Premium Essay

Labor Dispute

In: Other Topics

Submitted By elizafidelia
Words 2177
Pages 9
Comparative Industrial Relation 562
Master of International Business
Curtin Singapore

Research Journal on Labour Dispute

Lecturer: Dr. Charles Wang
Student: Eliza Fidelia Lim
Student ID: 16363579


This research journal is focusing in the increasing number of labour dispute today, especially in labour strike, this research journal will provide 6 different news articles in regards of labor strike in different countries in Asia Pacific region including that of South Korea, China, India , and one from the western country, United States. The relation of the topic and the literature will further be explained in the later part of this research journal, analysis, solution, and recommendation will be stated in each article and combined together in conclusion.

Literature Review

Labour dispute can be related to theories of comparative industrial relation such as the impact on international labour standards, development and changes in unionism, collective and individual bargaining, and worker empowerment and conflict management.

Impact on International Labour Standards (ILO), development and changes in unionism

In order for collective bargaining to be successful, there are several conditions that needs to be fulfilled, there must be a freedom for both workers and employee to form their own associations to represent their interests, and stability of union must be maintained in order for collective bargaining to be effective, and for union to be able to honor the agreement. Thirdly, employer must recognize the presence of union, after recognition of union; collective bargaining then can be made (Anita Chan, 2002; David M. Trubek, 1997).

Worker Empowerment and Conflict Management

There are three union models according to Hyman 2001, market oriented unions where economic actors are in pursue of economic goals, class-oriented unions…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay


...wanted his whole life why would he have any finale labors? Then after seeing what those final labors where. The author makes you realize that all Superman has ever really wanted was the things that us non superhero’s take for granted. Before finishing the book we were discussing what our final labors would be in class. I was thinking about all the crazy things I haven’t got to do yet in my life like skydiving and exploring undiscovered areas of the earth. However after finishing reading the book my outlook on my final labors changed pretty drastically. Superman made me realize that it’s not the things you do for yourself while you’re alive that you’ll be remembered for. But the things you do for others that will keep your name remembered forever. For my final labors I would like to accomplish 3 main goals, for my first goal I would like to complete college with a degree in business management. I feel that with this degree I can follow in my Father’s footsteps and hopefully own my own business someday and be as successful as him someday. Not only do I want to do this for my own good, but even more then that I want to make my proud. My whole life my dad has been pushing me to be smarter and stronger and most importantly a competent and successful human being. I know whatever I do accomplish in my life my dad will be proud, however I would really like to go above and beyond any expectations he has ever had for me. For my second labor I would like to settle down and have a......

Words: 592 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Labor and Relations

...Labor Relations Makeba Hester Professor Anthony Jacobs Bus405: Labor and Relations December 16, 2013 Abstract This paper will focus on the labor relations aspect of Super Retailer Walmart. Their employees have renounced Walmart and the unfair labor relations. Walmart practices and approach to insurance, wage and shift hours have all ways haunted the retail giant. Many companies condemned Walmart for being too large and not focusing on the employees but their primary goal is just to capitalize on the blood sweat and tears of their employees. I will formulate a comprehensive strategy to Walmart that can help at least one imperative area that troubles the super retailer which is health care. 1. Discuss the company’s stance toward labor and any specific labor-related issues it may be experiencing. (Ungar, 2012)After making a big deal of publicly supporting the Affordable Care Act, Walmart—the nation’s largest private sector employer—is joining the ranks of companies seeking to avoid their obligation to provide employees with health insurance as required by Obama care. Walmart been criticized for their horrible wages to the health coverage of their employees. The announcement was long overdue and the time for change is now. As Walmart, dominate the retail industry by offering a vast selection of products to consumers from shampoo, to prescriptions, a routine visit to the optometrist, eating at McDonalds to selecting office furniture. Walmart have mastered a...

Words: 1137 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...Labor relations are generally defined as relations between management and workers. They are also called industrial relations. Workers or group of workers are represented by trade unions. Labor relations may take place on different levels such as regional, national, international. The main challenge for such relation is ability to adapt to emerging changes. The world and technology develops very fast, so do relations between workers and management. Trade unions (also called) labor unions are organizations of workers who united to defend their rights, solving problems in the industry such as wages, working hours, bonuses, Union represent workers and negotiate with the management on behalf of the workers (Jochem, 2000). Such relations are usually accompanied by tensions and conflicts and company owners usually want to earn more and pay less. Workers are willing to work in better conditions for a better salary. Labor unionism in the United States is an expression of the American democratic spirit working itself out in industry is hardly to be doubted. Its beginnings coincided with the period when the free colonies were establishing state governments, and the principles of the federal Constitution were subjects of great political debate. It developed stretch in Jefferson's administration, and grew to a full-fledged labor movement during the presidency of Andrew Jackson. Workmen's clubs, unions, were part of the movement of "Republican-Democratic Societies" which marked "the......

