Premium Essay

Are You Man Enough to Be a Nurse? the Impact of Ambivalent Sexism and Role Congruity on Perceptions of Men and Women in Nursing Advertisements

In: Social Issues

Submitted By jklm6655
Words 5390
Pages 22
Sex Roles DOI 10.1007/s11199-014-0418-0


Are You Man Enough to be a Nurse? The Impact of Ambivalent Sexism and Role Congruity on Perceptions of Men and Women in Nursing Advertisements
Kimberley A. Clow & Rosemary Ricciardelli & Wally J. Bartfay

# Springer Science+Business Media New York 2014

Abstract Framed by role congruity and ambivalent sexism, the current study is designed to investigate perceptions of male and female nurses. Specifically, 167 Canadian undergraduates from Southern Ontario viewed a potential nursing recruitment advertisement (female nurse, male nurse, or masculinity emphasized male nurse), reported their perceptions of the nurse in the advertisement, and rated the appropriateness of nursing as a career for men and women. MANOVAs revealed that participants viewed the male nurses more negatively (less competent and more deviant) in the masculinity emphasized condition than the male nurse condition, which is consistent with role congruity theory. Correlations further revealed that men in the male nurse condition and women in the masculinity emphasized condition who were higher in hostile sexism were more likely to rate the depicted male nurse as deviant than their lower scoring peers. Female participants rated nursing as a more appropriate career for men than did male participants, suggesting that resistance toward male nurses may stem primarily from other men. The ambivalent sexism scores of men and women related differently in each condition to ratings of the appropriateness of nursing as a career for men and women, suggesting a complex relationship between sexism and acceptance of male nurses. The findings imply that attempts to challenge current stereotypes by emphasizing the masculinity of men in female
K. A. Clow (*) Faculty of Social Science & Humanities, University of Ontario Institute of Technology, 2000 Simcoe…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Man and a Women

...Since the start of time men and women have been divided into two separate categories. Men have been categorized as the protector and leader of his family. This could be due to a man’s common physical dominance or just the roles a man was taught when growing up. Women on the other hand have been categorized as the caretakers and breeders of their families. Yes, women physical have to breed a child in this world, but do only secondary responsibilities come with this burden. How come throughout the years there hasn’t been a king or even a modern day president who was a women? Perhaps it was the way we were wired through the beginning of time and past generations taught each other’s sex what roles to take in a society. The only thing for certain is knowing that the world is changing everyday when it comes to this issue. Just last election we saw Sen. Hilary Clinton make history by promoting herself in a strong case to be the next president of the United States. So the real question is why are women starting to take roles a man would normally take? The answer is clear and right in front of us with the feminist movement. Now one might be asking themselves what is a feminist? The truth is everyone has a different definition for the word, which bares a different approach. Some cultures may be practicing feministic rights, but could be at an early stage than others. The important thing is that when we say “feminism” we all have the same idea streaming through our minds. That idea......

Words: 1531 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

How Society and Nurses Affect the Roles of Nursing

...How Society and Nurses Affect the Roles of Nursing Lisa A. Turner University of Alabama Birmingham Transitions into Professional Nursing Practice, NUR 474 How Society and Nurses Affect the Roles of Nursing Introduction A nurse has many roles and parts to play in the daily routine of caring for patients. By examining the different roles of a nurse; health promoter, care provider; learner and teacher, we will see how nursing has evolved and how the philosophy of nursing changes. How these roles tie into society and into the symbiotic relationship between society at large and the nursing profession. The shift of healthcare to prevention, education, and the ever changing world of medicine, along with the realization that a nurse’s job is specialized, has tremendously affected the beliefs and ideas of the profession. Based on our textbook, research, and my personal experiences I will explore and clarify my philosophy of nursing. The purpose of this paper is to examine the fact that nursing is an ever-changing profession which society’s ideas and beliefs will impact, whether by necessity or through evolution. Health Promoter and Care Provider Health promotion or prevention is the latest hot topic in the healthcare arena. According 2 to Prochaska, J. and DiClemente, C. (1992), the nursing strategies for health behavior change are Precontemplation, Contemplation, Preparation, Action and Maintenance touch on every different type of nurse and show a need for growth. While......

