Premium Essay

Danone and Wahaha 'Failed' Joint Venture

In: Business and Management

Submitted By bomba
Words 812
Pages 4
A ‘failed’ Joint Venture between Danone and Wahaha

French’s Danone and China’s Wahaha had been a very successful joint venture in China. Danone’s capital, expertise & technology know-how, combined with Wahaha’s huge local presence in the market had seen the company soared in the food & beverage industry.
It was until then when Danone accused its partner, Zong, founder of Wahaha of illegally selling Wahaha brand products using a distributor not selected by the joint venture agreement. Danone also filed for arbitration (appoint an official body to settle the dispute) to resolve the trademark dispute.

Despite holding on to the majority stake of 51% in the Wahaha brand, Danone did not take any action until now because it needed the Wahaha brand as much as it needed Zong. Zong and his management were the driving force for Wahaha and Danone’s efforts in sending its own executives were futile.

The dispute highlighted a key issue which many foreign investors have long grappled in China due to the lack of respect and understanding of legal agreements in the country. In China where informal institutions play a larger role than formal institutions, Danone had used the wrong approach to resolve the dispute and had lost the support of the people in China.

Was joint venture appropriate for Danone to enter China?

Joint venture allows Danone which is a multi-national company based in France to tap into the lucrative market in China. At the time of the joint venture, China is pretty much a closed economy with little to no foreign direct investments. Danone saw joint venture with a local firm the way to overcome barriers to investment and do business in China.

Through tie-up with a local firm like Wahaha, it provides Danone with the access to the China market. Wahaha had the economies of experience in China being a local food & beverage brand but do not have the…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Joint Venture

...A joint venture is a special type of strategic alliance in that a new business entity is created that is legally separate and distinct from its parents. A primary advantage of a joint venture is that the venture can have a broader purpose, scope, and duration compared to other types of strategic alliances. Moreover, joint ventures tend to be more stable than non-joint venture strategic alliances. Joint ventures in which there is shared management or that are managed by one parent may have difficulties because there may be a tendency to try to please management from the founding companies rather than focusing on what is best for the joint venture. In contrast, non-joint venture strategic alliances are useful because they allow participants to focus on a particular project, yet do so without creating a new entity. Furthermore, non-joint venture strategic alliances can help firms overcome short-term hurdles. The basic benefits partners are likely to gain from their strategic alliances are ease of market entry, shared risk, shared knowledge and expertise, and synergy and competitive advantage. Strategic alliances can ease market entry because they allow firms to overcome barriers such as entrenched competition and hostile government regulations and/or reduce the cost of entry. Strategic alliances can also enable firms to reduce or control exposure to risk. Firms can gain knowledge and expertise via strategic alliances, as well as synergy and competitive advantage. ......

Words: 312 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Joint Venture

...Since 2007 the global recession has been remarkable for all entrepreneurs, and gradually had to go looking for alternative ways to take their businesses forward. The following paper will analyze the basics that can help or hurt a company in order to become internationally succesfull, and also remark the keys to business survival with the aim of expanding its presence in emerging markets.  exporting  licensing  joint venture  equity stake/acquisition EXPORTING Pros:  In developing countries it is necessary to reach an international level of quality, to upgrade machinery, raw materials and processes, based on imports needed for export.  In countries with higher manufacturing costs, probably out cheaper to import than produce, thus becoming resellers, from manufacturers to retailers.  In countries with free trade treaties gradual reduction of import taxes to zero, lower the cost of international purchases. Cons:  Buy in another country reduces income country where the entrepreneur. Symptoms of economic problems as higher imports than exports, reduce sources of employment, output and cause national currency is exchanged for foreign currency.  Imports are always implicit risk of increase in the price of foreign currency. Businesses tied to increased foreign currency for imports which are their main source of income, should contract hedging or futures brokerage firms in order to protect themselves.  Imports, in high degree, dependent on the entrepreneur...

