Premium Essay

Does the Punishment Fit the Crime in the Inferno

In: English and Literature

Submitted By jimmybud
Words 1128
Pages 5
The pardoner speaks of three men that lost their lives due to greed. This leaves the reader with the knowledge that money is the root of all evil.
Another aspect to consider is the greed of the pardoner. The pardoner seeks a commission from his audience for his tales. He himself is also one that is overtaken by money. Does he sincerely care about the condition of one's soul or is he just out for a quick buck? On page 9, the pardoner comments that his "holy pardon cures and will suffice/ So that it bring me gold, or silver brings/ Or else, I care not- brooches, spoons, or rings." Personally, I believe that the pardoner is willing to tell just about anything to receive money for himself. The story also portrays the effects that greed has on one's life. The tale of the three men overtaken with greed relates to this present decade of people. "Show me the money" has been the theme of this generation. Everyone is caught up in his or her own battle of gaining their share of the riches. This is very similar to the tale of the three men that struck gold under the oak tree. The men were concerned with how to travel with the money without looking like robbers as noted when they stated, "For men would say that we were robbers strong/ and we'd, for our own treasure, hang ere long" (p 7). They were not concerned about whose money they were stealing they cared only about their personal statue. They did not want to appear as robbers, so they planned to travel at night as seen in this quote on page 7, "This treasure must be carried home by night." The three travelers set out to slay death. An old man directed them to death's path. The path was under an oak tree that actually had a treasure of gold. In my opinion, the old man was very wise in pointing the fact out that death will be found at this tree. When the men reached the tree, they automatically begin to think only of…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Crime and Punishment

...Crime and Punishment Outline I. Introduction A. “What if man is not really a scoundrel, man in general, I mean, the whole race of mankind -- then all the rest is prejudice, simply artificial terrors and there are no barriers and it's all as it should be." Fyodor Dostoevsky, Crime and Punishment. B. In the short stories, The Most Dangerous Game by Richard Connell and The Destructors by Graham Greene, we will look at the similarities and differences in the characterization element of fiction as they relate to the crimes committed in the stories. II. Body A. The Most Dangerous Game by Richard Connell 1. Characters 2. Qualities and Motivations B. The Destructors by Graham Greene 1. Characters 2. Qualities and Motivations C. Comparisons of the Short Stories 1. The Most Dangerous Game crime 2. The Destructors crime III. Conclusion A. In the end of these two stories, “justice” was served. B. As the protagonists of the short stories, Rainsford and Trevor succeeded in “punishing” General Zaroff and Mr. Thomas for the crimes they committed while they in turn committed crimes themselves. Crime and Punishment “What if man is not really a scoundrel, man in general, I mean, the whole race of mankind-then all the rest is prejudice, simply artificial terrors and there are no barriers and it's all as it should be." Fyodor Dostoevsky, Crime and Punishment. When a crime is committed usually......

Words: 1099 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Punishment for Economic Crimes

...the punishment for economic crimes The history of economic/financial crimes is nearly as old as wealth itself. A white-collar crime is now synonymous with the full range of frauds committed by a business and/or government professionals in which the offender’s principal motive is economic gain. Fraud it’s not a victimless crime; a single scam or fraud can destroy a company, devastate families by wiping out their life savings, or cost investors billions of dollars. To combat white-collar crime, the U.S. Congress passed a wave of laws and statutes in the 1970s and 80s. The Racketeer Influence and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO) included things like embezzlement from union funds, bribery and mail fraud. RICO made it easier to prosecute corrupt organizations and seize assets related to corruption. When Enron and similar scandals broke out in the early 2000s, Congress took action. It passed the Sarbanes-Oxley Act Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) in 2002 to reduce unethical corporate behavior and decrease the likelihood of future corporate scandals (Kimmel, Weygandt & Kieso 2011). As a result of SOX, penalties for fraudulent financial activity are much more severe and now face longer sentences with less opportunity for early release (Podgor). In my opinion for the financial system to work properly, individuals that are privileged to manage hundreds of millions of dollars of other peoples' money must be held to a higher level of accountability that is proportionate to the...

