Free Essay

Realism Is a Set of Conventions That We as Viewers Understand, in a Given Historical Moment, to Be a Representation That Corresponds to Reality. Through the Close Analysis of Soap Opera – and with Reference to at Least

In: Other Topics

Submitted By desola93
Words 1684
Pages 7
Realism is a set of conventions that we as viewers understand, in a given historical moment, to be a representation that corresponds to reality. Through the close analysis of soap opera – and with reference to at least three academic sources, outline the conventions of realism and explain how they are used effectively in British soaps.

Realism has been universally recorded as the quality of representing a person or situation in an accurate way. Ever since the conversion from radio to television, British soap operas have used realism effectively to attract and sustain audiences. Coronation Street (1960- ), the British soap opera set in a fictional town in Manchester and Eastenders (1985- ), the British soap opera set in a fictional London Borough are currently the two main soap operas in Britain where realism is used effectively to draw audiences. The original producer of Eastenders once commented, “We don’t make life, we reflect it” (Geraghty, 1991:32). This shows that representing reality has always been the main aim in this genre. This also shows that they are not trying to create their own town, with their own conventions, but rather reflect what they see in everyday life into the soap opera.

One main way in which realism is conveyed is by the sense of place and/or community. A sense of place can easily be established by the title sequence alone. For example, Eastenders’ title sequence consists of a map of London’s east end (Allen 1995: 67). This sets up the sense of place, before the show has even started. Many British soap opera has some sort of community for example, Eastenders community is Albert Square. This community consists of a public house, houses, apartments, shops and café’s. Coronation Street’s community is called Weatherfield and consists of similar sets as Eastenders. “For the British soaps – the extension of familiar relationships into the community is very important, enabling a group to be brought together which might otherwise be split by the conflicting interests of age, gender and class.” (Geraghty, 1991:84). In regards to this, the pub is the main set where different people from the community are brought together. Here, Geraghty is claiming that a strong community is important to British soap opera because at the time of when British soap operas emerged, community was important to society. Therefore, creating realism.

The stability of the community is essential, as audiences for soap operas tend to engage with the show as a whole (the community and the characters) rather than individuals. This is why it is imperative that soaps get this area of production right.

However, although the community is a convention of realism, individuals have questioned if how the community gather does represent realism. Many have argued that many communities do not gather at the same pub every night, like what occasionally happens in Eastenders and Coronation Street.

Another convention of realism in British soap opera is the regional accents and characteristics the characters evoke. The accents and characteristics of the characters in soap operas are crucial, as they give a sense of place. (Geraghty, 1991:35) commented “regional authority gives the soaps a sense of specificity crucial to realism and the ability to work with regional characteristics”. Geraghty is claiming that representing a particular region in soap operas effectively evokes originality. It provides “an ‘authentic’ regional experience” (Geraghty, 1991:35). This convention is used effectively in all of the current British soap operas. For example, characters from Eastenders will use jargon specific to London, while characters from Coronation Street will use jargon specific to Manchester. This enhances realism as it shows cultural differences, which is in line with real life. Also, it wouldn’t be realistic if someone from Manchester played a character on Eastenders because their accent wouldn’t be consistent with the accents spoken in the east end of London.

One typical convention that British soap operas use to convey realism is by the issues and problems, also known as themes that the characters encounter. This convention is used effectively to create realism as it showcases characters that seem to be more relatable to the audience. “Some themes are of such significance that they achieve recognition and resonance – and unite or excite or trouble the nation as issues are revealed and explored” (Hobson, 2003: 141). Soap operas not only explore these themes for entertainment purposes but also to create awareness to the public, while also giving examples with how to deal with the issues. British soap operas have used this technique many times. For example Eastenders has addressed the issue of Bipolar disorder, marital violence and cancer. Coronation Street has addressed issues including rape and immigration. Brookside has also addressed real, everyday issues including poverty and industrial disputes.

The most recent and controversial issue is when Ronnie Mitchell’s child died of cot death on New Years Eve. This is an example of when a theme has troubled the nation. This storyline saw over 23,000 viewers complain to the BBC, while Ofcom received over 1,000 complaints (Hooper, 2011). Although Eastenders addressed a real issue that has affected many women around the world, viewers complained about how Ronnie reacted to the death of her child. As a result of Ronnie losing her child, she swapped her baby for Kat’s baby. Viewers that complained expressed their feelings that this was not a correct representation of how women who have suffered cot death would react. They believed that the show was representing them as ‘baby snatchers’.

