Premium Essay

Discuss Whether Indirect Taxes on Petrol Should Be Reduced

In: Business and Management

Submitted By saran17
Words 420
Pages 2
Discuss whether indirect taxes on petrol should be reduced

Petrol is seen as a de-merit good as it can cause market failure as the free market may fail to take into account the negative externalities of consumption (pollution) because the social cost exceeds the private cost. Consumers too may experience imperfect information about the long term costs to themselves of consuming products deemed to be de-merit goods

By imposing indirect tax on producers it raises their costs of production, shifting their supply curve inwards. If they have set the tax at the right level, this internalises the externality. By doing this the price of fuel will go up and so reduce the amount consumed and therefore reducing the negative externality which is pollution. It also provides incentives to reduce the negative externality such as pollution. E.g. cars have become more fuel efficient

It can also raise revenue for the government. One project could be investing in improving public transport , as this is a substitute for driving, and if it was improved it might give drivers an alternative to driving which would reduce the externality occurring in the first place. If the revenue was spent this way then all users of public transport would benefit, so those who currently use the bus and train would gain from the tax remaining high if that meant that their fares were cheaper (or service quality was better. They can also use the revenue to get rid of information failure regarding the overconsumption of the de-merit good which causes a negative externality. This could be done through advertisements and awareness campaigns funded by the government.

However there are many people who would all argue for the reduction in tax. drivers would benefit directly from a reduction in tax, as this would lower the costs of production for suppliers and push the supply curve back out Although…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Indirect Tax

...Indirect Tax Indirect taxes include value added tax, a range of excise duties on oil, tobacco and alcohol and fuel duty. VAT is levied on the sale of goods by registered businesses. Businesses add VAT to the price they charge when they provide goods and services to business customers - and non-business customers. There are different VAT rates, depending on the goods or services that are being provided. At the moment there are three rates: standard rate – 20%, reduced rate - 5 %, zero rate - 0 %. The standard rate of VAT is the rate that's charged on most goods and services in the UK. Some examples of reduced-rate are domestic fuel and power, energy-saving material and children's car seats. The examples of zero-rated items are food, books and newspapers, children’s clothes and shoes, public transport. Excise duty is paid on alcohol, tobacco and fuel. This is paid on top of VAT and UK is high relative to most EU countries. These taxes are levied by the government for a number of reasons – among them as part of a strategy to curb pollution and improve the environment. Some of the reasons for using indirect taxes should be briefly mentioned. Indirect taxes may assist in the redistribution of income, though various unfortunate side-effects were existed. Also, indirect taxes may be able to correct for market imperfections, such as the effects of monopoly on the supply of particular goods and the existence of externalities ignored by producers. In addition, where......

Words: 814 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Discuss Whether Margaret Thatcher Was a Pragmatist or an Ideologist

...Discuss Whether Margaret Thatcher was a Pragmatist or an Ideologist After Margaret Thatcher became Prime Minister in May 1979, the legislation to implement the ‘Right to Buy’ was passed in the Housing Act 1980 which had a huge impact on Britain's housing market. The high discounts made the offer a fantastic bargain for those lucky enough to be in the right place at the right time. It meant that there was some real growth in levels of owner occupation and was considered to be great for individuals. Half of the proceeds of the sales were paid to the local authorities, but they were restricted on spending the money (they were made to reduce their debt until it was cleared, rather than being able to spend it on building more homes). The effect was to reduce the council housing stock, especially in areas where property prices were high such as London and the south-east of England. 200,000 council houses were sold to their tenants in 1982, and by 1987, more than 1,000,000 council houses in Britain had been sold to their tenants, although the number of council houses purchased by tenants declined during the 1990s. The ‘Right to Buy’ can be argued to be both ideological and pragmatic. Firstly, it could be said that the reason that Margaret Thatcher followed through with this plan is because it appeases the traditional conservative ideology; that home owners are more likely to care for the society/the wellbeing of the country, including the responsibility of owning a home, if they......

