Premium Essay

Business and Management Kantian Ethics

In: Business and Management

Submitted By mjoseph
Words 1704
Pages 7
Kantian Ethical Analysis

Kantian ethics are perhaps one of the world most loved branch of ethical philosophy. It is to some extent the Eden lost of moral philosophy, for it argues that moral requirements are based on established standards of rationality, reason and dignity embedded in Categorical Imperative and whereas, immorality is somewhat a violation of moral philosophy and is not embedded in Categorical Imperative, which is self governing reason that each and every individual possess as a guiding factor in practical affairs, business decisions such as the failed merger of AT&T and TMobile merger. Reason, declared Kant, is the source and ultimate basis for morality (Cavico & Mujtaba, 2013). Meaning, morality is not based on the animalistic side of man, but, rather on a God given conscience weaved in the moral laws which are the opposite of intuition or utility. This moral law is binding on human beings, simply because they are rational (Cavico & Mujtaba, 2013), however; what makes man rational? Does the rationality of man only apply to personal matter not business matter? Does that rationality prevent business controversies? Rationality is a most desirable quality of man, however; such rationality does not always apply to business matter. The merger of the second and fourth largest telecommunications companies, AT&T and T-Mobile is a prime example of how far man will go in order to ignore his God given conscience. However, the same man that is often ready to make irrational business moves is somewhat careful when it comes to personal matter or family matters. A perfect example is the fast food industry, where without any doubt, these fortunes 500, companies would not allow their children to consume food in the dollar menu; but, that same man would not hesitate to open a restaurant in a poor neighborhood and contribute to the existing…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...Introduction: Ethics is a branch of philosophy that examines the moral standards of an individual or society, and asking how these standards apply to our lives and whether these are reasonable or unreasonable. Business Ethics: The application of ordinary human moral and ethical considerations in a business setting. Due to the complication or complexities of handling with human nature, many will agree that it is hard for everyone to agree on one, when it comes to determining a set of rules, guidelines or principles to follow in the business industry. Therefore, to a certain extent, the field of business ethics tries to come up with solutions to handle problems that arise within the business environment. On the contrary belief, one should not be confused with the meaning of morality and ethical theory. Morality has got to do with principles or rules that are used by people to decide between wrong and right (Jennings, 2008). Meanwhile, ethical theory tends to provide guidelines that justify an action to be right or wrong when settling human conflicts. This paper is going to discuss five different ethical theories. They consist of the utilitarianism, Kantian deontology, justice, rights and ethical relativism theories. After that, these ethical concepts will be used to identify some of the ethical issues that are presented in the article entitled ‘News of the World: What was it like on the inside?’ Finally, this paper is also going to come to a conclusion regarding the......

Words: 2674 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Business Ethics

...Executive summary: This report is about how ethically correct KFC and McDonald’s are in their business practices. They both are from the same industry which is food and beverage but still are two different companies. Basically Business ethics focuses on identifying the moral standards of right and wrong as they apply to behaviour within and across business institutions. In this report we evaluate and compare their business practices according to ethical aspects. Later on we discuss the 4 ethical theories for each of the company which are individualism, utilitarian, virtue ethics and Kantian theory and apply them to show how ethical the business practices of each company compared to the other company. We justify our report by giving authentic facts and figures for each company. Finally in the end giving a conclusion on the discussion done for both the companies. TABLE OF CONTENTS: * Background of the companies * Comparison between business practices according to ethical aspects * Constructive and commercial ethical aspects of both companies * Discussing and applying the ethical theories according to the practices of the companies * Conclusion * References A BRIEF DISCRIPTION ON THE BACKGROUND INFORMATION ABOUT KFC AND MCDONALD’S’: First we talk about KFC; it is one of the world's most popular fast food restaurant chains in the world founded by Colonel Harland Sanders in 1930. Every day, more than 12 million customers are served at......

