Free Essay

Impact of Precautionary Principle

In: Other Topics

Submitted By celliessays
Words 1290
Pages 6
To what extent did the precautionary principle assume significance in UK environmental law?

In the last few decades the Precautionary Principle has gained significance within the realm of modern environmentalism. It appears, although not always explicitly, in national legislation, international statements of policy, treaties etc. Despite its development, there is no commonly agreed definition of the Precautionary Principle nor is there any guidance on how to implement it. Its central role is to guide administrators and regulators who make decisions or develop policy in circumstances where there is no conclusive scientific proof of a clear link between the relevant action or substance and the harm“on the grounds that it is better to be roughly right in due time, bearing in mind the consequences of being very wrong, than to be precisely right too late.”
The first detailed reference to the Precautionary Principle in the UK was featured in the government's White Paper on the Environment, entitled "This Common Inheritance”. It put forward a weaker formulation of the Precautionary principle on the basis that you have to ensure that you balance the costs and benefits in order to dismiss any lack of scientific certainty when taking action against significant risks. It was weakened further in a sub-section of the White paper where it was made clear that all decisions relating to the environment had to “…look at all the facts and likely consequences of actions of the basis of the best scientific evidence available.” Following this, it is clear that there is a privileging of science over other forms of knowledge as it is assumed that science can soundly arrive at predictions and policy judgements and should be the basis of all precautionary measures. This suggests that the Precautionary Principle has a very limited role in the UK and its actual philosophy is more likened to the Preventive Principle; the aim of which is to prevent damage to the environment once the damage is known.
Conversely, there have been cases in the UK courts in which it has been discussed such as in R v Leicester City Council where the court acknowledged that the principle could have some doctrinal effect in UK law. However, Richards J was critical of this, arguing that it could not be simply argued as a “rigid principle that can only furnish one result.” In other words, it could only be viewed as a consideration. In Duddridge, Smith J effectively held that the principle did not have direct effect. From this we could understand Smith J to be saying that the principle is non-justiciable. In R v Derbyshire County Council, Maurice K J “it may in some fields of regulation be relevant to take into account the precautionary principle” but added that its limitations were more important.

Although the principle has proven to not be directly effective in domestic courts, domestic law has involved aspects of it, suggesting it is significant to an extent. For example, the Water Resources Act 1991 s.92 gives the Secretary of State power to make regulations in order to take precautions against water pollution. Section 161 of the Act also involves an aspect of the Precautionary Principle as it includes the powers to serve works notices to prevent water pollution. However, in general terms, there is no explicit reference to the principle and like in R v Secretary of State for Environment, it is clear that the lack of any settled mechanism of risk assessment means that most arguments in UK courts for the principle will fail.
Its significance in the UK can be compared to the way it has been adopted into Environmental Policy in the EU. An important case to illustrate this is Pfizer v EC which involved the prohibition of the use of antibiotics in food for health reasons. The ECJ accepted the precautionary principle as an argument in the case despite the lack of proof that it would cause a resistance in human beings to antibiotics. However, the case did not offer much guidance as to the application of the principle; it stated that the measure should be proportional to the desired level of protection but what is proportionate? At what point would uncertainty demand a precautionary response? There are advantages of this, such as it not being restricting but flexible so that Member States can adapt it according to their environmental law issues and circumstances. On the other hand, the uncertainty goes against one of the Unions main aims of uniformity across all member states. Clearly, there are competing principles in play here; taking precautions to protect the environment, which could lead to restricting trade verses the concept of a single market/free movement of goods. Nonetheless, Article 191(2) TFEU now has this principle enshrined.
Regarding International Law, the principle made an appearance in the Rio Declaration which stated that the principle applies where there are ‘threats of serious or irreversible environmental damage’ and where there is scientific uncertainty over those threats. In a case challenging the right of France to carry out Nuclear Tests in the South Pacific, although no substantive decisions were taken, dissenting opinions suggested that the role of the precautionary principle may be of increasing importance in the future. Judge Laing in New Zealand v Japan distinguished between the principle and a precautionary approach as he believed the latter would offer more flexibility. So although the court held that there was an obligation to act with prudence when it comes to doing research with natural resources it was cautious with the wording. Evidently, international law cases present an inconsistent application of the Precautionary Principle, however, again it can be argued that this is inevitable because a principle is in its nature just a general guide to action.
The lack of debate in Parliament shows that the Precautionary Principle is not as significant in the UK as it is on the EU and International scale. Nevertheless, although it has been limited, it still has had an effect on domestic law and has not been completely denied in the courts as an existing principle. It is a principle, not a rule, so the fact that it is rarely explicitly mentioned in domestic law and is sometimes uncertain or incoherent does not insinuate that its significance is non-existent.

