Free Essay

The Movie Philadelphia

In: Film and Music

Submitted By blmiller525
Words 1289
Pages 6
Barbie Miller
Philadelphia Movie Review

I think the movie was okay, not something I would have watched on my own. This movie shows how one is discriminated against because of his disease. Discrimination comes in all kinds of forms, from racism, gender, age and more. I am not sure how this really fits into this period, other than it was in the early 80’s when people started to learn about aids. Homosexuals started coming out of the closet as they say. You had to be afraid to be gay because you would be persecuted for your sexual orientation. Everyone thought Aids was just related to the gay community, but it was also from doing drugs with someone that had the disease. Sharing needles from during heroin with someone that was a carrier. Therefore, here is my take on the movie.

Andrew Beckett (Tom Hanks) is one of Philadelphia's most promising lawyers. He is the hot rookie and hired by a top law firm headed by Charles Wheeler (Jason Robards). Andy is also gay and dying from AIDS. When the physical signs of the disease begin to manifest themselves, the firm gets cold on Andy and he is out of a job. They tell him it is because he has an attitude problem and his work is mediocre, but Andy knows it is more personal than that. After no other law firm will take his case for unfair dismissal, his last resort is old adversary Joe Miller (Denzel Washington). Joe, a homophobe with an innate fear of AIDS, is reluctant to take the case also because of his personal reasons, but after seeing Andy humiliated in a public library, cannot resist standing his corner with him.

You can see immediately why Hollywood took this film to their heart. In typical Hollywood fashion, they cannot resist the temptation to dumb the issue down to make it easier to sell. It's a difficult thing sometimes, criticizing a film like 'Philadelphia' as it leaves the critic open to accusations of homophobia themselves, but 'Philadelphia' patronizes the homosexual community so much, it's like an instruction video for schoolkids "Listen kids - gays are people too, you know?". For instance, Andy's family is a carbon copy of the Walton's. A more loving, accepting family you could never hope to meet, right down to the last second cousin. Nevertheless, it would have been more interesting and realistic to show some conflict within the family. Would all of Andy's male heterosexual relatives been so accepting of him? People now who are still ostracized from their family because they are gay. In addition, gosh darn it, if Andy is not the sweetest human being you could ever hope to meet! He is handsome, great at his job, and loves babies too! This is not to say gay men are not like that at all, but this film is so scared of being homophobic, that it refuses to portray Andy as anything less than whiter-than-white. This is where it is so patronizing, that it becomes damaging.

There is one instant where the film does attempt to address the grey areas of these issues. Andy is questioned as to how he got AIDS, and it has revealed that it comes from an anonymous sexual encounter in a cinema. Nevertheless, Joe asking Andy to take his shirt off and reveal the lesions on his body neatly sidesteps this issue of personal responsibility. So just when the film is starting to make you question just how much danger Andy has been putting himself in, it distracts you with a moment of 'yuck' to make you conveniently forget these very relevant questions. "Hey everybody, don't worry about how he got it, just look at how nasty it's made him look!” It is this fogging of the personal and moral questions that makes 'Philadelphia' ultimately dishonest. Would this trick have been played if it was heterosexual man? Probably not, and it again highlights just how patronizing the films attitude is. We have to tiptoe around the dark areas, because he's - whisper it quietly- gay. There is attempts to color in the murky moral areas, but it takes more than groups of protesters crying, "God created Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve!" to achieve that.

Likewise, the law firm Andy sues. Instead of making them flawed, but understandable human beings, they are monsters. They are homophobic, racist and sexist. Who would have thought it? They sit around in their boy’s locker room telling homophobic and misogynistic jokes with an uncomfortable Andy present. Is there more to human beings than the odd sick or bad taste joke. Probably, but the film will not show that, it is too busy showing things in black and white. Philadelphia is guilty of the very clichés it sets out to crucify. A handsome student in a drug store hits upon Joe. Because Joe is obviously gay as he is defending a gay man in court, right.

