Premium Essay

Policy Analysis- Mandatory Vaccines

In: Other Topics

Submitted By sallychoi93
Words 2388
Pages 10
TO: President Barack Obama
FROM: Sally Choi
RE: Vaccine Mandates Regulation
DATE: April 22nd , 2015

Problem Statement:
What actions or measures can President Barack Obama take in order to balance the need to protect the public’s health in addressing concerns of citizens who may object to mandatory immunization requirements?

Background:
In the United States, virtually every state has enacted legislation in which they mandate some level of compulsory vaccinations for its citizens. In order for a child to attend public schools, they must receive all required vaccinations. Throughout history, many have disagreed and opposed vaccinations for various reasons. Many of the citizens do not believe that vaccines mandates to be constitutional. Also, many do not believe the state legislatures have the power to require everyone to receive certain vaccinations and view the authority as a violation of their constitutional rights. Recently, there has been an increase in people who are against to vaccinations as a possible factor to Autism in children. Also, religious beliefs play a role in opposing vaccinations for themselves and their children. These have built anger and opposition to the states mandates of some vaccinations.
In 1813, United States Vaccine Agency was established. “The U.S. Congress authorized and James Madison signed ‘An Act to Encourage Vaccination,’ establishing a National Vaccine Agency” (History of Vaccines RSS). This Act was the first push by the United States for citizens to get vaccinated. In 1855, Massachusetts was the first state that passed a law for vaccinations for all children that is attending school (History of Vaccines RSS). Passing laws for vaccinations brought more dispute and oppositions to vaccines, as well as, oppositions to vaccine requirements. By 1922, many United States schools required smallpox vaccination before children…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Vaccines Should Be Mandatory

...Vaccines should be mandatory The invention of the vaccinations has been one of the greatest health interventions, saving millions of people from infectious diseases (Ehreth, 2002). The vaccine program has had extraordinary success in decreasing the spread of preventable diseases (Zimmerman, 2000). Research shows vaccines are safe, provide a way to protect your child and society, and help avoid wide spread disease. Vaccines are not completely 100% safe, but it is safer than the infectious disease it is preventing (Concerns about vaccine safety, 2009). With any drugs, there are side effects, but serious ones are rare (Concerns about vaccine safety, 2009). Children are given vaccines at an early age when other development issues also come to light, and vaccines are given the blame (Concerns about vaccine safety, 2009). It is a coincidence that those developmental issues have surfaced at the same time. Most developmental issues surface in early childhood. Vaccine side effects are very rare. Before a new vaccine can be administered, vaccines endure many years of testing, making vaccines even safer (Wharton el al, 2001). Making the side effects even rarer. In 1999 most childhood vaccinations were reformulated to not contain Thirmosal as a preservative. Thimosal is 50% mercury containing organic compound most widely used in vaccines. It was used as a preservative in vaccines starting in the 1930’s. It has since been removed from vaccines for......

Words: 1247 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Policy Analysis

...Policy Analysis I What is she doing in a men’s jail? Transgender individuals in the right facility are a major concern of prisoners going through transgender change. As a refugee from Nicaragua, Luisa Espinosa was required to walk a gauntlet bare-chested while other inmates laughed, leered and made insults to her breasts. Espinoza stated many times inmates and officers made fun of her and making homophobic slurs. She had received this type of abuse in Nicaragua; she did not expect it here (Garvin, 2003). Espinoza was born male but had not yet completed the surgery to become a woman. She identified as a female her whole life. She has dressed as a female, wears her hair as a female and speaks femininely. She sits in jail awaiting the Immigration and Naturalization Service makes every effort to send her back to Nicaragua where she faces the same ridicule (Garvin, 2003). Formal complaints have been lodged with the Sacramento County Board of Supervisors by Espinoza and other transgender prisoners. They are stating the Sacramento Sheriff’s Department habitually violates the rights of transgenders. The grievances are the beginning to civil lawsuits and outline constant incidences of discrimination against Espinoza and other transgender inmates, prejudiced comments by jail employees and steady sexual harassment. This paints a picture of transgender people singled out for cruel and unusual chastisement in Sacramento’s main jail. Espinoza stated the San Francisco......