BIBLIOGRAPHY
BOOKS
Bell S, McGillivray D, Pedersen O.W, Environmental Law (8th edn, OUP 2013)
Wes Jackson, Protecting Public Health and the Environment: Implementing The Precautionary Principle (Island Press 1999)
CASES
Case T-13/99 Pfizer v European Commission [2002] ECR II-3305
R v Derbyshire County Council, ex parte Murray [2001] Env
R v Leicester City Council and others, ex part Blackfordby and Boothhorpe Action Group Ltd, [2001] Env

ARTICLES
Elizabeth Fisher, “Is the Precautionary Principle Justiciable?” J Environmental Law (2001)
James Cameron & Juli Abouchar, “The Precautionary Principle: A Fundamental Principle of Law and Policy for the Protection of the Global Environment” [1991] 14 Boston College International and Comparative Law Review 1
PAPERS
The Common Inheritance, 'Fact not fantasy: best evidence', (White Paper, HM Govt, 1990)

--------------------------------------------
[ 1 ]. Stuart Bell, Donald McGillivray, Ole W. Pedersen, Environmental Law (8th edn, OUP 2013)68
[ 2 ]. Wes Jackson, Protecting Public Health and the Environment: Implementing The Precautionary Principle (Island Press 1999)27
[ 3 ]. The Common Inheritance,'Fact not fantasy: best evidence',(White Paper, HM Govt, 1990, 11)
[ 4 ]. Bell(n 1)75
[ 5 ]. Cameron & Abouchar, “The Precautionary Principle: A Fundamental Principle of Law and Policy for the Protection of the Global Environment”[1991]9
[ 6 ]. R v Leicester City Council and others, ex part Blackfordby and Boothhorpe Action Group Ltd, [2001] EnvLR2
[ 7 ]. R v Derbyshire County Council, ex parte Murray [2001] Env LR26
[ 8 ]. Bell (n 1)74
[ 9 ]. Bell (n 1)70…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Analyze the Opposition to Precautionary Principle and Sustainable Development in Various Communities.

...Analyze the Opposition to Precautionary Principle and Sustainable Development in various communities. The Opposition to Precautionary Principle and Sustainable Development is related that implementing these principals will fall behind a society and cost money. In order to demolish these topics, opposition has stated various arguments, and the most relevant topics are the creation of a norm called Quantitative risk assessment, and the tremendous amount of money and time to implement these principals. Quantitative risk assessment, it was adopted by the United States in the mid-1980s and was established in the global trade agreements of the 1990s, is the most useful tool to prove that a product or technology is not very dangerous. Quantitative risk assessment shows the sets of numbers that harm is acceptable from a product. Quantitative risk assessment became the norm, commercial and industrial products attach to this norm to insist that harm must be proven "scientifically" before action was taken to stop a process or product. However, the biggest problem with sustainable development is that it will take years for cleaner and better practices can be implemented all over the world. A huge amount of research has to be done in order to find out which methods of production damage the environment the least. When one method of sustainable development is first tried out, the first results are often unacceptable. Finally, it will cost a tremendous amount of money up-front to do the......