This is a critical example of Eastenders using real issues and problems experienced in everyday life to create a sense of realism effectively, while also taking the issue too far to make the issue seem less real. However, it could be argued, like many British soap operas, it was simply heightening everyday life for entertainment purposes.

Another convention of realism is the authenticity of class representation. “One of the myths about soap operas is that they are watched by the working classes and that they are about their lives” (Hobson, 2003:119). In the historical context this would be true. For example, it has been widely established that when Coronation Street was first written in the 1960’s, it was intended to represent the northern working class community. British soap operas still centre the show around working class characters, however, as times have changed recently and more working class individuals have shifted class to lower middle class and even middle class. This is also known as the embourgeoisment thesis. This theory argues that, “the specific character of the working class – was gradually eroded so that we were all becoming middle class in our attitudes, values and ways of life.” (Dyer, 1981:3). Soap operas had to include representations of middle classes in the show to maintain realism. For instance, Coronation Street has characters representing all three of those classes: Ken Barlow, in recent years representing the middle class, Tina McIntyre representing lower middle class and Janice Battersby representing the working class. Coronation Street as well as many other leading British soaps like Eastenders and Emmerdale use class representation effectively. By having different levels of classes living and working together, it enhances the feeling of a community, which then enhances a sense of realism.

An accurate representation of class is vital for realism as many classes watch soap operas (mainly working class, lower middle class and middle class) and if they feel like they are not being represented efficiently they may question the realism of the show and begin take offence and stop watching.

An additional convention of realism in British soap opera is the use of temporality. Every episode and storyline is told linearly. A Soap opera episode will never start in the middle or the end. It will always start at the beginning followed by the middle and finally the end, or day going through until the night similar to real life. This may be a simple convention of realism but it is an important one. It helps the characters everyday struggles more relatable to the audience and therefore, real life.

However, one criticism that British soap operas receive is the omission of everyday duties, for example work. (Dyer, 1981:4) in regards to soap operas commented, “work is seldom shown and, when it is, is treated in terms of styles of personal interaction”. Dyer claims that we rarely see characters actually work and when we do, it usually initiates a personal conversation. Work is used to drive the narratives. For example, in Eastenders the work mostly shown involves serving someone: Patrick serving at the Minute Mart, Alfie serving in the Queen Vic or Shirley serving in the Café. Other aspects of real life is also omitted for example, main events: when East London was affected by the riots in the summer, none of the characters mentioned it or were affected by it. This is an example of where soap operas fail to covey realism effectively.

In conclusion, many sources have provided evidence of how realism is used effectively in British soap operas by the sense of place, regional characteristics, class representation, issues and problems and by the concept of temporality. However issues have been raised combating the use of realism in soap operas with the main issue being the omission of the everyday news and duties. Overall, every British soap opera use the same conventions, as it has proved a strong formula to create realism effectively.


GERAGHTY, C., 1991. Women and Soap Opera, A Study of Prime Time Soaps. Cambridge: Polity Press & Blackwell Publishers.

HOBSON, D., 2003. Soap Opera. Cambridge: Polity Press & Blackwell Publishers.

ALLEN, R.C., 1995. To be continued – soaps around the world [eBook]. Oxon: Routledge. Taylor & Francis e-Library [Accessed 6th December 2011]

DYER, R., 1981. Introduction from Dyer, Richard; Geraghty, Christine; Jordan, Marion; Lovell, Terry; Paterson, Richard & Stewart, John, Coronation Street. London: British Film Institute.

HOOPER, C., 2011. Eastenders cleared by Ofcom over baby swap plot [online]. The Metro Newspaper. Available at [Accessed 4th December 2011]…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Do the Right Thing Film Analysis

...The first time we saw each other after seeing Spike Lee's movie Do the Right Thing, my sister and I had a fight over lunch. It was one of those things you do with a lover, or sometimes with a close friend about politics, where the terms you disagree on are too buried to perceive or even to guess, at the time, that they're there. You can be agreeing about all the superficial details and about the largest of generalizations all along--my sister and I both found the film powerfully moving--and still wind up fighting about ... something--one of those disagreements that leave you dissatisfied and unexplainably angry. Her arguments weren't unfamiliar. I had run into very similar concerns, interpretations, and vocabulary in some of the mainstream criticism on the film. But it was only after stewing about our lunch for a couple of days that I began to figure out how completely at odds with the movie I saw was the one she--and those critics--had seen. The more I thought about it, the more I could see that these were no idiosyncratic subjective responses. Rather, our differences were bound up with Spike Lee's mix of styles of representation, which my sister and I responded to selectively and from very different perspectives. While Lee's representation of the Italians was moving and meaningful to her, she could find nothing in his portrayal of the black community that would provide for the same feelings. For, I came to see, while Lee uses to elaborate his white characters methods and......

