Free Essay

Susan Glaspell's Trifles

In: English and Literature

Submitted By taylorfly
Words 1361
Pages 6
ENGL 2304
Dr. Soto
8 October 2007
Feminism in Trifles In Susan Glaspell’s Trifles, a short play about rural life in the early twentieth century, a strong standpoint on feminism is presented to the audience. Throughout the play, much of the plot revolves around contrasting the men in power’s perception of a crime scene with the more subjective, emotional women’s point of view. In the conclusion of the poem, the women, Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale, decline turning in some potential evidence that they have discovered. Their line of reasoning is that they understand the circumstances of the crime: a cruel, oppressive man was killed by his wife because of his wrongdoings. They understand that most likely the man probably deserved his fate, so they do not submit any evidence for the crime to the country attorney and the sheriff. Ethics aside, this action creates a chasm between the perceived implications of the plot of the play versus the actual effect of the play on the audience. In the first sense of the play, there is the literal conclusion. The women outright refuse to give the evidence to the sheriff and the county attorney; instead, they do not even mention that they have “solved” the crime. They end up dismissing it completely. However, attempting to determine the meaning of these actions can be difficult. Looking at the play strictly in a literal sense, the women have apparently done nothing for the cause of feminism. Yes, it is true that the women have silently resisted the men and have asserted their own superiority. Further, it seems that the women are so confident with their actions that they do not even need to bother with telling the men. However, what did this accomplish? In the play, it still seems that the men are indeed talking down to the women and the men hardly care at all at whatever retort the women may make. The entire play seems to be characterized by silent aggression. The women talk about preserves, quilting, and other typically women subjects. In fact, their stereotypical women roles are allowing them to be emotional and understand the case. They have experience where the men do not, but most of this seems to support the idea that women are typically in these situations – cooking and sewing. In this sense, it appears that the roles the women are cast in match up to nearly any stereotype about women in American society of that time (and even, to some extent, present day). While it is true that they are portrayed to be smart enough to solve such a crime, it appears to just typecast their emotional side to come to any conclusions. For example, they refuse to submit the evidence not out of a sense of reason but instead out of their emotions they end up siding with the murderer. It is unfortunate to see this because it signals that emotional decisions are stronger than rational decisions. Rational decisions are generally based on a variety of ethical conceptions, such as those by Kant or Mill or even Plato or Aristotle, and in these situations it would be more focused on submitting the evidence rather than making a point about their power in the situation. And, while they passively showed resistance to the men, the men never knew about it, so the end result is the status quo. If for a given force there has to be a reaction, there was no force to cause any reaction in this situation. The men assumed that they were right and will continue to subvert the women’s rights. Absolutely no change will come from this for the women in the play. Perhaps if they had spoken up about how intelligent and thoughtful they were, they would have shown the superiority of women in some respect. But had this not been a play and instead a real life situation, this entire exchange would have been a nonevent in any circumstances. Of course, this is a play that many, many people have read (or seen) since its creation. It has been taken to be a great work of feminism for the period, and continues to be reprinted in collections for college students around the world. In this regard, the audience gets to experience the feminism in a different way. Instead of the play being taken for a real set of actions and consequences, it is best taken as a play that is making a point. The audience is supposed to be able to share in the secret that the women are having. In this way, the women are allowed to communicate with the audience that they are indeed smarter than the men and for a variety of different reasons. The audience is able to understand the motivations of the women more as well, which serves to make the presence of stereotypes a less dramatic portion of the dialog. In this way, the stereotypes that are used in the play are given depth and explanation that shows how the women are able to think through a problem, build evidence, and solve it better than the sheriff and the attorney can by themselves. In the conclusion of the poem, the act of silent defiance ends up making a profound point – women are capable and should be given more credit. And while the men have absolutely no clue that they are solving the case incorrectly and legal justice has not been applied to the murderer, the women have shown something greater than punishment could have done. As well, the audience is able to understand the men’s flaws in greater detail when they appear to have no sense of compassion, emotion, or understanding for the women. It should be noted that hiding the evidence allows for the women to show that they are superior. Even though there is no punishment, the point of the play is not to give strict legal justice, but to show that women have deep senses of understanding and that they dislike the treatment that they are given. Because they are not really able to stand up to the men and their omnipresent ability to oppress the women, they have taken the best route that was presented for them. As an audience, the point of the play has been driven home because of the passive aggression – it makes the women appear to be smarter than the men, and it gives them complete control over the situation. So, the women have exploited the men’s fallacies and have empowered themselves in the best way that they have been given. To the audience, it should be clear that women have ended up as the victors in the play, not the docile and submissive housewives that they were stereotyped to be. The play was so effective, it seems, that the play has become a staple of feminism because of how the positioning in the play was described. Overall, there are a variety of ways to read this poem. The two main groups, literally and as an audience, share many similarities, but the perspective in each changes the meaning of the poem in an extreme fashion. On one hand, the act of defiance on the women’s part proved absolutely nothing and no change would come from it. They were endlessly trapped by their silent anger created nothing positive for women in the long run; it almost appeared that they just continued to submit to the men. However, as an informed audience, the point of the play is greater than the literal truths presented in the plot’s conclusion. The audience is given a chance to see that the women are defiant in clever way that could inspire other feminists of the time to be defiant as well. While at first the conclusion seemed to be direct, the actual message of the play appears spread the word about women who are oppressed and the struggles they go through to fight the oppression, even if the methods are seemingly insignificant to the cause on a small scale. The story of the women, rather than their actions in the plot, is what creates this powerful message of feminism.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