Words: 991 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Indirect Taxation

... | | | | | | INDIRECT TAXATION CIA – II INDIAN TAX STRUCTURE TAXATION SYSTEM IN INDIA India has a well-developed tax structure with clearly demarcated authority between Central and State Governments and local bodies. Central Government levies taxes on income (except tax on agricultural income, which the State Governments can levy), customs duties, central excise and service tax. Value Added Tax (VAT), stamp duty, state excise, land revenue and profession tax are levied by the State Governments. Local bodies are empowered to levy tax on properties, octroi and for utilities like water supply, drainage etc. Indian taxation system has undergone tremendous reforms during the last decade. The tax rates have been rationalized and tax laws have been simplified resulting in better compliance, ease of tax payment and better enforcement. The process of rationalization of tax administration is ongoing in India. Direct Taxes In case of direct taxes (income tax, wealth tax, etc.), the burden directly falls on the taxpayer. Income tax According to Income Tax Act 1961, every person, who is an assessee and whose total income exceeds the maximum exemption limit, shall be chargeable to the income tax at the rate or rates prescribed in the Finance Act. Such income tax shall be paid on the total income of the previous year in the relevant assessment year. Assessee means a person by whom (any tax) or any other sum of money is payable under the Income Tax Act, and includes - (a) Every......

Words: 3542 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Discuss Whether Indirect Taxes on Petrol and Diesel Fuel in the Uk Should Be Reduced

...Discuss Whether Indirect Taxes on Petrol and Diesel Fuel in the UK should be reduced The main reason that a government imposes a taxes on fossil fuels is to try and correct for the negative externality (pollution) which is produced when they are consumed. Without the tax there would be a market failure as drivers would be over consuming petrol as they are not being charged for the damage to the environment. In order to order to answer this essay as to whether the tax should be reduced, I am going to focus on 3 aspects; those that lose from a reduction, those that gain from a reduction and finally at what level the overall price for petrol was BEFORE the tax reduction. In my conclusion I will show that this is key to deciding whether the tax should be lowered or not. The major argument for maintaining the level of taxation on petrol and diesel is to protect the environment. When the social costs of consuming a good are higher than the private costs, there is said to be a negative externality. As an individual consuming fuel is polluting the environment for all, then it can be seen that fuel produces a negative externality. This is illustrated in diagram 1 below. This shows that without any government intervention, the market equilibrium would consume Qp at price Pp. This is higher than the social equilibrium, Qs, meaning there has been a welfare loss to society of (shade triangle). Government fix this by imposing an indirect tax on producers, which effectively raises their......

Words: 1254 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Should Laws Reflect Indirect Harm?

...Verain Vasudeva PHIL17545G March 30, 2014 Professor Mark Reitsma Should Laws Reflect Indirect Harm? Laws reflect the moral code of the majority within a society. Therefore, the majority within a society depict if a law should be reflective of an indirect harm. Indirect harm is “an action which itself did not harm, but may promote or eventually lead to harm”(Reitsma, Liberty and its Limits: Extent of Freedom), it may have no correlation to leading towards harm. John E. Mills indicated “the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others” (Heydt), but lawmakers perceive it justifiable to create laws that are reflective of indirect harm. Laws against Prostitution and drug’s are reflective of indirect harm. If ones using drugs or is a prostitute is not directly harming others in society. Even though laws that reflect indirect harm are to prevent harm from happing, indirect harm should not be considered whilst making laws because they tend to restrict one's freedoms & liberties and there is no substantial evidence that indirect harm leads to harm. Laws tend to create restrictions upon individuals of the society. People are overwhelmed by the pressures of these restrictions and cannot express their freedoms & liberates. Firstly, if one is a distinguish as a criminal under indirect harm laws they will be condemned by society when they have not harmed any individual......

Words: 1308 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Should Alcohol Advertising Be Forbidden? Discuss.

