Free Essay

Pros and Cons of Stand Your Ground Rule

In: Social Issues

Submitted By kimchappell
Words 636
Pages 3
The infamous George Zimmerman case has stirred the controversy around Stand Your Ground laws and brought these laws to the public light, becoming the subject of vigorous nationwide debates whether these laws should be repealed or not. Like many controversial legislative, Stand Your Ground laws have their critics and proponents, and both sides tend to make valid points in defense of their position. The goal of this paper is to show cons and pros of Stand Your Ground laws. In Florida as well as 21 other American states, as stated by to the National Conference of State Legislatures, the above-mentioned laws are self-defense laws that relieve individuals of their “duty to retreat from an attacker before using force against them anywhere they are legally allowed to be” (Clark). While in general these laws do not use such a notion as “stand your ground” specifically, Florida together with nine other states has these words in its law. In Stand Your Ground law in Florida, particularly, it is stated that “a person who is not engaged in an unlawful activity and who is attacked in any other place where he or she has a right to be has no duty to retreat and has the right to stand his or her ground and meet force with force, including deadly force, if he or she reasonably believes it is necessary to do so to prevent death or great bodily harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the commission of a forcible felony” (qtd. in Clark). The major con of this law, as its critics think, is that it essentially gives individuals with malicious intent a legal loophole to avoid criminal prosecution for killing someone if these individual state that they had to defend themselves. Eric Holder, the US Attorney General, is among those opponents of Stand Your Ground laws who believe that these laws will allow individuals to provoke others to attack them first and then, as it can be deemed self-defense and these individuals will not have the duty to retreat, they will be able to kill them without fear of getting prosecuted (Cooke). In states with Stand Your Ground laws, people will not have to think twice whether they should use weapons to defend themselves against the attackers or retreat because they will have the right to kill their attackers. Such violence will breed further violence. Criminals may use this law to cover up the deliberate and premeditated killing of people. However, proponents of this law may respond to the above-mentioned claims of their counterparts as follows. This critique of Stand Your Ground crumbles under the weight of the argument that “In almost every state, if and when an individual enters into an altercation with the deliberate intention of provoking the other party into threatening him with death or injury, they lose the right to claim that they were acting in self-defense” (Cooke). All individuals have the right to liberty and life and therefore, they have the right to defend themselves. Those who attack people violate their victims’ rights to live, so Stand Your Ground laws legally recognize these rights, attempting to “tilt the balance in favor of the attacked” (Cooke). Both, the opponents and proponents of Stand Your Ground laws have reasonable and sound arguments, but they need to find some middle ground regarding these laws that will satisfy both sides.

Works Cited
Clark, Korey. Nearly Half of States Have "Stand Your Ground" Laws like Florida's. 2013. Web. 28 Nov. 2013. http://www.lexisnexis.com/legalnewsroom/criminal/b/criminal-law-blog/archive/2013/07/24/nearly-half-of-states-have-quot-stand-your-ground-quot-laws-like-florida-39-s.aspx. Cooke, Charles C.W. Stand Your Ground on Stand Your Ground. 2013. Web. 28 Nov. 2013 .…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Stand Your Ground

...Stand Your Ground Gerald Makey SOC 205 Strayer University The “Stand-your-ground law validates a person in using any physical force including deadly force, when they are not involved in illegal activity and is in a place where he or she has the right be, they have no obligation to haven and have the right to stand their ground. A quick breakdown of this law is that it give a person legal cover in the event that they find themselves in a certain situation in which their survival, or the preservation of their family necessitates them to stand their ground and use a weapon for defense. This law can be referenced back to the Supreme Court case Beard v. United States, 158 U.S. 550 (1895). It is defined in this case that, “A man assailed on his own grounds, without provocation, by a person armed with a deadly weapon and apparently seeking his life is not obliged to retreat, but may stand his ground and defend himself with such means as are within his control; and so long as there is no intent on his part to kill his antagonist, and no purpose of doing anything beyond what is necessary to save his own life, is not guilty of murder or manslaughter if death results to his antagonist from a blow given him under such circumstances (www.justia.com). In Houston, Texas a “Stand-your-ground” case has brought a lot of attention, but also a lot of controversy. In this case Raul Rodriguez was found guilty of killing his neighbor over a dispute over loud music. Rodriguez who was a retired...

