Premium Essay

Has the Relationship Between the Federal Government and the States Been Controversial Since 2000?

In: Other Topics

Submitted By boriszaykof
Words 1055
Pages 5
The relationship has in fact been incredibly controversial since 2002 as it had gone against previous patterns, specifically the notion that Republican presidents support states’ rights and dislike big government. It could be argued that this was due to many extraneous factors that caused the presidents to act in a certain previously unseen manner. Obama also caused huge controversies and caused further confusion in the relationship between states and the federal government. Even so, it could be argued that even though some parts of the relationship could be seen as controversial at first glance, they are sometimes actually following the ideological beliefs of the president in a way that may not seem too obvious. Therefore, even though there have been certain aspects which have either improved or not been incredibly controversial in the relationship between the federal government and states, in the majority of time the relationship has been incredibly controversial.

A reason why their relationship has been so controversial is due to extraneous factors which forced the president to act in a way that is contrary to his political stand on states’ rights. Bush faced many problems which had to be immediately acted upon, but in order to do so, he had to take away certain rights that were previously given to the states. For example he passed the “No Child Left Behind Act” in 2001, which meant that the children had to be tested at the end of each year in order to ensure that their education was up to a certain standard. That was an incredibly controversial act as it meant that the federal government was interfering with states and forcing them to act on certain policies which they may not have previously agreed with or supported. However it has not been so controversial because it was imminent that states will lose some of their rights as certain issues affected the…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Historically the State Has Been the Main Engine of Development

...The concept of the state in relation to development has been analyzed under different theories. First of all the state refers to a modern and western way to operate under a unify authority in each field in order to achieve the interest of the whole society. The state’s principal charge was to accelerate industrialization, modernizing agriculture, providing infrastructure that are necessary for the urbanization and improve living condition (i.e. health, education, welfare). Growth-oriented states pursued their commitment by developing trade and industry with well-designed, consistent, and thoroughly implemented policies. Specific policy measures varied but were generally aimed at easing supply-and-demand constraints faced by private entrepreneurs. Some of these interventions were direct, and others, indirect. On the supply side, for example, the capitalist states helped facilitate the availability of capital, labor, technology, and even entrepreneurship. Thus supply of capital was boosted at times by superior tax collection and public investment, at other times by using publicly controlled banks to direct credit to preferred private firms and sectors, and at yet other times by allowing inflation to shift resources from both agriculture and urban labor to private industrialists. In this essay there will be two ideal-typical historical patterns of how state authority is organized and used in the developing world: neo-patrimonial states and developmental state. Firstly the......

Words: 1287 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Politics and Its Relationship Between the Government and the State’s Minority Citizens

...Political science is governed by five myths: that it studies politics; that it is scientific; that it is possible to study politics separated off from economics, sociology, and history; that the state in our democratic capitalist society is politically neutral, that is available as a set of institutions and mechanisms to whatever group wins the election; and that political science, as a discipline, advances the cause of democracy.1 Politics, in the broadest sense, is the activity through which people make, preserve and amend the general rules under which they live. Politics is the process of who gets what, when, and how. Lastly, politics is a process of allocating scarce values.2 Various theorists and concepts define what the role of politics is in order to help us get a better understanding of how the study of politics is useful. Politics help us to understand the relationship between the government and the state’s minority citizens. Plato, the student of Socrates, defined politics in his own way. The ideal government proposed by Plato was the adherence of each individual to “universally valid principles” aimed at improving the lives of all the citizens instead of increasing power, prestige, or material wealth of a select few. Plato believed that this ideal government would be ran by individuals ho were full of wisdom and virtue instead of charisma and cunning. This is because in Athenian democracy, leaders were irrationally chosen based on irrelevant details such as......

Words: 1205 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

United States Has Undergone Massive Expansions Since Its Humble Beginnings

...The United States has undergone massive expansions since its humble beginnings. One such expansion started in 1848 in what is now known as the Gold Rush. After President James K Polk validated claims of gold found in California, the rush began (PBS, 2006). Tales of riches to be had from the mining of gold caused massive amounts of people from all over the United States and beyond to migrate into California. The chance of making a better life from the easy money that could be made from the gold was, to many irresistible. According to Eyewitness to History, the population in San Francisco, California rose from seventy-nine buildings in April 1847 to about one hundred thousand buildings by December of 1849 (“The California Gold Rush”, 2003). As California was not yet a part of the United States this significant increase in population could have only helped to insure California be included into the United States and allow the United States expand its borders. Gold was just one of many reasons for some people to migrate out west, fertile farmland was another. People are always looking for a chance to have a better life and this is no different from those farmers who migrated into the western plains. Farmers began to clear the land and the wheat that they had planted began to rise in value so much that even more land was cleared and more farming was done. That is until in 1931 when after the land had been overly farmed, a massive drought occurred (“The Dust......

