Free Essay

Stalins Five Year Plans Made Ussr Stronger. Agree or Disagree

In: Historical Events

Submitted By oliveeebrown
Words 1212
Pages 5

By 1941, Stalin’s Five Year Plans had made the USSR stronger. Explain why you agree or disagree with this view? (24 marks)

By 1941 Stalin had used the five year plans to strengthen his position as leader of the USSR, however the society as a whole was weaker. There were both advantages and disadvantages to the three five year plans: The five year plans were disorganised, there was difficulties with managers, it created a quicksand society and living standards were deprived. It did however help to create the Stakhanovite movement, it helped to finally abolish the New Economic policy (NEP) and most importantly to revolutionise the USSR’s heavy industry.

The plans determined the course of the Soviet economy from 1928 to the German invasion of 1941, when the plans achievements were tested. Throughout all three of the five-year plans it was agreed that the state decided what was produced and when it was produced however there was little idea of an ultimate goal for example senior party officials appointed and dismissed planner’s senior managers for political reasons rather political reasons than economical. The first five-year (1928-32) plan focused solely on advancing heavy industry through projects like Magnitogorsk and advancing the production of coal, steel and timber. It would achieve this through the Gosplan (the State Planning Committee) who were set up in 1921 as a forecasting agency to work out things like output and input figures for industries and their targets. At this time propaganda was used to drive soviet citizens forward and peasants were recruited as workers, this was ineffective as peasants were uneducated and unskilled making production rates slow-meaning that targets were not met. The second five year plan (1933-37) decided that not enough focus was put on consumer goods as in the 1930s it was difficult to buy a pair of shoes- they were targeted for their greater share of investment. The third five year plan fell during 1938-1941 original targets were for a 92% rise in industrial production and the provision of secondary education however, tensions of war were high and priorities changed so most targets were aimed on advancing the USSRs defence by producing munitions. As we can see there were three different five-year plans with each of their different goals, it did not outline the main goals of the communist party making it wholly disorganised and unclear. This is possibly the biggest disadvantage, which weakened the USSR.

Difficulties with managers and workers at this time were another disadvantage of Stalin’s five-year plans, which weakened the USSR. Managers had to fulfil their overly ambitious targets and would do almost anything to achieve them especially after the Shakhty show trial which saw a group of engineers in the Shakhty coal mines of the Donbas region accused of sabotage and treason. It is a significant event because Stalin manipulated it, he decided that the industry was full of bourgeois specialists and they needed reliable communists. Managers could only achieve their targets if workers cooperated but there was the economic pressure of labor shortage, shortages of raw materials and competition from military spending the targets were simply too ambitious. This meant that the USSR was less strong because of unachievable targets.

A major disadvantage of Stalin’s five year plans would be that it created a quicksand society and people had extremely poor living standards. During the first five-year plan 1928-32 many or the majority of the new workers were peasants who had been forced off the rural land through the process of collectivisation. People moved to find work and accommodation and once they found a better job (better pay) they would move on, this created competition between skilled workers who competed for higher wages and job perks so people did not stay in jobs for long periods of time. The biggest problem that employers faced was shortage of skilled workers and in 1951 it was estimated that less than 7% of the workforce were skilled or trained. Also, living standards at this time were dreadful. There were was major overcrowding of substandard accommodation as most materials previously used for buildings were pumped into industry, in addition to this there was a deep lack of consumer goods and food was rationed. Conditions for workers were also terrible; they lived in barracks with appalling conditions. This would’ve been a major disadvantage to Stalin’s five-year plans as it goes against the socialist idea of a united society; people had a profound lack of morale.

The Stakhanovite movement was a major achievement of the five-year plans as it supported the idea of rapid industrialisation. Stakhanovism came through Alexi Stakhanov (a miner in the Don Basin) who, after five hours, cut one hundred and two tons of coal, which was twice the amount of the average worker. He was only able to achieve this by having specialised tools (pneumatic pick) and uninterrupted work. Only two hours after he had finished Petrov assembled a party committee where he hailed Stakhanov a soviet hero and awarded him two hundred roubles. This is important reason why the five-year plans made the USSR stronger as it compelled managers to adopt the same production methods to increase the amount they produced. It was also a massive propaganda stunt and promoted the idea of a socialist society, which would mean that Stalin’s five-year plans helped to strengthen the social aspect of the USSR.

