Free Essay

Asses the View That Working Class Children Underachieve Because They Are Culturally Deprived

In: Social Issues

Submitted By AmyPownall
Words 843
Pages 4
Asses The View That Working Class Children Underachieve Because They Are Culturally Deprived

There are many cultural deficiencies often associated with a child’s potential and achievement in education. Cultural deprivation is a theory that many working-class children are inadequately socialised from a young age, and therefore lack the “correct” culture appropriate for a successful education.

Cultural deprivation theorists agree that humans acquire basic attitudes and values needed for education through primary socialisation in the family. However, many working class families do this inadequately, therefore their children become culturally deprived. There are three main aspects of cultural deprivation: intellectual development- which refers to the development of thinking and reasoning skills eg solving problems. Traditional Marxists believe that working class families lack educational books and toys that stimulate a child’s intellectual development, as they cannot afford them. Therefore children start school without the skills allowing them to progress. Douglas found that working class children scored lower than middle class children in intellectual tests. Bernstein and Douglas found that middle class mothers are more likely to buy educational toys to encourage their child’s learning from an early age; to assist the development of their thinking and reasoning skills, thus giving them a steady start and more likely to lead to educational success.

Engelmen and Bereiter claim that language used by working-class families is deficient. As a result, the fail to develop the necessary language skills and grow up incapable of abstract thinking. Bernstein identified two types of language, the restricted code and the elaborate code, which he claims to be partly responsible for the underachievement of working-class children. The restricted code is used by the working-class and includes a lot of hand gestures, grammatically incorrect sentences and restricted vocabulary. Their speech is descriptive and context bound, whilst assuming the listener understands the topic of their conversation. The elaborated code is used by the middle-class and includes good vocabulary, grammatically correct and complex sentences, which are not context bound. This gives working-class children a disadvantage in school as education is based around the elaborated code. Teachers communicate using the elaborated code, assuming that their pupils understand that style of language. Text books contain complex vocabulary and sentences and exam questions are written in the elaborated code. Therefore the working-class student is unable to understand the information to interpret, and they are unable to understand the question to then answer correctly. Early socialisation of the elaborated code means that middle class students are already fluent users when they begin schools and are more likely to be successful.

Cultural deprivation theorists argue that parent’s attitudes and value are a key factor in underachieving. Feinstein found that working class parents were less ambitious for their children and took little interest in their education. They were unconcerned and have been through the same cycle, so they are unable to help with their child’s homework and lack support. As a result, children had low motivation levels for school and struggled to engage in their learning. Sugarman’s idea of fatalism argues that working class have the idea of “whatever will be will be”. They think they are going to fail within education from the offset, so why bother. Hyman also says that working class families have present time orientation goals, they do things for the now instead of their future. This could lead to underachievement as they only think for what is happening now, and not what will benefit them in the future.

Another factor which affects working class children underachieve is within the home. Housing can affect underachievement directly and indirectly. A direct input is by over-crowding. This affects the child by distractions, making the child having a lack of sleep therefore less focus in school to learn. Furthermore, the distractions can make it difficult for the student to study and finish homework at home, allowing them to fall behind. Housing can affect indirectly by causing health problems. For example, over-crowding can cause accidents. Damp conditions in working-class houses can cause respiratory problems such as asthma. These can lead to multiple hospital visits, which decreases attendance and can again allow the student to fall behind. Lastly, a constant change of accommodation can leave the child feeling a lack of stability and can cause distress. These factors affect the child’s achievement by a lack of concentration, illness and attendance.

Alternatively, another factor that effects underachievement is the cost of education. With increasing use of external equipment needed for education, eg laptops and calculators, and a lack of financial support, working class children have much greater risk of underachieving. This is referred to as “the cost of free schooling” by David Bull (1980).