Words: 364 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Crime and Punishment

...Crime and punishment The crimes previous to the Industrial Revolution were largely the same, excluding the introduction of crimes enabled by new technology i.e. going over the legal speed limit when driving a car. Examples of said crimes - assault, breaking the Peace, murder, petty treason, seditious words, coining. The crimes previous to the Industrial Revolution were largely the same, excluding the introduction of crimes enabled by new technology i.e. going over the legal speed limit when driving a car. Examples of said crimes - assault, breaking the Peace, murder, petty treason, seditious words, coining. Crimes before the Industrial Revolution Crime Technology – many new inventions in the early 20th century had an effect on crime, but the greatest of these by far was the motor car. Aeroplanes also made international transport and smuggling easier. Beliefs – religious beliefs were declining and attitudes were shaped more by the media rather than the churches. This meant that people were less likely to see some crimes as bad as they would have done when society was shaped by religion. Government – the welfare state that was begun by the Liberals in 1906 gave greater security to all citizens. Although this meant that there was less chances of people living in poor conditions and in poverty, it also meant that there were more laws surrounding the welfare state that could be broken. Car crime The first car appeared on the road in Britain in 1894, by 1930......

Words: 750 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Crime and Punishment

...Society’s response to crime has impacted public policy differently over the years. The way crime and punishment has evolved over the years has been tremendous, but still has the same goal, punishment for a crime committed. The need for crime and punishment has and probably always will be a debate, but in the end what matters most is rehabilitating the criminal to reduce recidivism rates. Society’s views on crime and punishment have always had the same result in mind. Society wants an offender of a crime to be punished and pay for what they have done. The first formal legal code was created in 1780 BCE. The king of Babylonia created the Code of Hammurabi. These laws set out specific crimes and punishments, and had the principle of “an eye for an eye”. (Siegal, 2014). During this time, criminals were punished in proportion to their crime; a thief that was caught had his hand cut off. During the middle ages, the first correctional institutions were developed. These institutions were generally not used as a means of correction, only as a detention until the criminal could be punished by execution, corporal punishment, or exile. (Siegal, 2014). Today, the use of cruel and public punishment are no longer used; hanging, decapitations, torturing, etc. However, incarceration for life and execution are still used for most serious crimes. (Siegal, 2014) The need for punishments for crimes is still in debates. Dr. Karl Menninger argues that most criminals are sick and......

Words: 825 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Dante's Inferno How the Punishment Fits the Crime

...It’s an adventure, a tale, a dream (or nightmare) of different historical, biblical, and Greek gods and creatures living their lives in the afterlife of the underground world. Each level has its own form of punishment fitting the crime one has committed. Level one, Limbo: for those who have not acted upon sin to be punished for, but rather didn’t accept Christ as their savior. Those in Limbo aren’t harmed or living in suffering. They live in a deficient form of heaven. The place is green and peaceful, but the people there are full of sorrow and sadness. Because they lacked the initiative to accept God, they are punished by not being put in heaven and instead rest in a place that’s almost like it, minus state of mind of living in eternity with an overwhelming feeling of joy. They did not turn away from God, but at the same time did not let Him in their lives. The people here live in constant hope that God will again descend from Heaven and save their souls like he has before, but their desire is the only thing they live off of. Those that have sought after lust or have let it control their lives are stuck in the second level of hell. They are swayed restlessly by the strong winds of a storm. They are the first ones to be punished in hell. “the sins or crimes are mostly those of passion or weakness; in the second circle, for example, they encountered the adulterers Paolo and Francesca, who had been overcome by passion. Virgil tells Dante that the violent......

