Free Essay

Do Dogs Get Jealous?

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By sisterfred1
Words 560
Pages 3
Evaluating a Claim on Jealous Emotions Frequently, there are questions asked by dog-lovers, and owners, about their dog’s emotion and responses to certain things. Sue Manning took these questions into her own hands and wrote on two studies from Dr. Bonnie Beaver, and Christine Harris, on what they discovered when trying to figure out if dogs experience the same human emotion of jealousy (Manning, 2014). The two studies left the audience questionable but the professors were both after the answer to the same question, do dogs get jealous? As I mentioned before, Sue Manning took a closer look into these studies. She explained Harris` study pretty generally, stating how Harris worked with 36 dogs, videotaping owners ignoring their pets while petting and talking sweetly to stuffed, animated dogs (Manning, 2014). After reading this section of the article I noticed that Harris used a form of experimentation know as, naturalistic observation. She gathered data about behavior by simply watching and taking notes and not trying to change anything during the trials. She had to use this form of experimentation because of the number of dogs in her population. Most of my reflections were negative but some positive. My first negative response to this study is the lack background information she portrayed in her population. I feel as if, age or maturity level would be the first thing to effect the actions that the dog, or puppy, might have displayed. For if the dog was a puppy, or at a young age, they would have more energy and less control over there actions. Also, another concern, if she had done background information on the thirty six dogs, would they have been seeking attention all the time, no matter if there owners had stuffed animals or toy pails, or not. According to Manning (2014) Harris believes the dogs saw the stuffed animals as rivals. This could be true but little aggression was shown towards the actual stuffed animal, more attention was drawn to the actual owner in Harris` study. When shown the stuffed animal, thirty percent snapped at the fake dog, and only one percent did when the second trial was tried with a jack-o-lantern pail (Manning, 2014). How do we know this is a valid percentage? The dog could simply have had protective instincts for his or her owner, which most dogs, to my knowledge, do. The only thing that really stuck out to me from the experiment was Harris` different use of independent variables, or the stuffed animal and the pail. This really did make me question why they reacted so differently to the more lifelike variable. This was the only time I asked myself if the dogs did get jealous, I felt the rest of the information was not useful to the audience, because all of it needed more validity.
In conclusion, I believe that the claim is not completely reliable because of the reasons I stated above. When I first saw the title of the article by Manning I was quite excited because I actually felt as if it could be a very interesting study, and perhaps an actual thing, jealousy in dogs. But because of the lack of background information on her population, Manning did no convincing for me after I read through her article. Do dogs get jealous? The world may never know.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Too Much to Do -Not Enoughtime to Get It Done

...Too Much to Do- Not Enough Time to Get It Done! 1. What are the issues in this case? List them in order of priority. Panning: Business planning helps you define an agreed route-map for your business. It identifies your key objectives for the next three-to-five years and how they will be achieved. A business plan gives directions and timelines in which to achieve your goals, and provides a guideline for your day-to-day operations and decisions. Sally Paul, rush into her decision, maybe getting nervous that she might lose her customers. Instead of analyzing her strategy, she made an irrational decision, which in many cases can lead to a bad decision. Her goals should had identify the areas of improvement, like an increase in sales or a reduction in costs, and any additional expenditure in order to achieve these goals. Training: If Sally had not rushed in her decision to expand and lower prices to attract customer to her store, she could have develop a training plan to adjust to increase in customers and sales. Phil Bearman, the maintenance supervisor, why is he in charge of the expansion of the parking spaces. Does he have training in architecture? Training should have been part of the business plan. Staffing: One of the problems with understanding the true value of employees is the way many managerial decision makers focus on saving money. Sally should have hired additional employees to cover the additional hours the store is now open. Since Ms Sally wanted to offer...

