Free Essay

Modern Sovereignty

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By ahmedmustafak
Words 540
Pages 3
Sovereignty is understood in jurisprudence as the full right and power of a governing body to govern itself without any interference from outside sources or bodies. In political theory, sovereignty is a substantive term designating supreme authority over some polity. It is a basic principle underlying the dominant Westphalian model of state foundation.
Derived from Latin through French souveraineté, its attainment and retention, in both Chinese and Western culture, has traditionally been associated with certain moral imperatives upon any claimant.
Different approaches
The concept of sovereignty has been discussed throughout history, from the time before recorded history through to the present day. It has changed in its definition, concept, and application throughout, especially during the Age of Enlightenment. The current notion of state sovereignty contains four aspects consisting of territory, population, authority and recognition. According to Stephen D. Krasner, the term could also be understood in four different ways: domestic sovereignty – actual control over a state exercised by an authority organized within this state, interdependence sovereignty – actual control of movement across state's borders, assuming the borders exist,

The Roman jurist Ulpian observed that:
The imperium of the people is transferred to the Emperor.
The Emperor is not bound by the law.
The Emperor's word is law. Emperor is the law making and abiding force.
Ulpian was expressing the idea that the Emperor exercised a rather absolute form of sovereignty, although he did not use the term expressly.
Classical Ulpian's statements were known in medieval Europe, but sovereignty was an important concept in medieval times.
A later English Arthurian romance, The Wedding of Sir Gawain and Dame Ragnell, uses many of the same elements of the Wife of Bath's tale, yet changes the setting to the court of King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table. The story revolves around the knight Sir Gawain granting to Dame Ragnell, his new bride, what is purported to be wanted most by women: sovereignty.
Sovereignty reemerged as a concept in the late 16th century, a time when civil wars had created a craving for stronger central authority, when monarchs had begun to gather power onto their own hands at the expense of the nobility, and the modern nation state was emerging. Jean Bodin, partly in reaction to the chaos of the French wars of religion, presented theories of sovereignty calling for strong central authority in the form of absolute monarchy. In his 1576 treatise Les Six Livres de la République Bodin argued that it is inherent in the nature of the state that sovereignty must be: argued, "the growth of the State giving the trustees of public authority more and means to abuse their power, the more the Government has to have force to contain the people, the more force the Sovereign should have in turn in order to contain the Government," with the understanding that the Sovereign is "a collective being of wonder" resulting from "the general will" of the people, and that "what any man, whoever he may be, orders on his own, is not a law" – and furthermore predicated on the assumption that the people have an unbiased means by which to ascertain the general will. Thus the legal maxim, "there is no law without a sovereign."…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

The Rise of Indian Sovereignty

...Indian Sovereignty Long before the United States of America ever came to be, this land was ruled by the original Native Americans. As settlers started to make their way to America, the Native Americans were greatly affected. Some of it was good; they learned new farming instruments to help grow certain food, and horses were reintroduced to the land which brought the Indians a form of transportation. But some of the changes came with problems. Though horses were a great benefit for the Indians, they brought over diseases that the Native Americans couldn’t handle. The new settlers also brought diseases such as chicken pox, measles, and small pox. Since the Indians didn’t have built up immunities against these viruses, it caused many deaths, especially small pox outbreaks. Between 1790 and 1871, the United States Senate had ratified a staggering 380 treaties with the Native Americans. Congress had entered into these treaties with the Indian Nations to acquire land which the U.S. would then sell-off to cover the countries overwhelming debts. Growing a new nation, even back in that time, was very costly. And the U.S. was not strong enough at that early stage to try and take Native American land by force. What the new government had to offer them, in return, was sovereignty and peace. In the 1820’s, the state of Georgia challenged the legal concept of sovereignty in the Supreme Court. Chief Justice John Marshall took effort to examine this idea of sovereignty, and......