...Advertising is one of the most effective ways to promote a product. There are many ways to advertise, not just through the media; product placements in TV shows and films, and sponsorships of sporting and music events, are all advertising. Alcohol advertising and the impact it has, has been debated across many sectors. Some sectors are calling for it to be banned completely. It is the intention to discuss some of the arguments, for and against, a complete ban of alcohol advertising. The alcohol industry rely heavily on advertising to sell their products. It is estimated that £800 million is spent on advertising in the UK alone on a yearly basis (Alcohol Concern, 2013). The revenue that this advertising generates is vast, not only for the companies whose products are being advertised but also for the advertising companies, sporting events and the Government, to name but a few. If a complete ban on alcohol advertising was implemented this revenue would be lost. In contrast, the Northern Ireland Health Minister, has been reported to have said that the burden of cost due to alcohol misuse amounts to “…up to £900 million every year…” (Northern Ireland Executive, 2012), with 30% of this amount being endured by the Health and Social Care Trust. These figures are for Northern Ireland alone. The cost to the NHS nationwide is approximately £612.9 million (IAS, 2013). The Government believe that prevention and early intervention will help to reduce this cost. Sir Ian......

Words: 1188 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Uk Currently Has a Budget Deficit of £80bn. It Is Forecast to Fall to £0 over the Next 5 Years. Discuss Whether the Uk Government Should Either Raise Taxes or Cut Government Spending to Ensure That the Budget Is Balanced

...The UK currently has a budget deficit of £80bn. It is forecast to fall to £0 over the next 5 years. Discuss whether the UK government should either raise taxes or cut government spending to ensure that the budget is balanced. A budget deficit is a state of financial health in which expenditure exceeds revenue and it usually results in the government having to borrow money. They government can use fiscal policy to correct the deficit and ensure that a balance is kept however, it also depends on what state the economy is in and whether trade-offs will occur meaning that some other macroeconomic targets are put in jeopardy. By reducing government spending, it’s a way of demand management. An advantage is that it reduces the dangers of crowding out the private sector. When the government spends or runs a large deficit, much of the spending is financed through borrowing which is done through government bonds. To make these bonds more attractive the government will offer a higher rate of interest on these bonds. In addition, government bonds are seen to be safer than private sector investments, especially if the government has a triple A credit rating. Therefore when the government offers bonds, investors provide their money to the government, reducing the potential investment for the private sector. Moreover, if the government borrows through the banks then the increased demand for repayable loans will increase, pushing up interest rates and also increasing the cost of......

Words: 1302 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Whether We Should Develop Nuclear Energy

...deformities of 270,000 people. The other accident, the Fukushima nuclear disaster, also widely affected the lives and health of about 200,000 people including Japanese, Chinese, Korean and Russian (Schwarz and Cochran, 2013, p. 694). Schwarz and Cochran state that thousands of residents living in Fukushima lost their lives and more than 100,000 people had to leave their homes to avoid nuclear radiation which may affect their health for a long time. In addition, workers employed in nuclear plants are more possible to have a lung cancer or a bone cancer because they are constantly exposed to nuclear radiation (Palliser, 2012, p. 16). Considering the dangerous nuclear radiation on residents and workers, more and more people doubt whether nuclear energy should be developed or not. Another main concern is nuclear waste disposal which is difficult to solve. It is necessary for countries to find a solution disposing the radioactive waste. Bodansky (2007, p. 325) introduces that the most effective way to dispose the waste is the Deep Geologic Disposal. However, he states that although this solution can prevent the nuclear radiation from damaging people for a long time, it is difficult to build enough deep geologic storages. Bodansky points out that it usually costs a country 30 to 60 years from making a plan to select a suitable and safe site to completely construct it finally. Furthermore, serious accidents may occur during the way transporting nuclear waste. For example, in 1987,......

Words: 1549 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Britain Should Adopt a Codified Constitution, Discuss.