Words: 696 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Roles of State & Federal Governments in Employment Regulation

...Roles of State & Federal Governments in Employment Regulation Angela McIntosh Sullivan University Employment Law HRL404 Abstract This paper will provide an overview of the State and Federal regulations in employment and discuss relevant employment regulations. The findings will explain on how in today work environments that the business climate of companies seem to subject to a wide variety of laws and regulations. With these components in dealing with the regulated in benefits for employees that has become a particularly crucial issue in the past several years. State and Federal regulations play a large role in how a company treats its employees while at work. These laws ensure that those workers that report in dealing with the wrong doing of their employees are not discriminated. In concluding the State and Federal government have made sure that protection to the interest of the workers to carrying out their duties in a prudent manner and refrain from conflict of interest transactions specifically prohibited by law. The enforcement of the federal and the state minimum wage law to be enforced in the working field. The Federal Government has set up specific laws that apply to the regulation of unions and allows workers to join unions. The National Labor Relations Act allows the workers the option of joining an association. The government established the National Labor Relations......

Words: 1706 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Relationship Between Public and Private Policing

...Relationship Between Public and Private Policing Dana L. Dvorak Bellevue University Abstract This paper will explore the historical relationship between public and private policing. It will also discuss how the relationship has changed in recent years. Relationship Between Public and Private Policing Since the terrorist attacks that struck inside the heart of our country on 11 September 2001, civilian law enforcement agencies have been busy performing not only their regular duties of crime prevention and response, but also taking on a large number of homeland security functions and all of this during a time when local, state and federal budgets are ever tightening. Similarly, private security institutions are under comparable pressure to carry out their traditional duties to provide protection of information, property and people, as well as sharing the additional duties of homeland security. Despite the fact that public and private police organizations share the same ultimate goal of protecting the public, they do not have a long history of working well together. Security officers have historically been looked down upon by law enforcement personnel. Some police feel that there is a definite lack of pre-employment screening, certification, training, standards, and regulation of security officers. Other police officers feel that security personnel receive insufficient training, especially those who carry weapons. Another perception that some police have is...

Words: 1566 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Agriculture Trend Between 1980 & 2000

...of agriculture has fallen slightly from 1980 to 2000, the total productivity has increased constantly (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2008).This inverse trend between GDP growth and the proportion of agriculture is common in developed countries. In 2000, agricultural industry reached 4 per cent ($25 billion) of GDP and this proportion remains one of the highest in the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries (Australian Government Productivity Commission, 2005).There are several reasons for this upward trend during this period, which are specifically, advanced technology, change in farm structure, the change in demands, and trade. Even though there has been negative impact on agriculture, those four areas have led to the high performance of agricultural productivity during this period. Over the last thirty years, the use of technology in the agricultural industry in Australia has changed and improved dramatically. Layton states that one of the key elements to increase in supply is new and more efficient technology (2012, p67). The adoption of new technology is essential for farmers to maintain the level of profitability and to shift production possibility frontier out (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2008). For instance, satellite technology has been installed when making decisions on land use and some larger farms have invested in more sophisticated machinery and equipment to produce crops more efficiently. Technology has been developed to......

Words: 1671 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Multiple Governments and Intergovernmental Relationships

...Multiple Governments and Intergovernmental Relationships LaShon Thomas POL 215 September 18, 2014 Dr. David Waldman Multiple Governments and Intergovernmental Relationships The founding fathers created the constitution, outlaying the branches of government and clarifying their roles and responsibilities, providing a checks and balances system. It is comprised of three branches, the Executive Branch, the Legislative Branch, and the Judicial Branch. Each state, city and county has its own constitution that outlines the levels of local government. In the beginning, the idea was to create a government that could efficiently establish laws and enforce them, but also ensure that no one person or one group of people could not possess all of the power. Although the constitution offers the ability of all states to work together as one, it also sanctions the sovereignty of each state. However, to govern effectively and protect the rights of the people, all of these entities must work together in harmony to resolve issues. Advantages of Intergovernmental Relationships While state government has the most authority over the lives of the people through state laws and taxes, they often partner with the U.S. government to govern efficiently. This form of governing has its advantages and disadvantages. This theory allows the U.S. government to manage higher level situations such as international relationships as well as allocate funds or resource for issues pertaining to......