Stalin’s five-year plans were important in strengthening the USSR through the abolishment of the New Economic policy (NEP). Under the NEP Agriculture was still backwards for example strip farming was still used. The grain procurement crisis of 1927-28 meant that peasants were retaining their produce, as the income they received was not worth it. There was high unemployment and increase in kulaks (rich peasants). This was a major issue as NEP was largely a capitalist economic policy but it was only supposed to be temporary, however this went against the fundamental values of socialism in one country and communism. It was essential for Stalin to gain ultimate leadership and follow in the footsteps of Lenin that this policy be abolished and so to create the dream that Lenin embedded in societies minds.

The biggest advantage of Stalin’s five-year plans was the revolution in industry during the period between 1928-1941. The use of these plans meant that enormous industrial centres were built out of virtually nothing like the Moscow Metro which is an underground railway system in Moscow and unthinkable projects were undertaken like Magnitogorsk by the Ural Mountains helped to demonstrate what could come about through the new Soviet industrial machine. Large companies sent specialists, engineers and skilled workers to help set up and build new factories. Finally the depression in America due to the Wall Street helped to show that capitalism was weak and that the five year-plans were working.

Overall it can be argued that Stalin’s five-year plans weakened the USSR as they were poorly organised making the party as a whole look disorganised so they were less trustworthy. They created issues between managers and workers so there was social discomfort, it created a quicksand society, which went completely against the values of communism.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

An Approach to the Twelfth Five Year Plan

... Faster, Sustainable and More Inclusive Growth An Approach to the Twelfth Five Year Plan (2012-17) Government of India Planning Commission Contents 1 An Overview 1-14 2 Macro-Economic Framework 15-27 3 Energy 28-38 4 Transport 39-44 5 Sustainable Management of Natural Resources 45-58 6 Rural Transformation 59-66 7 Farm Sector 67-79 8 Manufacturing Sector 80-86 9 Health 87-95 10 Education & Skill Development 11 Social and Regional Equity 104-107 12 Challenge of Urbanisation 108-114 13 Science and Technology 115-118 14 Services: Tourism, Hospitality & Construction 119-125 15 Governance 126-134 16 Innovation 135-139 96-103 Tables Table 1.1: Structure of Global GDP 13 Table 2.1: Sectoral Growth Rates - Previous Plans and Target for Twelfth Plan 18 Table 2.2: Broad Macro-Economic Parameters - Previous Plans and Target for Twelfth Plan 19 Table 2.3: Projection of Centre’s Resources for the Twelfth Five Year Plan (2012-17) (Figures in Rs Crore at Current Prices) 23 Table 2.4: Projection of Centre’s Resources for the Twelfth Five Year Plan (as per cent of GDP) 24 Table 3.1: Projected Energy Demand 29 Table 14.1: Construction Sector: Contribution to GDP 122 Table 14.2: Construction Components Involved in Creation of Physical Infrastructure 122 Table 14.3:......

Words: 75065 - Pages: 301

Free Essay

How Successful Were the Five – Year Plans in Transforming Russian Industry in the Years Up to 1941?

...Molly Morris 22.03.2013 ‘How successful were the Five – Year plans in transforming Russian Industry in the years up to 1941? (June 2010) There is no doubt that to some extent, Stalin’s industrialisation process was a success in industrialising Russia as not only did he make use of Russia’s resources and invested them into beneficial industries, such as the massive hydroelectric Dnieprostroi Dam built to generate electricity on the river Dnieper, he also developed heavy industries such as coal, iron, steel and oil in order to increase output, which in turn increased foreign trade and international relations and led to the result of Russia becoming one of the leading industrial powers of Europe, highlighting that the five year plans were successful in industrialising Russia. However, it could be argued that the rushed procedure and ridiculously high targets set by the USSR can also allow the argument that although Russia did industrialise at a fast pace which benefited Russia’s industry, The unrealistic targets that were set meant that managers were more concerned about the quantity of what they produced, not the quality implying that the five year plans only benefitted Russia’s industry for the short term and did not provide Russia with the long term industrialised plans it needed in order to progress suggesting the plans were not a success. Firstly, there are various factors to suggest the five years plans did successfully industrialize Russia such as Oil exceeding......

