Premium Essay

Revisiting Market Efficiency

In: Business and Management

Submitted By SirVicNY
Words 6002
Pages 25

by Michael J. Mauboussin, Credit Suisse First Boston

t is time to shift the emphasis of the debate about market efficiency. Most academics and practitioners agree that markets are efficient by a reasonable operational criterion: there is no systematic way to exploit opportunities for superior gains. But we need to reorient the discussion to how this operational efficiency arises. The crux of the debate boils down to whether we should consider investors to be rational, well informed, and homogeneous—the backbone of standard capital markets theory—or potentially irrational, operating with incomplete information, and relying on varying decision rules. The latter characteristics are part and parcel of a relatively newly articulated phenomenon that researchers at the Santa Fe Institute and elsewhere call complex adaptive systems. Why should corporate managers care about how market efficiency arises? In truth, executives can make many corporate finance decisions independent of the means of market efficiency. But if complex adaptive systems do a better job explaining how markets work, there are critical implications for areas such as risk management and investor communications.


Take, for example, the earnings expectations game.1 In a complex adaptive system, the sum is greater than the parts. So it is not possible to understand the stock market by paying attention to individual analysts. Managers who place a disproportionate focus on the perceived desires of these analysts may be managing to the wrong metrics— and ultimately destroying shareholder value. A better appreciation for how markets work will shift management attention away from individual analysts to the market itself, thus capturing the aggregation of many diverse views. Standard capital markets theory still has a lot to…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay


...Efficiency: 1. More flexible compensation tools to simplify administration and less effort to adapt to the current rigid system. 2. Clarifying how employees are compensated and linking compensation to job performance should improve organizational performance and efficiency. 3. Formal compensation analyst infrastructure will provide more efficient determination of market-based compensation Flexibility and Responsiveness: 4. Linking employee pay to the marketplace will make the system more responsive to business need. 5. Flexible compensation tools will allow us to more accurately meet the business need. 6. A new system should be flexible enough to adjust as business needs change. Alignment: 7. Flexible compensation tools to support recruitment of needed staff. 8. Compensation linked to employee performance to encourage employee participation and employee development over the employee lifecycle. 9. Compensation that recognizes employees based upon the marketplace for their current competence which should also encourage staff to develop skills to advance their compensation and at the same time benefit the organization. 10. Compensation analyst infrastructure will assist in aligning compensation structure with other universities and/or private sector as applicable for the university to remain competitive for talent. Consistency: 11. The compensation system tools should be available across employee categories. The particular compensation system......

Words: 613 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Efficiency Analysis and Volatility Effect of Bangladesh Stock Market

...Banking Jahangirnagar University Savar, Dhaka FNB209: Financial Institutions and Markets | Executive Summary Submission of the Report on : Efficiency Analysis and Volatility Effect of Bangladesh Stock Market Submitted by:Sariful Islam(Student ID: 610)Ashfaq-ul- haq oni(Student ID: 621)Jafrin Siddique (Student ID: 1922)Zunaid Hossain (Student ID: 1928)K. M. Zeman Adnan (Student ID: 2128)William Masterson Shah (Student ID: 2129) | Submitted to:Dr. Sheikh Abu TaherLecturer,Department of Finance & BankingJahangirnagar University | August 2, 2012 Term Paper Topic: Efficiency Analysis and Volatility Effect of Bangladesh Stock Market Executive Summary: This paper empirically examines the behavior of stock returns in the Bangladesh stock market namely Dhaka Stock Exchange (DSE), the efficiency of the market in pricing securities and the relationship between stock returns and conditional volatility and the impact of some institution factors such as lock-in, circuit breaker, and caretaker government on volatility, using best known three different daily price indices DSEG, DSI and DS20. The results of autocorrelation function, results of ADF and PP tests and also the results of ARIMA models do not support the hypothesis of weak-form of market efficient of DSE. The results of GARCH (p, q)-M models indicate significant departure from the hypothesis of weak form efficiency; the tendency for returns to exhibit volatility clustering; and a significant......