Words: 1447 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Differences Between the State and Federal Court System

...DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE STATE AND FEDERAL COURT SYSTEMS 2 Differences Between the State and Federal Court Systems Both the state government and federal government have their own separate court systems. They select their judges differently, hear different types of cases, and are structured a bit differently as well. The states use different types of ways to select their judges for their courts. In some states, voters get to vote for their judges during elections. In other states, the governor appoints their judges. Each state indicates the number of years that the judges will serve. In the case for federal judges, they are elected differently. The President of the United States nominates the judges and then the Senate confirms each nomination. Typically, federal judges hold office for lifetime, unless they are impeached. Judges can be impeached for misconduct and have to go through Congressional impeachment proceedings. Different types of cases are heard in state and federal courts. In the state courts, typically, criminal cases, contract cases, family matters, etc. are heard. In the federal courts, cases that are heard are those that involve violation of laws of the United States, public ministers, bankruptcy, disputes between two different states, etc. Depending on each case, the case will be heard upon the state court or the federal courts. This is due to the different laws each state has. For example, Illinois’ laws are different from...

Words: 580 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Discuss the Process of Reconciliation Between Indigenous Australians and the Federal Government.

...Discuss the process of reconciliation between indigenous Australians and the federal government. Reconciliation is a process for Aboriginal Australians together with Torres Strait islanders and white Australians to be united as one. The reason why the government needed to reconcile is because it should uphold a harmonious and stable development in the society. Though the Australian government has recognised their mistakes and has said sorry to the Aboriginal Australian people in an attempt to reconcile, it is still not enough for the Aboriginal people. The Aboriginal people still need to deal with the agonising memories that the white government has caused. Rather than apologising verbally, they should improve the economic, education and living conditions for Aboriginal people. In this essay will be discussed the government did wrong in the past. Next, a discussion the process of reconciliation, the way they have improved the relationship with Aboriginal Australian people. Finally will talk about why the apology is not enough for Aboriginal people. In order to discuss what the government did wrong thing in the past, we need to understand what the stolen generation is. The stolen generation describe the event where the Aboriginal children were forcibly removed from their families by the government and assimilated into white society (Korff, 2015). In the past the white government did make many mistakes. According the movie ‘Rabbit Proof Fence’ (2000), there was a scene......

Words: 1119 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Federal Government Prevention of Bullying

...Federal Government Prevention of Bullying We have all heard the words; the words that tear us down and break us apart. A person can only bend so far before they break. No one is immune to it, we are all capable of bullying. By no means is bullying right; often times the repercussions of being bullied are devastating. Although there is no Federal law currently in place to prevent bullying, there are discrimination and harassment laws and many states have anti-bullying laws; there is hope for the Federal government to follow suit in enacting anti-bullying laws. Bullying in the United States is continuing to get expand, but the awareness of bullying is also increasing. There are several ideas of what exactly bullying is. The most common definition of bullying is “purposeful attempts to control another person through verbal abuse - which can be in the tone of voice or in content such as teasing or threats.” Sometimes the verbal abuse turns into physical abuse. Bullying is not limited to just schools; bullying is taking place in workplaces, homes, nursing homes and even in the military ("Why do People Bully?"). Research has proven that bullying happens more frequently in the middle school age years than any other school years (“New ways to stop bullying”). Over 160,000 children stay home from school every day in fear of being bullied (“Bullying and Suicide”). Seven percent of eight grade students stay home at least one day a month due to continued bullying and harassment by......

Words: 2954 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

To What Extent Has the British Constitution Been Effectively Reformed Since 1997?

...The new Labour government took power in 1997 began to reform the British constitution, introducing the Human rights act, Devolution and some reform of the House of Lords among other less important changes. Unfortunately Labour did not complete those reforms and a great deal was left undone. The question since then is how much has the constitution been reformed and how positive effect these reforms have had. There is no doubt that the HRA has transformed Britain. It created a means by which government and other bodies could be prevented from abusing our rights. The courts were given powers to enforce rights. This has meant that we now have more privacy and have the right to be treated equally under the law. However, the HRA was not made biding on Parliament and so governments can still abuse rights. This has been seen with anti-terrorism acts which give the police great powers including the ability to arrest suspects without trial. The HRA also does not protect us against the growth of surveillance and stop search powers or the prevention of some demonstrations. Similarly, the FOI act has been partly effective as it enabled us to know about the MP’s expense scandal and other aspects of government. However government can still conceal sensitive information thus perhaps the act should have been stronger. The introduction of Devolution as well supported in Scotland and Wales has made a huge difference in those countries as well as in Northern Ireland, the people of those......