Words: 1121 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Industrial Disputes

...Industrial Disputes Industrial disputes are conflicts, disorder or unrest arising between workers and employers on any ground. Such disputes finally result in strikes, lockouts and mass refusal of employees to work in the organization until the dispute is resolved. So it can be concluded that Industrial Disputes harm both parties employees and employers and are always against the interest of both employees and the employers. An industrial dispute is simply a disagreement between employers and workers. Industrial disputes are manifested in strikes (withdrawal from work by a group of employees) and lockouts (refusal by an employer or group of employers to permit some or all of their employees to work). These disputes are mostly represented by trade unions. It is a disagreement between workers and management over pay, working conditions, hours of work, etc., especially one that includes strikes (workers refusing to work). 1 Causes of Industrial Disputes The causes of industrial disputes can be broadly classified into two categories: economic and non-economic causes. The economic causes will include issues relating to compensation like wages, bonus, allowances, and conditions for work, working hours, leave and holidays without pay, unjust layoffs and retrenchments. The non-economic factors will include victimization of workers, ill treatment by staff members, sympathetic strikes, political factors, indiscipline etc. Wages and Allowances Since the cost of living index is......

Words: 6688 - Pages: 27

Free Essay


...workforce from families, and it even got as bad as it was common to see kids working to help their families make ends meet. Kids and women usually worked longer hours at an even lesser pay then the men. Tensions caused by these conditions inevitably reached the boiling point, and the first labor conflict to come to national attention occurred in 1877, when railroad workers went on strike and froze most of the country’s train traffic. This was huge. The railroad was the life blood of travel and the way American moved good and supplies at the time. The panic of 1873 caused for wage cuts even though the railroad was still expanding. The intervention of the American government only made things worse, especially when the government used the National Guard to break up strikers. This just caused more anger and violence. In St. Louis, striking railroad workers were joined by all other industrial workers in the city, shutting down all manufacturing establishments for four days. The city’s industry was at a standstill. The crazy thing is the strikers were defeated by the National Guard and their leaders were put in jail. The works took pay cuts. Though the workers in the end lost their fight bought the issue of labor activism into the national consciousness. It’s amazing that these people stood up so strong for something they believed in for their rights for what was fair and they lost and people lost their lives. I believe that from this stroke these workers did have the chance to......

Words: 355 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Ethical Labor Dispute

...The US Department of Labor defines a sweatshop as being a factory that violates two or more labor laws. Sweat shops in America slip under the radar but are not as common as those in under developed countries. This being said many of the successful fashion companies utililize sweatshop labor from the under developed countries. One of the largest sweat shop capitals is located in Indonesia, where women and children are forced to work unreasonable hours and paid unfair wages with poor working conditions. The list of violations are endless. It is unethical to use women and children as well as men in these sweat shops to reproduce a product that is going to give the CEO’s and upper management great financial gains. On average a worker is paid .24 per NBA Jersey they produce, that same garment is sold in the USA for more than $140. Studies have shown that when a sweat shop worker wages are doubled, the product would increase the cost to the consumer by only 1.8%. Many of those consumers would be willing to pay up to 15% more to ensure that fair and ethical conditions and regulations were instilled during the manufacturing of the product they are purchasing. Companies have a duty to the consumer to provide ethical business practices, thus giving the business and or brand a reputation that stands for conditions that are humane while the product is being produced. A company can stand behind their ethical business practices by setting higher standards for factories they......

Words: 398 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...Cassandra Rollins HIS125: Labor Assessment Assignment Linda Rhoades-Swartz: Instructor February 1, 2015 Write a 350-word essay in which you do the following: •Identify what you think to be one of the most significant strikes of the late 1800s or early 1900s. •Describe what it accomplished and what it failed to accomplish. The Homestead Strike was one of the most famous strikes that happen in the late 1800s. This is an example of the struggle between labor union and business owners. In some cases, as at the Homestead, the struggle turned violent. The Homestead Strike was at the Carnegie Steel Mill and owned by Andrew Carnegie. Carnegie thought that the labor union at the Homestead Steel Mill made it harder on the manager to run their business proficiently. Carnegie was out of town at the time of the strike but he knew that it was going to happen so he warned the steel mill top managers. The Labor Union which was called Amalgamated Association of Iron and Steel Workers was highly upset about the pay drop that was going to happen. Because the price of steel was dropping the pay was going to be reduced. The Union member and most other workers decided to have a meeting and they all decided to go on strike because they felt that they did too much for their pay to drop. When the manager decided to hired armed guards to protect the company from the strikers the whole situation became violent. They were also trying to protect the workers that they hired to replace the......