This was the first Tom Hanks performance to garner him an Oscar and it is easy to see why - he is playing a gay man AND a victim of prejudice and disease! The Academy voters could not have wrote his name down fast enough when they saw that. Two issues for the price of one in the same performance. Too bad, he is very blank in the performance. There is nothing going on beneath the make-up, he is such a wholesome chap with the seedy aspects of his life brushed under the carpet. Hanks skill is to use his everyman persona to reflect the character back at the audience, but the script gives him nothing to work with. His best part is with no dialogue, coming out of Miller's office after Miller has initially dismissed his case. He says nothing, but surveys the cold streets with his watery blue eyes and for the only time we get a sense of the fear and hurt within Andy.

Otherwise, he is bland and we have to suffer the 'aria' scene, where Hanks (for once) goes totally over-the-top. Entranced by opera (he's definitely gay then) he stumbles around his flat, spouting gibberish about why he loves the music and its meaning, and all the while Jonathan Demme puts a ridiculous red glare over the scene. A pointless, arty and distracting scene designed to do nothing more than highlight Hanks, but it stands out like a sore thumb. It is hard to credit that this is the Demme that delivered the sleek, tense ‘Silence of the Lambs’ as the courtroom scenes has no power to them, and the whole film has a flabby pace to it.

Washington however, is the only reason to really watch 'Philadelphia'. His is the only character that has any depth to it. Miller is a conflicted man, he hates gays but he also knows that it is an irrational fear. He also knows that a law has been broken and that takes precedence over anything else. Washington gives a tenacious, controlled performance that never tumbles into tearful histrionics, but has an adult air to it that the rest of the film sorely lacks. If anyone, it should have been Washington that was Oscar tipped for this film.

As a courtroom drama, it is extremely limited because the film makes no bones as to who is in the right and as to how it is going to turn out. As an AIDS and gay rights drama, it is patronizing and downright offensive. 'Philadelphia' is the type of film that purports to ask intelligent questions, but actually makes the audiences mind up for them instead. A great waste of a topic, director and cast, the gay community deserve better.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Philadelphia

...Philadelphia Hovedpersonen Andrew bliver til senior partner i hans firma, men kan lider af en blodsygdom ( ADIS). Den kommer hjem lige da han bliver udnævnt til partner. Andrew er bøsse Miljøet er overklasse, da han arbejder for et advokatfirma og folkene omkring ham er velhavende. Andy er blevet fyret, pga. en sag, han havde mistet et vigtig papir som ingen kunne finde, men han mener at der er nogen som har fjernet det fra hans computer. Han mener han var sat op. Joe Miller, har et stort problem med homoseksuelle derfor ville han ikke tage sagen for Andrew. Der er ikke ret mange mennesker omkring Andrew der kan lide hans pga. han er bøsse og pga. hans har ADIS. Men Joe Miller tager sagen efter set hvordan folk opføre sig overfor ham. De sagsøger Charles Wheeler. Joe Miller bliver bagt på af en jurastuderene. Joe Miller for sagde en til få en ny drejning. Han siger at sagen ikke er om ADIS men og frygten for homo’er. Andrew holder et kæld ud party for mange homo’er. Andy får et rigtig dårligt i retten, det ligner han er ved at stille træskoende. Andrew falder om inde i retten og det udleder til panik i retten. Han kommer ret hurtigt på sygehuset og retssagen forsætter uden andrew. Joe Miller vinder retssagen imod Charles Wheeler og Wheeler og hans advokat firma skal betale en hel del i erstatning. Hele hans familie er på hospitalet da Joe Miller kommer og overrækker papirerne som bevis på sejr. Andrew Beckett dør om......