"Trifles: " a Moral Justifacation for Murder

...Trifles: A Moral Justification for Murder The one act play “Trifles” depicts the views and passions of both men and women during the late-nineteenth century regarding the role of a woman. The characters in the play are the County Attorney, the Sheriff, and Mr. Hale, who are accompanied by Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters into the Wright’s home to investigate the murder of Mr. Wright. The men feel that the women are only concerning themselves with little things and make several condescending comments throughout the play displaying their views. While the men search for clues upstairs and in the outside barn yard, it is the women who cleverly piece together several clues leading to Mrs. Wright’s guilt in the murder mystery. But, because of the shocking evidence found by the women, they become sympathetic towards Mrs. Wright and decide to conceal their findings from the authorities. The women feel that the mental and emotional abuse Mrs. Wright received from her husband was justification for the crime in which she committed. Although murder is usually looked upon as an indefensible crime of selfishness, Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters actions were morally validated because of Mr. Wright’s own selfish and tyrannical actions; which left Mrs. Wright with no other alternative but to murder him in order to reclaim her liberty. From the beginning of the play, when Mr. Hale explains to the other men that he was visiting the Wright’s home in hopes of convincing John Wright to pitch in on a party......

Words: 1055 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Trifles: Susan Glaspel

...Heather Mitchell Intro to Lit E140-003 Trifles, pg. 1164 #4 “Trifles” by Susan Glaspell is an older play, written in 1916, and many of the main themes reveal this about the play. The root of all the problems and main conflicts in this play can all be traced back to one thing; the Wrights’ marriage. To say the least things must have been slightly rough in the Wright house for someone to have been murdered. When you marry someone, it should be because you want to spend the rest of your life with them. Also, this feeling should not fade or change throughout the marriage, though it often does. To me, both Mr. and Mrs. Wright showed a sort of trapped feeling, like seeing their spouse everyday was a burden, not a privilege. So how many forgotten goodnight kisses, petty arguments, and words left unsaid does it take to reach this feeling of entrapment? It seems as though, as so often happened back then and even today, that Mr. Wright did not appreciate his wife. She did the cooking, and the cleaning, and all the other upkeep. She saw Mr. Wright everyday but still felt all alone, which is why the bird played such a big role in her life. The bird was all that Minnie had. So after neglecting his wife and taking her for granted, Mr. Wright took the one thing keeping his wife sane. He killed the bird, leaving Minnie feel totally alone and most likely seeking revenge. I would have to say that the main theme of this play is that men do not appreciate women. Now do women always......