Words: 7201 - Pages: 29

Premium Essay

Representation of Illegal Drugs on Television

...For this analysis, the topic of illegal drugs will be traced across three different television serials that vary in genre. In each programme illegal drugs are a pivotal element to the storyline, with close reference to youth involvement. This analysis will investigate how different televisual forms shape the way illegal drug use is understood and made visible across three different genres of television with reference to youth involvement. In addition, this analysis will discuss to what extent this representation of illegal drugs assists in legitimating themes of drug use and how these representations have shifted throughout history. This analysis will explore the representation of illegal drug in Workaholics, 90210 and Arrow. The mass media are commonly seen to reflect and shape social attitudes and behaviours; therefore it is likely that representations of teen characters in film and television will assist in defining what normative behaviours and actions are for teen viewers (Stern 331). This contributes to the argument that television can influence and young viewers are using these representations to authenticate their behaviours according to the dominant values represented on television. The repetitive portrayal of drug use on television can be seen to glamorise drug use and provide an overabundance, and inaccurate representation of drugs (Long et al. 96). As it is more commonly discussed and glamorised, it becomes more likely that young people will associate substance......

Words: 1174 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Entry and Exit Demand Analysis: Economics

...Entry/Exit Demand Analysis [ to cite ]: Peter R. Dickson and Alan G. Sawyer (1984) ,"Entry/Exit Demand Analysis", in NA - Advances in Consumer Research Volume 11, eds. Thomas C. Kinnear, Provo, UT : Association for Consumer Research, Pages: 617-622. Advances in Consumer Research Volume 11, 1984 ENTRY/EXIT DEMAND ANALYSIS Peter R. Dickson, The Ohio State University Alan G. Sawyer, The Ohio State University ABSTRACT Past methods of measuring consumer response to the price of a branded good are reviewed and critiqued. A new approach- Entry/Exit Demand Analysis--is described. The method borrows from and improves past methods. Some initial evidence about the technique's test-retest reliability is presented. INTRODUCTION One of the most troublesome problems that confronts management is estimating the responsiveness of demand to changes in price. In the past, experienced managers may have been able to intuitively assess price elasticity based on a history of strategic price increases and decreases. However, over the last decade, many of the street-wise managers may have lost their touch because consumer demand has become much more volatile. Inflation, recession and cultural trends are three factors that have made the tracking of demand curves and price elasticity an even more elusive exercise. Inflation has changed the real purchasing power of the dollar and consequently required consumers to frequently change their reactions to price. Consumers have to adjust to both changes in...

Words: 4759 - Pages: 20

Free Essay

Media Representations of the Music Industry

...few shots of this programme, we can establish that it covers the codes and conventions used in documentary style T.V. shows. The producers of the text have reinforced the programme's content and message throughout by using the layout and delivery of the information. During the intro to the programme, we hear upbeat music being played in the background, similar to that found on a news show. Shortly after this we see a clip of a newsbroadcaster talking on the problem at hand, drugs. If up until this point, a viewer did not understand what this text was about, various words and phrases related to drug use move around the screen. We as an audience are made light that this is based on a very serious subject and in addition to the 'Horizons' logo displayed at the top, we have high expectations for the documentary as a whole as 'Horizons' are well-known for their stellar documentaries and controversial content. This contoversy becomes more apparent in the following sequence of clips. We are given information on this particular topic, through the use of first hand accounts e.g people. By using regular people just like ourselves this links with the Bulmer and Katz Uses and Gratifications theory as we feel connected with the people and what they have to say, which is the way the director would have wanted to get his point across. The connection is made through our acceptance and understanding of these first hand accounts as we can relate to the realism of their opinions. This......