Although cultural deprivation theorists have provided some evidence for the effects on educational achievement, there are still some criticisms of this approach. Keddie describes cultural deprivation as a myth and a victim blaming explanation. She argues working class families are different, and not deprived, and fail because of biases in educational system which put working class students at a disadvantage.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Using Material from Item and Elsewhere, Asses the Different Marxist View of the Relationship Between Crime and Social Class

...Using material from Item and elsewhere, asses the different Marxist view of the relationship between crime and social class (21marks) Marxist believes that in a capitalist society inequality and exploitation of the working class is inevitable. When assessing the relationship between crime and social class Marxist believe because of this exploitation crime inevitable. However there are two main views to this theory traditional and neo Marxist which believes in the same functions of crime (that is inevitable) however has conflicting views on how this occurs. Traditional Marxist believe capitalist society explains crime in 3 main functions criminogenic capitalism, the state and law making, and the ideological functions of crime. Criminogenic capitalism explains that the working class have no other option but to commit crime this may be because; they live in poverty so have no choice but to commit crime, lack of control over their lives therefore due to frustration commit non ulitarian crime such as vandalism, or Ulitarian crime may be the only way they can obtain goods that are advertised in capitalist culture. Traditional Marxism state it is not only working class that commit crime they state that a capitalist society encourages greed therefore promotes white collar crime such as corporate crime. From this the relationship between crime and social class is fairly equal as they both are victims of a capitalistic society. Gordon explains this as a ration response to the......

Words: 488 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Assess the View That the Working Class Under- Achievement in Education Is the Result of Home Circumstances and Family Background

...Assess the view that the working class under- achievement in education is the result of home circumstances and family background To fully assess the view that the working class under- achievement in education is the result of home circumstances and family background we must look at what is within education such as socialisation. Socialisation helps develop language and communication by talking to others and learning and repeating words they use. A factor affecting education is material deprivation; this is when someone cannot access the right resources needed for education e.g. books and the internet. Howard did research on how diet and health of a child can affect their concentration in school. Income can affect the diet and health of a child, income very big within material deprivation because low income means that you cannot afford fresh vegetables and cook nutritious meals and so their children will be less able to concentrate in class. Other factors of low income include smaller houses and overcrowding which then makes it difficult for children to concentrate if there is a lot of noise or not so much space so they can do their homework. However policies such as EMA and aim higher where put in place, these are forms of compensatory education giving extra help to those who need it. A second factor affecting education is cultural deprivation, this is when people don’t have experiences of middle class norms and values, and so affects education as the middle class are......

Words: 734 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Asses the View That Gender Difference in Achievement Are a Result of Outside the Educational System.

...Asses the view that gender difference in achievement are a result of outside the educational system. The gender difference in achievement in the past and the present portray two different perspectives. In the past boys did better than girls’ bout as times go on due to internal and external factors this has changed as girls are doing better than boys in the current education system. In this essay it will explore how the perception of girls in past were perceived and how external factors has contributed to the change in the gender difference in achievement. In the past girls underachieved in the education system due to the expectation created by wider society in the past. The fact of the matter is that in the past girls ‘feared success’ because they were not encourage to achieve because there was this idea that a girls future laid in domestic labour. Fontana argues that girls had lower self-esteem as it was constantly reinforced in the home and wider society that boys were superior to boys thus causing them to underachieve in the education system. Feminists argue due to early socialisation this idea that they had hardly no control over their own lives were fabricated form the roots. Therefore they were more likely to view their success down to luck and fate whereas boys saw their success was down to their ability. Feminists argue that female s are likely to suffer from material deprivation then males from a very early age which yet again reinforces this inequality within the...

Words: 1624 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Assess the View That the Education System Favours Middle Class Students.

...Assess the view that the education system favours middle class students. Over the past 50 years, sociological research and government statistics have shown time and time again that in general the higher a person’s social class of origin (the class they were born into) the higher their educational qualifications. There are many explanations behind why in general the education system tends to favour middle class students such as cultural capital, to succeed in the education system, students need certain norms and values which middle class students have and working class students lack. May working class students are labelled by teachers and cannot do as well as middle class students. Working class students are sometimes materially deprived where they have a lack of money and all the things money can buy eg; school equipment. All of things which will help them in the long run in the education system. During the 1960s, it was clear that the low educational attainment of working class students was due to material deprivation. Material deprivation is lack of money and all things money can buy such as school equipment, trip money etc.. Other things that come under this factor is also whether the student had a comfortable home life style, enough personal space and studying space, home internet.. all of things which help students perform better in education. They were not only materially deprived but also culturally where they lacked certain attitudes and skills, norms and......