Words: 1227 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Crime and Punishment

...There are five punishment philosophies used in the criminal justice system, deterrence, rehabilitation, incapacitation, retribution, and restoration.   (Meyer & Grant, 2003)   The goal of each philosophy is to prevent criminal offenses from occurring.   The first philosophy is deterrence, this philosophy tries to convince people not to commit crimes or violate laws.   When a person decides not to do something like parking in a handicapped space because they will be fined for breaking the law, this is called deterrence.   Officers can decide to write a warning instead of taking formal actions like having the offender appear in court.   (Meyer & Grant, 2003)   The two types of deterrence used are known as general and specific.   Specific deterrence or is when an offender decides not commits future crimes.   General deterrence is a person decides not to commit a crime, because others were punished for similar crimes and do not want to deal with the punishment if caught.   The philosophy of rehabilitation is when the criminal justice system tries to end criminal behavior by “curing” offenders of breaking the law.   (Meyer & grant, 2003)   Under the philosophy of rehabilitation a crime occurs when a criminal or “sick person” commits a crime.   The person has a physical illness, psychological disorders, or a social disorder that causes them to commit these criminal offenses.   The offenders that the system deems rehabilitated are paroled and released from prison.  ......

Words: 283 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Crime and Punishment

...Crime and Punishment: A Dissection of its Various Elements. “The true measure of crimes is the harm done to society” – Cesare Beccaria. Crime as a concept and its origin There is no easy definition for what denotes a crime. Any theory on criminal law has to answer two questions – ‘What acts should be punished?’ and ‘To what extent can it be punished?’ Glanville Williams, admitting the impossibility of a workable content based definition of a crime, points out that the definition of crime is one of the thorny intellectual problems of law. Russell also admitted that ‘to define crime is a task which so far has not been satisfactorily accomplished by any writer’ Personal safety, particularly security of life, liberty and property, is of utmost importance to any individual. Man realized this when he started living in a community. He realized that he had certain rights. Rights are essentially conditions for self-development. At the same time he understood that he was also obligated to behave in the same manner in which he expected his neighbour to behave. This was the crux of the social contract which man entered into with his fellow beings. The social contract allowed men to live together in a community and leave behind the “nasty, short and brutish” life he led hitherto. The social contract paved way for the State to come into force and start making laws for everyone. Naturally, the rational and selfish nature of man would make him look out for his best interests......

Words: 3376 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Crime and Punishment

...Crime and punishment considered by many as the magnum opus of Dostoevsky, graphically essays the tragic tale of murder, guilt, suffering and redemption, unfolding in an utmost dismal setting of St. Petersburg of the mid-19th century. The central character of the story is Rodion Romanovitch Raskolnikoff , a man with little means oftener found lost in reverie gets possessed with an idea, a theory of his own about ‘ extraordinary men being above the law’, and in order to bring ‘’ new thoughts ‘’ into the society they have a moral license or authority to even deprive a man from his basic right to live . He then sets out to put his theory into practice and as a consequence murders an old woman. The story gyrates around this murder. Through raskolnikoff Dostoevsky provides an in-depth exploration of the psychology of a criminal. The inner world of Raskolnikoff, with all of its doubts, deleria, second-guessing, fear, and despair, is the heart of the story. Dostoevsky does not lay emphasis on the actual repercussions of the murder but the way the murder forces Raskolnikoff to deal with tormenting guilt. Indeed, by focusing so little on Raskolnikoff’s imprisonment, he seems to suggest that the actual punishment by law is much less terrible than the stress and anxiety of trying to avoid this punishment. Further through the portrayal of extreme guilt, suffering accompanied with love Dostoevsky paves the way for raskolnikoff’s redemption from the crime committed Not only raskolnikoff...

Words: 288 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Crime and Punishment

... How St. Petersburg represents Raskolinkov’s State of Mind Devvyn E. Rhodes I.B. English, P.2 Woodrow Wilson High School Woodrow Wilson High School Abstract In the book Crime and Punishment the author, Feodor Dostoevsky tells a story about a man named Raskolinkov that struggles with an internal and external decision making that leads him to committing a murder. Changing his state of mind as he dwells in the city of St. Petersburg, the author provides the reader with a suggestion of representation between the main character, Raskolinkov and the city of St. Petersburg. The representation of the city being a ruin, and as well Raskolinkovs mind. I found how his mind struggles, as well the city of St. Petersburg struggles on a loose foundation of poverty, moral decay, and chaos. How St. Petersburg represents Raskolinkov’s State of Mind In the first page Feodore Dostoevsky’s “Crime and Punishment”, the city of St. Petersburg is resembled as a low down, dirty, and stifling place to be where men squander around bars blatantly drunk, where women sell themselves on corners for a cheap price; where children have looks of despair written across their faces, as they beg on the streets, digging through the trash cans for a chance of finding some food to stay alive (1). This is an example of a city that is falling to its ruins. Ruins are the leftovers of what there once was, and signifies as the......