Words: 1025 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Sovereignty Since Merdeka in Malaysia

...Insider, October 5) that the Malay Rulers “retained their sovereignty while under British rule, [even though] they were compelled to accept advice from their colonisers.” This may make practical sense to a political “spinmaster”, sloganeer or “message manager” and certainly to a political party leader and spokesman. But to an informed student of political philosophy it makes no good or clear sense. If by “daulat” one means a traditional aura of royal sanctity, grounded broadly in Southeast Asian (and originally Hindu-Buddhist) cosmology, then the largely powerless Malay Rulers may have enjoyed that kind of metaphysical prestige. The British not only permitted but actively encouraged them, in their mutual interest, to enjoy that kind of sublime elevation and closely managed dignity. But if one here means sovereignty in the jurisprudential and political-philosophical sense of absolute, or at least ultimate, reality-defining authority, then under the British the Malay Rulers were regrettably bystanders, or largely sidelined outsiders, to that kind of rule-grounding and law-founding political standing. That may be an unpalatable conclusion to draw. But unpleasant truths too must be faced. The Malay Rulers, sad though the point may be for many to accept, were not, during the years of British rule, the ultimate basis of effective, operative, everyday political reality. In that sense effective sovereignty had moved elsewhere. It had been seized and appropriated......

Words: 428 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Sovereignty of God

...ATTRIBUTES OF GOD - SOVEREIGNTY Michele Kennedy Box 563 Theology I February 27, 2013 Outline I. Definition of Sovereignty II. Scriptural Evaluation III. Personal Application Definition of Sovereignty The sovereignty of God is defined by Arthur W. Pink as “meaning that God is the almighty, the possessor of all power in heaven and on earth, and no one can defeat His counsels.[1] “As applied to God, the term ‘sovereignty’ indicates His complete power over all of creation, so that He exercises His will absolutely, without any necessary conditioning by a finite will or wills. The term does not occur in Scripture, although the idea is abundantly implied.”[2] “He does what He wills with His own.”[3] To some the light of the gospel is sent; others are left in darkness.”[4] Scriptural Evaluation God created all and He does as He likes with His creations, “Our God is in the heavens; He hath done whatsoever He pleased” (Ps 115:3).[5] He decides when we will be born, how we will live and when we will die, “Behold, all souls are mine; as the soul of the father, so also the soul of the son is mine” (Ez 18:4). All belongs to Him and man has no right to question His authority, “Is it not lawful for me to do what I will with mine own?” (Matt 20:15). “They rejoice that the Lord God omnipotent......

Words: 603 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Evangalism and the Sovereignty of God

...Summary of the Chapters In chapter one of Evangelism and the Sovereignty of God, J.I. Packer doesn’t waste time explaining the general truths. He already expects his readers to know that God is sovereign over His world. He is the author and source of all things, therefore, our prayers do not force the Lord of all to do anything. Packer wants his audience to realize that because the God is sovereign, we cannot save ourselves. Our salvation comes through Him and in Him; it is nothing we did ourselves. Packers gives two examples, that he believes can prove that God is sovereign in salvation. The first, he argues that we (Christians) thank God for our salvation. By doing so we acknowledge that God is solely responsible for our salvation. We do not thank ourselves for being saved, do we? No, because we know that it is God who is in control. The second way we acknowledge that God is sovereign in salvation, is that we pray for the conversion of non-believers. Packer defends his reasoning by saying, “Do you limit yourself to asking that God will bring them (non-believers) to a point where they can save themselves, independently of Him?”[1] Again, by praying to God for the salvation of others we practice the act of acknowledging God is sovereign. Proven now, that God is sovereign, in chapter 2 the author explains what an antimony is and how to deal with hardships that come along with it. An antimony is an appearance of a contradiction between conclusions which seem......

Words: 1791 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay


...Melting Pot The Modern Melting Pot? The Modern Melting Pot? The concept of a melting pot is the theory that anything put in will become blended and yields a result of something entirely new. This theory idealistically explains how the United States is perceived to be the Melting Pot of the World. This essay will address the concept of the modern Melting Pot and examine ways the idealistic vision of Melting Pot assimilation has been achieved through the development of American society as well as the limitations of this theory. “No, the real American has not yet arrived. He is only in the Crucible; I tell you he will be the fusion of all races perhaps the coming superman” (Zangwill n.d.). The Modern Melting Pot is a metaphor for cultural assimilation. It is the anticipation of a diverse society becoming more harmonious, where the elements of all cultures melt together to form a society that is released from animosity and cultural divisions, one with a more common culture. The term Melting Pot refers to the belief that societies in America that were formed by immigrant cultures, ethnic groups and religions will through assi...