Words: 925 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Joint Venture

...Joint Venture The globalization strategy our team is going to explore for Moonglow is Joint venture. We are going to discuss the pros and cons to a joint venture along with some environmental factors that Moonglow needs to consider before deciding on a location. We are also going to explore different organization structures and give a recommendation on how to restructure Moonglow to succeed in the global market. Lastly, we will describe ways Moonglow can expand internationally while maintaining its eco-friendly practices and continue producing organic products. According to Jones (2011) a joint ventures is a “strategic alliance among two or more organizations that agree to establish and share the ownership jointly of a new business” (p. 342). Joint ventures are formal and bounded by a legal agreement with all parties’ rights and responsibilities spelled out. Joint ventures are considered one of the best methods for entering into foreign markets. As with any business venture, there are pros and cons that need to be considered (Jones, 2011). Many foreign markets have the potential to be closed to outside companies. Joint ventures make entering into closed markets easier. The pros to entering into a joint venture are access to limited capital resources, transfer of technology, bypass of legal restrictions, access to raw material, knowledge of regulatory climate, and investment incentives (Hall, 1984). In a joint venture, Moonglow will......

Words: 2524 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Danone's Wrangle with Wahaha

...Wrangle With Wahaha Isabella Tennant – 300276839 Danone began in Spain as a small yoghurt stand. It was successful, becoming the first industrial manufacturer of yoghurt. The Danone business kept expanding globally, having a presence in all continents. Danone began to sell many different products early on. In 1997 the Danone group decided to focus only on three worldwide business lines. These were Fresh Dairy Products, Beverages, Biscuits and Cereal Products. This focus meant that Danone’s human and financial resources were freed up allowing for swift expansion into new markets in many continents, such as Asia. Danone faced challenges while operating in China due to a lack of market knowledge, such as the challenges with Robust. Robust, the second largest company in the Chinese beverage industry was purchased by Danone in 2009. Once purchased, Danone decided to manage Robust directly instead of using the original management. The new management was not familiar with the Chinese Beverage Market and Robust struggled, resulting in its milk and tea products almost disappearing from the markets. Wahaha was a company established by Zong Qinghou in 1987 that sold a nutritional drink for kids. A joint venture was formed in 1996 between Danone Group and Wahaha Group. The structure of the joint venture (JV) consisted of three participants: Hangzhou Wahaha Food Group, Danone Group and Bai Fu Qin (Baifu). The Wahaha Group owned 49% of the shares. Whereas, the Danone Group and......

Words: 990 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Joint Ventures in Developing Countries

...December 27, 13 Project – MKTG 410 – Export management Answers to questions of article: When joint Venture goes wrong Done by Abdullah Izaldeen Introduction to International marketing: * What is International Marketing? * Marketing is a tool used by the organizations to help them to direct their goods and services to consumers in order to make profit. Marketing is used both in domestics and internationally and the difference between them is that international marketing is that the process takes place in more than one country. International market is various and can provide a lot of profitable opportunities. However, this diversity could complex international marketing operations, requiring the coordination of a variety process in order to be successful. * Most of the time, the basic marketing principles are applicable to all markets around the world. The only difference is that you should be capable of applying those principals in environments that you are not used to dealing with. * Many of the issues international marketers face are outside of their direct control, so they need to be prepared to adapt their strategies to cope with unfamiliar situations and problems. Q1: What are the factors that a multinational firm should consider when deciding to use a joint venture as a market entry strategy for a developing country? * PESTEL Analysis: * * Company Company Political factors * Economical factors *......

Words: 906 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Joint Venture

...A joint venture is a partnership or alliance among two or more businesses or organizations based on shared expertise or resources to achieve a particular goal.1 There are many good business reasons to participate in a joint venture partnering with a business that has complementary abilities and resources, such as finance, distribution channels, or technology, makes good sense. These are just some of the reasons partnerships formed by joint venture are becoming increasingly popular. A joint venture is also considered a strategic alliance between two or more individuals or entities to engage in a specific project or undertaking. Partnerships and joint ventures can be similar but in fact can have significantly different implications for those involved. A partnership usually involves a continuing, long-term business relationship, whereas a joint venture is based on a single business project. Parties enter joint ventures to gain individual benefits, usually a share of the project objective. This may be to develop a product or intellectual property rather than joint or collective profits, as is the case with a general or limited partnership. A joint venture isn’t like a general partnership; it’s not a separate legal entity. Revenues, expenses and asset ownership usually flow through the joint venture to the participants, since the joint venture itself has no legal status. Once the joint venture has met its goals the entity ceases to exist. Being a part of a joint venture has......