Words: 769 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Policy Analysis

...Policy Analysis Sandra Diaz Nova Southeastern University Newborn Screening for Congenital Heart Disease I represent the American Heart Association and this organization support Bill HB 81. The American Heart Association has been dedicated to the treatment and prevention of cardiovascular diseases of all age groups. Furthermore, our mission and goal is to" build healthier lives, free of cardiovascular disease, this is the single purpose that drives all we do and the need for our work is beyond question"(American Heart Association, n.d). Therefore, it is evident that this organization firmly support early screening, treatment and prevention of cardiovascular diseases. Congenital heart disease is the most common birth defect among newborns, affecting eight out of every one thousand newborn babies(Ewer et. al, 2011). It is also the leading cause of death among newborns within the first year of life. Early detection of congenital heart disease is crucial to newborn health and prevention of major problems later in child's life. Additionally, if detected early, congenital heart defects can be treated with surgical interventions or medication, depending on the severity. Pulse oximetry, a simple non invasive test and will be implemented as a screening tool for congenital heart disease(Kemper et. al, 2011). Bill HB 81 - Newborn Screening for Critical Congenital Heart Disease was sponsored by Cary Pigman(Republican, District......

Words: 2095 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Policy Analysis

...Running Head: POLICY Policy Analysis By Veronica Soto March 14, 2013 QNT/562 Professor Eboniece Cason Introduction Policy analysis is a social and political activity. Analysis means to break a policy down so it can be understood better. Thus public policy analysis is the examination of the components of public policy, the policy process or both. It is the study of causes and consequences of policy decisions. Policy analysis uses many different methods of inquiry and draws from various disciplines to obtain the information needed to assess a problem. There are eight different forms of policy analysis that will be discussed in this paper. Prospective Policy Analysis When using the prospective form of policy analysis it helps by using information and analysis before any action is taken. It is placing primary emphasis on what may be expected policy outcomes. According to Dunn, it is usually is systems analysts, decision analysts, operations researchers that are interested in using this type of policy analysis as it will give them information prior without any gathering of information. (Dunn, 2008) Retrospective Policy Analysis Retrospective analysis is a study in which a search is made for a relationship between one current condition and another that occurred in the past. An example would be a study of family history of young women whom have developed cancer which yields a relationship of the administration of “growth medicine” to the mothers of these......

Words: 707 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Policy Analysis

...Policy Analysis III Alicia Serna CJA 464 September 11, 2013 George Stragalas Policy Analysis III I will start this paper with a brief history on the crime control and due process models and the relationship with the criminal justice system. As stated on an article by Brandon A. Perron, who is a board certified criminal defense investigator, “The American justice system needs an effective strategy to combat crime,” which has been discussed for years(Perron, 2012). In the article, it states that the primary goals of the American criminal justice system has two primary missions which are: (1) the need to enforce the law and maintain social order, and (2) the need to protect people from injustice(Perron, 2012). However, the two goals are generally considered to be in conflict with each other. The first goal is referred to as the crime control model and was developed by Herbert Packer and presented to the academic workd in his analysis of the criminal justice system in the 1960s. The models place an emphasis and priority upon the aggressive arrest, prosecution, and conviction of criminals. The second goal is quite the opposite which focussed upon protecting the individual rights of the accused and is commonly referred to as the due process model. The are many policies that exist in the criminal justice system. Some of these policies have strong implication than others. Some of these policies can work in favor of the criminal and some of them can...