Words: 1607 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Parliamentary Sovereignty

...Parliamentary sovereignty, once the dominant principle of the UK Constitution, is now under considerable pressure. Discuss this statement with reference to the UK’s membership of the EU, the devolution acts of 1998, the Human Rights Act 1998 and recent judicial comments on the Rule of Law. "Certainly we want to see Europe more united… but it must be in a way which preserves the different traditions, parliamentary powers, and sense of pride in one's own country." Margaret Thatcher Over the course of the years many prominent figures such as politicians and academic writers have been concerned with the diminishing of Parliamentary sovereignty. “Parliamentary sovereignty is a principle of the UK constitution. It makes Parliament the supreme legal authority in the UK, which can create or end any law. Generally, the courts cannot overrule its legislation and no Parliament can pass laws that future Parliaments cannot change. Parliamentary sovereignty is the most important part of the UK constitution.” Historically, due to the lack of a single codified constitution in the UK, the Westminster Parliament is the most powerful and influencing factor on the British political frontier. As opposed to America where the constitution dominates US politics, and legislation can be deemed unconstitutional and revoked by the US judiciary. However, since further integration into Europe incorporating The European Communities Act 1972, The Human Rights Act 1998, European Conventions on Human......

Words: 1911 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Globalization and States' Sovereignty in Social Policy

...the effects of the proposed growing global interconnectedness, concentrating on the social policy perspective. Finally, section IIIII will conclude with an evaluation of the scope and effectiveness of states’ strategic policy choices by proposing that the level to which states are affected by the new world order depends on specific national matters. Considering the limited length of the essay, it is not the goal to conceptualize important terms such as ‘globalization’ and ‘global governance’. Neither will the essay consider the differences within the clusters of sceptics’ and globalists even though the author is aware that these are remarkable. II. Defining the state and global interconnectedness According to Held and McGrew (2003: 9) the modern state is a relatively new phenomenon which can be traced back to the peace of Westphalia in 1648. Following this, the concept of the sovereign state has been the central way to study world issues. Traditionally, states have served multiple purposes, amongst them legal, military, economic, political and social (Held and McGrew, 2003:9-11). It is important to mention, however, that the concept originates in Europe, and that over half of the world’s states were created recently, following the decline of colonies after the Second World War (Mishra, 1999:14; Held and McGrew, 2003:10). It can therefore be argued that this ‘Euro-centric’ or ‘Western’ approach to studying the world system is simplified. Side 1 af......

Words: 2266 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Evolution of Modern Europe

...Evolution of Modern State in Europe Introduction A break was marked in 1989 in the history of Europe. That year stands for the revolutions, breaking up of empires along with the re-ordering of the influence spheres. However, these changes happened in the established framework of the balance between the sovereign independent state and the power. However, 1989 has been unique, along with brining dramatic changes such as the re-ordering of alliances and the revolutions; it resulted in the change in the State system of Europe (Cooper, n.d.). Historically, the proper point of comparison is the year 1648 when after thirty years of war a system of modern European state was emerged in Westphalia. The same type of break point was marked in Europe in 1989. Moreover, it has resulted in not just the re-arrangement of the previous system but the formation of a new system. It is based on new forms of statehood in which the states are behaving differently as compared to the past. Furthermore, alliances, interference with the domestic affairs of one another along with the acceptance of the international court’s jurisdiction has highlighted that the present states are less absolute in terms of their independence and sovereignty (Cooper, n.d.). Furthermore, the first and second world war along with the Cold War resulted in devastation in Europe without any form of historical precedent. Moreover, it also froze Europe for almost forty years which allowed new systems and new ideas to......