Words: 331 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Why Do People Get Bullied

...It's hard to keep your mind on schoolwork when you're worried about how you're going to deal with the bully near your locker. Bullying bothers everyone — and not just the kids who are getting picked on. Bullying can make school a place of fear and can lead to more violence and more stress for everyone. Why Do Bullies Act That Way? Some bullies are looking for attention. They might think bullying is a way to be popular or to get what they want. Most bullies are trying to make themselves feel more important. When they pick on someone else, it can make them feel big and powerful. Some bullies come from families where everyone is angry and shouting all the time. They may think that being angry, calling names, and pushing people around is a normal way to act. Some bullies are copying what they've seen someone else do. Some have been bullied themselves. Sometimes bullies know that what they are doing or saying hurts other people. But other bullies may not really know how hurtful their actions can be. Most bullies don't understand or care about the feelings of others. Bullies often pick on someone they think they can have power over. They might pick on kids who get upset easily or who have trouble sticking up for themselves. Getting a big reaction out of someone can make bullies feel like they have the power they want. Sometimes bullies pick on someone who is smarter than they are or different from them in some way. Sometimes bullies just pick on a kid for no reason......

Words: 399 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Thoughts on Being Asked “How Do I Get Into Infosec?”

...So You Want To Get Into INFOSEC Huh? I got a request through a friend for a friend of that friends kid to talk to him about how to get into INFOSEC the other day. Now usually I am a curmudgeon (as you all know and love) and am loathe to be some sort of big brother of INFOSEC to anyone but in this case I said ok cuz I am just that nice. After some email wrangling we finally got together today (scant minutes ago actually) and now feel an obligatory blog post on the subject of getting into the business coming on …And there it is …Feel the burn… So after agreeing to a time to meet I began to wonder just what I would say to this kid as to how to get into the business. For that matter I really wondered if I should encourage him at all to get into INFOSEC in the first place. My mind started to ponder why I was in it still and just how if at all it was rewarding given all that I have seen and still deal with on a daily basis. Often times my daily job sends me in to apoplectic fits that you all see in my blog posts and on twitter screeds of 140 characters at a clip so I imagine all of you out there might not think that I enjoy my work on average. On the whole though I would say that I do enjoy my work but I would caution anyone looking to get into this business to take a deep look at their abilities and their coping mechanisms before they took the plunge. My conversation with this guy (in his 30′s) covered a range of things but I mainly focused on just how technical he was if at......

Words: 1490 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Get a Knife, Get a Dog, but Get Rid of Guns

...ENGRD 310 12 March, 2014 Get a Knife, Get a Dog, but Get Rid of Guns by Molly Ivins In the “Get a Knife, Get a Dog, but Get Rid of Guns”, Molly’s Ivins main point is an absolute abolition of civilian gun ownership, and gun control in the Second Amendment. She begins her essay with a fact that she is not anti-gun, she is pro-knife. Also another fact is that as a civil libertarian she supports the Second Amendment. During the all essay she urged us to consider the pros of knifes, giving the benefits of the knife she stating that, “A general substitution of knifes for gun would promote physical fitness.” She is absolutely convinced that the guns are more dangerous than knifes, because the guns can ricochet, and it is a fact that people are less likely to be killed by cleaning their knife as they would be cleaning their gun. In this way the author shows the probability of accidental killing, and indicates the accuracy why the guns should be taken under strict control. She believes that the Second Amendment has a reliability and means exactly what is says, “A well-regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed”, and she refer that a 14 years old youths, and crazy religions that should not owned a guns, because they are not a part of the Amendment. She insists that guns should be just in militia hands, and citizens also are not part of this Amendment. Then Molly Ivins......

Words: 699 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Jealous Husband

...O’Malley June 25, 2014 For the Love of Dogs The short stories, “Stay,” by David Schuman, and “Shepherd,” by Joy Williams, both demonstrate relationships between a dog and their owner. Pets, especially dogs, play a huge role in the lives of their owners. Just like every person is different, every dog is different as well. All dogs have their good and bad qualities and even though the dogs in these stories have differing personalities and get treated differently, both of the owner’s lives revolve completely around them. Throughout both stories, you learn about the dogs qualities little by little. It is important to understand the personalities of these two dogs in order to better grasp the owner’s feelings toward them. In “Stay,” the man goes to an animal shelter and asks for “the dog that would take up the most space in his house.” He names this horse-like dog Deli; reason being, that the dog seems to really “perk up” when the man mentions or gives him bologna. Deli is a very easy dog to read. Multiple times in the story, the man mentions Deli’s expressions. For instance, the first time the man and Deli ever see each other, the man explains, “He swung his gaze in my direction. His expression was frank. It said, Get me out of here” (Schuman 106). Sometimes, while eating breakfast, the man tells, “Deli would put his chin down on the tabletop and give me a look like, Why don’t you go get a wife?” (Schuman 108). Those expressions do give you some insight into Deli’s......