Words: 463 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Policy Analysis I

...Policy Analysis I CJA 464 October 7th, 2013 Policy Analysis I The constant battle of illegal immigration is a major issue in the United States that has been a constant issue for many years. The issues of illegal immigration are described as the migration of foreign citizens into the United States of America. This is done through illegal routes, such as hiding on boats porting in the United States, crossing through miles of treacherous terrain illegally to jump the borders of Mexico, and violating the agreement of a tourist visa as well as illegally boarding planes bound for the United States. It is a known fact that the men and women who enter this country do not meet the legal requirements to enter the United States from foreign countries. The research conducted will describe the issues of illegal immigration, whether the current policy is a regulatory or legislative-initiated policy, and the issue with the policy. A review of the possible constitutional violations will be described as well as if this issue or policy will affect the community, the accused, and the victims of any crimes committed by the illegal immigrants. The Issue The policy makers of the American government typically will take multiple routes in taking care of these issues before needing to develop a policy that will assist in combatting the concerns of the government. The existing immigration policies have been active for many years and for that same amount of time the policies have been......

Words: 1991 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Policy Analysis

...Policy Analysis I Zero Tolerance Policies Angelina Swofford October 27th 2013 CJA/464 Paul Brouillette Policy Analysis In this paper we are going to be discussing Zero-Tolerance policies and how they affect everyone in the community including the accused and the victim as well as those on the outside. We are going to discuss if this is a regulatory or a legislative policy and if there is any issues with the constitution with implementing this policy. There will also be a discussion of who started this policy and the reason for it being implemented into a policy. Zero-Tolerance Policies Zero Tolerance is something that happens in a lot of areas but the places we hear of it most is in schools and when it has to do with drugs. It is the intent of the legislature to promote safe and supportive learning environments in schools. This is to help protect all of those who are within the school building including staff and students. Zero-Tolerance Policies have to cover everyone within the school and all the same rules have to apply to everyone. In order to prosecute or give disciplinary actions within a school that hosts zero tolerance policies has to be based on a particular circumstance of a student’s misconduct (Florida Department of Education, 2005). Schools have a zero tolerance for bullying and drugs so these two zero tolerance polices go hand in hand. They also have zero tolerance policies that center just around drugs like in Elk Point South Dakota it is......

Words: 864 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Policy Analysis

...Policy Analysis Paper The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau began operation in 2011, after the failures within investment banks, commercial banks and government sponsored housing enterprises caused a financial crisis. The crisis caused a collapse of capital markets related to consumer lending. The results of the crisis included unemployment rates at 10 percent, a decrease in home values by 40 percent or more, and a sharp decline in household savings. Although the crisis affected all Americans, those that were most negatively impacted included the Hispanic and African American communities. The losses felt by these minorities widened the gap in financial assets that bipartisan policies had been trying to reduce. The driving force behind the financial losses within these financially vulnerable communities was mortgage lending due to the fact that some lenders were sold subprime mortgages although they qualified for prime rates. After the financial crisis, congress determined that regulation practices among federal bank and financial product regulators, as well as the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) was ineffective because it lacked adequate oversight and enforcement mechanisms. In attempts to remedy this issue, congress enacted legislation creating the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010 (Dodd-Frank Act). This Act reorganized the existing consumer financial protections into a new federal agency named the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau......

Words: 279 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Vaccine Policy Analysis in War Torn Countries

...On May 20, 2014 UNICEF released a statement where they expressed their appreciation of the U.S. Government not using vaccination efforts as a means to gather intelligence or for military purposes (1). When the hunt for Osama Bin Laden was underway, the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) launched a pseudo-vaccination campaign in Pakistan with the intention of discovering the DNA sequencing of the Bin Laden Family for identification purposes (3). This analysis looks at the various parties involved for this particular operation that spurred the statement as well as looking at the overall public health effects of this decision. Leadership In this CIA operation, the leadership included those in the CIA as well as those with Homeland Security and the Department of Defense. All stakeholders had one intention, which was about the defense of the Nation and not the public health implications. From a stakeholder perspective, if other members of the Federal Government were involved in this decision making process there could have been the potential for the operation being found out before a DNA sequence could be obtained. Decision makers had to determine the length that they were willing to go in an effort to capture the most wanted man in the world, or they could just make a formal apology to the world saying that they wouldn’t do it again after the fact. Norms and Standards If the number one goal of a nation is a self serving interest, then the United States proved that......