Words: 415 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Principle

...Heston E Cummings, Daman Sandhu, Jamiel Najmeddine Principle or rules based accounting Heston E Cummings, Daman Sandhu, Jamiel Najmeddine Principle or rules based accounting Table of Contents INTRODUCTION 3 Principle Based Accounting 4 Rule Based Accounting 6 CONCLUSION 7 REFERENCES …………………………………………………………………………………………… 8 Abstract There have been lots of discussions about principle and rule based accounting approaches, mostly people view U.S GAAP as rule based and IFRS as principle based. In this paper we will examine advantages and disadvantages or both approaches. Finally which is more applicable in real world settings. Introduction After incidents like recession, there have been discussions about principles based versus rules based among accountants, governments. As multinational businesses are increasing, there is need is an increased demand for high quality comparable financial information. “Accurate and consistent information is essential if the allocation of financial capital is to truly reflect comparative advantage, encourage diversified investments, and minimize cost of capital”.(Jermakowicz & Mcguire, 2002). If we look at two major accounting bodies, IFRS and US GAAP. “The IFRS emphasizes the fundamental importance of standards that focus on principle, drawn clearly from IASB’s conceptual framework, rather than on detailed rules”. (Jermakowicz & Mcguire, 2002). “This approach requires both companies and their auditors to exercise......

Words: 1399 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Un Global Impact Ten Principles

...The Ten Principles The UN Global Compact's ten principles in the areas of human rights, labour, the environment and anti-corruption enjoy universal consensus and are derived from: * The Universal Declaration of Human Rights * The International Labour Organization's Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work * The Rio Declaration on Environment and Development * The United Nations Convention Against Corruption The UN Global Compact asks companies to embrace, support and enact, within their sphere of influence, a set of core values in the areas of human rights, labour standards, the environment and anti-corruption: Human Rights * Principle 1: Businesses should support and respect the protection of internationally proclaimed human rights; and * Principle 2: make sure that they are not complicit in human rights abuses. Labour * Principle 3: Businesses should uphold the freedom of association and the effective recognition of the right to collective bargaining; * Principle 4: the elimination of all forms of forced and compulsory labour; * Principle 5: the effective abolition of child labour; and * Principle 6: the elimination of discrimination in respect of employment and occupation. Environment * Principle 7: Businesses should support a precautionary approach to environmental challenges; * Principle 8: undertake initiatives to promote greater environmental responsibility; and * Principle 9: encourage the......

Words: 14114 - Pages: 57

Free Essay

Marketing Principles

...Internship Report: HRMP in Standard Chartered Bank Abstract According to the universalistic perspective, organizations from different sectors, across industries, and through different time periods should use a series of select human resource management practices (HRMP). The main principle of this paper is to investgate whether i there is any relationship between HRMPs and organizational performance, regarding Standard Chartered Bank in Bangladesh. This study aims to investigate the relationship of training, employee participation, and selection with perceived organiz ational performance in the context of Standard Chartered Bank in Bangladesh. This study is co -relational in nature and it will examine the correlation among these variables. A single set of sample will be considered for this study and that will be the employees of Standard Chartered Bank. A set of structured questionnaire will be distributed among 200 respondents. Regression analysis will be conducted for the purpose of data analysis. -1- Internship Report: HRMP in Standard Chartered Bank Origin of the Report The BBA internship program is a mandatory requirement for the students who are graduating from the BBA program under the School of Business of North South University, Bangladesh. In the internship program, I was attached to a host organization named µStandard Chartered Bank¶ for 12 weeks. During this period I learned how the host organization works with the help of the internal supervisor....

Words: 12549 - Pages: 51

Premium Essay

The Impact

...The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/0268-6902.htm MAJ 21,5 The impact of international financial reporting standards: does size matter? John Goodwin School of Accounting and Law, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia, and 460 Kamran Ahmed School of Business, La Trobe University, Bundoora, Australia Abstract Purpose – This study seeks to examine the impact of Australian equivalents to international financial reporting standards (A-IFRS) on the accounts of small-, medium- and large-sized firms. Design/methodology/approach – For 135 listed Australian entities, the half-yearly accounts ended 30 June 2005 are examined to identify the effects of A-IFRS. Data are gathered on the change in major balance sheet and income statement elements, the major reconciling items and earnings variability. Findings – Findings show that more than half of small firms have no change in net income or equity from A-IFRS, and that there is an increase in the number of adjustments to net income and equity with firm size. The study also finds that A-IFRS has increased net income for small- and medium-sized firms. Equity has increased (decreased) under A-IFRS for small (large) firms. Small firms experience higher earnings variability than medium-sized or large firms under A-IFRS. Research limitations/implications – The sample is limited to 31 December reporting date firms and not all A-IFRS must be complied with when firms restate their......