Words: 844 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Evolving Role of State and Federal Government in U.S.Education

...Cheryl Chamblin August 07, 2011 Exploring Education as a Profession Latonya Pitts The Evolving Role of State and Federal Government in U.S. Education America established with the right to choose the religion that suited the people a right that is taken very seriously among the people of America. They escaped countries where they were forced to worship in one way. When they came to America, That freedom made America great. That freedom can also cause quite a bit of controversy in the public school system. The American public school system is not equipped to deal with the many different religions that the American families may have. The public education system has changed throughout the years as different amendments were added to the United States Constitution. This paper will examine certain cases that that have influenced the American school system. The separation of church and state in the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution is a separation of personal beliefs that is so different then one another and this makes religion a complicated issue for the public schools (Davis, 2003). Many significant cases have been set to change the direction of education to provide an equal education system Lau versus Nichols in 1974 under the fourteenth amendment of equal protection clause. This case under the Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits federally, funded programs from discriminating of the basis of race and national origin. This......

Words: 782 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Relationship Between Public and Private Police

...Relationship between Private and Public Police The relationship between public and private police has always been a one that is on the outskirts of each other. There is a thin line between what a private officer can and cannot do when it comes to enforcing the laws and rules on a property, there comes a point where they need the assistance of public officers who have the training and legal authority to handle a certain individual or situation. Although many of the individuals in the private sector have the same training as any public officer they cannot help in the situation because local laws set in place limit their authority. Although many states are starting to incorporate the private sector of security with the public side of it, it is a major work in progress. Private sectors do not receive the respect they deserve from the public because they do not have the same legal standpoint as public officers, with laws allowing private security the same authority as public officer a partnership could be works to have an officer in more square miles than there are now. If the public and private system join together and work with each other crimes could be solved faster and criminals could be caught faster. The separations of private and public security departments have been can be noted since the boom of private security companies in the early 2000’s and can be seen even before these years as private security has been around since the early 60’s, there are now major......

Words: 1013 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

The Dueling Banjos State vs. Federal

...Banjos (State vs. Federal) The United States Judicial System Dee Montano CJA/204 April 3, 2012 Sherre D. Corniel The Dueling Banjos (State vs. Federal) The United States Judicial System Frustration, confusion, and complexity; these three words can and are used regularly to describe the justice system within the United States. A better understanding of the history, principles, and role of the dual court system is necessary for a comprehensive understanding of the American justice system. FEDERALISM vs. ANTI-FEDERALISM The roots of the modern court system in the United States can be found in the principle of federalism. When the delegates met in Philadelphia for the Constitutional Convention among other issues that needed to be addressed was a national judicial system; the Articles of Confederation was woefully inadequate in providing for this. The dual judicial system that exists today was given life with the passage of Article III of the U.S. Constitution ("[t]he judicial Power of the United States, shall be vested in one Supreme Court, and in such inferior Courts as the Congress may from time to time ordain and establish.") Article III was a compromise between the Federalists, supporters of a strong central government, who thought that the federal judiciary should contain all of the courts (trial, appellate, and supreme). Whereas the Anti-Federalists, proponents of states’ rights, believed that an all-inclusive federal judiciary would minimize states’......

Words: 1654 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

A Relationship on the Rocks: the United States and Israel Since 1948

...A Relationship on the Rocks: The United States and Israel Since 1948 Adrienne Jacobs American Foreign Policy Dr. Dua May 2012 The relationship between the United States is one of the most turbulent and debated relationships in world history. Throughout the ages, since its establishment in 1948, Israel has been confronted with eight different American presidents, and eight varying attitudes toward Israel as a state, how the US-Israeli relationship should be dealt with, and the question of Palestine and its people. In this piece, we will review the history of the US-Israeli relationship in six episodes of history, and how US foreign policy on Israel has shifted over the decades to what it is today, and we will then discuss the prospect for Israel, Israel-Palestine, and US-Israel relations in the coming presidential term. Professor Robert Lieber of Georgetown University, and expert on US-Israeli relations asserts that the relationship between the United States and Israel in the past six decades can be separated into two schools of thought: the “special relationship paradigm,” and “national interest orientation.” The United States chose to be the first to recognize the State of Israel because at the time in 1948, and until today, the US Government believed that it shares certain common values and political aims. Under the special relationship paradigm, which still serves today as the basis of US support of Israel, the Truman Administration felt that Israel, like the......

Words: 2630 - Pages: 11

Vintage Camera Shoulder Neck Strap For Nikon Canon Sony Panasonic SLR DSLR UK | avril 2017 | Les Garçons sauvages