Words: 560 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Trifles

...O’Neil 1 Becky O’Neil Arquette Eng. 112-01 December 6th, 2012 “Trifles” by Susan Glaspell During the 19th century, possibilities for women were severely restricted. Women were not allowed to vote, could not control their own finances, and were not able to work outside the home(unless widowed), any money or property they had was turned over to their husbands upon their marriage. Much of history is written from the male perspective. Women of that era were struggling with finding a sense of themselves and a certain freedom from the traditional gender roles society had dictated for them. Susan Glaspell’s “Trifles” portrays these struggles through Mrs. Wright, who is expected to conform but resorts to an act of desperation to gain her freedom. The tale begins when Mr. Hale pays a visit to his neighbor, John Wright, only to discover That Mr. Wright is dead. Upon asking Mrs. Wright what killed him, she tells him, “He died of the rope around his neck.”(789) The sheriff and the County Attorney are called and arrive at the scene. However, in this case the professionals fall short in their task to find evidence of a motive for murder. It is the two women who accompany their husbands to the house who uncover the vital clues as to motive. Mrs. Hale, the wife of the man who reported the crime, and Mrs. Peters, the sheriff’s wife, are left in the kitchen. They are there only to gather a......

Words: 1769 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Trifles Paper

...of “Trifles”, Fidelity, and Women’s honor by Susan Glaspell. In writing “Trifles”, Fidelity, and The Visioning she drew from her past and current experienced events to create such stories. Her writing career had first begun when she was in high school and progressed further into her college years. While attending college, her career spun off as a reporter for Des Moines Daily News. After a short time of being a reporter, she and her husband decided to return back to her hometown Davenport, Iowa to become a full time writer. This was the beginning of her becoming “one of the early-twentieth-century America’s leading playwright”(Rudnick). Fidelity was Glaspell third novel which was published in 1915. It took place in a small town in Iowa about a midwestern woman name Ruth Holland who was a rebellion against the environment she was surrounded by. She was committed in a relatonship with a man name Stuart Williams who was also married. Throughout the story, Ruth wants to amends relationship with her family but they seen her only as a bad woman. She started to grow by filling the voids in her life. When Stuart’s wife granted him the divorce, Ruth at this point decided to leave for New York alone to find her idenity, “rather than marrying a man she no longer loves” (Carpentier). Though it did not received as much fame as her other writings, this novel proves that influences from other people helps a writer creat their story. Though Fidelity may be different from Glaspell’s......

Words: 1200 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Literary Analysis of Trifles

...Literary analysis on “Trifles” by Susan Glaspell Gender roles continue to change with time. It has only been a very short time that woman have broken through their defined roles and begin to be equal with men on a total basis. In Susan Glaspell’s “Trifles”, the story challenges the gender roles through the events that occur during the course of the play and through their own inner workings. The story is set in the Literary Renaissance –Drama period and leaves plenty of room for female characters to shine in certain roles. The story provides interesting points that challenge the reader to step back and look at gender roles in a new light. “Trifles” is centered on several married couples and is presented around the point of view of female characters. The story takes place at Mrs. Wright’s home a day after her husband has been murdered. Much of the long script takes place around a conversation between Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters. The two women are in the home because one is the Sheriffs wife and the other is the wife of the Attorney. The story is presented as though Mrs. Wright is suspected of killing her husband and there is no doubt that she did kill her husband. During Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters conversation it is established that the two women are lashing out against their gender roles by withholding evidence from their husbands. In the story woman compare themselves to birds. Mrs. Hale openly speaks about Mrs. Wright “was kind of a bird herself” (Glaspell 169). It......