Words: 856 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Five-Year Career Development Plan

...Five-Year Career Development Plan Human Resources Management Foy Wallace, III May 18, 2004 CAREER DEVELOPMENT PLAN Kathleen Thompson General Manager Goal: General Manager of Hammonton Auto Group I like my current job, but my main area of interest is Management. I would like to be recognized for the efforts that I put forward. With a positive attitude I will embark on a journey that will bring me great satisfaction. I hope to have the skills and knowledge to be qualified for a General Manager position at Hammonton Auto Group by summer, 2008. I feel that the University of Phoenix is the best choice for me to attain that goal. Current Education and Experience: I have several certificates from insurance school. I also have a certificate in Business Finance and Dealer school. I am currently working on my bachelor’s degree and have 60 credits to go. I have completed fourteen classes at UOP toward a Business Management Degree. While I am earning my degree, I will continue to work in the field of insurance sales. I have a long road ahead of me with regard to school. I will be taking some time off from my studies for the summer. I have been going through some difficult personal issues and feel my schooling would be better served if I take a break. In this phase of my life I want to build a strong base for knowledge that is necessary for the position I desire. My short term goals are fulfilled but my lifelong ambitions are yet to come. Current Skills: Knowledge......

Words: 745 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Success & Failures of Stalin's Five Year Plans

...“The Five Year Plans were successful in strengthening the Economy before 1941.” Explain why you agree or disagree with this view. Though with many flaws Stalin’s five year plans did create a strong industrial base for Russia. Stalin’s aims for strengthening the economy could identify the successes of the five year plans. Stalin wanted to strengthen the economy to increase military strength due to the fear of foreign invasion he needed a well-developed industrial base especially of heavy industry. He also wanted to achieve self-sufficiency, and to improve standards of living of people in Russia to bridge the gap between them and the West. A strengthened economy would fulfil and maintain the promise to international proletariat to develop the country and become the first socialist state by industrialising. In some ways, the five year plans fulfilled some of Stalin’s aims for example, the focus on rapid increase in industrial capacity and growth of industry especially, heavy industry and armament production. Coal and iron output doubled and defence armaments grew rapidly as resources were diverted to them. Also hydro-electric dams, canals, railways and other infrastructural projects were built. The five year plans transformed the primitiveness of the country, creating a massive urban working class and trebling electricity production. As well as strengthening the economy and achieving military strength this expansion gave Russia enough strength to resist and eventually beat......

Words: 570 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

In the Context of the Period 1825-1937, to What Extent Was the First Five Year Plan (1928-1933) the Most Successful Change to Russian Economic Output?

...The period 1928 to 1933 marked a transition, perhaps the most decisive turning point in the history of the country of Russia. While the NEP system was not formally repudiated, official policies increasingly came to contradicts fundamental assumptions. The first five year plan (1928-1933) could be construed as a general success even though it did have its moment of failure. The first five year plan was introduced in Russia in an attempt to catch up with the more advanced west. As Stalin said 'We are fifty or a hundred years behind the advanced countries. We must make good this distance in ten years.' The focus of the first five year plan on heavy industry made huge strides in modernising industry and increasing output, in that 'Coal, iron, and the generation of electrical power all increased in huge proportion’s and Russia felt it could compete again on a scale with its western rivals. However, despite overarching economic development, many of the targets set by central panning didn't consider the quality of products or waste of materials and on reflection, highlight a number of fundamental flaws in the measurement of success of the first five year plan. Stalin's idea of collectivisation forced the peasants to move to a commune, share the livestock and equipment whilst having to give the government their share of the revenue. 'The government figured that new technology and new farming machines, would allow mass production of food without the large amount of workers that...