Words: 1514 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Joint Ventures

...MARUTI SUZUKI INDIA LTD. Maruti Suzuki is India and Nepal’s leading automobile manufacturing company and the market leader in the car segment both in terms of volume of vehicles sold and revenue earned. Until recently, 18.28% of the company was owned by the Indian government and 54.2% by Suzuki of Japan. The BJP led government held an initial public offering of 25% of the company in June 2003. As of 10 May 2007 Govt. of India sold its complete share to Indian financial institutions. The Govt. of India no longer has stake in Maruti Udyog.  7. JOINT VENTURE Relationship between the Government of India under the United Front (India) coalition and Suzuki Motor Corporation over the joint venture was a point of heated debate in the Indian media till Suzuki Motor Corporation gained the controlling stake. The success of the joint venture led Suzuki to increase its equity from 26% to 40% in 1987, and further to 50% in 1992. In 1982 both the venture partners had entered into an agreement to nominate their candidate for the post of Managing Director and every Managing Director will have a tenure of five years.  8. CARS Manufactured locally 800 (Launched 1983), Omni (Launched 1984), Gypsy (launched 1985), WagonR (Launched 2000), Alto (Launched 2000), Swift (Launched 2005) Estilo (Launched 2009), SX4 (Launched 2007) Swift DZire (Launched 2008), A-star (Launched 2008) Ritz (Launched 2009), Eeco (Launched 2010) Alto K10(Launched 2010)  9. CONTD.. Imported Suzuki Grand Vitara,......

Words: 10019 - Pages: 41

Premium Essay

Joint Venture

...A joint venture is a business agreement in which parties agree to develop, for a finite time, a new entity and new assets by contributing equity. They exercise control over the enterprise and consequently share revenues, expenses and assets. There are other types of companies such as JV limited by guarantee, joint ventures limited by guarantee with partners holding shares. In European law, the term 'joint-venture' (or joint undertaking) is an elusive legal concept, better defined under the rules of company law. In France, the term 'joint venture' is variously translated as 'association d'entreprises', 'entreprise conjointe', 'coentreprise' and 'entreprise commune'. But generally, the term societe anonyme loosely covers all foreign collaborations. In Germany,'joint venture' is better represented as a 'combination of companies' (Konzern)[1] On the other hand, when two or more persons come together to form a temporary partnership for the purpose of carrying out a particular project, such partnership can also be called a joint venture where the parties are "co-venturers". The venture can be for one specific project only - when the JV is referred to more correctly as a consortium (as the building of the Channel Tunnel) - or a continuing business relationship. The consortium JV (also known as a cooperative agreement) is formed where one party seeks technological expertise or technical service arrangements, franchise and brand use agreements, management contracts, rental......

Words: 7550 - Pages: 31

Free Essay

Danone vs. Wahaha

...negotiation between Danone and Wahaha (2007-2009) On the 30th of September 2009 an almost 12 year relationship between French multinational enterprise Danone and Chinese Wahaha group ended by Danone withdrawing from the IJV (International Joint Venture) for monetary settlement. This report analysis the negotiation journey of the dispute and tries to classify the different negotiation steps based on the challenges of negotiating business deals in China. As a tool IRENEs framework on “Who/ How/ What” is used. Based on the analysis of the negotiation and the review of the cultural differences between western oriented and Chinese businesses suggestions will be made what could have been done differently by Danone. Overview of the Situation between Danone and Wahaha early 2007 The multinational Danone Group SA based in Paris in France is one of the biggest players on the global dairy product and bottled water markets. They are active on all five continents and the net sales in 2007 was more than 12 billion €. The Hangzouh Wahaha Group Co., Ltd. is a company that has grown from a small business, selling drinks to school children to become one of the most important and largest Chinese bottled-water companies already in 2007. Although it is difficult to find detailed financial figures on Wahaha it can clearly be stated that in 2007 the Group was much smaller than Danone. At that time Wahaha contributed approximately 6% of Danone’s profits. Wahaha was......