Words: 1372 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Notes on Crime and Punishment for Re

...Crime and punishment why do we need laws · if there were no rules there would be chaos · if there were now laws about business deals and work, society ould not operate · we need laws to protect the weak from the strong · we need laws to keep everything organised why does there need to be a connection between the law and justice · if the law is unjust, people will feel that it is right to break the law · if the law is unjust, they are not fulfilling their purpose of making sure that people are rewarded for their work. · if the laws dont create a just society , people will think the legal system isnt working and might start a civil war. · if laws are unjust, they will disrupt rather than unite society. theories of punishment 1. retribution is the theory that criminals should pay for their crimes because : · it makes criminals pay for their crimes in proportion to the crime committed . · it make s the criminals suffer for their crimes · it punishes the criminal. 1. deterrence is the theory that the punishment should put people off committing crimes . 2. reform is the theory tht criminals should be taught not to commit crime again.Many people think this is the best way because: · the onl way to stop crime is to turn criminals into law abiding citizens. · most criminals have had a bad upbringing and they do no know how to live without crime. · gives criminals meansto find propper jobs and stay out of trouble 1. protection is the theory......

Words: 1020 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Crime and Punishment Literary Analysis

...imagination at work. Such ideas can be used to explain the dreams of Raskolnikov in Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s novel, Crime and Punishment. Dostoyevsky’s use of imagery, symbolism and foreshadowing, in each Aspect of the dream reflect facets of Raskolnikov's complex personality and his attitude toward the crime he intends to commit. In his dream, Raskolnikov imagines himself as a young boy with his father. As they were walking, they noticed a drunken man, Mikolka, and a group of his drunk friends beating his horse to death for failing to walk while pulling an overloaded cart. Many aspects of the dream served as a symbol. The beaten horse in the dream, symbolizes Alyona, who Raskolnikov had planned to murder, while the young boy, Raskolnikov, and Mikolka together symbolize both sides of Raskolnikov’s conflicting conscience. While the young raskolnikov was pained by the brutal treatment shown to the horse, Mikolka felt as if the horse was useless to him and that she wasn’t doing any good for society and the people around her, and therefore deserved to die. The young boy represents the soft side of Raskolnikov that knows the crime he plans to commit is wrong. On the other hand Mikolka represented the side of Raskolnikov that believed that Alyona’s death would be a benefit to society. This showed that Raskolnikov wasn’t sure of himself, and that although he felt his crime would be justified, part of him knew it was morally wrong. Foreshadowing is also seen in the brutal way the......

Words: 498 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Crime and Punishment Hs

...Crime and Punishment Currently punishment for crimes committed is different for a juvenile than it is for an adult. Why would it be a different punishment for the same crime between juveniles and adults? Can juveniles really learn from their crime? What if the juveniles make the court believe that they learned from their mistake and they got out of jail and commit the same crime but worse. Is it really cruel and unusual to sentence life without parole to juveniles? Juveniles that commit extremely bad crimes should not be punished; who in their right mind thinks they should not be punished? Is life in prison with or without parole a better option for juveniles? It all comes down to what the juvenile did, and if the juvenile and the adult made the same mistake, they should get the same punishment. It should always be fair between adults and juveniles; there is no difference because they made the same mistake, a crime is a crime. To begin with, can juveniles really learn from their mistakes? Some juveniles can and others can't. Well how will the court make the right decision? For example a juvenile gains trust from the court and gets out of jail early but when they exactly get out of jail they go to a party and kill someone. It is the juveniles responsibility to not get in trouble because they have to be role models for the next generation of juveniles and be the adults. Juveniles can learn from their mistakes but there are always the juveniles that lose the opportunity...

