Free Essay

Peer’s Critique Feedback

In: People

Submitted By marty4512
Words 412
Pages 2
Peer’s Critique Feedback

COMM/110

Peers Critique Feedback Peer review would refer to the many habits in which peers can share their creativity for constructive feedback then uses that feedback to revise and improve their work. The writing process, the modification is necessary as the draft of presenting, but peers often feel that they could not let go of their original words for introducing. Peers offer productive feedback, accept constructive criticism. Methods on critiques a presentation speech, to critique a speech or a presentation it's necessary to evaluate the presenters abilities in both speech and delivery. On determining whether the presenter is using facts and narratives to make a case. One method will be evaluating the content, by including word choices, references, and sketches should tailor to the audience that will be listening to the speech or presentation. Then it will follow the evaluation the speech or presentation clarity. The presenter should use correct grammar and easy to understanding language, making it pleasant to listen to the speech and follow what it is. Other would be on seeing if the statement is convincing and educational, in a well-written speech or presentation arguments are skillfully put forth to prove high points.
The implementation that I would plan on the suggestions that my teammates have mentioned and will be adding to my future presentations. The tone of voice was the critiques that my teammates comment on my tone of voice was low-slung. The steps that I will be conducting would overlook my tone from begging of the speech to middle down to the end and listen to myself, as well as pausing overlooking my sketches and more practicing in order not to break during presenting. The views that I have ignored and would implement on becoming successful from my classmate's presentations would be on eye contact to perform a more satisfactory performance eye contact will have to improve. Animation would have to decline well presenting; the choices of topics by having the right thing it will not have and distraction well presenting and have full contact well presenting.

Reference:

Lucey, B. (2013). Peer review: How to get it right – 10 tips. Retrieved June 27, 2016, from http://www.theguardian.com/higher-education-network/blog/2013/sep/27/peer-review-10-tips-research-paper
Dlugen, A. (n.d.). Speech Analysis #2: The Art of Delivering Evaluations. Retrieved June 26, 2016, from http://sixminutes.dlugan.com/speech-evaluation-2-art-of-delivering-evaluations/…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Critique

...review of Mahmood, Saleh, Al-Alawi, and Ahmed’s (2008) literary review may cause some eyebrows to be raised. First, this research was conducted in 2008, however, almost all referenced materials were from between 1980 and 1999. While there is not anything necessarily bad about citing older resources, the fact that nearly a decade of knowledge appears to have been mostly unmentioned is cause for critical analysis. A cursor review of the cited sources clearly shows that the contents are very relevant to the conclusions drawn by the author. This further indicates that the author wrote his conclusion based more upon the research of other than on his own research. His own research is extremely contradictory to the conclusions that he draws from his peer’s research. In conclusion, while the author appears to be conducting a quality research report about the effects of soda drinking on young girls in the United Arab Emirates, his conclusions to not seem to match the research. After an analyses of the independent variables, it is unclear that soda drinking has any negative impact on health. The research that was conducted resulted in a much higher level of obesity in the non-drinkers when compared to the drinkers. The authors’ data table clearly shows this. However, they then state that there is no significant difference. After stating that there is no significant difference, they conclude by saying that drinkers have a much greater risk of obesity. Every part of this research......

Words: 1364 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Open to Feedback

...Any organization open to feedback is considered better for business and their customers. There are many things an organization can do in order to be more open to feedback. Developing friendly environment can be first step do in order to be open to feedback. In addition social gathering, direct communication with customers and employees, system for providing feedback, suggestion box and surveys will help organization open to feedback. Effective communication, leadership and problem solving training would be effective. If were boss I would have tell them that feedback from customers is our strongest endorsement. Feedback is information which helps organization to achieve the desired result by clients. In addition it also helps manager to get the information regarding strength and weakness of organization. Reference Focus groups are generally a group of ten or few people who represent the customers and tell the need and preferences of customers. The advantages of focus group are easy measure of customer’s reaction, researcher can directly interact with the people, and this process is very quick and capable to use non verbal responses. The disadvantages of focus groups are- it is an expensive method as compared to questionnaires and surveys, it may fail to represent the large population, result may be biased and it can’t deal with the sensitive topics. With the help of experienced moderators, specific set of questions, right audience and preparation focus groups can be......