Words: 381 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...Airline Labor Relations More than half of airline industry workers are members of unions. Airline unions have a relatively long history in the United States. They differ from unions in some industries in that that are craft unions; there are separate unions for pilots, flight attendants, mechanics, and the like. This has led to a multitude of recognize airline unions, making labor relations for airlines a particularly complicated endeavor that may require dozens of separate labor contracts. Airline Unions and Collective Bargaining: A Brief History In 1934, the National Labor Relations Board introduced industry-wide bargaining to the airline industry. The most significant development, though, came in 1936 when the airline industry was included under the Railway Labor Act. The Act put in place standardized procedures for collective bargaining, including procedures for developing labor contracts and mediating grievances. Under the Railway Labor Act, collective bargaining in the airline industry was placed under the oversight of the federal government through the National Mediation Board (Wensveen, 2011). From 1936 to 1978, labor relations in the airline industry ranged from initial hostility to occasional accommodation or even cooperation, but the arms-length dealing approach eventually became most common. Government regulation of the airline industry during this period imposed constraints on the bargaining process that made it fairly orderly, as compared with labor......

Words: 657 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...Labor Practices Paper Reginald D. Webb Jr. PHL/320 April 13, 2015 John Preis Labor Practices Paper This week I have had the opportunity to learn more about labor practices and how they work. I have learn enough this week to talk about it and what I feel I got out of it from one week thus far. In this essay I will discuss sweatshop labor justification and explain how consumer demands affect a company’s decision in business. I also will discuss how sweatshop justification labor has different ethnical perspectives guiding ethical decision making. Right before my conclusion of this I will discuss one last topic which would be an explanation of how a company influences their ethical environment. I hope you enjoy the final paper I write in this course. Sweatshop Labor Sweatshop labor is all around us and many companies are having this issue even today. With parents’ teenage kids working or young adults working the sweatshop we see many people protesting this discrimination they feel needs to be resolved. Nowadays in America it is mostly employees who work long hours with minimum wage pay which is very difficult to comprehend. Companies like Gap, Abercrombie & Fitch, and H&M have all experience some sort of criticism about having this type of labor in their company. I myself once attempted to apply for one of these companies not knowing the way they had planned to have me working and the type of pay they were going to give. It is......

Words: 729 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Labor and Management Disputes at San Miguel Corporation: Its Resolutions and the Implication in the Business Operation

...Republic of the Philippines SOUTHERN LEYTE STATE UNIVERSITY Sogod, Southern Leyte Philippines LABOR AND MANAGEMENT DISPUTES AT SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION: ITS RESOLUTIONS AND THE IMPLICATION IN THE BUSINESS OPERATION A Final Paper presented to The Faculty of the Graduate Studies Southern Leyte State University In partial fulfilment of the course MM 505 : Management and the Law Summer 2015 RIZA MAE B. FORTUNA Master in Management Student TABLE OF CONTENT Cover Page Page 1 Table of Content Page 2 I. Introduction Page 3 A. Objectives B. Company Profile, Mission & Vision Page 4 II. Antecedent facts of the case Page 6 III. Resolutions, Findings and Decision of the Labor - Page 7 Management Problem IV. Recommendation and Observation Page 8 V. Appendices Page 9 Whole Case citation Page 9 Nature of the Company Page 16 References Page 17 I. NAME OF COMPANY AND ITS PROFILE INTRODUCTION Corporation is defined as the most common business organization which is formed by a group of people. It has rights and liabilities separate from those of the individuals involved. It may be a non-profit organization engaged in activities for the public good; a municipal corporation, such as a...

Words: 5029 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Labor Management

...Labor Management (not covered in class; come from this handout) – 3 QUESTIONS  Labor-Management Relations 1. Unions have not fared especially well in recent years. In 1970, approximately 30% of the workforce was unionized. Today, it is about ½ of that. Why?  One reason is the shift from a manufacturing to a service economy.  Some would contend that unions are not as necessary now as they once were because so many state and federal laws already protect employees. 2. Unions are gearing up to increase their membership  Targeting women and minorities, which is ironic because unions have traditionally been controlled by white, blue-collar men who had little interest in seeing women and minorities make gains in the workplace.  4 Major Federal Labor Law Statutes 1. Norris-LaGuardia (1932)  Outlaws yellow dog contracts (whereby employee agrees that he will not become involved in union activity and acknowledges that employer has the right to fire him if he does), and  Limits power of federal courts to issue injunctions in labor disputes (traditionally, employer could easily get injunction, thereby putting an end to planned labor activities—strikes, for example). 2. Wagner (1935) - Outlaws unfair labor practices by employers.  Grants employees the right to form, join, assist unions, and to bargain collectively (through union, instead of contracting individually with employer—strength in unity—employer doesn’t need any particular worker, but does need......