Words: 874 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Using Material for Item a and Elsewhere, Asses the Importance of Cultural Factors in Causing Social Class Differences in Education Achievement.

...Students that are in a working-class have the tendency to underachieve in school, in contrast to those students that are middle-class, this is due to external and internal factors. External cultural factors are claimed to be a key cause of social class differences in educational achievement according to various sociologist. These factors consist of Cultural deprivation, cultural capital and material deprivation. Students from working class backgrounds often experience economic problems (poverty) more so than any other class; this is linked to material deprivation which these pupils are exposed to throughout their time. Being in poverty could entail the students not having enough money to buy all the essential equipment that they will need for educational attainment, supported by sociologist - Bull. This is closely linked to educational under achievement for example in 2006 33% of children on pupil premium (free school meals) achieved 5 A* to C grades in comparison to 61% not on pupil premium. However, statistics cannot prove that material deprivation is the cause of under achievement as the government doesn’t always collect statistics that is supporting the claim 100%, therefore the claim cannot generalise. To support this claim sociologist Flaherty also states that having money problems in the family were a significant factor in younger children’s low attendance at school, which links to under achievements at school. The idea that children from working class......

Words: 1071 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Teaching Culturally Diverse Children

...tyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm Teaching Culturally Diverse Children SOC:312 Child Family, and Society (BFE1322A)Instructor Laura Schutz8/26/2013 Lisa Gatts | Teaching children from culturally diverse backgrounds can be challenging. In the United States today there are many children that have moved here from other countries. It is important that these children are educated properly. It is also important for teachers to learn the appropriate strategies that are effective for challenges that may arise in the classroom so that they are able to meet the needs of these children. Teachers and students should be taught to embrace diversity. Everyone has something to offer as a contribution to the citizens of our country. People from other countries come to the United States and culturally influence our films, music, ideas, art, foods, and our political systems. Teachers and students who learn to work together among culturally diverse groups are better prepared for the ever changing world we live in today, and will also prepare them for the continuously growing future. Teachers should provide a classroom with examples from different cultures such as books, films, and other learning resources so the students can......

Words: 1162 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Assess the View That Social Class Differences in Educational Underachievement’s Are the Result of School Processes Such as Labelling.

...assumptions about their class background. Howard Becker (1971) carried out an important interactionist study of labelling. He carried out interviews with 60 Chicago high school teachers. His findings were that they judged pupils according to how closely they fitted an image of the ‘ideal pupil’. Pupils work, conduct and appearance were key factors influencing teacher’s judgements. Middle class children were seen as the closest to ideal by teachers however lower working class children were seen as furthest away from it because they regarded them as badly behaved. Aaron Cicourel and john Kitsuse’s (1963) study of educational councillors in an American high school shows how such labelling can disadvantage working class students. Cicourel and Kitsuse found inconsistences in the way the councillors assessed students’ suitability for courses. Although they claimed to judge students according to their ability, in practice they judged students largely on the basis of their social class and/or race. Another type of social process that leads to educational underachievement is streaming. Streaming involves separating children into different ability groups or classes called streams. Each ability group is then taught separately from the others, for all subjects. As Becker shows, teachers do not usually see working class children as ideal pupils. They tend to see them as lacking ability and have low expectations of them. As a result, working class children are more......

Words: 2534 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Assess the View That Social Class Differences in Educational Underachievement Are the Result of School Processes Such as Labelling.

...In this essay, the view that social class differences in educational underachievement are the result of school processes such as labelling will be assessed. Internal and external factors will be assessed with the use of researchers such as: Bernstein, Bereiter & Engelmann, Keddie and Howard. Internal factors such as labelling have been shown to effect education achievement. To label someone is to attach a meaning or definition to them. Becker carried out a study on labelling on 60 Chicago high school teachers, and found that they judged pupils according to how closely they fit an image of the ideal pupil. The pupils work, conduct, and appearance were key factors to the teachers’ judgements. Becker found that middle class children were closer to the image of the ideal pupil whereas the working class children were furthest away and seen as badly behaved. Cicourel & Kituse’s study of educational counsellors in an American high school shows how this labelling can disadvantage working class student. They found that the way in which counsellors would assess the student’s suitability for courses. They judged students on the basis of their class and/or race. Where students would have the same grades, they work more likely to label middle class pupils as having college potential and to place them on higher level courses. Rist did a study on an American kindergarten and found that the teachers used information about the children’s home, background and appearance to place......

