Premium Essay

Do We Have Free Will

In: Social Issues

Submitted By mungai
Words 1346
Pages 6
Student:
Instructor:
Class:
Date:
Do we have Free Will? Yes. The issue of whether we have a free will or not is disputable. For the purpose of this study, I will look into what others have said about this topic. First, I will consider the opinions of three writers who have written contrary to my opinion supporting their argument with the reasons they have given. Secondly, I will analyze the opinions of those writers who believe that we have free will. This will of course be followed by supportive argument behind their opinions. On the last section of this study, I will rebut on the two different opinions. It seems that we do not have free will. For as (Merrill 293), the idea of free will is invalid because conditions of free will are not succinctly stated. There exists a problem of stating the conditions due to a foggy idea of the meaning in the cause effect relationships. The notion between the cause effect relationships is based on experience. In other words, this relationship is based on a succession of time. Although the succession in time can be proved in the laboratory, it cannot be consciously proved because a human being can do the same thing twice but with different consciousness. It seems that we do not have free will. For as (Clement Dore 500-501) free will is associated with making choices out of consciousness. Free will knows no coercion and one accepts responsibility for his actions. People engage in logical reasoning in making their day-to-day choices, they also have self-control that determines their actions. According to this writer, free will is causality and our consciousness does not affect our behavior. He supports his argument by the use of laboratory experiments that show that before a human being makes decisions, the brains will have already made groundwork for such.

It seems that we do not have free will. For as (Steven 223-252) the…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Do We Have Free Will?

...Do We Have Free Will? It is Friday night and your friends have just invited you to what is supposed to be the best party of the year, but it is your little brother’s birthday. Right before the party, you sit down to weigh your options and decided to stay home to celebrate your little brother’s birthday. Did you just make a free choice, or was your decision just the result of the natural laws in the universe coming together forcing you to stay home? In the words of Arthur Schopenhauer, ""Man can do what he wills but he cannot will what he wills" . According to this, though you may believe that you have the complete freedom to choose where you wanted to go, your ultimate choice was caused by the events that occurred before this one. Although the choice of going to the party or staying home may seem to have given the illusion of free will, there was ultimately a physical law that could most likely explain why this decision was made. First off, there are three main viewpoints on the idea of free will: compatibilism, determinism, and indeterminism. Compatibilists state that it is possible for both free will and determinism to exist at the same time. Given an instance, a compatibilist will say that even though you are only really presented with one option in all situations, if this option is in accordance with the your true desires, then you have free will. Another idea some compatibilists believe is that there is always a natural law that can explain an outcome, but......

Words: 895 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Why We Do What We Do

...RUNNING HEAD: Why We Do Why We Do What We Do “To be or not to be that is the question” (Shakespeare, 1945) most notably said in Shakespearian text. Today we ask the same question within our actions. Are we able to be ourselves in the decisions we make or are we not? In business we exam many problems and situations and act appropriately based the business needs and practices. In many cases the decisions we make our not within our means or not based on whom we are. Many business decisions are made with utilitarian approach. The decision is based not on the character of the person but the decision itself. Decisions like these can often make or break a company. “Character is a major component of leadership. This goes hand and hand with integrity and commitment will come naturally.”(Klann, 2007) Developing Character can lead to major personal achievements within an organization. Virtue Theory shifts the focus of decision making based on rules and regulations to morals and ethics based on one’s self being. This can be seen in a positive light depending on the business someone conducts. In many situations it can lead to difficult decision making when it comes to organizations that have to abide by certain policies and procedures that may not agree with an individual’s morals and ethics. “Is it wrong to steal a loaf of bread to feed your family…?” (Groening, 1989) Deontology brings us the dilemma of what the moral high ground is and why. Individual morality differs for each......

Words: 437 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Why We Do Not Do Drugs?

...The first cause is simple curiosity. Many teens have heard about drugs, and they are curious to experience them for themselves. They have heard that drugs can be fun, or make a person feel and act different. Maybe they have seen their friends or family members behave differently while on drugs, and they want to see how it really feels. We see drugs on TV and movies every day. Many young people encounter them at school, at home or in their neighborhood. It is not unusual to be curious about something you see and hear about so often, so many people first try drugs because they are curious about them. Another reason young people take drugs is to escape their reality. Maybe their home life is not very happy. Maybe they have a boring job, are not doing well in school, or are just not happy with their life for whatever reason. For many people, drugs are a way to escape that unhappy reality. They can feel a little braver, stronger, a little smarter, more beautiful or more important. Of course this doesn't last long, but that doesn't matter. For the brief time that the drugs are taking affect, the user can forget about the problems, responsibilities and limitations of everyday life and escape to a fantasy world. It is no secret that drugs change the way you feel; this is why they are so attractive to young people despite their dangers. Young people also take drugs to feel cool and impress their friends. If your friends all smoke marijuana, you will probably be expected to smoke it,......