Words: 1208 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Globalization and Sovereignty in Pakistan

...| Globalization and Sovereignty in Pakistan | | | With a relatively constant rise in economic production over the last forty years and continued advances in communication technology, it is clear that individuals, institutions, and states are connecting and interacting with each other through a variety number of ways. Whether it is chatting with someone on the other side of the globe through social media or the flow of capital in the international banking system, our world has become increasingly interdependent; however, the benefits are not universal. From a Marxist perspective on international relations theory, particularly Wallerstein’s capital economy, I will define “globalization” as a phenomenon constructed by the bourgeoisie (elite members of society) in order to take advantage of developing countries that constitute Marxist proletariat. Using this approach on globalization, I will discuss the effects it has on “sovereignty” followed by a case study on Pakistan as a prime example. Ultimately, I will argue why the idea of sovereignty should still play a role in states like Pakistan. I draw primarily on the work of the German philosopher Karl Marx who, in his Marxist (or ruling-class) theory, claimed that capitalist societies were dominated by the “bourgeoisie” – individuals who control the means of production (therefore power) and take advantage of the proletariat (also known as the working class). Applied to a global scale, the concept of bourgeoisie......

Words: 2698 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Austins Theory of Sovereignty

...John Austin, in his Lectures on Jurisprudence writes : The notion of sovereignty and independent political society may be expressed concisely thus : ‘If a determinate human superior not in a habit of obedience to a like superior, receives habitual obedience from the bulk of a given society, that determinate superior is sovereign in that society: and the society (including the superior) is a society political and independent’. Laws are defined simply as the command of a superior to an inferior. In Austin’s words : ‘Law is the aggregate of rules set by men as politically superior, or sovereign, to men as political subject’. The chief reason for the bulk of a given society rendering habitual obedience to a determinate human superior is the power it possesses ‘to put compulsion without limit on subjects or fellow subjects’. As to what is the core nature of law, Austin's answer is that laws (“properly so called”) are commands of a sovereign. He clarifies the concept of positive law (that is, man-made law) by analyzing the constituent concepts of his definition, and by distinguishing law from other concepts that are similar: • “Commands” involve an expressed wish that something be done, combined with a willingness and ability to impose “an evil” if that wish is not complied with. • Rules are general commands (applying generally to a class), as contrasted with specific or individual commands (“drink wine today” or “John Major must drink wine”). • Positive law...

Words: 2480 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Lost Sovereignty(Revised)

...Alexis K Pointer ENGL 1101 Dr. Dominy 1 December 2014 Lost Sovereignty When an individual looks at the bigger picture than the small one in front of you and enjoy the experience instead of looking for ways to show proof to someone what you did or what you saw. I lost my sovereignty, power over something, because of a postcard I received in the mail from Philadelphia, which did not look the same in person. The postcard had beautiful, old buildings and clear blue sky. When we went a few weeks later the buildings were just old and the sky was not clear. I was so excited by the way Philadelphia looked on a postcard that I did not really experienced what it had to offer. Many people just like myself have lost their sovereignty at an event, place, or even showing evidence that they went somewhere. In “The Lost of the Creature” Walker Percy gives many examples of people losing their sovereignty while visiting places. A man from Boston is one of Percy’s examples. This man from Boston had seen a picture of the Grand Canyon on a postcard. While visiting the Grand Canyon the man was shocked by the way it looks. The canyon does not look the same as it does on the postcard. So the man was in a sense cheated out of a great experience that he could have had, because the postcard looked one way and was expecting the canyon to look the same way. As Percy stated “that the thing is no longer the thing as it confronted the Spaniard. It is rather that which has already been formulated, by...

Words: 709 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The Rise of Modern China

...The rise of modern china Student’s Name Name the course Instructor’s name Date   Erez Manela immediately after world war one, started writing on international and transnational arena, his writings revolve around 1919 Paris peace conference from the perspective of an outsider. Erez chose not to focus on the subsequent peace process that followed after the war and its impact on the main powers like European powers but rather he focused on the impact of the peace process on the side states like Korea and china. These countries didn’t play a major or rather significant role in the peace process in fact they were largely ignored. Central to his thesis is the Wilsonian message of national self-determination and equality among states. To be well conversant with the encumbrance and openings implanted in China's the excellent place to start is on Jonathan D. Spence's good new book. ''The Search for Modern China,'' a detailed account across centuries from the fall of the Ming dynasty in 1600 up to the point of death of the democracy movement in June 1989, will educate everybody students and public alike of Chinese history. The effect and similar causal sequence of Wilson's discourse from 1918 up to the end of Paris peace conference is what Manela defines as the "Wilsonian Moment. As per Manela, Wilson radical ideals was based on his need and determination for all the nations of the earth to become self-governed and to embrace colonial ideologies. Wilson was directing his message to......