...“Britain should adopt a codified constitution”, Discuss. (40 mark) Intro A constitution is a set of rules/principles, which aim to set the duties and powers of government. There are two different types of constitutions, codified (written) and uncodified (unwritten), which the UK is an example of an uncodified and the U.S.A a codified. Codified and Uncodified Constitutions An uncodified constitution is a constitution made from principles that are not formatted into one single document and unlike codified is not authoritative and also not entrenched. A codified constitution is where the principles or rules are collected within a single document. Codified constitutions have three key features, the first is that the document itself is authoritative in the sense it constitutes a ‘higher’ form of law. The other key feature is that It binds all political institutions. And the final key feature is that they are said to be entrenched which means they are difficult to abolish or amend. UK for a Codified Constitution Some people argue that if the UK adopted a codified constitution is a good thing. If it was to be adopted it would significantly change the UK because it would affect: the power of the government and people’s rights and freedom. One of the biggest arguments for adopting a codified constitution is the fact it would make all rules/principles a lot clearer as they would all be in 1 single document and more clearly written meaning it would create less......

Words: 557 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Should Smokers Pay Health Taxes or No?

...Essay 3: Should smokers pay health taxes or no? Minh Anh Nguyen City University of Seattle Smoking is something that happens every day in our life. People can easily find someone smoking in some street corners, even in public places like train station, hospital, dormitory. It is not strange if you cross the road and see a mom who is enjoying her cigarette in front of her child. It is a kind of action that has become a part of our society and it accidentally makes people think that smoking is normal and it is just a habit and people do not feel like they have to stop it. Even some people are aware of the negative impacts of smoking they still ignore it and let it happen. People used to have the same thinking and concept about smoking. Not long ago, humans believed that smokers should not pay a health tax because the idea of “smoking is just a habit” it went deep into their mind. Until the day they all witnessed cancer took away people’s lives, which was the moment when all the memories and images of smoking throughout her life came up in their head. Now they can remember cancer like it just happened yesterday. It made humane society see things in a different way. Not only cancer is caused of smoking but also million people are getting killed by heart diseases every day. According to Centers for diseases control and prevention (n.d), “Tobacco use causes nearly 6 million deaths per year, and current trends show that tobacco use will cause more......

Words: 1314 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay


...tackling tax avoidance, it is important to take into account the overall contribution to government revenues by MNEs and the existing tax base, as well as new productive investments by MNEs and the future tax base. The degree to which MNEs engage in tax avoidance varies by industry and home country (among other factors), but tax avoidance practices are widespread. They cause significant tax revenue losses worldwide – in both host and home countries of international investors. Not only do they cause economic and financial damage to countries, they also raise a basic issue of fairness. In almost all cases, the shift in profits through the use of offshore investment hubs does not reflect actual business operations (i.e. the profits reported and taxes paid in a jurisdiction are disproportionate to the activities that take place there). The shifting of profits between jurisdictions results in an unfair distribution of tax revenues between jurisdictions. The practice is especially unfair to developing countries that face certain tax related challenges. • Limited tax collection capabilities. Accurately identifying tax planning practices requires an analysis of global operations for individual MNEs, an unrealistic task for most countries, and especially developing ones. There is a clear case for technical assistance to developing-country tax authorities. • Greater reliance on tax revenues from corporate investors. Developing economies tend to rely relatively more on tax revenues......

Words: 2089 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Discuss the Meaning of Justice. Discuss Whether the Law Achieves Justice and Whether It Should Seek to Do so.

...This essay shall discuss initial the meaning of justice then I shall discuss whether the law achieves justice and whether it should seek to do so. Justice has been traditionally defined through its reference to the Latin maxim suum cuique tribuere its means to allocate each to their own. Many theories have been formed to try to define their own personal form of justice, an example being Aristotle who was a Greek philosopher who made the original distinction between distributive and corrective justice which remains relevant to this day. Distributive Justice concerns the correct distribution of wealth and privilege between the members of society. Aristotle argued that there should be a proportionate distribution of such goods and burdens but he did not mean by this that there should not be an equal distribution of goods and burdens. Also stating that some people of limited capacity were unable to obtain or appreciate the good life, and therefore argued that those people should act as slaves to support others in society. In today’s issues a distributive justice issue would be known as a matter of politics. It could be said that the current law system incorporates Aristotle’s theory through section 18 and section 20 Grievous Bodily Harm (GBH). To be guilty of section 20, one must either be ‘reckless’ or ‘intend’ some harm, in some cases this poses a possible 5 year sentence. In great contrast to this is section 18, where a defendant must have ‘intended’ really serious harm and......