Words: 492 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Do We Need Government

...Running head: DO WE NEED GOVERNMENT? Do We Need Government? If so, What Should be its Role Abstract The topic of government has always been a large area of conflict. In the following, I will discuss why we need a government and I believe we do need a government. First, do we need government and if so, what role should be its role? I began my paper by addressing these questions by looking at the United States Constitution. “We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.” People are the ones working alongside government to carry out these mandates stated in this important document. Do We Need Government? If so, What Should be its Role Role of Government In responding to the questions Do we need government? If so, what should be its role?, my answer has to be yes. Thomas Paine’s quote, “Government, even in its best state, is but a necessary evil; in its worst state, an intolerable one.” (Paine, 1995) is as true today as it was during the Revolutionary War when he wrote it. In my opinion, we need government and the government needs us, so that Americans can continue to work together with government in harmony, to keep our country growing and developing. Our forefathers escaped to the New......

Words: 1542 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Free Will; Do We Have It or Not

...Free Will; Do We Have it or Not The question of free will is one which has been hotly debated for millennia. Some people believe that humans have the capacity for free will - the ability to choose their actions without being forced to follow a certain course by either by the influence of others or by natural laws. For many theists, free will is regarded as a special gift from God. The notion of human free will is also an important premise for a lot of what happens in human society - in particular, when it comes to our legal system. Free will is necessary for the notion of personal responsibility. If people do not have free will, then it is difficult to argue that they are personally and morally responsible for their actions - and if that is the case, how can they be punished for their misdeeds? In fact, how can they be praised for the good things they do, if those actions were not also freely chosen? George Orwell did not have free will when it came to shooting the elephant. Orwell expresses his conflicting views regarding imperialism through three examples of oppression by his country, by the Burmese, and by himself on the Burmese. Thus he was not morally responsible. This made Orwell realize his role in society and has made him a stronger man. But first let’s see what led to his feeling toward the Burmese people. The building up of the feeling of pressure starts with Orwell feeling humiliated and disrespected from the Burmese and shifts to a feeling of......

Words: 1204 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Why Do We Have Organizations

...PSY 360-GS Assignment 1: Why do we have organizations? We are surrounded by organizations. What does organization mean? Why do we have organizations? What kind of impact organizations have in our in our society? These are many questions regarding organizations. In order to understand organizations we need define the meaning. When one reads the definition in the dictionary (Webster’s Pocket Dictionary 1990) it says “being organized or organized group; as a club”. In Wikipedia, it has a more definitive meaning indicating “social arrangement which pursues collective goals, which controls its own performance, and which has a boundary separating it from its environment”; two different sources with similar meanings. This gives us a broad idea the meaning of organization. Organization implies that group of individuals come together working / supporting a common goal. Everyone has a role and understands their responsibility in obtaining/ achieving the goal. We now understand the meaning of organization. Why do we have organizations? Organizations are the foundation of our being. It gives us structure on how to function in our day to day activities and helping in achieving the completion of common goal. It defines our role & the importance of our talent/skill to succeed in meeting our objective. By defining everyone’s role, it can maximize production efficiently in completing and meeting the group’s goal. It’s like a long chain...

Words: 387 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Do We Have to Allow Abortion

... Khetib Safi Myriame Should We Allow Abortion A baby is a human being, even if he is in his mom’s stomach. This action is not a new one, but the real debates about it have just begun because of the taboos that Islam impose. Abortion means to kill a baby when he or she is just a fetus. It has a lot of reasons, it can be wanted or sometimes a woman aborts for health reasons. However, a baby is a gift from God, and a mom who kills her baby knows that and has strong reasons to kill her own creation. Abortion may be prohibited by Islam, but nowadays, this act is considerate as a subject of conflicts between pros and cons. Therefore, I completely agree with those who fight to allowed abortion. Opponents of abortion say that this act is a crime and to kill a baby for any reason is against the law in Morocco and the punishment is prison and sometimes death penalty. They do not care on the reasons; So what can they say if I tell them that health is a reason that cannot be discussed? I found some cases that show that if a mother gives birth to a baby, she will die. Don’t they see that it is a danger for the mother? What will happen to this baby without his mother? In this case, there are some extreme cases in which the mother has AIDS or a handicap that will affect the baby. Are these risks to take just to have a baby? To care about the feelings of the baby, when he will growth is very important. It reminds me...