Words: 1579 - Pages: 7

Free Essay


...Sovereignty After over 300 years of history, the question of Indian tribal sovereignty is still being debated and litigated daily. The question is, Who should exercise sovereign power over a wide range of governing activities — the tribes themselves, the states, the federal executive branch, Congress or the U.S. judicial system? Each legal entity has some claim to power, and the balance of authority between these powers has shifted over time. Because of this, tribes were forced to act under contradictory federal policies. * For some issues, tribes act as sovereign government entities similar to states within our federal system. * They act as special interest groups for other issues and at other times in their history. * Sometimes, they have to act as both simultaneously. Even those who have been dealing with the questions most directly admit they don't necessarily understand sovereignty. In Spiral of Fire, the former Principal Chief of the Eastern Band of the Cherokee Nation, Joyce Duggan, says, "Many people still have a hard time today understanding sovereignty. What does this sovereignty of Indian nations mean? I have a hard time with it too because we're not sovereign in this nation. If we were sovereign in this nation we would not have to depend on federal government dollars. We would not have to go to the state for gaming approvals. We would be able to live independently in our own nation, which is what we were doing in 1838 at the time of the......

Words: 992 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Popular Sovereignty

...Jaiza Williams U.S History Popular Sovereignty 06/17/2016 Pop culture is music, move, theater, film, T.V., verse and Art which is delighted in by a wide gathering of individuals. Some individuals would contend that pop culture in the 1960's cause hurt. Other individuals be that as it may contended that different variables conveyed damage and change to society. Some individuals would contend that music would bring about mischief due to the verses in pop tunes. Verses like 'Lets spend the night together' by The Rolling Stones, impacted youngsters to have easygoing sex. Moreover 'Lucy in the sky with Diamonds' by the Beatlesinfluenced youngsters to take drugs. Some individuals would contend that mainstream culture brought onto society through music verses. Mainstream culture was seen to damage society since youngsters venerated the individuals from pop gatherings. A case would Janis Joplin. Some individuals were stunned to learn 'she passed on of a medications overdose in 1970' (source G). They believed society would be hurt as progressively and more youngsters replicated her. Some segments of society were concerned by the responses of the fans to mainstream music bunches. Fans were seen to be 'a hurling deranged shouting mob'(source B) which may have been extremely startling to some segments of society. More established individuals from society could see the response of fans as harming to society in light of the fact that vast quantities of......

Words: 488 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Globalisation and Sovereignty

...In the context of IPE, what is globalisation? To what extent has the authority of nation states been eroded by globalisation? Discuss with reference to any OECD country. IPE and Globalisation In order to explain globalisation in the context of International Political Economy (IPE), I will begin by discussing the frameworks that IPE uses to describe the social constructs upon which human society is based. This discussion will then extend to issues pertinent to the essay question, including the concepts of globalisation, the nation state, authority and sovereignty, and the extent to which a nation state’s participation in a globally interdependent system influences that nation state’s authority. IPE connotes a multidisciplinary method of enquiry to explain the ever-changing relationships between states, markets and societies across history and in different geographical areas. IPE includes a political dimension that accounts for the use of power by a variety of actors including individuals, domestic groups, states, international organisations, NGO’s, and transnational corporations. IPE also involves an economic dimension that deals with how scarce resources are distributed among individuals, groups and nation-states. (Ballam and Dillman, 2011, p7) To place globalisation within the context of IPE, one must view the concept in terms of the causes and effects of the world market economy, the relationship between 2 economic and political change, and the......

Words: 3076 - Pages: 13

December 25, 2018 | Last Post | William Lo