Words: 289 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Feedback

...essay will discuss that teacher feedback on assessment has long been part of the teaching and learning process and teacher-student relationship at university. Conversely, it is probable that teachers and students value feedback in diverse ways. Accounting to Hattie and Timperley(2007,p. 1) feedback was identified as acknowledge provided by teachers and students. Feedback has become an indispensable part of education, especially with teaching and learning procedures. According to Ovando(1994, p. 19) feedback has become a method to promote the learning process and teaching consequence. Understandably, instructors and learners have a different point of view on feedback. The assessment that students obtain from teacher's modification has been became a great volume of argument in collage across the world(Blair, Curtis, Goodwin &Shields, 2013,p. 66). The essay argues that normally, feedback is valued by both students and teachers, although this is not evident in all situations, or with all types of students and teachers. Further, it is argued that the instructors and students have different views on the value of feedback. The essay also states that although teachers and students form a different perspective on feedback, it is still important for both sides. One of the most powerful factors in learning and achievement is feedback, and this may be why students like feedback. Early research (Hattie & Timperley,2007, p. 15 )reported that feedback is among the most significant......

Words: 1009 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

360degree Feedback

... Berdasarkan hal diatas, maka perlu dilakukan perfomance appraisal dan 360° feedback. Perfomance appraisal merupakan penilaian kinerja karyawan di mana perusahaan menilai atau mengevaluasi kinerja kerja karyawan. Kegiatan ini memperbaiki kinerja serta memberikan feedback kepada para karyawan tentang pelaksanaan kerja. Performance appraisal adalah penilaian satu arah dari atasan terhadap bawahan dengan mengevaluasi, mengidentifikasi, dan mengembangkan kinerja karyawannya agar tercapainya tujuan-tujuan perusahaan. Performance appraisal menghasilkan suatu evaluasi atas kinerja karyawan di masa lalu atau prediksi prestasi di masa depan. Penilaian kinerja 360° feedback memungkinkan karyawan untuk memperoleh feedback dari beberapa sudut pandang. Sudut pandang yang dapat diberikan oleh metode penilaian kinerja 360° tentu saja luas yaitu sudut pandang dari atasan, bawahan, rekan kerja, dan dirinya sendiri. Hal ini bisa memberikan feedback yang signifikan terhadap karyawan. Metode penilaian 360° feedback juga menghemat waktu manajer karena banyak orang yang terlibat dalam proses tersebut. Feedback yang didapat dari metode penilaian 360° feedback ini tentunya mempunyai misi untuk meningkatkan kinerja karyawannya. Dengan umpan balik atau feedback yang didapat dari sudut pandang orang lain akan dapat membantu karyawan dalam mengoreksi dirinya sendiri dan pekerjaan yang dilakukannya. Feedback yang membangun diperlukan bagi setiap karyawan agar dapat mengubah diri nya......

Words: 17308 - Pages: 70

Premium Essay

360degree Feedback

...Table of contents 1. Research 360 degree feedback? …………………………………… 2 2.1 What is 360 degree feedback? ……………………………………… 2 2.2 What is 360 degree feedback intended to do? ……………………. 2 2.3.1 For individuals……………………………………………… 2 2.3.2 For organization ……………………………………………. 3 2. Analysing how heuristic, personality and social factors may affect the effectiveness of 360 degree feedback …………………………………. 3 2.1 Heuristic …………………………………………………………. 3 2.1.1 Confirmation ……………………………………………… 3 2.1.2 Representativeness ………………………………………… 4 2.2 Personalities ……………………………………………………. 4 2.2.1 Neuroticism ………………………………………………… 4 2.2.2 Conscientiousness …………………………………………. 5 2.3 Social Factors ………………………………………………….. 6 2.3.1 Interpersonal liking ………………………………………. 6 2.3.2 Referent power ……………………………………………… 6 3. References list ………………………………………………………. 7 1. Research 360 degree feedback 1.1 What is 360 degree feedback? 360 degree feedback is characterized as a multi-source feedback. Feedback comes from people, who work around with ratees, involving supervisors, colleagues, subordinates, internal and external customers as well as ratees. It is used in human resources management for different purposes such like decision making relating to rewards, performance evaluation, and employee development. Furthermore, it is......