Words: 1167 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Are We Free

...answer was that of fate and free will. Do we have control on our life? We are so attached to it but does it really exist? Do we have the possibility to make our own choices or do we follow a predetermined path? I believe that the existence of free will mainly depends on many factors. First and foremost is how we define free will. I think it is the ability to choose any possible course of action without earlier determination by divine or physical forces. one of the major argument that can be made about this definition is the so called “Standard Argument Against Free Will” which considers determinism and randomness to be the only two logical alternatives. Divided in two parts, it states that if determinism is the case our will is not free, and if randomness is the case will is not under our control and therefore we cannot be held responsible for our actions. Thus it results fundamental in the debate to consider the belief in destiny, karma, God or every other creed that has a deterministic component in it, because free will appears totally incompatible with them. However my conjecture is that the other part of the argument, the one which concerns randomness, does not clash with it. I think that it is true that all events occur at a random moment in a random way but what makes the difference in our lives is how we react to these random events. Yet this definition of free will is still not complete. If we consider, for instance, Professor Libet’s experiment we realize that our......

Words: 529 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Why Do We Have Organizations?

...Essay question: Why do we have organizations Simply put, we could theorize we have organizations to accomplish a unified goal – we have organizations to get things done. From the first time a man met a woman and they had a family, we had an organization. The family unit has a unified goal of, at least, survival. Two or more family units together in the earliest age of Earth, had a goal of survival and, perhaps, comfort and company or society. Each organization going forth from this simplest structure exist for at least one reason, to get things done. From our earliest days, we are a part of or impacted by organizations every day. We are born into a family, as noted previously the simplest organization and with at least one unified goal. We may attend daycare and a public school. These organizations are more complex with multi-faceted goals. As we graduate high school and consider going to college, joining the military, or starting our careers, we will always be part of an organization, and likely multiple organizations. Each of these organizations exist to achieve a common goal. Society is a type of organization, so it is perhaps redundant to say we live in an organizational society. They, organizations, permeate every aspect of our lives. If we have a medical need, an educational need, a work need, there will be an organization that fulfills that need. They are the structures we move within day in and day out. From year 0 until we are here no longer; from our......

Words: 329 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How Free Are We?

...How free are we? Whilst I tend to think of myself an an individual and the choices that I make, I make on my own accord, this may not necessarily be the case (Furze et al., 2015. p. 6). Society may be unknowingly playing a part in my decision-making and therefore prohibiting freedom from being obtained by anyone. In my life, major decisions have been made, for example the choice to continue my schooling at university. The reason that this aspect of my life has been chosen is that I feel as though it makes sense. I felt that I was making my own decision by choosing to go to university. However, looking at the idea of society and the choices we make based on societies values, I believe I made a welcome choice. At the time I thought that the decision I made was just mine. However, delving further into this concept of real freedom, I now know that my then decision was not made with freedom intact. I realise that there were different social structures that were at work during the making of that decision. These structures being microstructures and macrostructures (Furze et al., 2015. p. 7). The microstructures refer to my family, friends and my work associations, and the macrostructures refer to the “social relations that lie outside and above your circle of intimates and acquaintances” (Furze et al., 2015. p. 7). The above social structures were processed consciously. I had no idea that I was going through one at a time ticking off whether each group would......

Words: 563 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Do We Have a Morally Acceptable Level of Privacy in This Kind of Society?

...Nakashima Phil 103 Prof. Denman – T 6:00PM 11/24/15 Do We Have A Morally Acceptable Level of Privacy In This Kind of Society? In today's world people are giving out and taking in information that because they are living in an IT-configured society. Most people all over the world are connected by some kind of technology, whether that be a phone, computer, or console. Being connected through technology is the fastest and best way to stay in touch with family, friends, and work. When using a computer, phone, or console you do not expect someone to be eavesdropping on what you are saying or typing. If you knew someone was eavesdropping on you, you would feel that your privacy was violated. The question of today's society is, do we have a morally acceptable level of privacy in this kind of society? In an IT-configured society, we should have some privacy to certain personal information and have our information gathered if and only if we give our consent. The importance of privacy, information gathering, and work are some focuses as to why privacy to certain personal information should be respected and retained if and only if given consent. When a person goes on to the internet they do not expect their information to be gathered and spread throughout the internet. Most people think that their privacy to personal information is important and that it should be respected. Shaw gave three aspects of our concern to privacy. “First, we want to control intimate or personal......

Words: 1247 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Are We Completely Free?