Words: 1553 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

The Expression of Emotion Through the Pupils of Animated Character

...expression of emotion through the pupils of animated character Statement: A research paper submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Bachelor of Arts Author: Sam Watterson Qualification: Honours degree in Design for Interactive Media School: UWIC School of Art and Design College: University of Wales Institute Cardiff Submission Date:12/05/05 Declaration: I hereby declare that this research paper entitled, ‘The expression of emotion through the pupils of animated character’, is entirely of my own work and has never been submitted nor is it currently being submitted for any other degree. Date: Candidate: Date: Director of studies: Abstract The aim of this paper is to explore the concept of animating characters with realistic pupils. Meaning, pupils which change according to focus, light levels, level of concentration, like and dislike, along with touch and pain. Expressive pupils already exist in animation, through this research I attempt to extend upon the current level of pupil expression. An analysis is carried out on existing animated characters, looking at character expression, and how the type of animation effects the level of realism and eye expression. To gather this information I used questionnaires aimed at viewers, character animators and also used animation guide books for reference. The main aim being to understand the......

Words: 4580 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Reality Tv

...Grierson referred to the documentary as a text that has ‘documentary value’(Grierson, 1926). Using this definition as a starting point, discuss whether ‘reality’ TV should be classified as a documentary. “We take television for granted in the same way as we take everyday life for granted.” (Silverstone, 2000) Reality television, being a mix of the two, is often an over-looked and disrespected television genre, as it can seem worthless and therefore worthy of the term ‘trash TV’. However it appears that reality television has started to take over our screens and is pushing other, more reputable genres out of the schedule. John Grierson is said to be the man who first coined the phrase ‘documentary’ and therefore documentarians often look back to his quotes and theories to be used as the bible for accepting or rejecting television shows into the genre. Grierson used the quote when he was evaluating Robert Flaherty’s film Moana. Flaherty, producer of Nanook of the North, used actors to portray the characters in the documentary rather than the people themselves, which conflicted with Grierson’s principles, arguing that using the real person in their original environment, “thus taken from the raw” are far better than a fictional alternative. However vague Grierson’s quote may seem, it is clear what he intended by it. The word ‘documentary’ comes from the Latin root ‘docere’, meaning to teach or instruct, however the more modern relation is to ‘document’, which is a factual......

Words: 2389 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

The Matrix - Analysis Esssay

...Analysis of The Matrix by the Wachowski brothers * Question: Films use Cinematographic techniques to enhance the their purpose of entertaining, informing and persuading. Discuss how one film you have viewed uses cinematographic techniques to fulfil this purpose. * * The movie the Matrix, made by the Wachowski brothers in 1999, was one of the movie highlights of the new millennia revolving around the genre of scientific fiction and exploring themes such as Man vs. Machines, Reality, Technophobia, Salvation, Simulation simulacra and to a small extent, on war. The Matrix was made to open our eyes to how humanity lives today and a very possible dystopic future where humanity might face the wrath of its own creations. The Matrix is a very intricate movie that entertains the audience, informs and messes with the audience’s mind evoking strong responses through the use of cinematography, conventions and SWAT codes. Movies are created with a purpose and for most movies that purpose is to entertain and inform the audience about certain issues that exist in our social norms or some other thing that the directors of the movie may want to send across to the audience. A casual viewer could watch the entire Matrix without assessing all the other philosophical and Intertextuality references and still enjoy the movie. The Matrix is a very entertaining movie and it uses Technical codes such as Computer graphics to keep the audience engaged and greatly entertained. The Matrix......

Words: 2048 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Musical Films Analysis

...Major Essay: Question One Musical films have been present in Hollywood since The Jazz Singer (1927) premiered. Mast states that a film is a musical when the primary entertainment and investment lie in the musical numbers (p. 309, Wood, 2008). Musical films are often a beloved or hated genre due to the unrealistic nature of characters erupting into song and dance. This essay analyse four main conventions of the musical genre the spectacle, the narrative, the adaption of established stories and the power the combination of lyrics and music can achieve on screen. Examples from different periods in Hollywood will be used to explore these conventions and how they apply and have evolved to suite conventions of modern cinema. Kellner (2005) explains spectacles have been present in different cultures since pre-modern times. Examples of these spectacles include plays, the Olympics of Ancient Greece, in Ancient Rome public offerings of bread, circuses and gladiator games (Kellner, 2005). The human desire for the spectacle has not fallen into extinction but rather evolved with society and technology. Entertainment has always been a prime field of the spectacle and film has been one of the most productive industries to utilise the spectacle (Kellner, 2005). Hello Dolly (1969), My Fair Lady (1964) and Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Cinderella (1997) are three examples of film musical spectacles. All three of these movies contain elaborate costumes, bright colours and large......