Words: 2888 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Ethics in Business and Management

...or a business should only act according to their own perceived interest. In this case, for Barrick, it is to maximize profit. The original purpose of opening the mines in Tazania is to utilize natural resources and cheap labour to gain a competitive advantage and make profit. So if Barrick’s management team tries to resolve the problems by sacrificing shareholders’ self-interests and taking care of the community; then, it is going against egoism principle and put the interest of the shareholders at risk with these expenses. Let us turn to option 2. Using Milton Friedman CSR business concept, Milton would agree with this option. In his view, a corporation’s only social responsibility is “to make as much money as possible while conforming to the basic rules of the society” (Textbook, p. 42). Clearly, in this case, Barrick has complied to all the laws and ethical customs. Specifically, when relocating families around the mine to different locations, critics criticize the company for giving penny compensation; however, it is due to “the socialist-era law that deemed all land to be owned by the state” (York, p.2) and Barrick just follows it. In addition, in attempting to be beneficial to the community, Barrick has joined a number of associations such as “International Council on Mining and Metals, International Cyanide Management Code and Voluntary Principles on Security and Human Rights” (Regent, p.2) to show their friendly intentions. Having said that, based this CSR business......

Words: 2126 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...TOYOTA 1.0 Introduction Ethics as according to (Riley 2012), are moral guidelines in which governs a person to behave appropriately. Thus, it could be assumed that one whom behaves ethically is also doing what is morally right. From this, it could be understood that business ethics as according to (Riley 2012) is regarded as good business practice. (Collins 1994) on the other hand claims that business ethics is an oxymoron, a contradiction of two concept. What (Collins 1994) mean is that there are not or cannot be ethics in business, or that business in some sense is unethical. In some sense, it is not surprising that some thinks this way as there are countless scandals involving undesirable business activities happening nowadays. Examples of notable scandals as according to (Garrison et al. 2008) includes Enron, WorldCom, Global Crossing, and Tyco International. As according to (Crane and Matten,2007), unethical business practices such as exploitation of workers, pollution of the environment, bribery, and deception of consumers has been going about business today. Thus as according to (Watson 1994), majority of businesses do require the maintenance of basic ethical standards such as trustworthiness, teamwork, and truthfulness. Without it businesses would not be able to proceed smoothly as consumers no longer trust vendors while employees refused to comply with employers. In short, as according to (Crane and Matten 2007), business ethics is the study of right or......

Words: 3588 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

The Human Element “Ethics” in Business Research Management

...Human Element “Ethics” in Business Research Management Kanak Tara*, Archana Yadav** and Ritesh Kumar*** *JRF, Indian School of Mines, Dhanbad **M. Ed., Xt. Xavier College, Patna; ***Scientist, Central Institute of Mining & Fuel Research, Dhanbad ABSTRACT India, like some of the other developed and developing countries in the world, is greatly facing problem of ethics in business research and its management. The large amount of new wealth creates incentive to cut corners to get rich. The pressure to succeed at all costs has created a ‘cheating culture’ that threatens to undermine academia as well as the social and economic fabric of society. However, good business ethics help a society as a whole, and some say that good ethics can be a source of competitive advantage for an organization. Steps can be taken to improve ethics in business research and its management at the societal level, at the individual level, and more importantly at the organizational and the governmental level. In addition to ethical leadership, we believe that one key to improving ethics at the organizational level is human resource management. Improvement can be made in the areas of recruitment, selection, performance appraisal, performance management, compensation and benefits. Personnel policies can help ensure ethical conduct within the organization. This paper outlines and discusses the ethics in general as well as in Business research. INTRODUCTION Today’s challenge to business......

Words: 3058 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Describe the Strengths and Weaknesses of Utilitarian and Kantian Ethics.