Words: 272 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Movie

...Metaphor for Telling It has been countless years since I have watched a movie about Native Americans, and even longer since I have witnessed a decent one. Most films on the subject of the Native American people are often set in the past and are habitually on the subject of brave Indian warriors. I had never viewed a Native American motion picture filmed in a present day setting, dealing with contemporary issues until I watched Smoke Signals. In the movie Smoke Signals, co-producer and scriptwriter Sherman Alexie uses unexpected humor, numerous significant flashbacks, and modernized Native American storytelling traditions to best narrate his story and the historical plight of Native Americans. First of all, Alexie employs wit by mocking stereotypical reservation life, the frequently biased film industry, and even his own people, the Native Americans. From the opening scene as tribal meteorologist and traffic reporter Lester Falls Apart covers his seemingly uneventful daily traffic report, as he has for the last twenty-six years, from the rooftop of his broken down KREZ van, we are introduced to the odd and amusing way of life on the “rez.” In another scene, Victor and Thomas are embarking on their solemn journey and are offered a ride by Thelma and Lucy driving down the road in reverse; again, it is suggested that they exist in a somewhat backwards nation. In addition, Alexie is quick to taunt the movie industry by belittling white cowboy heroes; he even goes so far......

Words: 1048 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Cause of Crimes in Philadelphia

...El Batina Bokhoum English 098/099 June 8, 2014 ! ! ! Causes of Crime in Philadelphia ! The U.S most biggest cities such as New york, Los Angeles, Chicago and Philadelphia have faced different problems over centuries. One of the biggest problems is crime. Philadelphia residents have lived with high rates of crime and violence for decades. In 2005, Philadelphia had a crime rate of 15.2 percent, made it the highest in the U.S during that time. These crimes which are usually murder , robbery, rape and thefts can be explained for many causes. By interviewing a Philadelphia resident , it can be seen that easy access to gun , poverty , alcohol and illegal drug use are the causes of crimes. One the main causes of crime in Philadelphia is the easiness to access to gun. People with access to gun are usually more exposed to commit a crime. The lifestyle in Philadelphia can't be described without talking about its gun culture. People carry almost carry guns everywhere. They carry them on the streets, some students bring them at schools, others bring them at work. As the results , they randomly and easily use their guns when their is the fight . It’s very common in the "1 Philadelphia news that someone has been shot. You cant watch the news without seeing a person got shot. Even tough you need an authorization to carry gun , a lot of people have illegally a gun. They get gun from the corrupt stores , which are licensed to sell guns. Criminals in......

Words: 594 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Philadelphia

...Facts of film (What is the film about): Philadelphia is a film about a lawyer who was fired due to his sexual preference and being infected with AIDS. He had kept this information from his employers due to the circumstances in which he most likely contracted the deadly virus- engaging in homosexual activities. He didn’t feel comfortable informing his employer about his sexual preference due to a session in which much fun was made about homosexuals. During trial, his employers try to demonstrate that they were unaware of his condition or sexual preferences as he did not inform them. However, one of his partners had worked with a woman who had contracted AIDS via a blood transfusion and was familiar with the lesions. Rules of Law raised in film (if none, state none): Issues at hand are discrimination and wrongful firing due to a disability. Andrew, being a homosexual with aids, was discriminated upon. He was wrongfully let go and informed that it was due to his inability to perform at the level he was expected and had performed in the past. The Americans with Disabilities Act clearly prohibits discrimination based on a disability. Any impairment, physical or mental, that significantly limits major life activity is considered to be a disability. Andrew was able to perform his job without too much difficulty, so the fact that they were trying to fire on the grounds that he was sloppy with his work and the quality diminished was just a pretext for getting rid of him. It......

Words: 633 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Movie

...SAB 110: Substance Abuse Overview Professional Term/ Concept Application Movie/Book Assignment Directions: Use this form to review your book/movie. You will then apply 5 professional terms/ concepts to the movie or book that you chose. You can type your answers below, behind each section of information that you must provide. To get credit, you must use this form to submit your work. To get credit, you must also list the names of each of the 5 professional concepts/ terms that you chose and must give a detailed example of how each of those 5 terms/ concepts was demonstrated in the movie or book. To get credit you must use professional concepts/ terms from your course text. You must write in complete sentences and with good grammar to get full credit. Your Name: Deitra Crompton Date: 10.07.2014 Name of the Book or Movie That You Selected: Goodfellas Brief description of the plot, especially as it is relevant to substance abuse (2-3 paragraphs) This film views the mob lives of three pivotal figures in the 1960's and 70's New York. Henry Hill is a local boy turned gangster in a neighborhood full of the roughest and toughest. Tommy Devito is a pure bred gangster, who turns out to be Henry's best friend. Jimmy Conway puts the two of them together, and runs some of the biggest hijacks and burglaries the town has ever seen. After an extended jail sentence, Henry must sneak around the back of the local mob boss, Paulie Cicero, to live the life of luxury......