Words: 4670 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Joint Venture

...idea of joint ventures in the universal vitality division and builds up a joint endeavor model, as a business advancement and evaluation device. The joint endeavor model displays an orderly strategy that depends on present day business brainpower to evaluate a potential business wander by utilizing an adjusted score card method to screen potential accomplices, in view of their mechanical and budgetary center abilities. The model can be utilized by business improvement administrators to saddle the capability of joint dares to make monetary development and reasonable business extension. Besides, associations with nearby organizations can help to moderate econo-political hazard, and encourage purchase in from the national governments that are ordinarily the essential partners in the vitality area wanders (specifically or in a roundabout way). The specific instance of Eskom Enterprises (Pty) Ltd, a completely claimed auxiliary of Eskom, is highlighted. Table of Contents 1. BACKGROUND 4 2. INTRODUCTION 4 3. PROBLEM STATEMENT 5 4. CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF A JOINT VENTURE STRATEGY 5 4.1 What are joint ventures? 5 4.2 The elements of business strategy 6 4.3 Partnership capabilities: a value-added perspective 7 5. ALIGNING THE TECHNO-FINANCIAL STRATEGIES OF PARTNERS 8 5.1 Technology strategy 9 5.2 Financial strategy 10 5.3 The need for a strategic fit between partners 11 6. THE JOINT VENTURE MODEL (JVM). 12 6.1 RECOMMENDATION FOR THE FIRM OF JOINT......

Words: 3204 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Joint Venture

...en Chine : la représentation, la Joint Venture (JV) et les sociétés à capitaux 100% étrangers (WFOE) c'est-à-dire la filiale 100%. Parmi elles, la Joint Venture a longtemps été la première forme d'investissement autorisée et le mode d'opération favorisé par les entreprises étrangères en Chine car il est souvent le seul à être permis. Les joint ventures dans la création de sociétés en Chine Aujourd'hui, il existe en Chine un enthousiasme sans précédent pour les joint ventures. Même s'il ne faut pas nier l'existence d'un ralentissement de la croissance du nombre de nouvelles sociétés de ce type, il y a toujours des entreprises étrangères cherchant à s'installer en Chine. Selon M. Yao Shenhong, ancien porte-parole du ministère chinois du Commerce, ce pays a absorbé davantage d'investissements directs étrangers en 2013 que l'année précédente, dépassant les 85 milliards d'euros. Par contre, il faut prendre conscience qu'aujourd'hui, les mésaventures de certains groupes commencent à faire douter de la pertinence de cette organisation juridique. En ce qui concerne la main d'œuvre, c'est aussi un souci majeur posé par la création de joint ventures, les entreprises étrangères acceptant souvent une main d'œuvre mal qualifiée de la part de leur partenaire. Il faut alors fournir une série de formations coûteuses et longues afin qu'ils soient qualifiés pour leur poste. Pourquoi avoir recours à une joint venture ? Malgré tout, le mode joint-venture possède encore des......

Words: 678 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Danone&Wahaha

...China Basically, Danone chose joint venture as their entry mode at the early stage of entering Chinese market. More specifically, in 1996, they began a joint venture with the other two companies: Hangzhou Wahaha Group Corparation (Wahaha Group) and a Hong Kong corporation called Bai Fu Qin (Baifu), and formed five new subsidiaries in China. However, it should be noted that Danone and Baifu did not directly invest in the JV, but established Jin jia Investment, a new corporation in Singapore instead with Danone as their controlling shareholder. In this case, Wahaha Group held 49 percent of the entire shares of JV while Jinjia owned the remaining 51 percent. The reasons why Danone decided to form a joint venture rather than a wholly owned subsidiary or other formats can generally be associated with the considerable benefits they may gain from it. Firstly, as a French company who has just entered the Chinese market for no more than 10 years since 1980s at that time, Danone’s knowledge about domestic market was still limited and may face a challenge if they run their business solely. Therefore, it is essential for them to learn from their partner in terms of related market knowledges, such as the competitive conditions, culture, political and business systems in China. Secondly, the partnership enabled Danone to share related costs and risks of developing a new product or process, in turn, led to the increase in their profit margin. It can be generally seen that Danone, as a......