Words: 563 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Pareto Efficiency

...Markets, Organizations and the Role of Knowledge What is Pareto efficiency? Why do economists use this criterion for comparing alternative economic systems? An allocation of resources is Pareto efficient when there is no alternative that keeps all individuals at least as well off, but makes at least one person better off. One reason that economists use this criterion for comparing economic systems is that it is relatively uncontroverisial. Stronger criteria are likely to be met with more disagreement. What is a property right? What role do property rights play in a market economy? A property right is a socially-enforced right to select the uses of an economic good. A property right is private when it is assigned to a specific person. Property rights are alienable when they can be transferred (sold or given) to other individuals. Since owners bear the wealth effects of their actions, there are strong incentives to rearrange property rights in market transactions to increase efficiency and value. Many economists favor free trade between nations. They argue that free trade will increase total world output and make people of trading nations better off. Discuss how this argument relates to concepts presented in this chapter. Free trade allows countries to concentrate on producing goods and services for which they have a comparative advantage. This specialization increases the total production of goods in the global economy. Thus, each nation can be better off......

Words: 321 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Bank Efficiency

...Efficiency enhancement has been a challenge for banks all over the world since years ago. It is proven banks which focus on efficiency enhancement are more organized to fund investments and will benefit from a greater stock-price growth. To improve efficiencies, banks have to carry out an enterprise-wide approach which is time-consuming and may require a change in culture. Besides budgets reduction, processes improvement, freezing expenses and headcount, and reduction of contractors on external, banks are looking forward to improve their performances and qualities time-after-time. There are numerous ways to boost banking sector’s efficiencies in Malaysia. Firstly, restrictions on salaries and staff mobility in banking industry can be removed as workforces are claimed to be the most important asset in order to develop a banking system efficiently and effectively. The ability of attracting and rewarding the best people according is needed to make a successful banking institution. However, in key areas like systems development and risk management, there is still a lack of specialized senior talent in this field. The best talents need to be attracted in order to enhance the efficiencies of domestic banking institution and this talents include workforce that have gained more skills in the more developed financial markets. To improve staff mobility, banks should undertake efforts by building efficient methods for sourcing for new talents and redistribution of staff. Although......

Words: 718 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Market Efficiency and Anomalies

...FINC3017 Investments and Portfolio Management Essay: Market Efficiency and Anomalies Topic:Stock price momentum: Jegadeesh and Titman (1993) Momentum anomaly and EMH Anomaly is a stock return deviation that challenge efficient market hypothesis (EMH). Jegadeesh and Titman (1993) theorise price momentum anomaly in the stock market for the first time. It contradicted to efficient market hypothesis thereby is widely debated. EMH states that no consistent excess return can be achieved since security prices fully reflect all available information (Fama 1970). Therefore, future prices cannot be predicted through technical analysis of past prices. If the hypothesis is true, passive investment strategy ought to be taken, because it is impossible to get abnormal return by aggressive trading. However, Jegadeesh and Titman show that stocks performed well over the previous 3 to 12 months tend to continue to perform well over 3 to 12 months holding periods. Buy past winners and short past losers earned statistically significant positive return of averaging 12.01% per year. Predictable price patterns and excess returns contradict the efficient market hypothesis. Investors and fund managers perform actively in pursuing abnormal profits. Literature review and the reason of anomaly A large number of literatures illustrate that momentum anomaly exist. Some important literatures are Chan, Jegadeesh and Lakonishok (1996), Conrad and Kaul (1998) and Moskowitz and Grinblatt (1999)....