Words: 2739 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Classical Realism

...I-Introduction: The term "realism" was first used to formulate the philosophical doctrine that "universals exist outside of the mind" (Freyberg-Inan, 1). Yet, in political theory, "realism" represents a school of thought that analyzes the political process as it is or as it is disclosed by historical forces " ... that the able political practitioner takes into account ... and incorporates ... into his political conceptions and his political acts "(Ibid, 1-2). In the field of international relations, realism became the dominant analytical paradigm mostly after the start of the Second World War, when it displaced idealist doctrines, promising "to provide more accurate information, more powerful, and more relevant answers" to the roots or causes of peace and war (Brecher& Harvey, 54). At the same time, many features of the current realist paradigm can be traced back to the time of Thucydides, Niccolo Machiavelli and Thomas Hobbes. Among contemporary thinkers recognized as major writers and contributors to the realist tradition are Hans Morgenthau, Edward Carr and Kenneth Waltz (Freyberg-Inan, 8). What are then the basic tenets or common features of a realist thinker? Machiavelli would acknowledge that to be a realist one has to look at history as "a sequence of cause and effect whose course can be analysed and understood by intellectual effort, but not directed by imagination" (Carr, 64). Hobbes would persist in the same train of thought and insist that to be a realist......

Words: 17639 - Pages: 71

Free Essay

Fil Analysis Example Outline

...APPENDIX Writing a Film Analysis Films are made to be seen and heard, to appeal to our visual and aural senses. Like any art form, however, films are also meant to be felt and understood, to appeal to our emotions and minds. One of the best ways to determine whether a film has succeeded in any or all of these goals is to analyze the elements that make up the whole work. To write an analysis of a film, you must study the film carefully. Your critical analysis should be derived from your personal encounter with the film, not from published criticism. Access to a videocassette recorder or DVD player is essential if you are going to perform a critical analysis of any depth. It is not enough to like or dislike the movie; you must determine why it succeeds or fails in reaching out and encompassing the viewer. The first step is to view the film in its entirety. From this viewing you can get an initial reaction to the many parts of the film that you will have to explore in more depth. When you first view the film, it is best not to try to take notes or separate the parts of the film; you should be familiar with the textbook in order to know what to look for. After you have formulated a thesis and have begun the process of supporting that thesis, you should view the film at least once more in its entirety and two or three times in segments in order to review scenes of major importance. The thesis statement is the element around which to structure your analysis. Because the......

Words: 9329 - Pages: 38

Premium Essay

Affects of Soap Operas/ Reality Shows on Society to viewers, which makes this the preferred method for entertainment and receiving information (Holmes and Jermyn). But this preference for communication also brings along with it certain concerns linked to how people have embraced this form of communication. Reality shows are a type of Television shows which have gained continuous popularity over the years. Due to reality shows being linked to real life scenarios, they have grown popular among viewers who prefer them and willing to watch them as compared to other shows available on Television (Ford and Kosnik). Soap-opera, survival and wildlife documentary are just some of the popular reality shows aired on TV in recent years with each attracting its own audience but yet these shows are very unrealistic. Each Reality show will have a different effect on a viewer. Some People may like survival and wildlife commentary that tend to provide actual knowledge, while others like soap-operas. Soap Operas tend to attract more women than men. Some examples include Love and Hip Hop, The Real Housewives etc. These types of shows are more destructive to the family unit because they glamorize and over exaggerate family problems. Soap-opera’s mainly focus on creating shows that depict families and couples suffering from major disputes and stress. At home family problems should not be handled the way they are on tv(Wyatt and Bunton). While this may be overlooked by many people to be just a Television show, these reality shows......

Words: 994 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Film Form Analysis

...Film Form and Analysis Cinematography Cinematography describes the process by which a film strip is exposed to light to create an image. It encompasses many factors: the camera’s distance from the action, camera angle and direction, type of lens, camera movement, and lighting, among others. The art of cinematography also includes mise-en-scène—the arrangement of objects and movements in the frame. Shot Types The amount of visual information included in the image depends on the distance of the camera from the action and on the focal length of the camera lens. Throughout the history of cinema, filmmakers have favored certain combinations of camera distance and focal length, or shot types. * Extreme long shot: Captures a scene in its entirety; used for establishing location in exterior shots. Used frequently in epic genres such as westerns and war films, it reduces human beings to mere dots on the screen. * Long shot: Accommodates at least the entire bodies of figures (if that is all the shot includes, it is called a full shot). Captures movement, background, and broad gestures and expressions. * Medium shot: Contains a figure from the waist or knees up. It is a functional shot, favored in classical Hollywood editing, often used for scenes with dialogue. * Close-up: Includes very little if any background, concentrating on an object or, if an extreme close-up, a fragment of an object, such as the human face. Close-ups often accord great significance and......