Words: 454 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Discuss Whether Indirect Taxes on Sugary Food and Drink Should Be Increased

...Discuss whether indirect taxes on sugary food and drink should be increased An indirect tax is a tax where the burden of the tax falls largely on the consumer but it is actually paid by the producer. Examples include Value Added Tax, excise duty and sales taxes. Indirect taxes on sugary food and drink will increase costs for producers so they cause the supply curve to shift to the left. The cost of the negative externalities is internalised in the price of the good, this may reduce demand for the good and the level of its production, eating sugary food and drink will increase the likelihood of obesity, early death, depression and certain heart disease. Poor health will also adversely affects work and productivity. Higher prices would discourage people from consuming unhealthy foods. Reducing consumption of sugary foods would have a significant impact in improving health. Also, adding tax on sugar can create an incentive for firms to supply alternatives which are healthier. If firms have incentives to promote healthier foods and drinks with substantially lower sugar content, then consumers will to an extent follow the supply. Moreover, taxes raise revenue for government, this can be spent on alternatives like tax on cigarettes could be used for funding government services to help people to stop smoking. However, it is difficult to measure the level of negative externality. Demand for sugary and drink tend to be price inelastic, so higher taxes will not reduce demand much.......

Words: 442 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Why Does Stress Should Be Reduced in People’s Live?

...Tuan Le ENGL 101 Feb 25, 2016 Why Does Stress Should Be Reduced in People’s Live? In modern life, stress is so common that it has become a part of life. Stress is not always bad. Stress with positive force can help us perform under pressure, motivate us to do our best such as studying for exam, working with deadline or a job interview. However, when stress is a negative force, it can adversely affect everything in our live such as health, mood, relationship and quality of life. Therefore, stress is a harmful force, and it should be reduced in people’s live. Let’s talk about stress. Stress is body’s way of responding to many kind of demand, and it can be caused by both good and bad experiences. In addition, stress happens when people can’t face with pressure, and this pressure can be in many shapes and forms. But, a negative stress can cause may horrible physiological reactions for people. Physical effects, nervous system effects and psychosocial effects are the main effects that stress can cause on human’s body. The first is physical stress effects; according to Stress Symptoms, Signs, and Cause, a negative stress can cause many physical effects on human’s body such as weigh gain, hair loss, digestives problem, heart attack, etc. The research’s show that 40 percent of deaths and 70 percent of diseases in the United States are related to stress. For example, hair loss is the most common stress, and this stress usually have been seen in individuals who have a......

Words: 594 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Discuss Marx's Theory of Alienation and Assess Whether It Is Still Relevant in the Contemporary Workplace

...Option 1 Discuss Marx’s theory of alienation and assess whether it is still relevant in the contemporary workplace. In a capitalism society of those days, workers worked solely for the profit and rarely any focus will be spared on if the products were of the social need. On top of that, while the social classing was still heavily emphasized, most of the employees were not given sufficient protection and the fundamental benefits as a committed worker. This brought to the rising of Karl Marx with the term ‘Alienation’ in the year of 1844, which reflected that things naturally belong together had been separated or to put another antagonism between things that were properly in harmony. Making this statement, Karl Marx attributed the cause of alienation to the systematic result of capitalism. From the term alienation, Karl Marx had classified it into four types of alienations, namely alienation from the product, alienation from productions, alienation from others and last but not least, alienation from self. Referring back to Karl Marx, alienation from products gives the meaning that the workers have no rights to decide what they are going to produce, instead they are only focusing on the profits while the social needs are entirely ignored. Alienation from productions refers to the condition whereby the workers are not allowed to develop freely physically and mentally, they are forced to cling to the rigid rules and regulations. For the alienation from......

Words: 2174 - Pages: 9

Miss Advised | Play Movie | Influence of Entertainment Media - 659 Words