Words: 3975 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Five-Year Personal Growth Plan

...FIVE-YEAR PERSONAL GROWTH PLAN Liberty University Online PLED 325-DO3 LUO BY Desmond W. Akenteng Instructor’s Name: Dr. Tyler Scarlett Date: October 29, 2014 Introduction Every man/woman whom God has called want to do the work God has giving to him/her and do it successfully, God works with time and He does everything orderly. So in order for me to do God’s work successfully and accurately, I have to have a time table to guide me so that I would not waste time on things that will not bring glory to God. In this assignment, I would seek to provide my five-year personal growth plan for the next five years to come and with God’s help, I would grow from grace to glory. Section 1: Mastering the Calendar. Every Year, I plan to: Every first week of June, I will go to North American Baptist Association of (Ghana Baptist convention) pastor’s retreat. And also every last week of July, I will go to North American Baptist Association of (Ghana Baptist convention) Annual convention. And before fall school starts, I will have one-week personal retreat to seek the face of God. My family and I will take a vacation every year. This is what I have planned to do every year. Every Month, I plan to: I will attend evening church prayer meeting four times. And I will also spend four days in fasting and prayers; I will also attend once a month church council meeting. And I will also make sure that I will read my book as scheduled. ...

Words: 1399 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

How Far Do You Agree with the View That the Development of the Cold War in the Years 1945-49 Was Mainly Due to ‘Stalin’s Own Errors’?

...How far do you agree with the view that the development of the Cold War in the years 1945-49 was mainly due to ‘Stalin’s own errors’? I disagree with the statement - sources 7, 8 and 9 all suggest that the Cold War had many contributing factors, although it was ultimately the USA’s own economic and national interests to blame, rather than Stalin’s errors, as a result of acts and policies such as the Marshall Plan and Truman Doctrine in 1947. Both providing evidence to support this view are sources 8 and 9, with source 7 giving the impression that it was the errors of Stalin that contributed most. In addition to these two factors, conflicting ideologies also played a small role in provoking the Cold War, as shown in source 8. Despite this, it was fundamentally the economic and national interests of the USA that was mainly to blame for the start of the Cold War in 1945 and its development through to 1949. Europe was destroyed physically and economically after the Second World War. America saw this as a chance to become a world hegemony, as well as economically advancing the nation - source 9 proves this, saying, “The liberal capitalist US economy needed ever-increasing trade and investment opportunities”, as well as “The Marshall Plan was designed to implant an informal American Empire in Europe”. This shows that the USA not only used Europe’s fragile situation after WW2 to prosper itself, but more importantly increase its world influence, aiming to produce some sort of......

Words: 1496 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Agree to Disagree

...| | Agree to Disagree China is frequently regarded as a rising power, which challenges the United State’s dominant position in the International System. Theory, as well as history suggests this to be a dangerous situation and there have been calls from Chinese leaders for a new type of great power relations. Perhaps the major challenge for this new type of power relations, is the relation between the U.S.A.- Japan – and China. China recently expressed rather clear views on that relationship during its military parade in honour of the 70’s anniversary of the Chinese victory over Japan, also expressed through the strong words of President Xi Jinping at the same event. While the speech exhibited a particularly strong rhetoric, its aspects were not new. In fact, similar language can be found in a People’s Daily article as old as the 3rd of March 1971, showing that Japan has played a role for Chinese foreign policy considerations for a while. Especially in terms of the Chinese historiographical memory, the picture of Japan has stayed remarkably stable. In fact, the Chinese core assumption, that it has been the “victim of international aggression” and a “unique and continuing neuralgia toward Tokyo” consistently constitute Chinese intentions on the international field. The continuity with which this thematic reappears in Chinese public discourse does not suggest, that they are bound to change any time soon. At the same time, Japan continues to be one of the most......

Words: 743 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

How Far Do You Agree Stalins Five Year Plans (1929-1941) Improved the Russian Economy?

...How far do you agree that Stalin’s five year plans (1929-1941) improved the Russian economy? I strongly agree with the view that Stalin’s five year plans improved the Russian economy because of the significant growth in the Russian economy between this times in which the economy was growing at 14% a year. Stalin’s 5 year plans did improve the economy due to heavy industry increased the production of steel. Iron and coal, also by the end of the 5 year plans Stalin’s successfully increased production of vital things such as grain and wheat, the plans also geared and prepared Russia for war. However along with the many pros of the 5 year plans also came some cons, for example many people died within the duration of the plans up to 20 million people died because of his harsh policies during the course of these plans. The first five year plan started in 1929 the aim of this plan was to increase heavy industry all throughout Russia because Stalin believed as quoted that “we are 50 to 100 years behind the advanced countries, either we make this distance in 10 years or we be crushed” so following this his plan was to increase output of raw materials such as steel, iron and grain. To make sure this rapid industrialisation was to happen, Gosplan the supervised committee which controlled the various aspects of the USSR planned economy then employed 500,00 bureaucrats to set targets for every workshop, factory mill and mine, these target set were to unrealistic so because of the......