Words: 2054 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Customer Feedback

...Opinions 3 Connections 5 Recommendations 6 Conclusions 8 References 9 Customer Feedback Many ideas explain why feedback does not satisfy a company’s needs. This paper will cover topics that researchers found to improve customer feedback. The major themes are survey methods, survey fatigue, and interpreting surveys. Data will be gathered from scholarly and unscholarly peer-reviewed journals. The articles demonstrated an application of knowledge to understand usable customer feedback. This paper will concentrate on revealing why businesses are dissatisfied with customer feedback and strategies a business can focus to improve customer feedback. We will also have a better understanding of why the customer feedback does not satisfy a company’s needs. The intent of this proposal is to show that businesses need to keep it simple when it comes to surveys. Obtaining usable customer feedback will give businesses a competitive advantage (Purdy, 2013). A business will understand that customers are overwhelmed with feedback and not answering correctly, or not doing surveys (Pecoraro, 2012). Customer feedback is the answer for keeping one business higher in a competitive business world (Jeppsen, 2010). Analysis and Opinions The literature review revealed the three themes that provided an insightful and thorough analysis of the issues that surround customer feedback. Survey methods is a structured questionnaire given to customers and designed to obtain specific......

Words: 1898 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Feedback

...3. Select a situation which you made a wrong inference. Analyze how the misinterpretation was made and discuss how you might avoid similar misinterpretations in the future. How important is feedback as an aid to avoiding inference problems? There was this one time when the Senior Accounting Processor, my immediate supervisor, asked me to accomplish an office requirement for her. After finishing the task assigned, I submitted the file to her and upon inspection she noticed that I filled up a different form. The form was indeed a necessary requirement to be passed but it wasn’t the one she needed at the moment. Looking back at what happened, the misinterpretation occurred because not one of us asked what the other meant. Both of us deduced that we were thinking of the same thing because we probably didn’t mind the fact that the requirement involved many forms to be filled up. As a result, I completed a form different to the one the accountant urgently needed. Learning from what happened, it would be best to communicate and verify my thoughts on the task before I do it to ensure that we indeed have an understanding. Therefore, I could say that feedback is very important in avoiding miscommunication and inference problems. 4. Describe a situation in which you experienced role conflict or role ambiguity. What caused it? How are the two idea related and how are they different? Role conflict occurs when there are incompatible demands placed upon an employee such that compliance...

Words: 395 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Critique

...A Critique on Mission Statements I. Introduction Upon entering into the market, a company does not necessarily have to have a mission statement; however, most successful companies achieve their objectives and goals through operating with and being founded upon a mission statement. The mission statement’s purpose is for companies to say much more about their business scope and purpose of ‘who they are, what it does, and why it exists’. Some companies project future growth in their mission statement; however, that projection can be stated in the company’s vision statement. This paper’s mission is to list and critique the mission statements of Spring Hill College and eight S&P 500 companies being: Google, Coca Cola, Avon, Walt Disney, Target, Wels Fargo, All state and Verizon Wireless. II. Spring Hill College’s Mission Statement Spring Hill College is a Jesuit Institution founded in 1830 by Michael Portier, Mobile’s first Catholic bishop. The mission of Spring Hill College a liberal arts and Jesuit College of the south reads: “Rooted in its Catholic heritage and continuing the 450-year-old Jesuit tradition of educational excellence, Spring Hill College forms students to become responsible leaders in service to others. We offer our students a thorough preparation for professional excellence; and we strive to awaken mind and spirit to the pursuit of truth and to the ever-deepening appreciation of the beauty of creation, the dignity of life, the......