Words: 298 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Pro and Cons of Legalizing Marijuana

...The Pro and Cons of Legalizing Marijuana Genaro Esparza SOC 120 Jenna Soard May 1, 2011 The Pros and Cons of Legalizing Marijuana In 2010 an estimated 443,000 people died prematurely from smoking tobacco or exposure to secondhand smoke, and another 8.6 million live with a serious illness caused by smoking. Despite these risks, approximately 46.6 million U.S. adults smoke cigarettes. Alcohol use last year led to 14,406 alcoholic liver disease deaths and 23,199 other alcohol related deaths excluding accidents and homicides. (Alcohol Use, 2009) Despite these alarming statistics, these substances remain legal and socially acceptable while marijuana, which has never killed anyone anywhere, is illegal, remains classified as a stage one controlled substance, which likens it to killer drugs such as LSD, and heroin, both so lethal you could die with a single use. Why is it socially acceptable to use substances, which kill thousands a year while a plant that is practically a miracle drug remains portrayed as one of the most dangerous substances, known to man? In this paper, we will look at the pros and cons of legalizing marijuana the financial impact as well as the effects it would have on industry. We will also look at social impact caused by legalizing marijuana can it be socially acceptable. Alcohol and tobacco continually kill people by the thousands and yet remain legal, why then is marijuana, a drug that has never killed a single person still illegal. The...

Words: 2860 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Stand Your Ground Law

...t Stand Your Ground Laws Name Institution Date Abstract The dissension encompassing Stand Your Ground laws have recently seized the nation’s heed. So far about eighteen regimes have accepted laws extending the right to ‘self-defense with no duty to retreat’ to any region a person has a legal right to be. Several governments are also debating the passing of similar legislation. Inspite of implications that the laws may have for public well-being, there has been less empirical investigation of their impact, not only on crime but also on victimization. This laws makes it easier for some people to use deadly force when their “reasonably fears” result in serious injury at the hands of others. In such cases, those persons may be entitled to immunity from prosecution and civil liability. In fact, these laws usually confer powers that police have on private citizens, without the need of training kind and accountability. Before the Stand Your Ground laws, right to use deadly force was strictly not allowed. An individual had to show that it was reasonable to believe that the use of such force was necessary to prevent sudden death or great harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the imminent commission of a forcible ‘felony’. Only when a person was attacked in his home by a person not having an equal right to be there, she/he had a duty to retreat if he/she could do so in safety. Florida was unambiguous in protecting human beings.an individual......

Words: 2285 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Pros and Cons

...about what you’re wearing, looking poised and feeling self-assured in all situations. Would you believe that something as simple as how you dress could affect your attitude and self-confidence? The truth is, how people dress is related in some way to how they feel. They feel first and dress later. Just think of a time when you didn’t feel well, did you want to pull out all the stops and dress smart? Not likely. You probably pulled on whatever was closest to you and dressed the way you felt – not that well. If we change the way we dress the way we feel will change. When we are dressed well and look good we automatically feel better. When we feel good we are more likely to feel good inside, have more energy and treat others better. You can boost your attitude, self-confidence and feel good about what you’re wearing if you: 1. Knowing the occasion 2. Know your audience 3. Know your personal style 4. Know the effects of colour http://www.selfgrowth.com/articles/Dress_with_Confidence_How_Dressing_Affects_Your_Attitude_and_Confidence.html Know Your Personal Style Your personal style is expressed in everything you do. When it comes to fashion your style is evident in the patterns and texture of fabrics you like to wear as well as your accent pieces such as jewelry, handbags and shoes. When you are aware of your style and feel comfortable with it then you can express yourself with confidence. Take a moment to decide which one of the four style preferences best suits......