Words: 1725 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Labor Relation

...Background of Labor Relations Labor relations can refer broadly to any dealings between management and workers about employment conditions. Most commonly, however, labor relations refers to dealings between management and a workforce that is already unionized, or has the potential to become unionized. Labor relation is the field that emphasizes skill managers and union leaders can use to minimize costly forms of conflict and seek win-win solutions with labor force. The decision for management involves whether the organization will work with unions or develop non-union operations. The decision is influenced by outside forces such as competition, public opinions etc. while there are several advantages of unionism to both the members and the employers, negative consequences on profitability and productivity have also been found by researcher. The best labor relation strategy is dependent on the tradeoffs between the positive and negative consequences and external legal environment. The term ‘Labor management Relations’ comprises of two terms: ‘Labor’ and ‘Relations’. “Labor” refers to “any productive activity in which an individual (or a group of individuals) is (are) engaged”. By “relations” we mean “the relationships that exist within the industry between the employer and his workmen.” The term labor management relations explains the relationship between employees and management which stem directly or indirectly from union-employer......

Words: 1253 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay


...proceed the negotiation. I feel the CEO does in fact gain much home court advantage because she is the head boss in charge over everyone, not only that but she is choosing how they will meet. Jackie does not know whether it would be face to face, over the phone, email or what. A matter concerning a raise is much more of a face to face conversation but in this case it all depends on the CEO. CEO’s are very busy people, there is almost never a moment where they get to think and have time to themselves. A simple phone meeting or shooting Jackie an email would not be a bad idea to the CEO, but it honestly is not the right way to negotiate concerning a pay raise. References Frey, M. (2003). Negotiation. In Alternative Methods of Dispute Resolution (p. Pg. 101, 99). Clifton Park, New York....

Words: 466 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Labor Relations

...that provides a Labor Relations Office to look out for the well-being of the federal employees as well as the Bargaining Unit Employees in utilizing the best approach in resolving labor disputes and labor conflicts while working closely with the union. Most federal employees are represented by the American Federation of Government Employees, Local 1920 which without membership is the union who also fall under the Bargaining Unit. The Labor Relations office is there to provide guidance as representatives should the bargaining unit employees find themselves in a dispute with their employer or supervisor that could lead to filing grievances or they choose to address their issues to the union. As a federal employee myself and of the 5, 5000 federal employees on Fort Hood, I chose to conduct an interview with a Labor Relations Specialist working with in the Labor Relations office of the Human Resource Department on the installation to gain a better insight of how the labor issues are handle from the federal government perspective while working hand in hand with the AFGE. Labor Relations Functions Fort Hood being a military installation holds a Human Resource Department within the Civilian Personnel Advisory Center (CPAC). Human Resource department also has a Labor Relations office consisting of three Labor Relations Specialists. I had the opportunity to conduct an interview with Catherine Levandovsky, Labor Relation’s......

Words: 1968 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Dispute Paper

...This paper will provide information upon an article one of the many recent disputes that made local papers. The dispute arose between a policy holder and Allstate insurance claims department about the claims process stated in the contact between the two. In addition, provide information on the court process of criminal and civil cases and the possibility of many different verdicts including one from a criminal court stand point. In July 1997, Geneva Hager, an Allstate policyholder was involved in a rear end auto accident resulting in neck and back injuries. The claimant’s auto insurance paid out to Allstate and Ms Hager, his policy limit of 25,000 for body injury. Therefore in December 1999, her claim was closed with Allstate and her injuries had been compensated as from Allstate’s point of view. However, Ms Hager disagreed, she retain an attorney and filed a lawsuit against Allstate stating that they did not handle her claim in bad faith per the insurance contract. She proclaimed the claim process was prolonged in order to make her accept a low settlement for her body injuries. Ms Hager and her attorney demanded 475 million dollars for mental anguish and 950 million in punitive damages to be paid out (Orbitz, 2007). Ms Hager’s attorney gathered information about Allstate policy contract also with some replicas of their claims handling manuals to build their case. Allstate did the same by reviewing Ms Hager‘s claim and several similar ones to ensure the claim handling......

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

プロム用ドレス | Adobe Photoshop Lightroom Classic CC 2019 v.8.0 Multilanguag | 180 x 145cent Buchenwälder auf Papier NUR Tintenstrahlentwertung