Words: 2255 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Feedback and Opportunities

... Feedback: Important to the evaluation of an employee is the preparation for effective feedback and should include notes or specific details important to the review. If there are complaints to discus, issues about behavior, or performance, schedule enough time to review each subject thoroughly. As this is taking place the employee has enough time to prepare and be comfortable with the meeting. The next important factor in the feedback process is to ask the employee for an interview. Asking shows respect and gives an opportunity for the employee to consider if he or she wants to listen. If the employee decides not to listen another approach must be taken to ensure that the task is completed. Although many managers find the process of feedback distasteful, it is the responsibility of the manager to perform this task in an open and positive manner. The performance and behavior of the individual, when considered, should be assessed with thoughtful consideration for personal development. Avoiding criticism helps, and if there is a problem, setting mutual goals with the employee shows a caring attitude and respect. Also, following up on solution-based objectives if necessary, will benefit the employee and the organization. Opportunities provided for new employees after feedback is given: Adjusting to the new life in an organization can be challenging. After settling in and performing the job duties assigned, an opportunity for feedback......

Words: 1614 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Feedback

...[pic]Feedback: Transactions - week 2 This is a feedback page. Please review this page carefully because later pages in this practice set build on the feedback provided here. After you have reviewed your feedback page, click Continue at the bottom of this page to move on to the next page of your practice set. Your progress [pic] |[pic] Completed: |24% (approximately) | |[pic] Remaining pages will take: |up to 16 hours | The time frames we provide are a guide only. It may take you more or less time to complete each step. Your grading |Your grading outcome (still in progress) | |  |Awarded |Total | |Points (prior to this page) |212 |238 | |Points (on this page) |183 |219 | |Points (after this page) |− |824 | |Total |395 |1,281 | |  | Information from previous pages ▪ General instructions ▪ Policies and procedures ▪ All transactions ▪ Adjusting entries information ▪ Trial balance - May ▪ Schedules of accounts - May ▪ Inventory cards - May ▪ Bank reconciliation - May ▪ Bank statement - June ▪ Special printing information ▪ Journals and ledgers instructions ▪ Inventory cards instructions You are now instructed to record transactions that occurred throughout......

Words: 2725 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Feedback

...The feedback skill of interpersonal communication is beneficial to the workplace as it improves performance by enhancing creativity, promoting trust, and strengthening individual motivation (Baker, Perreault & Reid, 2013). Interpersonal communication can be defined as a type of continuous communication between people, that treat each others as unique individuals. This occurs systematically and throughout this engagement both parties construct and reflect selected personal information to create shared meaning (Wood, 2013). Interpersonal communication occurs when people genuinely reveal who they are and what they feel to each other. The interpersonal skill of feedback helps to create shared meaning by indicating higher responsiveness (Wood, 2013). Eunson (2012) states that feedback is a type of communication response that aims to provide advice and critique to another person supportively. In the workforce feedback can be used constructively to provide information on employees to promote positive change by reflection of performance goals and recent behaviours, this aligns employer performance with the company's objectives (Baker, A & Perreault, D & Reid,A 2013). For feedback to be beneficial in the workplace it must be effective to encourage the receptiveness towards ideas that aim to modify behaviour. The way feedback is delivered alters the receivers perception of the intended messages, the perception of organisational fairness and being treated respectful......

Words: 378 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Feedback

...Giving Feedback Keeping Team Member Performance High, and Well-Integrated Watch this video to learn how to give feedback effectively. "Performance review." Does the mere mention of this event make your heart sink? Employees and managers the world over dread this ritual and therein lays the main problem: We have institutionalized the giving and receiving of feedback. We save up our comments and document all the things we note about a person's performance. And then, like a big cat ready to pounce, the manager brings a hapless employee into the office and springs a year's worth of "constructive criticism" onto him or her. No doubt the process is seen as unnerving and fear provoking. And this is exactly the wrong emotional environment in which to discuss performance, introduce suggestions for improvement, and talk about goals for the future. This is a shame, because giving and receiving feedback is some of the most important communication you can engage in with members of your team. When done in the right way and with the right intentions, feedback communication is the avenue to performance greatness. Employees have to know what they are doing well and not so well. For them to really hear your thoughts and suggestions on ways to improve, though, that feedback has to be delivered carefully and frequently. Giving feedback effectively is a skill. And like all skills, it takes practice to build your confidence and improve. The following is a collection of "feedback giving"......