Words: 5540 - Pages: 23

Free Essay

What Signs of Mod Culture Illustrate a Dominance of Masculine and European Influence Seen Through the Creative Mediums of Photography, Music and Fashion?

...WHAT SIGNS OF MOD CULTURE ILLUSTRATE A DOMINANCE OF MASCULINE AND EUROPEAN INFLUENCE SEEN THROUGH THE CREATIVE MEDIUMS OF PHOTOGRAPHY, MUSIC AND FASHION? Danny Lowe A Dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirement for the award of the degree BA (Hons) Fashion Photography London College of Fashion University of the Arts London Date: 15th April 2012 i Declaration I, Danny Lowe, certify that this is an original piece of work. I have acknowledged all sources and citation. No section of this literature review has been plagiarised. Signed: ….......................................................................................................................... ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract List of Illustrations Introduction Methodology Literature Review Chapter 1: Chapter 2: Chapter 3: Historical and Cultural Contexts – Defining the 'Mod' and Youth Cultures in Post WWII Britain Americanisation – Music, Motives and Movement The Signs of Style iv v vi ix xi xi xvii xxi xxii xxiv xxvi xxviii xxix xxxii Interpretative Analysis Photography: Music: Fashion Conclusion Bibliography Appendix iii Abstract The purpose of this research study is to identify the signs of masculinity and European influence that dominated aspects of 'Modernist', or Mod, culture and lifestyle. The Mod is a British subculture which developed in the 1960's. The first stage of this study involves introducing the subcultural theories attributed to the......

Words: 8441 - Pages: 34

Premium Essay

Soap Industry Analysis (Dove)

...SOAP INDUSTRY: DOVE (ANALYSIS) SOAP INDUSTRY ANALYSIS ABSTRACT The origins of personal cleanliness date back to prehistoric times. Since water is essential for life, the earliest people lived near water and knew something about its cleansing properties - at least that it rinsed mud off their hands. A soap-like material found in clay cylinders during the excavation of ancient Babylon is evidence that soap making was known as early as 2800 B.C. Inscriptions on the cylinders say that fats were boiled with ashes, which is a method of making soap, but do not refer to the purpose of the "soap." Such materials were later used as hair styling aids. Soap got its name, according to an ancient Roman legend, from Mount Sapo, where animals were sacrificed. Rain washed a mixture of melted animal fat, or tallow, and wood ashes down into the clay soil along the Tiber River. Women found that this clay mixture made their wash cleaner with much less effort. Some of the early instances of commercial manufacturing of soap are: In Britain references began to appear in the literature from about 1000AD, and in 1192 the monk Richard of Devizes referred to the number of soap makers in Bristol and the unpleasant smells which their activities produced A century later soap making was reported in Coventry. Other early centers of production included York and Hull. In London a 15th century "sopehouse" was reported in Bishopsgate, with other sites at Cheapside, where there......

Words: 2634 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Anti-Realism and Reality Principle

...Does anti-realism violate the reality principle in denying the existence of a verification independent 'target for our thoughts to aim at'? On the Realists view, there is a mind-independed world about which we form beliefs, and truth is the correspondence between a statement or belief and the mind-independed world the statement or belief is about. Central in the Realists conception is that its obtaining is independed of our ways of finding out about it. That is, that truth transcends our ability to know the truth. For the Realist, if reality did not contain answers to our questions, then there would be no ‘target for our thoughts to aim at’ and ‘truth’ or ‘falsity’ would cease to matter. Opposed to Realism is the Anti-Realists view that ‘reality’ is constituted in part by our conceptual activities or the conceptual tools we employ in our inquiry. The anti-realist seeks a notion of truth that can be constructed out of verification. For anti-realism truth is to be analyzed in terms of concepts like evidence or scientific inquiry. For a statement to be true is to be capable of being verified or asserted. Reality for the Anti-Realist is defined as the totality of these ‘actual truths’. The Anti-realist identifies truth with verification. He argues that when we are making any assertions, the actual standard these assertions have to pass, is the best interpretation of the best available evidence. So the Anti-realist asks ‘what use does a truth that......

Words: 1056 - Pages: 5

Sneakers | Rivestimento sella nero / cuciture nero Ducati Monster 1994-2007 mod. Confort | AUDIOSLAVE - Cochise MP3