Words: 814 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

A Movie

...cited all sources from which I used language, ideas and information, whether quoted verbatim or paraphrased, and that any and all assistance of any kind, which I received while producing this paper, has been acknowledged in the References section.  This paper includes no trademarked material, logos, or images from the Internet, which I do not have written permission to include.  I further agree that my name typed on the line below is intended to have, and shall have the same validity as my handwritten signature.   Student's signature (name typed here is equivalent to a signature):  _Keisha Coleman__________________________     ___ Adulthood and Life Transitions The movie that I chose to view from a from a biological, cognitive, and psychosocial perspective was “Autumn in New York. The main characters of the movie were Will (Richard Gere) and Charlotte(Winona Ryder. They were two people that live life opposite of each other. Will is middle-aged man who manipulated woman and feels he needs to be in control of every relationship. Charlotte is twenty two woman who lived life full of happiness and joy because she did not what to expect in her life because of her heart condition she had. As they the two were connected their views of life changed and the both were in love with each other. Will who thought he could manipulate every relationship was not capable to do that with his relationship with Charlotte. When she explained to him about her heart condition he could of......

Words: 1125 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Ethical Issues in the Movie Philadelphia

...Philadelphia. The movie “Philadelphia” tells us a story about a successful lawyer – Andrew Beckett. He was fired when his boss figured out that he has AIDs. Andrew wants to sue the company for discrimination, but every lawyer refused him. Finally, he found Joe Miller, a person he used to work with once. At the end Beckett succeeds in his case. There are a lot of ethical issues in the movie, but I am going to write about three, I found the most important. The first ethical issue is discrimination. Beckett was fired from the company, when his co-workers figured out that he has AIDs and he is homosexual. The second ethical issue that I found interesting is lying. Is it okay that Andrew hided from his co-workers that he has a disease and he is homosexual? The third ethical issue is the betrayal. Basically, his co-workers and his boss got read of the documents he left on the table, which was unfair. The ethical dilemma that I want to look at in details is discrimination. The first step of Ethical Decision Making tells to gather the facts. What happened in the movie is that Andrew’s employers just knew that he is sick and homosexual. They did not know a lot about his life and personality. So, they did not gather the facts. However, during the movie we figure out that Andrew Beckett is good guy. Moreover, in 1990s, people did not have a lot of information about AIDs and how it spreads. The second step is to define the ethical issues. Andrew was fired without taking his case in...

Words: 494 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Philadelphia Phillies

...Case Study Analysis: Philadelphia Phillies Question- assessing the competitive environment the Phillies participate in and suggest ways for them to manage their product and highlight their brand accordingly. Philadelphia Phillies are a major league baseball team. They are the oldest continuous, one name, one city franchise in all of professional American sports. Philadelphia Phillies had participated in so many activities such as the Phillies baseball academy for boys and girls ages 6-14. Offers campers unforgettable baseball and softball experiences they will treasure for a lifetime. Many of us are familiar with a close relationship in which all parties’ benefits from relationship. A common example of mutualism relationship is between a dog and human. Dog supply protection and companionship and the human provide shelter and food for the dog. However nature is not the only place that mutualism relationship can occur. In facts they can occur in business, particularly in the form of sports sponsorship. The relationship between sponsors and sports events, sports organization is not different than the human and dog relationship they have. All relationships operate based on some essential characteristics that can be illustrated in the relationship management theory. “The most important supported elements of mutualism are trust commitment, satisfaction, and control relationship. “ As I have discuss in a previous paragraph, trust between......