Words: 7633 - Pages: 31

Premium Essay

Principles

...INTRODUCTION TO PRINCIPLES OF MANAGEMENT DEFINITIONS Management is a process of achieving organizational goals by engaging in the function of planning, organizing, leading and controlling. Kibera (1996) defines management as a set of activities directed at the efficient and effective utilization of resources in pursuit of one or more objectives. A manager is a person responsible for directing the efforts aimed at helping the organization achieve its goals. Managerial performance is the measure of how efficient and effective a manager is i.e. how well he/she determines and achieves appropriate objectives. Organizational performance is the measure of how efficient and effective an organization is i.e. how well it achieves appropriate objectives. MANAGEMENT FUNCTION Management is referred to as a process because it is a systematic way of doing things. Like any other process, all managers engage in certain interrelated activities in order to achieve their desired goals. Four of the key management functions are:- a) Planning - Is the process of setting goals and deciding how best to achieve them. b) Organizing - Involves allocating and arranging human and non human resources for the successful implementation of plans c) Leading - Is the process of influencing others to engage in work behavior necessary to reach the organization goals. d) Controlling - Involves regulating organizational activities......

Words: 12514 - Pages: 51

Premium Essay

Accounting Principles

...Generally Accepted Accounting Principles and Healthcare University of Phoenix Online December 23, 2013 Generally Accepted Accounting Principles and Healthcare Accounting measures allow the public, those granting credit and investors, the opportunity to review a business’s financial performance through the review of financial statements. The financial market is grounded on the truthfulness of financial statements that allow investors to estimate the value of securities. The usage of generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) is part of an organized and regulated method for financially educated professionals to create financial statements. GAAP outlines in detail the components necessary for large and small businesses to disclose their financial performance as accurate as possible to avoid bias (Federal Accounting Standards Advisory Board, 2013). GAAP addresses the wide range of accounting practices down to the small and specialized business. Accounting Principles “Generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) are rules established by the Federal Accounting Standards Advisory Board (FASAB)” (Finkler, Kovner, & Jones, 2007, p.104). The development of accounting principles became emergently necessary because of the trend of major financial disasters. The stock market crash and demise of Enron were a result of faulty and deceptive accounting practices which failed to disclose the true state of the organizations. Events like these precipitated the need for......

Words: 1062 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Management Principles

...Management Principles Introduction Management is a vital role of the HR department that ensures that an organization has what it takes to accomplish its goals and objectives. It comprises interrelated social and technical functions and activities that pull people and other resources together in a formal organizational setting in the effort of facilitating the achievement of these goals. Management principles refer to some strategically developed guidelines and set timelines that are used to organize staff, maintain organizational structure, delegate authorities, and establish policies and procedures in the view of implementing the vision of any organization. Henry Fayol, a Frenchman and a coal-mining engineer, developed fourteen management principles that form the basis for today’s effective organizational management. Fayol’s management principles help managers to make crucial decisions towards the accomplishment of individual and organizational objectives. Apparently, management and leadership go hand in hand in the process of running an organization. On the other hand, Stauffacher describes leadership as an interpersonal role of an individual to influence and provide purpose, direction, motivation, and support of other people in the achievement of the mission. Leadership is the most essential element of the management process. However, it is knowledge, skills and experience that culminate into a leader’s effectiveness. Therefore, the objective of this paper is to......