...Describe the strengths and weaknesses of utilitarian and Kantian ethics. Utilitarianism is a consequence based ethics perspective which makes decisions that promote the greatest overall amount of good consequences over bad consequences for the greatest number of people in the world. An ethical tradition that directs us to decide based on overall consequences of our act. It is a cost-benefit analysis that fits with business decision making and into people’s intuitive criteria for deciding moral problem. It provides an objective and attractive way of resolving conflicts of self-interest. When most people feel that justice is done, it is easier to implement and defend based on the “common good”. Utilitarianism makes policies for the benefit of the majority of workers, suppliers and customers; think through a number of “frames” before making a decision and therefore the quality of the decision making should be higher. However the nature of the consequences is biased as too much focus on ethical ends can lead to ignoring moral consideration of the means. Eg, if an organization needs satisfy the shareholders hence they retrench 20% randomly so that 80% of staff are kept. But is the financial outcomes the best? It is difficult to evaluate all consequences. For example, through the stakeholder analysis, the rights and interests of minority is ignored (eg, suppliers) or those who are affected in the future. It is unfair to those who lack......

Words: 484 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Business Organization and Management Ethics

...Abstract The assignment/paper is an ethics exercise with two different cases to analyze and determines what direction/decision I would take in each case. The first case is to justify my decision to allow a top performing staff member, Kay, to apply for a different position within the company. Kay and I both are aware that I would not be allowed to replace her due to budget cut and a friend of the boss is also applying for the position. The second case is Marty has miss applied an expense for a local community development committee dinner meeting. Case 1: Stephanie Lyncheski, after careful consideration and working through the Checklist for Making Ethical Decisions matrix (Schermerhorn Jr., 2010), I have made my decision to allow Kay Smith to apply for a new position within the company. I know that I would not be allowed to replace Kay due to budget cuts and she is a high performer for my group. The decision is what is best for the company and Kay. I want to walk you through my decision process to provide you an understanding of why I believe it is the best decision to allow Kay to apply for the new position within the company. I utilized the Checklist for Making Ethical Decisions matrix with the steps below: • Step 1: Recognize the ethical dilemma. • Step 2: Get the facts. • Step 3: Identify your options. • Step 4: Test each option: Is it legal? Is it right? Is it beneficial? • Step 5:......

Words: 1481 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...University of California Theresa Carter Module 1 Case Assignment ETH501: Business Ethics Saturday, April 26, 2014 A Master’s paper submitted to the faculty of University of California In partial fulfillment of the requirement for the award of Graduate Diploma in Master’s Degree in Business Management Introduction The purpose of this assignment is to provide a critical analysis of the 2002 collapse of Adelphia Communications as seen through the lens of Immanuel Kant deontological ethics. This analysis will be accomplished by providing a brief time lime of the Adelphia, identifying and discussing two key ethical problems raised and describing what is meant by deontological ethics. More specifically this paper will show how Kant’s Categorical Imperative (CI) applies to this scenario. The latter discussion will apply the deontological framework of business ethics to the two key ethical problems by constructing CI to the Adelphia scenario. The supporting material for this discussion can be found at Harvard University’s 2011 lecture: Justice, What’s the right thing to do? as presented by Professor Michael Sandel8. To examine the elements of the case, we will inspect the unethical behavior of five key figures culpable in the “rise and fall of the small town saga of epic dimensions8”. John J. Rigas (Founder), his two sons; Timothy J. Riga’s (CFO), Michael J. Riga’s (VP of Operations), James R. Brown (VP of Finance) and Michael C. Mulcahey (Director of......

Words: 2164 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...Touro University California Theresa Williams-Rivers Module 1 Case Assignment ETH501: Business Ethics Dr. Gary Shelton Saturday, April 26, 2014 A Master’s paper submitted to the faculty of Touro University California In partial fulfillment of the requirement for the award of Graduate Diploma in Master’s Degree in Business Management Introduction The purpose of this assignment is to provide a critical analysis of the 2002 collapse of Adelphia Communications as seen through the lens of Immanuel Kant deontological ethics. This analysis will be accomplished by providing a brief time lime of the Adelphia, identifying and discussing two key ethical problems raised and describing what is meant by deontological ethics. More specifically this paper will show how Kant’s Categorical Imperative (CI) applies to this scenario. The latter discussion will apply the deontological framework of business ethics to the two key ethical problems by constructing CI to the Adelphia scenario. The supporting material for this discussion can be found at Harvard University’s 2011 lecture: Justice, What’s the right thing to do? as presented by Professor Michael Sandel8. To examine the elements of the case, we will inspect the unethical behavior of five key figures culpable in the “rise and fall of the small town saga of epic dimensions8”. John J. Rigas (Founder), his two sons; Timothy J. Riga’s (CFO), Michael J. Riga’s (VP of Operations), James R. Brown (VP of Finance) and Michael...