Words: 1631 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

The Evolution of Stock Market Efficiency over Time: a Survey of the Empirical Literature

...THE EVOLUTION OF STOCK MARKET EFFICIENCY OVER TIME: A SURVEY OF THE EMPIRICAL LITERATURE Kian-Ping Lim Universiti Malaysia Sabah and Monash University and Robert Brooks Monash University Background This paper provides an insight into the empirical literature as pertains the evolution of stock market efficiency over time, with a keen focus on the weak form Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH). The authors provide a systematic review of the correlation between several financial factors namely: Adaptive Markets Hypothesis (AMH), Efficient Markets Hypothesis (EMH), Evolving Return Predictability, Stock markets and Weak-form EMH. The authors pay keen attention on how return predictability from past price changes is affected by key players and determinants on the stock markets. From the survey they conduct, the posit that the bulk of the empirical studies examine whether the stock market under study is or is not weak-form efficient in the absolute sense, assuming that the level of market efficiency remains unchanged throughout the estimation period. The authors acknowledge that one field that has drawn extensive investigation by scholars and other players alike is the predictability of stock returns on the basis of past price changes. This is partly due to its direct implication on weak-form market efficiency. They find that a vast majority of the literature implicitly assumes the level of market efficiency remains unchanged throughout the estimation period. However, the......

Words: 1925 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Operations Efficiency

...Operational efficiency is performing operations tasks well, even better than competitors. Strategy, on the other hand, is a plan for competing in the marketplace. Operational efficiency and strategy must be aligned; otherwise, you may be very efficiently performing the wrong task. The role of operations strategy is to make sure that all the tasks performed by the operations function are the right tasks. These include developing an understanding of what business the company is in (the company’s mission), analyzing and developing an understanding of the market (environmental scanning), and identifying the company’s strengths (core competencies). _Mission A statement defining what business an organization is in, who its customers are, and how its core beliefs shape its business. Environmental scanning Monitoring the external environment for changes and trends to determine business opportunities and threats. What Does Environmental Scanning Tell Us? Environmental scanning allows a company to identify opportunities and threats. For example, through environmental scanning we could see gaps in what customers need and what competitors are doing to meet those needs. forming partnerships with international firms, called strategic alliances _Core competencies The unique strengths of a business. Core Competencies The third factor that helps define a business strategy is an understanding of the company’s strengths. These are called core......

Words: 1510 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Evaluate the Economic Efficiency of Different Market Structures and Their Effect on Consumers

...Economic Efficiency Economic efficiency is when objectives of the individual, firm or government are attained by the combination of the various factors of production at a minimum cost. Efficiency can be measured in different forms; productive, allocative and X-efficiency. Productive Efficiency In evaluating the productive efficiency of a market, we are looking at the minimum cost derived as a result of producing or supplying a good. In the short term, efficiency is achieved when a unit of output is attained at the very base of the average cost curve as shown in Fig 1a below. FIG 1a Cost FIG 1b Cost Economic Efficiency in the long run MC AC LRAC C1 SRATC1 Economic Efficiency SRATC2 C In the short-term Ce 0 Q Output 0 Q1 Qe Output From Fig 1b above, the market productive efficiency level can be best measured in the long run. In the long run, the various short term output levels on the scale of production compared, reveals the most minimum cost as a result of producing a unit more of output. As shown in Fig 1b, the most efficient level of production is at CeQe on......

Words: 1065 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Market Efficiency

...MARKET EFFICIENCY - DEFINITION AND TESTS What is an efficient market? Efficient market is one where the market price is an unbiased estimate of the true value of the investment. Implicit in this derivation are several key concepts - (a) Market efficiency does not require that the market price be equal to true value at every point in time. All it requires is that errors in the market price be unbiased, i.e., that prices can be greater than or less than true value, as long as these deviations are random. (b) The fact that the deviations from true value are random implies, in a rough sense, that there is an equal chance that stocks are under or over valued at any point in time, and that these deviations are uncorrelated with any observable variable. For instance, in an efficient market, stocks with lower PE ratios should be no more or less likely to under valued than stocks with high PE ratios. (c) If the deviations of market price from true value are random, it follows that no group of investors should be able to consistently find under or over valued stocks using any investment strategy. Market Efficiency for Investor Groups Definitions of market efficiency have to be specific not only about the market that is being considered but also the investor group that is covered. It is extremely unlikely that all markets are efficient to all investors, but it is entirely possible that a particular market (for instance, the New York Stock......