Words: 3404 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Assess the View That Working Class Children Under-Achieve Because They Are Culturally Deprived

...educational experience. Many suggest that due to working-class children are ‘culturally deprived’ compared to middle class children due to them having more access to things such as classical music, educational holidays or trips and literature. Bourdieu (1984) uses the term cultural capital to refer to the knowledge, attitudes , values , language , tastes and abilities of the middle class. He sees middle-class culture as a type of wealth due to it giving an advantage to the people who possess it. He suggests that through this middle class children acquire the abilities to grasp and analyse abstract ideas which leads to more intellectual interests and a better understanding of what they need to do to succeed. This gives middle-class children an advantage in school where such abilities are and interests are highly valued and rewarded. In contrast, working class children find that their culture is devalued to be ‘rough’ and inferior compared to that of the middle-class. The lack of cultural development in the child leads to exam failure, truanting, early leaving and just generally not trying. Alice Sullivan(2001) used questionnaires to conduct a survey of 465 pupils in 4 schools. To assess their cultural their cultural capital, she asked them about a range of activities, such as reading and TV viewing habits and whether or not they visit art galleries, museums or the theatre. She also tested their vocabulary and knowledge. She found that children who watched documentaries and......

Words: 638 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere, Assess the View That Working Class Children Underachieve Because They Are Culturally Deprived.

...assess the view that working class children underachieve because they are culturally deprived. Do working class children underachieve because they are culturally deprived? Cultural deprivation is the notion that the underachievement of working class children in exams is a result of their home background and parent’s failure to socialize them into the skills and values required for educational success. The three aspects of cultural deprivation are: Intellectual development, Language and Attitudes and Values. One of the aspects of cultural deprivation is Intellectual Development, which is the development of thinking and reasoning. Working class children may be less intellectually developed as their homes may lack books, educational toys and activities that stimulate their intellectual development. Douglas’ study found that working class pupils scored lower on tests of ability that middle class pupils, and due to this he argues that working class parents were less likely to read with their children thus stunting their intellectual growth and development. However, is has been argued by sociologists that cultural deprivation is not the only factor contributing to the underachievement of working class children, and that material deprivation and internal school factors may be just as important, if not more so, than cultural deprivation. The second aspect of cultural deprivation is Language, which is the differences that exist in the language used by the middle class and the......

Words: 933 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Working Class Children

...‘’Assess the view that working class children under-achieve because they are culturally deprived’’ Cultural deprivation theorists argue that most of us are taught the attitudes and skills needed for educational success during primary socialisation. However, there are a percentage of students who do not have cultural capital, and are therefore deprived of what is needed to be successful at school – this percentage, according to cultural deprivation theorists, are working-class. There are three main aspects of cultural deprivation: intellectual development, language, and attitudes and values. Cultural deprivation theorists argue that intellectual development plays a big part in the educational failure of the lower classes. Due to cost constraints, working-class parents are unlikely to buy educational toys which would stimulate their child’s mind, and intellectual development. This stimulation of the mind is vital for when a child begins their educational journey, as many middle-class mothers would say. J.W.B Douglas found that working-class children tend to score less on tests of ability than middle-class students because working-class parents are less likely to support their child’s intellectual development – even by simply reading to them. Bernstein and Young also found that middle-class mothers are more likely to buy toys which encourage thinking and reasoning – skills which are needed for educational success. However, although intellectual development may seem like a......