Words: 966 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Social Perception of Women

...I choose to write about the Social Perception of women in the workplace, because women in the professional industry are overlooked everyday especially when u a woman of different race; It becomes very difficult to gain respect or even promotion in that field. In today’s world women of different race are forced to deal with racism and sexism and they have to tolerate it if they want to keep that job but when does this behavior stop; I mean how long can this women continue to keep silent just because they want to provide for their families and if they fight back they are painted as the aggressor “saying she wanted it” but do a young woman walking an office asking for job, or even walking the office asking to be harassed about her body or been called names wanting it. In order for women to talking seriously in his century they have to act like men, be aggressive like them, make their presence by been hard which sometimes can lead to people calling her names; but as a woman of color I understand that they have no choice but to act that way because that’s the only way anybody in that office will take them seriously. With most women of color today the perception of how they see other women been treated can alter their choices in career, so sometimes they settle for career where they feel more comfortable it may not be the dream career they want, if you take a look at most fortune 500 companies almost all their CEO’s are men it rarely before you see a woman CEO in any company......

Words: 4166 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Sexism Against Men

...Sexism against men in school. Sexism against guys in our society is not taken seriously. Girls can get away with a lot more than guys can now a days. There are things that girls can do and it is acceptable in society that guys cant do. It is unfair to treat guys differently. The way we view sexism against men need to change. It needs to be stopped. Don’t get me wrong, we have come a long way since the eighteen hundreds. Women are able to vote, own property, get jobs, and so forth. I am all for women’s rights and women’s suffrage. Girl power is great. Women are taken seriously now and that’s great. The way we used to treat women was bad. It was a don’t ask don’t tell thing. Like if a man was cheating on his wife or beating his in the early nineteen hundreds people didn’t speak of it. The women was the mans property and he could do whatever he wanted. Now things have changed, laws have been made and enforced. Now its looked down upon to beat your wife and you will go to jail. Now there are all sorts of sexual harassment laws that are mostly enforced for the protection of women. In school the other day, there were some sophomore girls that made up a game. You got a certain amount of points for touching senior guys butts. I think it was forty or fifty points for grabbing or slapping their butt. Then you got twenty for “grazing” a guys butt. If sophomore guys played that game with senior girls, all of us would probably be expelled and charged with sexual harassment. ...

Words: 648 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Sexism in the Media

...Running head: SEXISM IN THE MEDIA 1 Sexism in the Media Ada Anderson Chamberlain College of Nursing/DeVry SOCS 185N: Sociology Feb, 24, 2013 SEXISM IN THE MEDIA 2 Television and commercial advertising have been a dominating force for over sixty years, and people learn to specialize and are trained to create ads that entertain and provoke the viewer into buying certain products. The main purposes of commercials are to stand out from competitors, and to sell an idea or way of life for those who allow themselves to become influenced by the appeal. Women and young girls are often subjected and greatly influenced by these advertisements, and many from an adolescent age will alter and pattern their lives to partially adhere to this televised fantasy. Often, some young girls use these forms of advertisements to psychologically change their views about themselves, and thus, may have an unhealthy attitude towards their body type or status in society. I would hope to analyze the effect that commercials have upon society, and how it can create a prejudice frame of mind through subtitle symbols. Television commercials are an agent of socialization and have been used to persuade the viewer into voting for a certain president, stereotyping a certain ethnic group or race because of comical value, using sex to make a product look appealing, or learning what qualities in a beer is important. Yet, although such trivial information exists in commercials and would......