Words: 1156 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

How Do People Get New Ideas

...I think the essay "How do people get news ideas" absolutely relate to our course and LINKS. Working as a team is to bring people in many skills together in order to solve problems, to gather information and even to get new ideas. I found some quote that relate to this, as followed: If you have an apple and I have an apple and we exchange these apples then you and I will still each have one apple. But if you have an "idea" and I have an "idea" and we exchange these "ideas", then each of us will have two ideas.---George Bernard Shaw According to Isaac Asimov' essay, The optimum number of the group would probably not be very high. I should guess that no more than five would be wanted. A larger group might have a larger total supply of information, but there would be the tension of waiting to speak, which can be very frustrating. It is absolutely true. Although having a large number of people within team may provide a lot of information, it will frustrate to members. Then within the team should collect only appropriate people such as different skills. However, teams have proved that they can make many great solutions and provide several new ideas, but sometime those Ideas may be similar because they do, work, think in the same or similar environment. According to the essay, sometimes teams need to have a conference at different places such as coffee stores and someone' home to have new environment and it easier to get new ideas. To improve individual skills are also......

Words: 475 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Why Do Justice Get There Jobs for Life

...Why do justices get their jobs for life? The section “Why do justices get their jobs for life” by Patricia Smith is about how the nation’s highest court (The Supreme Court) really work. The Supreme Court is the center of today’s most important inclines and declines. With health care, crime and punishment. Americans have called for the court to answer the questions to why are we having the problems and what are they doing to solve them. One of those questions are “Why do justices get their job for life?” Some say it is to protect them from fear of political actions of the decisions they have made while in office. The constitution says federal judges in The Supreme Court serve under “good behavior” but, other judges do not get the same benefit. This causes conflict because justices are serving much longer than they use to. Between the time period 1789 and 1970, justices served an average of 15 years. Then between 1970 and 2005 the rate went up to 26 years. “Longevity isn’t the problem” says Patricia. Justice John Paul Stevens, who retired back in 2010 at the age of 91 after serving 34 years on the Court, was full active in the court and the work until his retirement. But, William O. Douglas remained on the Court practically a year after suffering a serious stroke back in 1974. An importance of life occupation is the occurrence of Dwayne Flott Page 2 Vacancies. This first occurred when President Jimmy Carter had no Supreme Court vacancies to fill. But, President Nixon...

Words: 387 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

How Do I Get Paid?

...How Do I Get Paid? HRM 531 May 2, 2011 Brian Frank How Do I Get Paid? The employment team I have been given responsibility of, consists of five employees. Their job titles and duties range from one spectrum to the other. Their job functions are purchasing, billing, two customer service representatives, and a graphics designer. With some being more administration work and some being sales, I had to devise a compensation plan that would fit everyone. This new compensation plan will take into account their evaluation score and their level of pay when compared to other employees with the same job title in the industry or compa ratio. The new plan will be set to a graph. The x axis will be the compa ratio and the y axis will be their yearly evaluation score. Where the two points meet will determine the percent of pay the employee will receive. If by chance an employee is at the top of their compa ratio, a one-time payment will be calculated. This calculated amount will be given as a onetime check instead of the hourly pay increase for the year. This system is designed to bring up the newer employees who have a low compa ratio and don’t have to work for the company twenty years to get a significant salary. Some employees may ask how this will work. The individual evaluations are based partially on department or company goals and then the remaining percent is based on direct goals for that employee. In order to get a higher percent pay raise, the employee will......

Words: 824 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Do Dog People and Cat People Differ in Terms of Dominance?