Words: 489 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Weak Form Efficiency and Calendar Anomalies: Comparison Between Developed and Developing Equity Markets

...Weak form Efficiency and Calendar Anomalies: Comparison between Developed and Developing Equity Markets Syed Zulfiqar Ali Shah Assistant Professor-Finance, Department of Business Administration Faculty of Management Sciences, International Islamic University Islamabad E-mail: Muhammad Husnain Ph.D Scholar (Finance) Mohammad Ali Jinnah University Islamabad Email: Abstract Financial economists have continuously questioned the efficient market hypothesis especially in last decade. Major part of discussion is whether the equity markets are efficient and if not then up to what extent one can forecast the meaningful future movement of equity prices. On one side there are believers of random walk and contrary there are followers of chartist theories. Those who negate the random walk suggested that there exist anomalies in the equity markets and hence are not perfectly efficient. The major objective of this study is to check the weak form of efficiency and presence of calendar anomalies in equity markets of developing and developed countries. On the basis of most recent and relatively longer horizon (14 Year) data on daily basis and a range of powerful econometrics this study suggested that in broader sense both of developed and developing equity markets are weak form inefficient. Hence there is no remarkable difference in term of market efficiency in equity markets of developed and developing countries. Hence one can reject the random......

Words: 8230 - Pages: 33

Free Essay

Risk Premium and Market Efficiency

...Risk premium Risk premium ontstaat wanneer investeerders binnenlandse en buitenlandse bonds niet langer zien als perfecte substituten. Als ze bijvoorbeeld vinden dat binnenlandse bonds een relatief hoger risico hebben dat buitenlandse bonds, dan zullen ze op de binnenlandse bonds een hogere return verwachten. Deze hogere return wordt de risk premium genoemd. Voor een risk premium moet er aan drie voorwaarden worden voldaan: 1. Risicoverschil tussen binnenlandse en buitenlandse bonds. 2. Investeerders moeten risk averse zijn. 3. Er moet een verschil zijn tussen de risk-minimizing portfolio en de echte portfolio. Twee definities: 1. r - r* = Eṡ + RP r r* Eṡ RP = binnenlandse rente = buitenlandse rente = verwachtte depreciatie van binnenlandse munt tov buitenlandse munt = risicopremie voor binnenlandse bonds 2. Premium om risicio te vermijden: Stel Nederlandse importeur moet $1 betalen op tijdstip t+1. st+1 is onbekend en dus risico. Importeur koopt forward van B en betaalt ft euro op t+1 aan B. B heeft nu het risico en wilt ft > Est als compensatie voor het hebben van euros op tijdstip t+1 ipv dollars. Importeur betaalt dit om risico te vermijden. RP = f-Es Er zijn verschillende bronnen van risico. Deze bronnen zijn onderverdeeld in twee categorieën: Currency risks Inflation risk: Dit risico ontstaat wanneer de inflatie in de binnenlandse en buitenlandse economie onzeker is. Als dit het geval is dan is de real return niet zeker en is er dus risico. ...

Words: 547 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Market Efficiency

...Article 1 Title of Journal Article: Testing for the Weak-Form Market Efficiency of the Dar es Salaam Stock Exchange DETAILS:- Author(s)- Year- Name of Journal- Volume- Issue- Page number | Authors : Yilmaz Guney - University of Hull, Gabriel Vitus Komba - Mzumbe University, School of BusinessDate: October 21, 2015. | - RESEARCH OBJECTIVES(s)-RESEARCH QUESTION(s) | This study investigates into the weak-form efficiency of the Dar es Salaam stock exchange (DSE), a frontier market, in Tanzania. | - HYPOTHESES- VARIABLES:Eg: Dependent variables, Independent variables | The weak-form efficiency of the Dar es Salaam stock exchange (DSE), a frontier market, in Tanzania.Dependent Variable: Weak-form efficiency of DSE | METHODOLOGY:Eg: Scope of study, Respondent type & number, Analysis used | The study covers the period from January 2007 to December 2014. To establish the consistency and robustness of the obtained conclusions, we employ different tests (i.e., Augmented Dickey-Fuller test, variance-ratio test, and Ranks and Sign test) to examine the hypothesis that the returns based on the price and return indices follow a random walk process | FINDINGS & DISCUSSION:Eg: Types of relationships (support or not), Reliability & variance | Wright (2000) shows that ranks and sign tests can be exact, and have better power properties than the conventional variance-ratio tests. Moreover, they demonstrate that rank-based variance-ratio tests have, generally, more power......