Words: 836 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Trifles

...Susan Glaspell’s one-act play, Trifles, is based on actual events that occurred in Iowa at the beginning of the century. For two years Glaspell worked as a reporter for the Des Moines News, where she covered the murder trial of a farmer’s wife, Margaret Hossack, in Indianola, Iowa. Hossack was accused of killing her husband, John, by striking him twice in the head with an ax while he slept (Trifles 216). Trifles, written in the early 1900’s by Susan Glaspell. Glaspell wrote this play during a time of controversial feminist issues.  Glaspell wrote "Trifles" to demonstrate the male assumption that women were insignificant members in a male dominated society. Because the men underestimate them, the women are able to prove they are not insignificant. The play opens at the Wright farmhouse where Mr. Wright has been murdered in his sleep. They entered in the house: county attorney, the sheriff, Mrs. Hale, and Mrs. Peters. The men and women have come to investigate the case against Minnie Foster, the wife of Mr. Wright.  Most of the stuffs which the male characters supposed to be insignificant objects like the broken bird cage door, the quilt, the dead canary, and the entire kitchen consequentially lead to the solution (Trifles 219). The improper assumptions by men toward women can have dire consequences, as demonstrated in Glaspell's world. Combating these narcissistic assumptions displayed by men can result in a unity among women that can overcome any male caused......

Words: 2194 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Plot Summary for Trifles

...Plot Summary The setting for Trifles, a bleak, untidy kitchen in an abandoned rural farmhouse, quickly establishes the claustrophobic mood of the play. While a cold winter wind blows outside, the characters file in one at a time to investigate a violent murder: the farm’s owner, John Wright, was apparently strangled to death while he slept, and his wife, Minnie, has been taken into custody as a suspect in the crime. The sheriff, Henry Peters, is the first to enter the farmhouse, followed by George Henderson, the attorney prosecuting the case. Lewis Hale, a neighbor, is next to enter. The men cluster around a stove to get warm while they prepare for their investigation. Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale follow the men into the kitchen; yet, they hesitate just inside the door. They are obviously quite disturbed by what has happened in the house and proceed with more care than their husbands. In a play filled with minor details (trifles) that take on major significance, the entrance of the characters is very revealing. There is an obvious divide — social, psychological, and physical — separating the men from the women, a fact that takes on a larger significance as the play progresses. The investigation begins with Henderson questioning Lewis, who discovered the murder the day before. Lewis explains that he was on his way into town with a load of potatoes and stopped at the Wright farmhouse to see if John and Minnie wanted to share a telephone line with him, since they were......

Words: 2998 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Trifles

...Shaurese Grate ENG 102 Professor Stone 17 September 2014 Trifles Trifles is a one act play in which the setting is on an old farm in a house in an unkempt kitchen. The plot basically revolves around a murder in which the wife is a suspect of killing her husband. In the beginning of the play, the County Attorney, the Sheriff, Mrs. Peters (who is the wife of the sheriff), and Mrs. Hale (who is the wife of the man that discovered the victim) were all in the home of the suspect and the victim. As the Attorney and the Sheriff investigate the crime, they proceed to make snide remarks about the upkeep of the kitchen. They make it clear that they believe that it is a woman’s place to maintain the household. “And yet, for all their worries, what would we do without the ladies? Dirty towels! Not much of a housekeeper, would you say, ladies?” (Glaspell 1369) As the men proceed to go upstairs and investigate the crime scene, the wives begin to do a little of snooping of their own. At this time they discover a dead bird and a quilt that Mrs. Wright was working on. They were confused as to why she switched from stitching to knotting. As the men returned to the women, they overheard their conversation about the quilt and found it humorous. “They wonder if she was going to quilt it or just knot it!” (Glaspell 1371) Here the Sheriff is acting as if the women are not smart enough to talk about anything except domestic tasks. However; I feel that this is ironic......