Words: 1422 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Feedback

...negative, given or received, feedback can be tricky. We shatter some popular misconceptions to guide you. Feedback isn't always easy to give or receive. But it's vital, and timing is crucial. Here are 12 popular feedback misconceptions corrected. Misconception 1: We don't need to worry about feedback, we conduct performance appraisals. Truth: Annual performance appraisals aren't enough. If you've been working unsatisfactorily for 12 months, you're awfully good at doing something incorrectly. And if you've been doing something well for 12 months and no one has mentioned it, your performance appraisal might feel like too little, too late. Performance appraisals should be summaries of everything employees and supervisors have been discussing all year. If you're a supervisor, find ways to provide feedback each week for each person who reports to you-- 52 mini performance reviews a year. Misconception 2: It's not my job to give feedback. Truth: At any company that values continuous improvement, feedback is everybody's job. If your workplace isn't feedback friendly, start a trend. First, praise. Reinforce positive actions and behaviors. Don't forget your boss: Positive feedback passed up the organization can have amazing results. Participate in suggestion programs honestly and enthusiastically. And request feedback on your own performance. Misconception 3: If you're not asked, keep your mouth shut. Truth: When you don't deliver critical feedback, you declare your......

Words: 2845 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Critique

...Critique Ayman, Chemers, and Fiedler reviewed the model of leadership previously described by Fiedler & Chemers in 1974 and Fiedler in 1967 Ayman, Chemers, and Fiedler (1995) found the following: The model predicts that a leader’s effectiveness is based on two main factors: a leader’s attributes, referred to as task or relationship motivational orientation [formerly referred to as style], and a leader’s situational control [formerly referred to as situational favorability]. The model predicts that leaders who have a task motivational orientation compared to those who have a relationship orientation or motivation will be more successful in high- and low-control situations. (p. 287) The purpose of their article was to address the confusion surrounding the model’s components like how they relate to each other (Ayman, Chemers, & Fiedler, 1995). According to Ayman, Chemers, and Fiedler (1995), “the model’s constructs are: (1) leader’s characteristics, (2) situational control, and (3) leadership effectiveness” (p. 288). Ayman, Chemers, and Fiedler’s conclusion is that contingency model of leadership has been in practice and aided by research for the last thirty years. They revised the strengths and weaknesses of the model. According to Ayman, Chemers, and Fiedler (1995): The greatest strengths of the model reside in: (1) the conceptual and statistical independence of its central constructs, LPC and situational control; (2) its emphasizes on independence and, where......

Words: 3483 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Feedback and Support

...Mentoring in the Clinical Setting Module 5: Feedback and Support in Coaching and Mentoring Module 5: Feedback and Support in Coaching and Mentoring An important aspect of coaching and mentoring is the ability to offer effective feedback and support. Again, these are transferrable skills which can be developed to help you facilitate a range of situations. It is also important that you personally receive effective feedback to assist you in your ongoing professional development. Learning objectives On completion of this module, students should be able to:     Describe the components of effective feedback; Initiate strategies to obtain feedback on their own performance in the clinical setting; Use effective strategies for giving feedback to others within the coaching/mentoring relationship; Identify an appropriate method for obtaining ongoing support in relation to their own professional development. Overview The overall aim of this unit is to equip students with the skills and understanding necessary to use coaching and mentoring techniques when facilitating professional development in the clinical setting. An integral part of this will be the giving of feedback to learners on aspects of their performance and professional development journey. Additionally, to further develop yourself as a skilled educator, it is important that you utilise skills for obtaining feedback on your own performance. In this unit, we use the term „feedback‟ to describe any communication which......

Words: 2770 - Pages: 12

For Apple iPhone XS Max XR X Front and Back 9H Tempered Glass Screen Protector | Secret Agent | The Disaster Artist