Words: 1476 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Male Nurses

...forces might have conspired in the murder. (Poison may have been used; bullets may have been fired only as an afterthought; perhaps they were fired by the victim himself, before he died . . .) Yarn can tell us the story only in certain circumstances. As a researcher and a writer, Matthew Gribble analyzes his crime scene with diligence and care. The crisis: The shortage of nurses in America. The question: How and why did this shortage become a persistent problem? Matthew affixes strings of yarn to a number of gunshots: the increasing average age of the workforce, long hours, work that is often menial or clerical, and finally, relatively low salaries. But these strands lead to new questions, wider causes which have nothing to do with social yarn. These new questions have to do with rhetoric and the enduring association of nursing with “women’s work” and “femininity.” Matthew has the audacity to ask how the rhetoric of femininity actually functions. How and why are we compelled to accept images and tropes as ‘normal’ or ‘natural’ when they are anything but normal and natural? Is it possible that the rhetoric of nursing is responsible for the shortage? Or perhaps it is the rhetoric of femininity and masculinity as such? But how did such a crime take place, right under our noses, when so many of us never noticed that an injustice ever took place? This essay is brilliant and provocative because it will not stop until the crime scene has been analyzed to the author’s satisfaction –......

Words: 6796 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Future Impact of Nurses Role

...Future Impact of the Nursing Role Future Impact of the Nursing Role In November of 2010, the Institute of Medicine (IOM) issued a report titled “The Future of Nursing: Leading Change, Advancing Health.” It’s a look at how nurses should change their practice and role in healthcare. The new legislative reforms in the nation are being phased in over the coming years. This reform will expand the scope of the nursing profession and practice. This reform states that: “A number of barriers prevent nurses from being able to respond effectively to rapidly changing health care settings and an evolving health care system. These barriers need to be overcome to ensure that nurses are well-positioned to lead change and advance health (IOM-2010) .“ The Institute of Medicine (IOM) developed four key messages that form the origin for the analysis and endorsements presented. The first three are referring to the nursing role, and these are in summary: 1). Nurses should practice to the entire extent of their training and education. 2). Nurses should strive for higher levels of education and training, through a quicker more user friendly educational system that promotes seamless progression from one degree to another higher degree. 3). Nurses should be considered equal colleagues with physicians and other health care professionals, when remodeling health care in the United States. What is the impact on nursing practice...

Words: 1018 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...An Analysis of Sexism in English Language [Abstract] Language plays an important role in society. As a phenomenon of society, language reflects all the sides of human society naturally. Sexism is a phenomenon that takes a male-as-norm attitude, trivializing, insulting or rendering women invisible. As a special social phenomenon, sexism is inevitably reflected through language. To start with, the thesis traces the reasons for the occurrence of sexism in the English language. In nature, sexism in language reflects sexism in society. The two are closely related. Social connotations of sexism in English tell the relationship between phenomenon of sexism in language and essence of sexism in society. Then the thesis analyses sexism in terms of the generic masculine, word order and semantic derogation of women in greater detail. Finally, a large part of the thesis is contributed to how to change sexism in English. The author of the thesis thinks the key to the problem is: (1) solve the problem of generic pronouns; (2) neutralize lexis; (3) strive for balanced naming and addressing system; (4) coin new corresponding words. The elimination of linguistic sexism lies in social change. Only by changing the social structure, that is, women and men own really equal status, can language equality be truly achieved. [Key Words] sexism; English language; lexical neutralization; feminism 浅析英语中的性别歧视现象 [摘 要] 语言在社会中所处的地位尤为重要。作为一种社会现象的语言,必然会反映出人类社会的各种社会观念。性别歧视作为这其中的一种,是指把男性视作社会规范和中心,轻视,......