Words: 1217 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Asses the View That Under-Achievement in Lower Class Is Due to Cultural Deprivation

...the view that working-class children under-achieve because they are culturally deprived Social class is ‘a division of society based on social and economic status’ This hierarchy classifies the working-class as those who are employed for wages generally in skilled labour occupations. The term ‘Cultural Deprivation’ is an external factor outside of the education system in having a negative impact on a child’s success, which generally occurs within working-class families as of reasons which will be further explained in this essay. Those who are culturally deprived tend to have not acquired basic values and skills which are vital for educational success, potentially due lack of economic wealth, poor attitude to the institution of education and an in-adequate upbringing . Several sociologist theorists argue for and against the view ‘under-achievement is caused by cultural deprivation in working-class families‘ as there’s evidence that other factors contribute to educational under-achievement in working class children also. Cultural deprivation comes in three aspects during primary socialisation, including lack of intellectual development, poor language skills and not having the correct attitudes and values to drive them to their success. A working-class family generally can not provide educational toys or books which enable intellectual progression, and therefore their children score lower than middle class children on tests of ability as shown by Douglas (1984).......

Words: 1624 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Social Class Underachievement

...ociologists suggest that working class children are at a disadvantage to the middle class with the education system due to many out of school factors. One out of school factor is Material deprivation where children lack the physical necessities of life, such as adequate housing, diet and health and income. However not all poor children fail, those with supportive parents may have high levels of motivation and that material deprivation also ignores in school factors. Housing could have an affect on a working a child’s performance as there might be inadequate space in their home meaning there isn’t any space for the child to do their homework. Overcrowding in the house could lead to the child not being able to concentrate but it can also affect their sleep. A criticism of this is it may be overcrowded however if there is a lot of siblings they might be able to help one another with homework so this could be a positive. Health and Diet is also another material deprivation, Howard proposed that young people from poorer home have a lower intake of energy, vitamins and minerals. This can affect someone's health by weakening the immune system which can lead to absences from school. However a problem with this is that having a poor diet can happen to anyone including the middle class and also healthy foods tend to be more expensive which some working class people can’t afford. The income of the family can also be a factor of underachievement.......

Words: 661 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Class Differences in Achievement

...Examining class differences in achievement (1) external factors a) Explain briefly what is meant by the term ‘elaborated speech code’. (2 marks) The term ‘elaborated speech code’ refers to the language used by the middle class. It has longer, grammatically correct sentences and a wide vocabulary. It is a varied type of speech and may can communicate abstract ideas, in addition to this it is context free. b) Identify three policies that governments have introduced to compensate for material and cultural disadvantage, apart from education priority areas. (6 marks) Firstly, one policy is Operation Head which is a multi-billion dollar scheme in the USA, its aim was planned enrichment of the deprived child’s environment in order to motivate them and help them to develop learning skills, the well-known television programme Sesame Street was part of Operation Head Start and it provided means of reaching young children and transmitting values and attitudes needed for educational success. Secondly there is the United Kingdom version of Operation Head Start, called Sure Start. Sure Start is a nationwide programme aimed at pre-school children and their parents. However, unlike Operation Head Start it also has non-educational goals, like improving the child’s health. Sure Start promotes physical, intellectual and social development so that they can flourish and be educational successes in the future. Finally, there are EAZs (Education Action Zones) There can be many zones in a......

Words: 1277 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The View That Working Class Children Cultural Deprivation Is the Reason of Their Underachievement Can Be Very Rightly True

...The view that working class children cultural deprivation is the reason of their underachievement can be very rightly true. Cultural deprivation is the lack of certain rules of behavior in social situations, values, belief that something is a worthwhile, attitude and skills these are all of what society calls “normal”. Working class children are less likely to succeed in life because they are less likely to be found in nursery schools, less likely to go to university and more likely to be poor readers when they start school, more likely to be in lower sets and streams in secondary school, more likely to leave school early, more likely to underachieve at GCSEs and a level, more likely to be excluded and suspended. This is because the middle-class culture children are suitably prepared for school, but it's totally reverse for working-class culture; it basically fails to prepare children adequately for educational success/achievement. Cultural deprivation has been identified as one reason why the working class children are generally achieving less than middle class pupils. It attributes the working class under-achievement to the fact that they have often been brought up with a negative attitude towards education. The difference is working class people have a different culture from middle class people. That means working class children do less well in education. Some people then make a causative link between the two ideas and come up with the idea that working class children do......

Words: 519 - Pages: 3

BlackCam - BlackWhite Camera iap | Food Wars!: Shokugeki no Soma staffel 0 folge 6 deutsch stream | Red White (2)