Words: 515 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Stand Your Ground Rule

...Stand your ground rule Julio Martinez ITT Technical Institute Mr. Horne Abstract A "stands your ground" law states that a person may use deadly force in self-defense without the duty to retreat when faced with a reasonable perceived threat. So what's the problem with this law, it seems that since the shooting of Trayvon Martin this law got put in the spot light, or is it racial profiling. Can the press play a big part on how this law is being criticize or are they using these shooting for rating. Stand your ground rule So what is the stand your ground rule? A “stands your ground” law states that a person may use deadly force in self-defense without the duty to retreat when faced with a reasonable perceived threat. The laws expand on the “Castle doctrine,” which says that a person is protected under the law to use deadly force in self-defense when his or her property or home is being invaded. About sixty percent of the states have some kind of “Castle doctrine” or “stand your ground”. So what’s the problem with this law, it seems that since the shooting of Trayvon Martin this law got put in the spot light. Are we the people abusing this law or are we just ignorant to the law. So is this law case in particular out in the spot light because of a young black man been shot or because the shooting was wrongful. What about Jordan Davis? Did Michael Dunn have the right to shot Jordan Davis in self-defense? Did he deserve to die because of loud music? So here we have a...

Words: 1225 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Pros and Cons of an Employment Contract

...Pros and Cons of an Employment Contract Abstract An employment contract or contract of employment is an agreement between an employer and an employee which sets out their employment rights, responsibilities and duties. These are called the terms of the contract. The employment contract does not have to be in writing. However, the employee is entitled to a written statement of the main employment terms within two months of starting work. (Heathfield) The employment contract is made as soon as the employee accepts the job offer. When the employee starts work it will show that they accepted the job on the terms offered by the employer, even if the employee does not know what they are. Having a written contract could cut out disputes with the employer at a later date, and will help the employee understand their employment rights. Introduction A written employment contract is a document that the employer and employees sign setting forth the terms of the relationship. The employer does not have to enter into a written contract with every employee you hire. In fact, written employment contracts are generally the exception, rather than the rule. In some situations, however, it makes good sense to ask an employee to sign a contract. (Heathfield) The concept of an employment contract seems simple enough: “You work for me and I pay you for that work.” But there are some very important contractual nuances to the relationship between employers and employees which all human......

Words: 2272 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Stand Your Ground Law, Trayvon Martin Case

...17, went to the store to buy a bag of skittles and a can of ice tea when attacked by neighborhood watchmen, George Zimmerman. Martin is a resident of Miami, but was visiting his father in Sanford. Zimmerman saw Martin walking in the gated community that he lives in and called 911 to report him for “suspicious action”. After being told by the emergency operators not to follow Trayvon, Zimmerman proceeded. He pursued young Martin and ordered him to “stand his ground”. Alarmed by what was happening, Martin turned his back and continued to walk back to his father’s fiancé’s home. Zimmerman attacked Martin and in the process was hurt. Zimmerman pulled out a gun and fired two shots. The first shot had missed, but the second made direct contact. Trayvon Martin died from a bullet wound minutes after being shot. Neighbors around the area called 911, claiming to have heard gunshot. Zimmerman was released on terms that he only attacked due to “self-defense”. According to Florida laws, Zimmerman is a free man under the “state you ground” law. This has caused a national outrage with protests and marches taking place all over the United States. President Obama has stated that if he had a son, he would look like Trayvon Martin. He has also requested a more in-depth investigation in the case. Now thousands march the streets in protest against the ruling of the case. The people see it as unfair that Zimmerman is allowed to go free. About 8,000 people came from all over the nation to......

Words: 1471 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Stand Your Ground

...Morthland, R. (2012, March 28). 'Stand Your Ground' Laws Protect the Innocent. Retrieved November 4, 2014, from http://www.usnews.com/debate-club/are-stand-your-ground-laws-a-good-idea/stand-your-ground-laws-protect-the-innocent Wallace, P. A., & Crowe, K. (2008). Stand your ground, revisited: Measuring reasonable fear. Forensic Examiner, 17(1), 74-77. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/ docview/207651496?accountid=35812 Weaver, Z. L. (2008). Florida's “Stand Your Ground” Law: The Actual Effects and the Need for Clarification. University Of Miami Law Review, 63(1), 395-430. Retrieved from http://web.a.ebscohost.com.ezproxy. apollolibrary .com /ehost/detail/detail?vid=3&sid= aec30e20-5a5e-4b4c-8159-f2e72c79a41b%40 sessionmgr4003&hid=4101&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZQ%3d%3d#db=lgs&AN=502051509 What would you do if you were in a situation where you felt you were in danger? The Stand Your Ground law “states that an individual has no duty to retreat from any place they have lawful right to be and may use any level of force, including lethal, if they reasonably believe they face an imminent and immediate threat of serious bodily harm or death,” as stated by U.S. Congress candidate, Michael McKenna. Don’t be a victim! The Stand Your Ground law is an important tool in protecting the right of self-defense. Though there is still much scrutiny regarding the clarity of the law, as identified in Florida's "Stand Your Ground" Law: The Actual......