Words: 363 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Trifles

...Can women do a man’s job? Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale are two major characters in Glaspell’s Trifles. We enter a story where the women are following the men into the kitchen of the now abandoned farmhouse of John Wright. Hale’s wife speaks about Minnie’s (John’s wife) alienation from her nearest neighbors because of John’s stingy and unfriendly ways. She is being accused of being his murderer and Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters make observations of things that Minnie has left undone or unfinished around the house. This story is during an era where women were seen as incompetent to do a “man’s job”, yet these women were more observant and resourceful when trying to solve this crime. The women begin prodding around the kitchen and taking notice to things Minnie has just left untidy in the kitchen. The women had been sent to grab some belongings for Minnie, so they proceeded in doing so. The women then begin conversating about whether or not they believe Minnie is innocent. They move around the house and notice the quilt that was being pieced. They then notice simple clues of things being out of place in the house, but things that only a woman would take notice to. As the women are speaking about the quilt the sheriff enters and mocks the women. “They wonder if she was going to quilt it or just knot it!” [The men laugh and the women look abashed] (897). The men leave and the women sit at a table and resume in further noticing more evidence. “Mrs. Peters,......

Words: 683 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Trifles

...Essay Inequality of the sexes back before the 2000’s was very prominent. Trifles (a play) and A Jury of Her Peers (a short story) by Susan Glaspell are both the same story. Throughout both works, there are many instances in both that show this inequality. In both, it shows that women like to worry about things that don’t matter so much (at least to the men). This shows that men think that only they think about what is important and women only think to look at insignificant things. The characters spend the whole story/play searching for clues regarding the murder. Although women are thought to be the lesser, they actually discover the important information, not the men, which is ironic. The Sheriff, County Attorney, and Hale, all search the house and barn for evidence on their own, and make fun of the women. The women having focused on the quilt, broken bird cage, and dead bird, are able to piece together what happened. The women were able to figure out who the murderer was by paying attention to what they thought had mattered, and prove that these things are important regardless of what the men had thought at first. At the start of the play, all of the characters enter the abandoned farmhouse of John Wright, who was recently hanged by an unknown killer. The Sheriff and County Attorney start scanning the house for clues as to who killed Mr. Wright, but make a major error when they search the kitchen poorly, claiming that there is nothing there “but kitchen things.” This...

Words: 359 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Trifles

...Frohlich 1  Makenzee Frohlich  English 1020  Mr. French  18 December 14  Symbolic Beyond Sexism  “Well, women are used to worrying over trifles,” says Mr. Hale in Susan Glaspell’s play,  “Trifles.” While demeaning women and their concerns is criticized as sexist in the twenty­first  century, mere decades ago people accepted sexism as common and even warranted. Since the  male­dominated society considered women’s tasks less important than men’s, men treated  women with a lack of consideration. In the 20th century drama “Trifles,” Glaspell challenges the  suppression in effect during her lifetime, basing the play on a series of news stories she wrote  about the real­life court case of a woman prosecuted for murdering her husband. In “Trifles,”  Glaspell uses symbolism to show that male sexism causes a lack of empathy which leads to  men’s failures as much as it does women’s.  From the first scene to the final line, Glaspell uses spatial symbolism to reason her case  about the detrimental effects of men’s stereotypes of women. According to the stage direction,  the initially timid female characters, Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters “...come in slowly, and stand  close together near the door,” clearly displaying a reluctance to enter a widow’s empty home.  However, as Mr. Hale, the sheriff and the county attorney “go at once to the stove,” they discuss  what happened the previous day. When Mr. Hale had first knocked on the door to request Mr. ......

Words: 1334 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Information Trifles

...the rural community * Married to Mrs. Peters * Arrested Minnie, but leaves George Henderson to head the investigation * Mrs. Peters, though she didn’t know the younger Minnie, can relate to Minnie’s loneliness and isolation as she recalls her own losses; she helps Mrs. Hale hide the evidence Mrs. Peters * Married to the Sheriff John Wright * The murdered man and owner of the house Mrs. Minnie Wright (f/k/a Minnie Foster) * John Wright's wife and his suspected murderer ************************************ Summary Feminist Drama Trifles is an example of early feminist drama. Though its plot focuses on a single moral choice, that of Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters deciding whether or not to expose why Mrs. Wright killed her husband. It addresses the principal issue of justice and contemporary issues of gender and identity politics. Susan Glaspell’s power comes from the way she interweaves these issues until they are impossible to separate....