Words: 1313 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Movie

...be a major topic in life, coming-of-age will be as well. For centuries, teens have been misunderstood by their families. They don't understand our thought process or why we even thought that way in the first place. That's when great writers and great producers came together to make films surrounding that. The coming-of-age films were most popular in the 80s--coincidentally while the fashion was also very out there and misunderstood. Personally, a movie that stood out the most in the Generation X era, was American Pie. Though it was very comedic, it's very relatable. The film focused on a group of teenage boys attempting to lose their innocence, but also shows the main character's parents constantly trying to "fix" him. As a viewer, you are immediately on the main character's side. Throughout the movie, his father is always trying to piece in on his life. The father feels that he knows exactly what the teen is experiencing because of him unexpectedly walking in on an unusual sexual act the teen was committing. Throughout the movie, he is giving him tips on sex and tries to "rectify" his "situation," when nothing the father is offering is necessary. The main character was trying to have actual sex and since he had a hard time doing so, at times, he'd use inanimate objects in replace of an actual human being. As teens "came of age," based off of previous experience, parents understood that that was the time that they should have "the talk." Realistically, that represented......

Words: 427 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Movie

...panicky side of the youngsters. The main characters Moon, Ah Lung, Ah Ping and Susan in the movie represent the problem youth in the society. The monologue of Moon at the very beginning unveils the failure of educational system in Hong Kong. As an exam-oriented society, elites with good academic results are highly praised but for those cannot obtain high marks are doomed to failure. Moon being the later one leaves school at the early stage and winds up being a gangster. However, students who go to school are not free from problems associated. Fruit Chan in the movies shows the evil side of students, there is a scene which a group of secondary students bully ah Lung in the public toilet in order to feel a sense of superiority. Also, Susan in the movie are unable to manage pressure and bad times in her life, she finally resorts suicide in order to escape from the reality. The leave of Moon’s parent, the unconsciousness of Susan’s teacher and a driver for her death, connotatively show the reaction of adult on the youth problem, they choose dodging rather than facing up to it. The marks-based society creates a new generation with high marks but low emotional quality, Fruit Chan has depicted the youth problem in an humanistic angle, awakened the society on the flaws about the current educational system and the lack of support for teens in the society. Another local problem shown in the movie is the grass-rooted problem in HK. In Made in Hong Kong, the replacement of glamorous......

Words: 1283 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Case Study Philadelphia Phillies

...Philadelphia Phillies: Managing product and branding in its Competitive Enviroment. Kristopher L. Tilley Empire State College Abstract Philadelphia Phillies was founded in 1883; the team is today the oldest, one-name and one city franchise in all professional sports. Al Reach, a professional baseball player becomes the first owner along with attorney John Rogers; the team’s name “Phillies” (due to its geographical roots in Philly) was Reach decision. In 1901, after losing several games and some of their best players, the team is sold for first time. The Phillies has the second-longest streak of consecutive losing seasons in American professional sports, sixteen straight from 1933 to 1948.The franchise has won two World Series championships (against Kansas City in 1980, Tampa Bay in 2008), and seven National League pennants. Phillies had own five different home stadiums. The most recent one have a fan-friendly design and is part of their complex marketing strategy to increase revenue and happy customers. In 2013 Forbes ranked the Phillies #41team in the World’s most valuable Sports Team. The franchise is estimated to be worth $893 million. But, how does a sport team keep increasing its revenue during bad seasons? The Phillies not only represent a changeable and unpredictable “product/brand” but also compete in a market with many other substitutes that may take away fun attention, support and possible sponsorships. In this case study, we would analyze the team’s......