Words: 2168 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...BUSINESS ETHICS 'COLLECTIVE ACTION PROBLEMS' IN PARTICULAR HOW MUCH RESPONSIBILITY DOES AN INDIVIDUAL MANAGER HAVE FOR THE ETHICAL CULTURE OF HIS/HER ORGANISATION? Ram Visvanathan Business Ethics May 28, 2014   Introduction. Ethics is very important for the prosperity of any organization. Every employee or stakeholder of an organization has got an important role to play in nurturing an ethical culture in an organization. This research paper discusses the level of responsibility that an individual manager has in the ethical culture of his or her organization. This is done with close attention to academic journals and research. The paper will derive its arguments from veteran theories like the Utilitarian and the Kantian theories. The paper will also relate its discussions with the case study about Enron a USA company that collapsed as a result of unethical behavior in the management.  Some of the components that will be highlighted in the paper include; the importance of an ethical culture in an organization, the dangers of lack of ethics in an organization and the strategies that can be used to promote ethics in an organization. Justification of the research. The study of the role of individual managers in the ethical culture of an organization is a justified venture. This is because of the increased calls for ethical behaviors in organizations. The expectations of the staff and the society at large on ethical behaviors have increased......

Words: 5413 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Explain Kantian Ethics.

...Immanuel Kant was born in Königsberg, Germany in 1724, and it is he who is the namesake of Kantian Ethics. In his early years Kant was a scientist, but later he became more of a philosopher when in 1770 he published the revolutionary Critique of Pure Reason, it showed Kant’s belief that we could have both sure and certain knowledge, but this said more about the way we think than the world itself. His most famous work however was published by him in 1785, called the Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, it also looked at the presuppositions we make. For example, he said if there is morality there must also be free will, given to us by God, and as a result of this there must also be an afterlife, for without it morality wouldn’t make any sense. Kantian Ethics are then Kant’s own ethical theories and observations. This theory is synthetic a priori according to Kant, and this means that the substantive rules can be applied prior to experience. The first key part of Kantian Ethics are Good Will and Duty, as in the search for an intrinsic good Kant came to believe that no outcome was itself inherently good, his reasoning, both pleasure and happiness can result out of the most evil and heinous of acts, murder or rape for example could potentially cause the person committing the acts to become the recipient of some form of pleasure. Furthermore, Kant would also go on to say that there are also no good character specific traits, intelligence he would give as an example, or......

Words: 499 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...BUSINESS ETHICS AND VIRTUE A review on On Robert C. Solomon’s many ways of being ethical SUBMITTED BY: NAME: STEVE AGONO OBADO COURSE: MsIT BUSINESS ETHICS AND VIRTUE A review on On Robert C. Solomon’s many ways of being ethical SUBMITTED BY: NAME: STEVE AGONO OBADO COURSE: MsIT BUSINESS AND VIRTUE INTRODUCTION The author of this thesis seeks to examine unexplored solutions that could add value to the already existent ethical disclosure and because there is a lack of consensus regarding ethical issues in the workplace. He therefore specifically chose to study the virtue framework articulated by Philosopher Robert C. Solomon, precisely in the business context. He deals with the philosophical problem in a twofold approach. 1. One refers to virtue ethics and 2. Application in the specific branch of business ethics. His thesis will attempt to show the richness and value of such an approach to solve ethical dilemmas in business and in life. MAIN THRUST OF THE ARGUMENT The aim of the thesis is to show how an application of virtue reflects one of many ‘ethical styles’ (Solomon 1999). He goes through various interpretations of virtue ethics. 1. TAYLOR’S INTERPRETATION He thinks that by exclusively adopting the virtuous ethical standpoint one will have a definitive answer to every moral problem. The others believe that Taylor’s proposal is flawed in some aspects. 2. ARISTOTOLE’S ETHICAL THEORY IN CONNECTION TO BUSINESS ETHICS The author......