Words: 454 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Pro / Con

...potential employees before they need to fill a job. Or, as Harvey Mackay, well-known, irreverent, author and speaker, says about networking, Dig Your Well, Before You're Thirsty. A strategy that the organization can implement to attract and select qualified applicants could be to offer a referral program with incentive for the employee. Referral programs can do marvels for a business. Referred employees have a greater retention rates and increase employee commitment in their business. By opening up the opportunity for more people to make referrals only increases your chances of finding good talent that is if the right people are doing it. Keep in mind that this isn't about filling an open space, this is about filling the right slot with the right person. My second idea or strategy would be to elevate what we use daily, the world wide web. Instead of the , dryly transcribed job listings about an open positions, our web site will need to include this vision, this info that sets your business apart from others in your business. Our job listings must ooze with personality and charm so a probable candidate thinks, "this organization is for me." Then, now that you have their attention, we also need to make available a way for candidates to easily submit resumes for consideration for future openings. A successful way to ensure that your companies job analysis is working would be to measure the employees to handle each function on the job analysis from a scale of 1-10. I would......

Words: 2229 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Pros and Cons of Css Styles

...It237 week 2 Pros and cons of Css Styles There are many pros and cons of the cascading style sheets and three different ways that they are used there is in line external and imbedded. The inline method is not really practical because of the consumption of bandwidth that it takes to display each code on each page because on the inline style the code requires web developers to apply this CSS code to each tag be applied this would require developers to have to apply the code so many times that it will take up a lot of time to write. The separation of markup rom CSS presentation is not optimal with an inline style this is the inline style applied to heading The external CSS is another type of style sheet and this was more practical for updating many documents at one time. Another pro about the external CIA says is that your style information can be cashed by the browser so you will not have to write it into individual tags. The cons that I found with the external style sheets is that in some circumstances when import was used it will render the flash with slow environments here’s an example of an external style sheet Body {font-size: medium; Font-family: Serif; Background-color: black; Color: white;} #page {background-color: white; Color: black; Padding: 1em;} H1 {font-size: xx-large; Font-family: San- Serriff; Color: black; Text-align: center; Border-bottom: solid 4px orange;} P {text-indent: 1em; Text-align: justify; 1in-height: ......

Words: 395 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Pro Con

...is inappropriate. The loss, theft, unlawful disposition and/or recovery of an item in this category will be investigated in accordance with DOD 4000.25-25-1-M and DOD 7200.10-M. 8 High Sensitivity (Category II) - Arms, ammunition, and Explosives with a physical security classification of confidential. 9 Controlled Cryptographic Item (CCI). CCI is described as secure telecommunications or information-handling equipment associated cryptographic component, or other hardware item that performs a critical COMSEC function. Items so designated are unclassified but controlled and will bear the designation "Controlled Cryptographic Item or CCI." $ Nuclear weapon use control (UC) ground equipment which is CIIC unclassified but may need special controls. Use control ground equipment is described as recorders, verifiers, adapters, power supplies, cables, programmers, monitors, controllers, code processors, power converters, computers, and data modules which perform a nuclear weapon use control function. PILFERABLE ITEMS: A CIIC Pilferable Items Code indicates that the materiel has a ready resale value or civilian application as to personal possession, and therefore, especially subject to theft. I Aircraft engine equipment and parts. J Pilferable Item - Pilferage codes may be designated by the coding activity to items coded U (unclassified) by recoding the item to J. M Hand tools and shop equipment. V Individual clothing and equipment. W......