Words: 1233 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Five Year Plans of India

...Summary: Five Year Plans in India Plan Notes First Plan (1951 - 56) It was based on Harrod-Domar Model. Community Development Program launched in 1952 Focus on agriculture, price stability, power and transport It was a successful plan primarily because of good harvests in the last two years of the plan Second Plan (1956 - 61) Target Growth: 4.5% Actual Growth: 4.27% Also called Mahalanobis Plan named after the well known economist Focus - rapid industrialization Advocated huge imports through foreign loans. Shifted basic emphasis from agriculture to industry far too soon. During this plan, prices increased by 30%, against a decline of 13% during the First Plan Third Plan (1961 - 66) |Target Growth: 5.6% Actual Growth: 2.84% At its conception, it was felt that Indian economy has entered a take-off stage. Therefore, its aim was to make India a 'self-reliant' and 'self-generating' economy. Based on the experience of first two plans, agriculture was given top priority to support the exports and industry. Complete failure in reaching the targets due to unforeseen events - Chinese aggression (1962), Indo-Pak war (1965), severe drought 1965-66 Three Annual Plans (1966-69) Plan holiday for 3years. Prevailing crisis in agriculture and serious food shortage necessitated the emphasis on agriculture during the Annual Plans During these plans a whole new agricultural strategy was implemented. It involving wide-spread distribution of high-yielding varieties of seeds,......

Words: 1095 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Five Year Development Plan

...Running head: ARCA: FIVE YEAR CAREER DEVELOPMENT PLAN ARCA: Five Year Career Development Plan University of Phoenix ARCA: Five Year Career Development Plan A. Career Goals and Objectives a. Long Term (5-10 years): to help the developmentally disabled individuals I work with drastically improve and become independent and to become a division director or beyond at ARCA in the Assisted Living Department. b. Short Term (current- 1year): Continue to get to know the individuals I work with and learn their needs. To establish a good trusting relationship with them, (Noe, Hollenbeck, Gerhart, & Wright, 2007, pp. 308). B. Possible Promotional Opportunities for Career Growth a. Assisted Living Teacher (current position) ( Assisted Living Case Worker ( Assisted Living Program Manager ( Assisted Living Assistant Division Manager ( Assisted Living Division Director, (Noe, et. al., 2007, pp. 308). C. Methods for Career Management a. What is Career Management? Also called employee development planning, it helps employees select development activities that prepare them to meet their career goals. It helps employers select development activities in line with their human resource needs, (Noe, et. al., 2007, pp. 288). b. Employee Responsibility involves 4 steps: i. Self Assessment: Identifying opportunities and needs for improvement ...

Words: 1069 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

India’s 12th Five Year Plan

...India’s 12th Five Year Plan to Focus on ‘Inclusive Growth’ Apr. 25 – As India’s government prepares to submit its approach paper for its 12th five-year plan (a plan which covers years 2012 to 2017), the Planning Commission’s focus on instilling “inclusive growth” is making headway. The plan is expected to be one that encourages the development of India’s agriculture, education, health and social welfare through government spending. It is also expected to create employment through developing India’s manufacturing sector and move the nation higher up the value chain. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, however, warned that maintaining fiscal discipline is important as well. The commission will likely strive to enact policies that will achieve somewhere around a 10 percent growth rate in factories and a 4 percent growth rate in farm produce, though Prime Minister Singh has asked the plan to set the nation’s growth rate firmly at 9 percent to 9.5 percent. Come May, a view into the implementation of these goals should be apparent. A question that India’s government will have to grapple with, much like that of any emerging market, is whether to continue to focus on GDP growth in the face of soaring food prices and economy-wide inflation. An important aspect of generating “inclusive growth” is shifting the target of government aid to rural areas. Typically, large projects such as power generation, roads whereby freight can travel, and airports receive the lion’s share of government...