Words: 718 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Policy Analysis- Unemployment Insurance Policy

...Debbie Nahom Post University Policy Analysis- Unemployment Insurance Policy Historical Background Unemployment benefits are in place to provide temporary funding to help individuals and families to survive during unemployment. The policy analysis model will be used to review all aspects of the policy, including historical origins, strengths, and weaknesses, as well as how the policy has succeeded or failed in reaching the goals it was created to achieve. The origins of unemployment benefits date back to the 1700-1800s, when Switzerland and other European countries established voluntary benefits programs to aid those in need. Even the state of Wisconsin, in the early 1930s, had a voluntary unemployment benefits program, however the United States as a whole did not officially enact the unemployment benefits program until August of 1935 in response to the devastating effects of the Great Depression (DeWitt, n.d.). The Great Depression, one of the most devastating recessions the country has seen, caused more than 25% unemployment rate and had both federal and local governments spending over a billion dollars in relieve funds (DeWitt, n.d.). Legislatively, some efforts had been made over the years by the federal government as well as individual states, to address the problem of unemployment. Bills were introduced in 1916 and 1922 by states such as Connecticut, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New York, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, and......

Words: 1565 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Policy and Analysis

... POLICY AND ANALYSIS Name Course Tutor Date President George W. Bush’s and President Obama’s economic policy The US economy had experienced a series of depression in the past years but it was worst hit by the major terrorist attack of the September 11, 2011 that not only shook the nation but also the world at large. The realities of the recession started hitting the nation officially in December 2007, signaled by the collapse of the housing market and subsequent losses on mortgage related financial assets which in turn resulted to great stress and significant turbulence in the financial markets. All this resulted to an overall fall in the broader economic activity. In an attempt to respond to the worsening economic conditions, the administration lowered the federal funds rate by half the percentage point and as the crisis intensified, Bush’s government instituted the federal tax cuts on all the tax payers (Palley, 2011). The recession came to an end in June 2009 but the resultant economic weakness continued to be experienced in the nation with significant high rates of unemployment levels. There were severe job losses, a fall in family incomes and a rise in poverty levels which impacted negatively on the social life of many Americans. The economic environment also suffered severe losses in terms of drastic fall in investments due to uncertainties in the economy’s future. The adverse effects and subsequent fall in the trading activities led to significant falls in the......

Words: 1093 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Policy Analysis

...Policy Analysis Assignment HA415 After reading the assigned scenario for Congresswoman Moody, it involves what options are available for her to ensure that medical care is available to everyone within her area of jurisdiction. There have been issues with funding and it is my job to having a structured policy analysis to the given situation. First step of a concise policy analysis is defining the problem. In this case, the funds allocated to these trauma centers are nearly exhausted and can potentially cause catastrophic effects on the areas patients. Soon the trauma centers will be refusing the patients who rely on Medicaid and Medicare resources. What can be done to prevent the refusal of healthcare to these patients and ensure that bailouts are not the solution to this healthcare crisis? To provide more in depth about this problem involves the background for a policy analysis. It has been stated that with numerous amount of undocumented workers and the state’s unemployment rate to continually remain high, it is making it difficult for these trauma centers to accept these patients. They rely soley on Medicaid which has caused a depletion of the state’s budget. This has caused two of the three trauma center to rely on private payer instead of federal aid programs. In the long run how can these HCO’s say they are providing quality effective healthcare to their people by denying it to certain groups? This will now lead us to......