...Jean-Paul Sartre claims that man is completely free. To understand what this statement means, this essay will look at Existentialist philosophy and evaluate the central concepts namely freedom, anguish, abandonment and despair. Through analysing Sartre’s lecture entitled ‘Existentialism and Humanism’ and his book, ‘Being and Nothingness’ this essay will explain what he meant by this statement and will argue that while man is free to a certain extent, he is not completely free. Sartre delivered his lecture in a time of guarded optimism and unrest. The truth about the Nazi power and Auschwitz had just become known and the first atomic bomb had been dropped. People were becoming aware of how evil others could be and were looking for answers. There was a need to re-examine life as they knew it and Sartre, through Existentialism, offered a new approach to life. While Sartre himself later repudiated parts of his lecture it still remains his most widely read writing. (Philosophynow.org, 2016) Sartre used the word, ‘freedom’ which would have appealed to the people of that epoch having just been freed from Nazi occupation, however he says man is condemned to be free as he believed freedom came with great responsibility. The main reason for Sartre’s lecture was to defend Existentialism against its critics who thought it would lead to ‘quietism of despair’. They thought it was contemplative and would discourage people from taking action. Due to the words he used, namely anguish,......

Words: 2709 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

What Needs Do We Have for Seeding Machine Industry

...What Needs Do We Have for SEEDING MACHINE Industry? Seeding machine is the essential machine in corn processing and other grain processing. What’s the requirement for seeding machine manufacture? As people living standard rise, demand for food quality is becoming higher. Seeding machine is the main equipment for corn processing, which widely used in corn processing industry. With the continuous development of seeding machine, number of seeding machine manufacturers also increase, so, below are some requirements for seeding machine manufacture: The seeding machine plant should be built in the absence of harmful gases, smoke, dust, radioactive substances and other invasive pollution source region. The plant should guarantee good ventilation effect, reasonable design, which can meet the requirements of seeding machine production process, at the same time to ensure the production area separated from the living quarters. When seeding machine manufacturer plan to build the workshop, you should have enough space to ensure the material storage and transportation. Ensure the cleaning of plant and seeding machine, avoid the invasion of the rats, flies and other insects. Besides, Farmers' overall living level improves. Corn products from small scale of SEEDING MACHINE, and cannot meet their requirements for the bad flavor and taste. So many of them give up processing by themselves but going to shop to choose corn products. The grain planting structure is also changing.......

Words: 540 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

What Needs Do We Have for Seeding Machine Industry

...What Needs Do We Have for SEEDING MACHINE Industry? Seeding machine is the essential machine in corn processing and other grain processing. What’s the requirement for seeding machine manufacture? As people living standard rise, demand for food quality is becoming higher. Seeding machine is the main equipment for corn processing, which widely used in corn processing industry. With the continuous development of seeding machine, number of seeding machine manufacturers also increase, so, below are some requirements for seeding machine manufacture: The seeding machine plant should be built in the absence of harmful gases, smoke, dust, radioactive substances and other invasive pollution source region. The plant should guarantee good ventilation effect, reasonable design, which can meet the requirements of seeding machine production process, at the same time to ensure the production area separated from the living quarters. When seeding machine manufacturer plan to build the workshop, you should have enough space to ensure the material storage and transportation. Ensure the cleaning of plant and seeding machine, avoid the invasion of the rats, flies and other insects. Besides, Farmers' overall living level improves. Corn products from small scale of SEEDING MACHINE, and cannot meet their requirements for the bad flavor and taste. So many of them give up processing by themselves but going to shop to choose corn products. The grain planting structure is also changing.......

Words: 540 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Does Man Have Free Will

...Does man have free will? This question has been asked within the church since its inception. If man’s will is free then in a sense there is a part of creation that exists outside of God’s control, bringing His sovereignty into question. If man does not have free will his significance as the height of the created order is lessened. The question is further clouded by the fact that the Bible seems to support both ideas; that man is free and wholly responsible for his actions and that God is sovereign over every action within his creation. Paul Tillich describes the issue writing, “The question is whether the moral imperative is dependent on the divine grace for its actualization, or whether divine grace is dependent on the fulfillment of the moral imperative.”[1] This debate has been the cause of much disagreement throughout the history of the church. Brought to the forefront of debate by Augustine, arguing for the sovereignty of God, and Pelagius, arguing for the free will of man, the discussion over the relationship between God’s control and man’s ability has continued to this day. Later, during the reformation, Calvinists and Arminians continued the debate over the role man plays in the salvation process. This disagreement has caused Roger E. Olson to write, “We need to shoulder the responsibility of choosing between Calvinism and Arminianism. That does not mean choosing between Christianity and something else. It means choosing between two respectable......

Words: 3179 - Pages: 13

Greta Garbo | MiXLauncher_3 3_Prime apk | Harry Shannon