Words: 1515 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

The Precautionary Principle as a Basis for Decision Making

...1.) In the featured article “The Precautionary Principle as a Basis for Decision Making”, the author, Cass R. Sunstein provides his view on the practicality of the Precautionary Principle and the impact it could have on major policies across the world. The basic underlying principle of the Precautionary principle is that “it is better to be safe than sorry”. The principle can be adopted in many scenarios and it different aspects. An example of the strong application of the precautionary principle was at the Wingspread Declaration at 1998, which advocates the use of precautionary measures even before the cause and effect relationship is examined. The European Union has openly endorsed the principle as a basis for decision making but is yet not clear on how it would be applied to specific scenarios. The Author suggests an examination of the principle’s strengths and weakness as it has potential application in critical areas such as climate change, nuclear power and even war. Even the basic interpretation of the principle raises difficult queries. Without assigning costs to safety, one cannot quantify on how much safety is required while applying the principle. Another issue with the strong application of the principle is that it completely tries to eliminate risk without realizing that eliminating or reducing risks at one end will definitely impact and increase the risk at the other end. There exists risk in every scenario as we live in a world which is scarce in resources......

Words: 3090 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Impact

...Impact Illegal immigration has caused much turmoil in Malaysia. When the illegal immigrants enter into Malaysia they are bringing in harmful diseases that have never been a problem in this area such as tuberculosis and leprosy. http://marygibson8.blogspot.com/ Public Health Risks Because illegal immigrants, unlike those who are legally admitted for permanent residence, undergo no medical screening to assure that they are not bearing contagious diseases, the rapidly swelling population of illegal aliens in our country has also set off a resurgence of contagious diseases that had been totally or nearly eradicated by our public health system. http://www.fairus.org/issue/illegal-immigration-and-public-health The migrations of the illegal immigrants also bring another big problem to our country that is dangerous diseases. As we know illegal immigrants come from rural areas and when they enter our boundaries they do not even go to the public or the private health department for a medical check-up. Diseases such as HIV, AIDS and TB are some of the disease brought by them. The health problem will enlarge because this illegal immigrant brings lot of health problem from their country. For instance the HIV, it refers to the smuggling of women for the purposes of forced prostitution and this will lead to HIV virus in other hand it will increase the total of fatality. Because of these diseases, entire citizens become afraid to be affected by those and some of them have been a......

Words: 426 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Impact of It on the

...and cards and maintain a set of information on stock levels and carryout attachments by the touch of a button. In large organizations where goods are bought into the storehouse in very large quantities and are also fast moving, it may be cost effective to adopt the use of information technology. With the wind of advancement blowing, many organizations have embraced the use of information technology in stores administration. The researchers will look into the usefulness or contributions of information technology in stores administration. 1.1 STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM It is clear from the above introduction that IT has brought about many changes into stores administration. It is as a result that the researchers are investigating the impact that IT has on stores administration at Koforidua Polytechnic. 1.2 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY The objective of this work is to: 1. Assess the IT facilities available. 2. Examine the use of IT. 3. Asses the quality of personnel available. 1.3 SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY The research was undertaken to give recognition to the numerous advantages accruing to any organization that uses stores administration process that is fused with Information Technology. The study was directed towards finding realistic solutions to problems encountered in stores administration. The study was also undertaken to serve as a source of reference and information to promote further studies. The research would also help personnel......

Words: 870 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Impact

...THE IMPACT OF EXTRACURRICULAR ATHLETIC ACTIVIES ON ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT, DISCIPLINARY REFERRALS, AND SCHOOL ATTENDANCE AMONG HISPANIC FEMALE 11TH GRADE STUDENTS A Dissertation By Kelly J. Manlove BS, Stephen F. Austin State University, 1996 MS, University of North Texas, 2006 Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of DOCTOR OF EDUCATION In Educational Leadership Texas A&M University-Corpus Christi Corpus Christi, Texas May, 2013 THE IMPACT OF EXTRACURRICULAR ATHLETIC ACTIVIES ON ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT, DISCIPLINARY REFERRALS, AND SCHOOL ATTENDANCE AMONG HISPANIC FEMALE 11TH GRADE STUDENTS A Dissertation By Kelly J. Manlove BS, Stephen F. Austin State University, 1996 MS, University of North Texas, 2006 This dissertation meets the standards for scope and quality of Texas A&M University–Corpus Christi and is hereby approved. Kamiar Kouzekanani, Ph.D. Bryant Griffith, Ph.D. Chair Committee Member Jacqueline Hamilton, Ed.D. Pamela Meyer, Ph.D. Committee Member Graduate Faculty Representative JoAnn Canales, Ph.D. Interim Dean of Graduate Studies May 2013 © Kelly Jean Manlove All Rights Reserved March 2013 v ABSTRACT THE IMPACT OF EXTRACURRICULAR ATHLETIC ACTIVIES ON ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT, DISCIPLINARY REFERRALS, AND SCHOOL ATTENDANCE AMONG HISPANIC FEMALE 11TH GRADE STUDENTS (March 2013) Kelly J. Manlove B.S., Stephen F. Austin State University M.Ed., University of North Texas Dissertation Chair: Kamiar......