Words: 300 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Trifles Annaylsis

...Men’s Pride Leads to Downfall in Glaspell’s “Trifles” “Well, women are used to worrying over trifles,” says Mr. Hale in Susan Glaspell’s play, “Trifles.” While demeaning women and their concerns is criticized as sexist in the twenty-first century, mere decades ago people accepted sexism as common and even warranted. Since the male-dominated society considered women’s tasks less important than men’s, men treated women with a lack of consideration. In the 20th century drama “Trifles,” Glaspell challenges the suppression in effect during her lifetime, basing the play on a series of news stories she wrote about the real-life court case of a woman prosecuted for murdering her husband. In “Trifles,” Glaspell uses symbolism to show that male sexism causes a lack of empathy which leads to men’s failures as much as it does women’s. From the first scene to the final line, Glaspell uses spatial symbolism to reason her case about the detrimental effects of men’s stereotypes of women. According to the stage direction, the initially timid female characters, Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters “...come in slowly, and stand close together near the door,” clearly displaying a reluctance to enter a widow’s empty home. However, as Mr. Hale, the sheriff and the county attorney “go at once to the stove,” they discuss what happened the previous day. When Mr. Hale had first knocked on the door to request Mr. Wright’s help, he tentatively entered when he thought he heard “come in”; now that Mr. Wright is......

Words: 1325 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Trifles

...In Brian Sutton’s work “‘A different kind of the same thing’: Marie de France’s LAUSTIC and Glaspell’s Trifles”, he analyzes the similarity regarding the core symbol, a murdered songbird, and the powerful meaning of that symbol. Sutton compares both works to derive with his conclusion; that both works are linked to a piece of literary history connecting listening to a songbird with “a longing for the ideal and far off.” Even more so both works are compared with the will for freedom. Looking strictly at his opinions regarding “Trifles”, Sutton states how the dead canary “evokes a wife’s urge to escape her marital dreariness”, which is expressed in quotes from “Trifles” from Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters. However, the dead songbird is used for numerous other symbols throughout the play. Such as how Mr. Wright killing the bird is easily portrayed as an attack on his wife. Sutton interpreted the canary to be Mrs. Wright, more so the cheerful side extinguished by the depressing marriage between herself and Mr. Wright. Quotes withdrawn from “Trifles” can support this idea, again being stated by the lone women in the play, Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters. Sutton reasons that the killing of the bird (by Mr. Wright presumably), equates to a symbolic attack on Mrs. Wright. This attack only adds onto the guilt of already killing Mrs. Wright’s spirit, hence the presence of the songbird, where the canary is a “stand-in” for Mrs. Wright. This article constructed by Sutton only focuses on one......

Words: 441 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Trifles

...April 7th 2009 Lit & Comp Trifles Marriage and beliefs can cause tension when it comes to law and justice. This is demonstrated in the one act play “Trifles” by Susan Glaspell. “Trifles” is a play that takes place in the early 20th century. This play is set at the scene of a murder, where a house wife is suspected of killing her husband. The story comes down to two women deciding what to do with newly found evidence. This causes tension between law and justice. The treatments these women receive during this story portray a larger statement about the role of gender and justice in society. For example, the Sheriff, Mr. Peters and his wife represent the conflict between law and justice because Mrs. Peters has to choose between her marriage to the “law” and her beliefs of justice. One important role in this story is sexism. “Trifles” involves drama within the male dominated society of the time period. The men in this play such as the Sheriff, the County Attorney, and Mr. Hale all represent the law. These men are in the play to try to enforce the law and find evidence against the suspected murderer Mrs. Wright. Justice is demonstrated in the characters Mrs. Peters, Mrs. Hale, and Mrs. Wright. Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale are at the crime scene supporting their husbands to find evidence. After being mocked by their husbands, Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale conceal the evidence they find to bring Mrs. Wright closer to justice. Mrs. Peters keeps her mouth shut and goes along with Mrs....

Words: 767 - Pages: 4

James Caan | One Piece 242 | Mademoiselle de Joncquières FRENCH HDRiP 2019