Words: 3831 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Market Efficiency

...Efficient Capital Markets Topic 4 Davenport University FINC 620 - Financial Management June 3, 2016 Efficient capital markets Market Efficiency An efficient capital market is: “A market where information regarding the value of securities are incorporated into its prices accurately and in real time. Since the value of securities fluctuates depending on the present value of future cash flows, an efficient capital market enables these fluctuations to be reflected in the securities' current price” (, n.d.). What this means is that investors who invest among the stock market try and determine if the market is efficient, and whether it accurately emulates all of the influential prominent forces that are put on prices, and affected by such forces in real time. The efficient market hypothesis (EMH) is a theory among investors that states that it is impossible to out-smart the market because the efficient market always mirrors current events and information making it impossible to veer buy stock underpriced or overpriced – prices will always reflect the fair market value based on market influences. The only way to succeed in the market is to gamble with high-risk returns (Investopedia. n.d.). How this all works is investors will buy up stock and generate cash flow into the stock market, looking for a return on one’s investment. They are not always satisfied with a return; they want to maximize the return more......

Words: 1085 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Revisiting Intention to Restaurants

...Revisiting Intention To Restaurants There are so many reasons for a customer to visit a restaurant, it might be regarding to the staff attitude, the food or even the price. George Pettingell (October 2005) recognized that “Most of the customer don’t visit a restaurant to eat.  Most of the time they only come for other reasons which has a little reason on eating.  Yes, well prepared and tasty food is very important, as is ambiance and price of the restaurant. For most people, the bottom line has everything to do with personal needs, experiences and also satisfactions.”  According to June, L.P. and Smith, S.L. (1987) identified that “Five characteristics of customers going to a restaurant have been found which is price, atmosphere, liquor license, service and quality. They summarized that different standard would be used when the respondents were choosing restaurants in different occasions.” Customers are sometimes attracted by the atmosphere of the restaurant, it was proved by the following newspaper journal that lots of customers go to a particular restaurant for special purpose.  According to Sunday Morning, Bill Geist, (Dec 3, 2006) stated that “Los Angeles hot spot, Opaque, offers dining in total darkness.  It's a hip spot on Sunset Strip in Los Angeles called Opaque, where patrons dine in total darkness.  Menus are useless so diners order before going in.”    According to Restaurant Demand Today, Promotion Marketing Association of America (1994)......

Words: 424 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Technological Efficiency and Free Market Economies

...TECHNOLOGICAL EFFICIENCY AND FREE MARKET ECONOMIES Evans Gwaro Kisii University 15th July, 2016 Technological Efficiency and Free Market Economies Betz (2011) defines technology as the ability to influence any piece of knowledge to suite the best interest of human nature. While, on the other hand, Zupan (2011) refers a free market to system in which the prices for goods and services are agreed freely by accord between vendors and users, in which the rules and requirements on supply and demand are not interfered with by the authorities, price-setting monopoly, or other power. Free markets have various merits. The most accepted is the extension of individual choice, through commonly appreciated give-and-take situation. Subsequently, free market differs with a regulated market, where the government intercedes in supply and demand through non-market approaches that include regulations forming obstructions to market entry and/or directly setting prices. As such, the concept of a free market is where prices are structured by the equivalent demand and supply opportunities. Subsequently, as aforementioned, the influence of choice which enshrines to the free market alignment employs preeminent use of discrete entrepreneurial skills which inspires technology advancement. Essentially, in a free market economy, there are three components that include competition, active but limited government, and the self-interest. Competition in the market place provides quality goods to......

Words: 1012 - Pages: 5

The Changing o season 24 episode 11 | ← Anterior | Madonna von Lourdes Statue Deko Figur Mutter Gottes Heilige Maria Heiligenfigur