Words: 826 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

12th Five Year Plan

...Introduction on 5 yr plan: The economy of India is based in part on planning through its five-year plans, which are developed, executed and monitored by the Planning Commission. The tenth plan completed its term in March 2007 and the eleventh plan is currently underway First five year plan (1951- 1956) The first Indian Prime Minister, Jawaharlal Nehru presented the first five-year plan to the Parliament of India on December 8, 1951.This plan was based on the Harrod-Domar model. The plan addressed, mainly, the agrarian sector, including investments in dams and irrigation. The agricultural sector was hit hardest by the partition of India and needed urgent attention.[3] The total planned budget of  2069 crore was allocated to seven broad areas: irrigation and energy (27.2 percent), agriculture and community development (17.4 percent), transport and communications (24 percent), industry (8.4 percent), social services (16.64 percent), land rehabilitation (4.1 percent), and for other sectors and services (2.5 percent).[4] The most important feature of this phase was active role of state in all economic sectors. Such a role was justified at that time because immediately after independence, India was facing basic problems—deficiency of capital and low capacity to save. The target growth rate was 2.1% annual gross domestic product (GDP) growth; the achieved growth rate was 3.6% Second five year plan (1956-1961) The second five-year plan focused on industry, especially heavy......

Words: 3059 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

The Patriot Act; Agree of Disagree

...The Patriot Act: Agree or Disagree Amanda Collier ENG/215 August 27, 2012 Bruce Massis The Patriot Act: Agree or Disagree President George W. Bush signed into law on October 26, 2001 The USA PATRIOT Act. The title of the Act is a letter acronym: Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism Act of 2001 (PUBLIC LAW 107–56—OCT. 26, 2001) This Act was written to prevent and punish terrorist acts here in the United States as well as around the world, to help law officers, and to strengthen U.S. measures. Three essays have been studied on this subject, (U.S. Patriot Act – Damian Coles, and The Patriot Act: Wise beyond Its Years – John Ashcroft, and Cassady Pitt - U.S. Patriot Act and Racial profiling: Are there consequences of discrimination?) to come up with this critical argument essay. There are advantages and disadvantages of the Patriot Act. Although The Bill of Rights gives us privacy that could be invaded, is effectual for our country because this helps law enforcement have more resources and more freedom to help. Here are two disadvantages of the Patriot Act to be discussed. First racial profiling and, second America’s right to privacy under the Bill of Rights. When someone is considered a criminal or terrorist just because of how they dress, look, or the religion they practice, this is racial profiling. Racial profiling was a problem in the United States even before 9/11 and the Patriot......

Words: 877 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Five Year Marketing Plan of Vitamin Water

...Executive Summary Vitaminwater is a product of a privately owned subsidiary of Coca-Cola Company, Glacéau. It aims to provide nutrients drinks to meet people needs throughout the day. Its bottles are colorful, which targets at the youth currently. To achieve the goal of rising popularity of Vitaminewater in local marketing within 5 years with a consumer expand and sales increase, marketing plan is proposed. Vitaminwater is recommended to expand the target customers to people who concerned with their health, not just the youth in Hong Kong. Thus, repackaging Vitaminwater is essential in attracting potential customers and stand out from other drinks manufactures like Pepsi. Moreover, Vitaminwater is suggested to engage into different advertisement channels and distribute to different selling locations. Therefore it can increase awareness among Hong Kong people. Ultimately, Vitaminwater improves the sales performance to meet sales target at HK 200,000 by 2014. SWOT Analysis Figure 1 shows the internal and external factors affecting the marketing opportunities for Glacéau-VitaminWater since 2007 when it became the subsidiary of Coca-Cola Company. Figure 1. SWOT Analysis for Glacéau-VitaminWater Internal Factors Strengths Weaknesses Management Purchased by Coca-Cola Company, Glacéau can utilize Coke’s well developed system with experienced management Conflicts between financial management and shareholders Offerings Good taste, healthy, high-quality, high-price......

Words: 1739 - Pages: 7

Deadpool | Planetarium | Age.of.Empires.II.HD.The.Rise.of.the.Rajas-RELOADED