Words: 12965 - Pages: 52

Premium Essay

Management Principles

...Introduction Nowadays, more and more companies pay attention to achieve social responsibility in order to increase their public image. One of the ways that is adopted by many companies to become more socially is green management which is referred to using various policies to reduce much of environmental problems when the managers woke up to and concerned for the impact of their organization on the natural environment. The environmental problems of various pollutions, global warming, solid waste, ozone layer depletion and so on arise and endanger sustainability of economic along with the rapid development of industries. Therefore, the practices of green management are needed as soon as possible. Green management practices can not only be done by large organizations, but even for small organizations since it can increase the public image of the companies and thus will affect people’s perspectives and the investors’ behavior. In short-term, going green means that the management assists in saving the natural environment, however in long-term, the costs will be reduced and thus the profits can be increased as well as they will try to achieve green management through waste minimization, and improving energy efficiency. That will make a “win-win” complexion. By contrast, those companies that always cause pollutions would be criticized as companies of social irresponsibility, their public image will be damaged, even affect sales amount of their products. To study the green......

Words: 3884 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Ethical Principles

...Ethical Principles John Durham III PSY/305 March 7, 2016 Dr. Daven Salmi Ethical Principles Introduction The ethical issue that I chose to examine was an article about the relationship between ethical and abusive coaching behaviors and student-athlete well-being. I found this article very interesting because not a lot of people are aware of the ethical issues that have been and are currently going on in the athletic background. Believe it or not there are many ethical issues that relate to psychology in the athletic field. Ethical Issues in Collegiate Athletics One of the biggest ethical issues in collegiate athletics was the abusive behaviors of the coaches to the athletes. This is a big ethical issue because the actions and behavior of the coaches resulted in the players to cheat. When you look at coaches you think of them as the parent of many children on the field or in the gym. The ability of coaches to impact the performance of their athletes is well established (Horn, 2008; Weiss, Smith, & Stuntz, 2008). When a coach instructs an athlete to perform certain actions the first response of the athlete is to do what the coach says. Part of the duty of coach is to prepare athletes for competition through physical training, planning, and instructions; as well as designing strategies and game plans that affect the performance of their athletes and teams during competition. Preparing and motivating athletes to succeed during competition is an important......

Words: 1462 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Principles of Economics

...Assignment 1: Principles of Economics Due Week 4 and worth 200 points Write a three to four (3-4) page paper in which you: 1.Suggest how an economist would approach the problem of alcohol abuse. Provide two (2) possible solutions to this problem. Include the four (4) elements of the economic way of thinking in your analysis. 2.Analyze how prescription drugs affect the demand and supply of other products and services in this country. 3.Formulate a reason why the elasticity of demand is an important consideration when analyzing the impact of a shift in supply and why the elasticity of supply is an important consideration when analyzing the impact of a shift in demand. Include at least one (1) example in each scenario. 4.Provide two (2) examples of increasing-cost industries in your state and propose why they would have a positively sloped supply curve. 5.Suggest how, under certain conditions, a perfectly competitive market is economically efficient. 6.Use at least three (3) quality resources in this assignment. Your assignment must follow these formatting requirements: •Be typed, double spaced, using Times New Roman font (size 12), with one-inch margins on all sides; citations and references must follow APA or school-specific format. Check with your professor for any additional instructions. •Include a cover page containing the title of the assignment, the student’s name, the professor’s name, the course title, and the date. The cover page and the reference......

Words: 354 - Pages: 2

Pet Sematary | NEW Boveda Butler Smart Humidor Sensor Monitor with One Step Calibration Kit | ศึกอัศวินดำก่อเกียรติ