Words: 672 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Public Policy Analysis

...Public Policy Analysis Fredrick Wallace Capella University POLICY ANALYSIS OF THE ACT TO AMEND SECTIONS 4145 AND 4147OF, AND REPEAL SECTION 4146 OF , BUSINESS AND PROFESSION CODE, TO AMEND SECTION11364OF,AND TO ADD CHAPTER 13.5 (COMMENSING WITH SECTION 121285) TO PART 4 DIVISION 105 OF, THE HEALTH AND SAFETY CODE, RELATING TO HYPODERMIC NEEDLES AND SYRINGES (Senate Bill 1159) SUMMARY Senate Bill (SB) 1159 makes the Disease Prevention Demonstration Project (DPDP), cooperation in the middle of drug stores and nearby and the government health authorities. Area under discussion of the local government approval, Senate Bill 1159 permits authorized drug stores which are listed enlisted in the health division that offer ten or less sterile needles and syringes, permitting the government to take an interest in the management state venture. The procurement dusks on December 31, 2010, if not the governing body revises law which amplify otherwise dispense with the nightfall day. Senate Bill 1159 mandates drug stores that create deals that embrace endorsed exercises, together with submission of clean injection disposal projects towards assurance to those syringes and needles will be discarded within a suitable way, as well as giving composed data otherwise unwritten advising taking place the most proficient method to get to medical action, in addition to assessment and cure of HIV and hepatitis C infection (HCV). Senate Bill 1159 allows an individual to have 10 clean......

Words: 2329 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Policy Intervuew Analysis

...Policy Interview Analysis For this essay I chose to interview Carla, a Registered Nurse, with twenty years of experience, from the Operating Room. She has seen many changes occur in healthcare during his career. This paper will discuss some of the values he finds most important for creating an equal healthcare system. In order to establish an equal healthcare system, coverage needs to be affordable, with equal opportunities for everyone, and American’s need to feel they have the freedom of choice for the type of coverage they want. Healthcare coverage first of all, needs to be affordable. Employers should pay all or most of the healthcare premiums to cover their employees. The coverage should be competitive and at the same time the employee should have the right to choose if they want to be covered or seek private insurance. Mandatory physical exams and blood work should be discussed in detail at employee forums and human resources should not just assume all employees know their coverage rights. Physician’s office staff should be well educated in insurance literacy to let their patients know what their coverage rights are. This will keep the patient from getting a surprisingly high statement in the mail. Those who are eligible for Medicare should not have deductibles. If they are on Medicare then they obviously fall below some standard and therefore do not have the money to pay for medical coverage. Carla states, “Medicare should not be eliminated......

Words: 874 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Vaccine Should Be Mandatory

...should I get vaccinated? It is just a waste of time and money. I never got vaccinated before and never will.” That’s what one of my colleagues said when he was asked to get vaccinated during the outbreak of SARS, severe acute respiratory syndrome, few years ago in Mongolia. Then, I had reasoned him that disease comes all of a sudden and it is more serious than he thinks. As reported on CDC, Centers for Disease Control, 40 percent of all American parents were refusing one or more vaccines for their children (Willrich 3). So it is clearly one of the most significant public health issues today. There are lots of people who hold the belief against vaccination because of several reasons. Even though there is a public notion that vaccine has bad effects on human body, I strongly believe that vaccinating is the most crucial and effective way to keep people healthy by preventing future diseases and it also helps people to avoid spreading out the infectious diseases. Therefore, vaccination should be mandatory. First of all, I believe that the precaution of future disease should be imposed. People need to get vaccinated to improve their immune system to avoid future diseases and they need to be responsible for their safety. According to Michael Willrich, an internationally recognized historian, the contagious disease called smallpox spread out across the country at the turn of the 20th century. It is one of the deadliest diseases in human history that killed twenty five to thirty......

Words: 1094 - Pages: 5

DELL LAPTOP WINDOWS 10 PC Core i5 2.4Ghz 4GB RAM WiFi DVDRW NOTEBOOK 250GB HD$144 18d left | Watch Movie | Fundamental Problems of Economic System