Words: 6428 - Pages: 26

Free Essay

Impact of Women Portrait in Advertisement

...ABSTRACT The aim of the study is to investigate the impact of women portrait in advertising messages on viewing audience. The researcher’s employed the survey method using both primary and secondary sources of data collection. In order to get data for the study, one hundred (100) questionnaires were administered to randomly selected respondents in Federal polytechnic Bauchi. The study found out that women portrait in advertising message has positive impact on the viewers. Also, that women should be allowed to participate in advertising, because they are very attractive, they can quickly draw attention of the viewers. 78% of the respondents which were given questionnaire agreed that women portrait despite the objection by some tradition should be allowed to participate in advertising messages. Findings also revealed that most of the respondents which were surveyed are not sexually active by the women portrait in advertising messages. The study recommends that women portrait in advertising standard should be maintain, because it influence choice of consumers. TABLE OF CONTENTS Title page - - - - - - - - - i Certification - - - - - - - - - ii Approval page - - - - - - - - iii Declaration- - - - - - - - - - iv Dedication - - - - - - - - - v Acknowledgement - - - - - - - - vi Table of contents - - - - - - - - vii Abstract - - - - - - - - - ix CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION 1.1 Introduction- - - - - - - - 1 1.2 Statement of the......

Words: 426 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Men and Women

...Addressing the Issue: Men’s Men and Women’s Women The vast majority of people, with the exception of transvestites and other people with physical deformities, can be put into one of two categories; man or woman. Generally, the views and expectations one has for their own gender and the views and expectations one has for the opposite gender can be described as gendered stereotypes. Although stereotypes are not always close to the truth, in some cases they can hold some weight to an argument when they present the generalized representation of a certain group or groups. In this essay I will show how gendered stereotypes are used by advertising companies to appeal to each gender. Here in the U.S., you need not go far to bear witness the very apparent signs of genderfication and gendered stereotypes, tools used by advertisers that play important roles in our consumer-styled society. One only needs to go as far as their living room couch and turn on the television to be bombarded with shows and advertisements containing gendered images of the expectations our society has for its men and women by men and women. Author Steve Craig puts these gendered ideals into four distinct categories; Men’s men, Men’s women, Women’s men, and Women’s women (Craig). For this essay I will analyze four video advertisements, and, using Craig’s criteria, I will try to see under which of his categories each advertisement would fall and why. The first advertisement I will analyze is a three......

Words: 1274 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Why Are There Not More Male Nurses

...will more than likely be a nursing staff that consists almost entirely of female nurses. However, while waiting to see a physician, you more than likely expect a male doctor to walk into the room. Both health professions deal with nurturing and caring for patients, so why is it that male nurses get such a bad reputation? They make up for 6.6% of the nursing population, an increase from 5.7% from 2006. (Shah) The answer may be found by looking into gender roles, stereotyping, and the history of nursing as a profession. Nursing began with the care of infants and children. Hundreds of years ago, mothers would have been considered to be nurses. However, when diseases started to spread, people soon realized that love and nurturing were not enough to heal the sick. Early practices of nursing can be correlated with the age of Christianity, "modeling its practice after the teachings of Christ, caring for the sick, feeding the hungry and burying the dead. Therefore, during this period the history of nursing is intricately tied to the Church" ("Gonursingschools"). After the crusades, the world was ready for change. One of these changes that took place would have a major impact on the history of modern nursing. The Establishment of an institute in German: "Deaconess Institute at Kaiserswerth, Germany. A small hospital was opened which included a training school for deaconesses. Their training system was a close parallel to the educational system for nurses that we see today.......

Words: 1554 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ambivalent Sexism and Dumb Blonde Jokes

...Ambivalent Sexism and Dumb Blonde Jokes Eryn Haygood Oklahoma State University Diversity can be defined as individuals interacting with different races, nationalities, religions and gender to create a group, organization or community. A diverse organization is an organization that values the variance in people. It identifies that people with different attitudes, backgrounds, experiences, and skills bring in new ideas and opinions. Diverse organization also promotes and join these differences to make everything related and welcoming. These types of organizations have the widest range of views and skills so it can help the need of change for the people who are involved. Diversity encourages and benefits society. In the study of Greenwood and Isbell had three goals that they wanted to complete in their study. The first goal, they wanted to explore a certain sexist joke which are the dumb blonde jokes. These type of jokes are unpleasant to women and extremely known and accepted “form of disparaging humor” (Greenwood et al., 2002). They wanted to know how the reactions of women to these jokes would find out the degree of sexist attitudes. There next goal was to determine the line of sexist humor and ambivalent sexism. The dumb blond jokes may show a result to conflicted heterosexual ambivalence so, hostile and ambivalent sexist might react different to these types of jokes. Hostile sexist may like the jokes more than benevolent sexists and with ambivalent sexist may more......

