform testing while also safe guarding the animals. Prior to any testing a cost benefit analysis must be applied. In this analysis they review the potential research benefits with the......

Words: 863 - Pages: 4

في التلاجههل تحتاج لوصفات سهلة للطعام ؟ هل تريد اكل... | 6x01 Drunk History | Baseus (1066)