...“Do Dog People and Cat People Differ in Terms of Dominance?” http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/canine-corner/201503/do-dog-people-and-cat-people-differ-in-terms-dominance Stanley Coren Ph.D., F.R.S.C. Published on Mar 18, 2015 Yinyin Zhu COM 231 June 3, 2015 In the article, “Do Dog People and Cat People Differ in Terms of Dominance?”, the author compared people preferring dog as their pet and people preferring cat as their pet. The author has focused on a study that tried to find the relation between people’s pet preference and their personality trait of social dominance, as in “social dominance orientation”, “interpersonal dominance”, “competitiveness”, and “narcissism”. The study has put an emphasis on the idea of “social dominance orientation”, which is a belief for a structured social relationship, based on the social rank or status, and believe that is appropriate to the society. The result of the study showed that dog people stay high on this category, which explained their preference of dogs as dogs are more submissive to them, “at least to the degree that they obey their commands”. Moreover, the level of competitiveness, or the desire to outperforming others, is also higher among dog owners than cat owners. However, the result didn’t show a decisive difference between dog people and cat people with regards to the tendency to have an aggressive interpersonal behavior, nor a strong feeling of self-importance over their pets or other people. The......

Words: 638 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Get Your Team to Do What It Says It’s Going to Do

...Get Your Team to Do What It Says It’s Going to Do by Heidi Grant Halvorson Say you’re in the early stages of planning your department’s budget for the next fiscal year. Your management team meets to establish short-term priorities and starts to think about longer-term resource allocation. You identify next steps and decide to reconvene in a week—but when you do, you find that very little progress has been made. What’s the holdup? Your to-dos probably look something like this: Step 1: Develop a tentative budget for continuing operations. Step 2: Clarify the department’s role in upcoming corporate initiatives. Those steps may be logical, but they’re ineffective because they omit essential details. Even the first one, which is relatively straightforward, raises more questions than it answers. What data must the team gather to estimate requirements for continuing operations? Who will run the reports, and when? Which managers can shed additional light on resource needs? Who will talk to them and reconcile their feedback with what the numbers say? When will that happen? Who will assess competing priorities and decide which trade-offs to make? When? Creating goals that teams and organizations will actually accomplish isn’t just a matter of defining what needs doing; you also have to spell out the specifics of getting it done, because you can’t assume that everyone involved will know how to move from concept to delivery. By using what motivational scientists call if-then......

Words: 470 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Why Do People Chose Certain Breeeds of Dogs

...Why do people chose certain breeds of dogs? Amanda Ware Department of English, Coastal Carolina University Abstract People are motivated by various influences when choosing the breed of dog that they want. It was hypothesized that people chose dogs for functional reasons rather than cultural reasons. According to research conducted through web research and a college class survey, the trend of choice varied between function and culture. The web research conducted showed a positive correlation than negative correlation of cultural influence rather than functional influence in choosing a breed of dog. The college class survey showed a stronger positive correlation than negative correlation of functional influence rather than cultural influence. The results of research suggests that the majority of people are more motivated by cultural influence rather than functional influence when choosing a particular breed of dog though the small survey suggested the opposite. Why do people chose certain breeds of dogs? We have dogs, but what are the motivations behind our choosing a particular breed of dog? Dogs play as part of the overall family picture for those of us that chose to have them. We buy dogs, adopt dogs, and are given dogs, but are we motivated by cultural or functional influences when choosing a particular dog? This paper examines these influences. Web research seemed to narrowly observe the topic of influence when choosing a particular breed of dog. The......

Words: 935 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Why Do You Get Goosebumps

...Goosebumps Ever wonder why you get goose bumps? Do they serve a purpose? Why do they develop when we are cold? Cutis anserine is one of the medical terms for Goosebumps (cutis means skin and anserine means goose). The term describes a change in the skin from smooth to bumpy which usually occurs after exposure to the cold. Most animals regulate their body temperature at a particular level. For humans it is 37°C. If the temperature is too high the body will apply different mechanisms to decrease its temperature. E.g. sweating and dilation of blood vessels. If the temperature is to low the body will counteract to increase the temperature. E.g. shivering, constriction of blood vessels and goose bumps. This is a negative feedback system which allows us to maintain homeostasis. Homeostasis is the process of keeping a constant internal condition. How do we keep things the same? To keep our body at a constant temperature we need three things: receptors, a processing centre and effectors. Thermoreceptors in the skin detect changes in external temperature. They pass this information on to the processing centre in the brain called the hypothalamus which is a tiny gland in the brain. An important......