Words: 1587 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Medieval Cociety Roles of Women and Men

...Reversing the Roles of Medieval Women Throughout the Medieval period women were forced to take background roles in society. They were considered inferior to men and reduced to roles that were limited to motherly figures and skilled work. Unlike men, they were not allowed to take arms and once married their ownership was passed on to men. In Beowulf, whose author is unknown, and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight by Geoffrey Chaucer, women took more active roles in the lives of them than society allowed them. In Beowulf, Grendel’s mother is portrayed as a monstrous woman who attacks men to avenge the death of her son Grendel. In Sir Gawain and the Green Knight Lady Bertilak and Morgan le Faye diminish the roles of men proving them to be cowards that don’t live up to the standards of powerful men. These women proved to be exceptions to the ideal medieval woman who were ultimately separate from men. Women play a minor role Beowulf, Grendel’s mother plays a significant role as she is known as just that, Grendel’s mother. She is not given a name as other women in the poem although she comes in direct contact with the poem’s main character, Beowulf. As a descendent of Cain, she invades Heorot to avenge the death of her son Grendel, who is killed by Beowulf to save their civilization. Throughout medieval literature women play background roles as mothers, caregivers, and peacemakers; they were not allowed to take arms but were reduced to their roles as women. The role that......

Words: 1037 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Reducing Sexism: Equality Between Men and Woman

...Reducing Sexism: Equality Between Men and Woman November 2015 Introduction Reducing Sexism –Equality Between Men And Woman * #YesAllWomen! Tweets with key words like “gender” and “violence” reveal that equality between men and women is on the minds of many Americans. An inspiring 1,936,516 tweets put this subject in eighth place within the 10 social issues Americans talk the most about on Twitter (Dwyer, 2014). * Average earnings of men almost always exceed the earnings of women in the exact same occupation (Buckley, 2001). According to Statistics Canada, based on data collected from men and women aged 16 and over, men make an average of $68 500, whereas women make an average of only $45,500. Men employment rates are also significantly higher than women (Statistics Canada, 2009). * Sexual violence is a problem for college communities. The National College Women Sexual Victimization study estimates that one in five college women experience completed or attempted rape during their college years. (Fisher, Cullen, & Turner, 2000). Women have always faced significant challenges throughout their lives due to inequality between men and women. Stereotyping, lack of opportunity, pay differences, sexual harassment, gender-based violence and discrimination represent some of these challenges, which ultimately is disempowering women. This disempowerment has numerous consequences for society today. Times have changed and although unlike in the......

Words: 2988 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

The Roles of Women and Man

...4/2/2011 The Roles of Women and Men For many years women were looked down upon by society. This all started to change when women started to get rights in the mid twentieth century. Even though they had rights they were still not treated equally by society. Men have always been seen by society as being the providers of a family. They often are workaholics who provide for the family and have very little time for their children. Women on the other hand are seen as the care givers and care for he children. They are usually depended on their husbands for physical and monetary needs for the family. In “I Want a Wife” Judy Brady talks about being a wife, and how she would like to have a wife that portrays the role of a husband in the family. She is arguing about expectations that men have towards women and marriage. In addition Brady writher how easy men have it, according to her men’s only responsibility in marriage is to be a provide. One the contrary, Ellen Goodman in “the company Man” argues that it isn’t easy to be a provider in the family. She supports that opinion with an example of a fifty-one year old men called Phil who worked himself to the death. Gender roles have been quite significant and important throughout the history, however now due to the harsh capitalistic society that we live in they are fading away. While Phil was a hard worker for his family, in “I Want a Wife” Judy Brady is portrayed as being a women who wants to become like Phil. She wants a wife that...

Words: 675 - Pages: 3

あかあおきり実況プレイ | West Wind Web Surge 1.0 | The Awakening 2011 LIMITED 1080p Bluray x264 MAXHD