Words: 1579 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Danone and Wahaha

...Introduction: In 1996, Danone, a multinational foreign company entered into a joint-venture contract with a local Chinese beverage company named Wahaha in order to better access to Chinese market. The form of the joint venture was a great success at the beginning stage, with both parties gained substantial benefits from the relationship. However, in 2001, conflict arise when Wahaha Group created a series of Non-joint venture companies that sold the same product as the joint venture and use the Wahaha trademark. Since then, a long time dispute continued around the ownership of the “Wahaha” trademark, the rationality of the existence of non-joint ventures and the non-compete issue. Several lawsuits were carried but all ended in Wahaha’s favor. Eventually, Danone relinquish the claims and secede from the joint venture by selling its 51 percent share to the business’s Chinese partners. Main body With a global standing and desire for international expansion, Danone entered the Chinese market in the late 1980s. Compared with many developed countries where markets almost reach saturation, China has a promising market with cheap labor which provide a good opportunity for Danone to further develop. At early stage, Danone entered China through forming a joint venture with the local enterprise Wahaha. There are three main reasons for why Danone use the joint venture mode instead of using other modes to enter China. First, Danone can benefit a lot from Wahaha’s knowledge of local......

Words: 1773 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Joint Venture in the Philippines

...RESEARCH ON JOINT VENTURE IN THE PHILIPINES Group Research Work Submitted to the Ramon V. Del Rosario College of Business De La Salle University – Manila In Partial Fulfillment Of the requirements in BUS520M Business Law Submitted by: GROUP 4 Amparo, Lourdes Lagman, Mia Marie Legaspi, Jill Noreen Submitted to: Atty. Antonio Ligon April 6, 2016 I. Background 1. Philippine Business a. History 2. Doing business in the Philippines b. Forms of business 3. Definition and Origin of Joint Venture (JV) II. Statement of the Problems 1. What are the applicable laws in joint ventures? 2. What are the tax implications? 3. Are our current joint venture laws sufficient? Especially with the Asean integration? III. Statement of Objectives The research study aims to: 1. Identify the applicable laws in joint ventures 2. Identify the tax implications in joint ventures 3. Identify insufficiencies (if any) in our current joint venture laws and make recommendations IV. Discussion 1. Nature of Joint Ventures in Philippine setting 2. Governing Laws 3. Foreign Investments 4. Scope of Joint Venture Business Activity 5. Taxes in Joint Venture 6. Example of JVs in the Philippines V. Analyses VI. Recommendations VII. Learning Points VIII. References I. Background of Philippine Business History Historians state that the early start of......

Words: 6012 - Pages: 25

Free Essay

Joint Venture

...Sunshine powers joint venture in India 1- Because BP company is using the solar power which is not harming the environment by the smokes that pollute the weather. Yes I think it is taking sufficient measures toward developing new forms of fuel as they have the capability to manufacture solar cells, assemble solar modules and balance solar power systems. 2- India is a good location for developing solar power products due to several reasons, First it has the suitable weather that is needed for producing such energy in an effective way , Also the availability of the skilled work force and the Engineers as there are over 600 workers who are employed at three manufacturing centers and eight offices that the BP company owns in India, it provides its products for all of India. Another good country is Sri lanka, it is rich with the sources needed for producing solar power products, also there are high skilled workers with low wages and suitable regulations and rules. 3- I think the pros are motivating the economic activities and increasing the flow of money, reducing the unemployment and encouraging domestic companies to be more efficient. And the cons are having an inflation and some domestic companies may suffer from the competition. They might only perform in their home country, yes I think it is a wise to allow them to operate independently because they may have good strategies and management plans that help in increasing the profit as each branch is related to different......

Words: 347 - Pages: 2

Majikoi - Oh! Samurai Girls (12) | The Tall Man BLuRayRip | A 47 Metros BluRay-Screeener