Words: 607 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Do American Companies Get Harmed by Immigration Workers

...English 110 06/02/15 Do American Companies Get Harmed by Immigration Workers Immigration is one of the more debated topics in America nowadays. Historically, immigrants have come to the U.S. because of difficult times living in their home countries. Many immigrants choose to move, some even get forced to move, but most migrants do it in a search for a better future. “There are many reasons for a country to attract immigrations; the most common reason is the need for labor.”(Annan, 149) Immigrants perform services that the host population is willing to consume but is either unwilling or incapable to provide for itself. Jobs vary from highly skilled work in research to less skilled jobs in fields such as nursing the sick and elderly, working on construction sites, running shops that are open 24/7, or taking care of households and their housework, often while the owners are pursuing their own career goals. American companies use of hiring immigrants’ instead of Americans benefits them in three different ways: first, immigrants fulfill the demand for low wage jobs; second, immigrants help countries increase their globalization; and third, immigrants help balance a countries economy. One reason that companies hire immigrants instead of Americans is to fulfill the demand for low wage jobs. While unemployed people in the U.S. first think about what their wages will be, immigrants from developing countries usually don’t care what kind of job it is as long as they get paid. So......

Words: 1048 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Dogs Don't Bite People, Bad Owners Do

...Title: Pit Bulls Don’t Bite People, Bad Owners Do Speaker: Amelia Auerswald Specific Purpose: To persuade people to my belief that pit bulls are not bad dogs. Thesis Statement: Pit bulls have lived – and died – under the stigma that they are vicious as a breed for decades, when in truth it’s owners who have used them in cruel ways that have given them such a heinous reputation. Introduction Before we get started, I want to tell you a story. This is a picture of my pit bull, Honey. I rescued her several years ago from my ex-husband’s brother, who was abusing her. Despite Honey’s bad youth, she was a sweet dog. When my oldest daughter was a baby, she would lay on the floor with her and let her chew on her ears. But Honey had a bad habit. She would jump the fence into my neighbor’s yard to play with her dog. One day, while I was at work, my neighbor called animal control and claimed that Honey had ripped through the screen in her kitchen door and attacked her. So animal control came to my house, took my dog while I wasn’t home, and put her down. All I received was a notice in the mail a week later, which I had spent looking for my dog. The funny thing is, there was no damage to my neighbor’s door, and she never had a mark on her. She was put down on the word of a cantankerous old woman simply because of her breed. My name is Amelia Auerswald, and today I hope to show you that pit bulls don’t bite people, bad owners do. First, we will look at some myths and facts about the...

Words: 1146 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Too Much to Do- Not Enough Time to Get It Done!

...Sally must hire additional employees in order to achieve her goal of proving the best customer service, to attract and retain current customers. 3. because of the extended hours and expansion activities, Bearman knows that he does not have the right number of employees with the right level of talents and kills in the right jobs at the right time performing the right activities to achieve what needs to be done—and done right the first time. What suggestions do you have for him? The best suggestion that I can offer to Bearman is to conduct a meeting with his employees and get a feeling on how they feel about working long hours. I would inform them to make a list of concern they have so that he can schedule a meeting with Sally and make changes as soon as possible. I would also suggest Bearman to encourage employees to request a meeting with Sally and let her know of the current situation. By informing management of satiations, they might not be aware of can have appositive outcome. 4. What would you do if you were Phil Bearman? Why? If I were Phil Bearman I would request a meeting with Sally and explain the current situation. I would request additional employees to cover the extended hours and be able to have normal working hours without stress. I would also request to have some type of rewards program to boost employee morale. Rewards program can be time of to be with family since they have been working extended hours these past few weeks....

Words: 873 - Pages: 4

Can You Ever Forgive Me? French Film Torrent BRrip 720p | 123Movies.io | Temporada 11