Words: 620 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Analysis of Crime and Punishment

...Jada Williams-Davis Per.2nd 3/28/2013 CRIME AND PUNISHMENT Prompt: 2004, Form B In Dostoevsky’s novel “Crime and Punishment”, Raskolnikov is the main character as the story is told almost exclusively through his point of view. Raskolnikov decides to plan his idea of the perfect crime, the murder of an old woman who is a pawnbroker, but when he actually commits the crime he embraces both a mental and physical devastation throughout the rest of the novel. The psychological journey the reader takes as they read the novel arises from this particular crime. Dostoevsky depicts the twisted mind of Raskonikov before and after his murder, making it evident what drives him to commit the crime and why. The story begins with Raskolnikov, a former student, who appears to be completely alienated from the world around him. He seems to have this resentment toward humanity leaving him to always remain alone. He already had an idea regarding the crime and had planned this out thoroughly but yet, he still could not bring himself to it. He is unsure and it is apparent in the context that he was dealing with an affective internal conflict. The reader sees how he struggles with his uncertainty “If I am so scared now, what would it be if it somehow came to pass that I were really going to do it?” He thought just before he visited the old woman. The reader can apprehend how he is reluctant to the idea of literally murdering her but he also still has the desire to do it. This idea......

Words: 663 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Crime and Punishment Essay

...satisfies this curiosity, leaving the reader informed and fulfilled. In Fyodor Dostoevsky’s Epilogue in Crime and Punishment, there have been speculations in regards to if the epilogue had any sort of significance. This argument sways both ways, but in the case of Crime and Punishment the books identity would be altered if the epilogue were to be absent. Ultimately, the role of the epilogue plays a vital role and is indeed necessary in the establishment of this novel. The epilogue gives the audience a accurate view on the character of Raskolnikov, allows them to see through his imperfections. It ties up any loose ends that the readers may have and most importantly displays the strong affection Raskolnikov and Sonia possess. Crime and Punishment’s epilogue truly uncovers Raskolnikov’s class as a human being. The audience can appreciate that fact that Raskolnikov is not a complete selfish human being, that he is capable of portraying acts of selflessness. Throughout most of the novel, Raskolnikov is characterized as a man who only thinks about himself. He in visions himself as a human of elite status, and the consequences of the average human do not apply to him. This theory of his is reveled to be just a fictional thought when he eventually derails from sanity shortly after the murder he committed. While Raskolnikov is consistently portrayed to be a self-interested man, he does embody acts of affection. Within the epilogue Raskolnikov has be seen doing many noble deeds......

Words: 1176 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Crime and Punishment

...Crime and Punishment Jessica Maxa 08-06-2012 Colorado Technical University Ms. Lisa The 5th amendment of the United States Constitution says introduces us to the double jeopardy clause. It is stated that no defendant shall stand trial more than once for the same charge brought against them. A defendant is put in jeopardy as soon as the jury is sworn in. If the case is dismissed then a new trial may be deemed necessary. Double jeopardy protects defendants only for retrials brought within the first jurisdiction; this meaning a defendant can be tried in federal court after being tried in state court. The double jeopardy clause will give the defendant a guarantee that they will not receive more than one punishment per offense (Legal Information Institute, 2010). In the United States a defendant has the right not be testify in his or her jury trial; this is a privilege made to us as citizens by the 5th amendment. The client with the help legal advice from an attorney should weigh this option heavily before making this decision. There are a few reasons that the defendant should not take the witness stand they are things such as If the defendant has previously been convicted of a crime, the prosecutor may be able to bring this fact to light which will lead to discrediting the character and reputation of the witness. Some defendants have a fear of speaking in public which could impair the ability to get out what they are trying. A jury may not believe a defendant, who,......

Words: 915 - Pages: 4

Printing & Graphic Arts | The Walking Dead Season 9 torrent | Busou Chuugakusei Basket Army OVA Episode 3 English Subbed