Words: 1945 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...Business Ethics: A Discourse on Rights: Moral, Legal, and Human Myriad optimistic forecasts, of what comprises the core of business ethics, have permeated numerous discussions on management and commerce practices in the marketplace today. Global economics and trading across borders nearly demands it. In fact, ‘ethics’ in business has come to represent one of the key buzzwords of our decade, along with ‘sustainability’ and the ideological concept of global warming – seemingly shoved down the throats of people. But what is business ethics anyway, and why does it matter? The discourse herein hopefully highlights a cogent and logically based compilation of answers as required from the rubric of Assignments Four. While this paper is written in essay format, for the sake of clarity and precision for the reader, each section shall appropriately and clearly display the topical area or question being addressed. (1) – Define a right, a legal right, a moral right, and a human right explaining how they are related. The philosophical idea of what constitutes a ‘right’ is an age-old concept that many men of God and theorists have confronted from ancient times. One things seems clear. A ‘right’ cannot be discussed without dividing the premise from a ‘privilege.’ According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, a right is simply defined as “being in accordance with what is just, good, or proper” as in conduct (“Right,” 2015). Judge Napolitano defined a right as “a gift from God that......

Words: 2383 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Uttilitarianism and Kantian Ethics

...Ethical issue: Is it ethical for the hotel to organize trips to the “Red Light” area for the purpose of boosting occupancy rates? According to Act Utilitarianism, The affected parties are: * Hotel Management (CEO – Jeronimo) * The Red Light package may boost the occupancy rate of the hotel, giving the hotel a significant source of revenue, which will ease the pressure from the shareholders. (Pleasure) * It may damage the hotel’s reputation since it is likely, that from this moment onwards, the hotel will somehow be associated with the Red Light in the minds of potential guests. (Pain) * It might affect the work ambience in the hotel, as some employees might not agree with the strategy implemented. This might even serve as a potential danger to the female staff.(Pain) * Guests * The Red Light package may provide some of the guests with a more convenient means to visit Red Light district who would like to engage in such activities. (Pleasure) * But this might lead to some guests contracting sexually transmitted diseases, should they not know how to protect themselves. (Pain) * But this might be a problem to the other guests who have no interest in such a service and could be doubted on their intentions to stay in such a hotel. Hence, loyal customers might avoid the hotel due to its new reputation. (Pain) * This is also not good for those guests who book as a family, especially those with young children. They may......

Words: 756 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...Responsibility Mulligan versus Friedman perspectives on moral business decisions * Mulligan: Execs have most knowledge and will be better at at analyzing problems and implementing solutions * Friedman: Execs are not competent to solve moral problems – should be left to governemtn Director/Officer “Duty of Due Care Standard” in the Business Judgment Rule Statutory duty to act: 1. “In Good Faith” – NO SELF INTEREST 2. “With Care of an ordinarly prudent person” BE INFORMED 3. “In manner reasonably believed to be in best interest of corporation” Comparison to a Professional’s “Duty of Due Care”: 1. Duty of Care 2. Breach of duty of care by a reasonably prudent professional 3. breach causes damages that were foreseeable. 4. Negligence Theory: , Can negligence be criminal—US v Parks case Yes! If informed of an issue, should follow through and ensure action was taken (supermarket example) States’ Differing Public Policy on role of stakeholders in making a decision that is in the best interests of the company * Half of the states say the officers and directors can take into account stockholders and other stakeholders (employees, customers, supplies, communities). * Pennsylvania and Indiana allow officers to place the interests of stakeholders above stockholders Why most companies choose Delaware to incorporate Management friendly. Example: business judgement rule Drucker’s Aristotelian......

Words: 2010 - Pages: 9

Medical terminology | Gintama : Porori Hen Subtitle Indonesia | Màn chiếu - Phụ kiện máy chiếu