Words: 17337 - Pages: 70

Free Essay

Pros and Cons

...Pros More coverage. Coverage will expand to cover nearly 95 percent of legal U.S. residents. With a recent study showing that patients without health insurance have a shorter life span, coupled with the number of uninsured approaching 50 million in 2010, that is perhaps the biggest reason to cheer. A more competitive insurance industry. Increased regulation will stop insurance companies from rigging prices–that recent 40% insurance premium increase in California comes to mind. Competition with newly formed public entities will ideally make the entire industry more competitive. Also, insurance companies are now required to post their balance sheets, executive compensation, and administrative costs online. Insurance companies will have to accept everyone. No more pre-existing condition exclusions. They can’t place limits on coverage anymore, either. Cheaper prescriptions for seniors. It’s reform. We need reform. We’re in a situation where healthcare is even becoming unaffordable to employers, leaving employees with higher out-of-pocket expenses even if they’re ensured. Healthcare costs have jettisoned innumerable people from the middle class. People get sick and die because insurers won’t take them. This isn’t functional. Any kind of reform helps. Cons Cuts in Medicare. The elderly on Medicare will see their benefits changed dramatically. The biggest item being used to pay for the new program is more than $500 billion in cuts to the program at a time when......

Words: 434 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Pros and Cons of Marijuana

...claims that medical marijuana may work wonders for people suffering from chronic and terminal illnesses, there are people out there who find drugs, even for medical purposes to be completely morally wrong. For some religious believers, any type of substance abuse, even medical, can and will be seen as a sin. Legalizing marijuana would send many religious fanatics into frenzy because of this aspect. * A very serious reason why, in my personal opinion, I feel as though it should not be legalized, is that if the drug is so widely used, and easier to get your hands on, it could just as easily get into the hands of minors. It is already an epidemic with younger generations becoming addicted to cigarettes and alcohol, who is to say that the same will not come of the legalization of marijuana? Reasons Why Possession and Use of Marijuana Should Be Legal: * As I mentioned in the above list of cons, there are also medical pros to such use of marijuana. Studies have shown and verified the positive effects of medical marijuana use by cancer patients and those faced with terminal and chronic illnesses. It is said to greatly help reduce stress and depression of those going through chemotherapy, and can help alleviate pain related to the illness. * With the legalizing of marijuana and possession thereof, the police that once harassed those possessors (mostly being men and women of color), would be freed up from petty crime charges against civilians, to handle more serious......

Words: 709 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Pros & Cons of Police Unions

...Analysis Paper 3: Pros and Cons of Labor Unions The right to self-organization is the right of every worker, free of any intrusion from the employer to form, join or assist in the formation of any legitimate worker's organization or union of his or her own choice. The reason for granting this right is grounded on the essential unfairness in the bargaining situation between an employer and his employees. As the issue of employment bargaining is concerned, there is no doubt that the employer stands on higher ground than the employee. That being said brings me to ask the question: Are labor unions good or bad? To start with, there is greater supply of labor than the demand for labor. Consequently, the employer has the choice to levy demands upon his employees. Next, the need for employment by labor often times arises out of desperation and necessity. As a result, the labor must protect labor to the extent of raising him to equal stability in bargaining relations with his employers and to protect him against abuses. This is in recognition of the principle that those who have less in life should have more in law. The right to form unions is a palpable indicator of the protection accorded by law to labor. By giving employees the opportunity to unite themselves against the employers, they can negotiate with their employers for better wages, benefits and terms and conditions of employment. Certainly, there is no better vehicle for securing change in the workplace than the......

Words: 834 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Pros and Con of Globalization

...1. In your opinion; what are the pros and cons of globalization? Humans are the only living species in the world that are very genius. Humans have a very highly developed brain and are able of abstract reasoning, problem solving, creating and language. Humans adapt the way of communication, exchange of ideas, organize and develop the basis of human society. Humans never stop learn new things which is lead to the world more connected to each other than ever before and international communication is more common place. As Deresky (2011) define “globalization is global competition characterized by networks of international linkages that bind countries, institutions, and people in an interdependent global economy” (p.18). Globalization become one the most talk of the town subjects, and has been considered cause of changes which positive and negative impact the quality of human life. Globalization is a double-edged sword. It narrows the world for people to know different culture, trade product and technology, and job are created in other country. The world is connected by worldwide market for companies and consumers to access product from different countries. Therefore, people will exchange the knowledge of different culture, traditional and information. Socially we have become more open, and people who live in the other part of the world are not considered aliens. According to Krueger (2003), he described that many benefits from trading between each countries, “A large......

Words: 444 - Pages: 2

Rosenthal Figur Frühlingsbote Figurine Jugendstil Figure Caasmann 1910 1 Wahl | Singapore | Weihnachten