Words: 2706 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

A Movie

...1300 layouts of films contain the cut of camera work, camera speed and space relation between characters and backgrounds; it gives me an insight of the process of animation making. Hence, I would like to comprehend more about the film produced by animation powerhouse-Studio Ghibli, especially the masterpiece-“Spirited Away”, which helps to promote Japanese animation to worldwide audience. “Spirited Away” is an animated film written and directed by the director of Studio Ghibli, Hayao Miyazaki (Cavallaro 2004) in 2001, which have won awards in a number of international film festivals, including Academy Award for Best Animated Feature Film and a Golden Bear at the Berlin International Festival (Reider 2005), and become the top-grossing movie in Japanese history. In the following, the film’s themes based on the plot, use of photography and camera angle and aesthetic symbols and motifs will be analyzed throughout the essay to understand the key of success of this fantasy adventure film, which was set in a traditional Japanese bathhouse. A. Overview of “Spirited Away” The story begins with Chihiro, a spoiled ten years old girl and her families accidentally enter a spirit world and she is warned by a young boy-Haku to leave here before sunset while wandering off into the park. However, it is too late that her parents have already transformed into pigs by the curse of without asking permission to eat......

Words: 2272 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Movie Char

...Movie Character Health Assessment Presentation Details: In this assignment, you will be creating a PowerPoint presentation based on the application of the functional health assessment of a movie character. To complete this assignment, do the following:Choose a movie from the following list and identify a character from the movie on whom you would like to do a health assessment. If you wish to use a character from a movie not included on the following list, get the approval of your instructor. 1. Away From Her 2. Lorenzo's Oil 3. Mask 4. My Sister's Keeper 5. Philadelphia 6. Rain Man 7. Steel Magnolias 8. Stepmom 9. The Elephant Man 10. The Mighty 11. The Tic Code Create a PowerPoint presentation of 10-12 slides using the template "Movie Character Presentation." 1. Provide an introduction and background overview of the movie character (client). 2. Assess the client using the "Functional Health Pattern Assessment." 3. Based on your "observations" and thoughts, document your assessment, providing examples from the movie. 4. Describe any observed or potential cultural, geographic, religious, ethnic, or spiritual considerations of this client. 5. Describe two normal health patterns of the client as well as two abnormal health patterns that you observe, and provide examples. 6. Develop an appropriate nursing diagnosis for the client based on your assessment. 7. Identify and describe three interventions for the client: health promotion, health prevention, and......

Words: 344 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ethics in the Movie Philadelphia

...ETHICS IN PHILADELPHIA MOVIE (1993) In this paper, we are dealing with matters of ethics and profession from a contemporary perspective. Diseases also come in when you look at matters of employment and what the disease can do to someone in a particular profession. From an ethical perspective, one needs to stay honest in what they do. In this case of ours, Andy Beckett is forced to conceal his secrets about his health status and sexual orientation for fear of rebuke and rejection. These actions proves that he is unethical in his profession. However, it can be rightfully argued that he was right to stay like that. This is a condition of ethical dilemma whereby if one decides to be very honest as they are required they will lose credibility in their profession and end up being hurt. If they hide their secrets, they are thus breaching the ethical codes. This film presents to the audience the issue of discrimination and ethics. Thus, this Philadelphia movie of 1993 is an opportunity for all to discuss ethics as well as HIV/AIDS in the current organizations. I think that any lifestyle can never render someone inefficient and ineffective in their jobs. Beckett actually would still deliver what was expected of him. He had been a gay for a very long time but still delivered the work properly. By the fact that he defended his bosses in very many cases successfully since he is a quality lawyer. In the law field, Beckett had been a very successfully competent......

Words: 1992 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Convention in Philadelphia

...Aidee Salgado American Government 6/29/2016 The Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia The three proposals that were debated at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia in 1787 were the Virginia and New Jersey Plan and the Connecticut Compromise. Legislatures of twelve states had selected seventy-four delegates, and fifty-five filled these seats. These delegates consisted of twenty-nine college graduates and the remaining twenty-six included notables such as George Washington and Benjamin Franklin. The goal of the the Philadelphia convention was to establish a new Union. The Virginia Plan was the first plan proposed at the Constitutional Convention. This plan was written by James Madison and was led by Governor Edmund Randolph and called for a strong central government. The plan consisted of the following: A two house legislature, with numerical representation, where popularly elected lower house elects the upper house. Broad, yet undefined legislative power, with absolute veto over laws passed by state legislatures with taxing power. Single executive elected by legislature for fixed term. National judiciary elected by the legislature. Council of Revision composed of the executive and judiciary to review laws passed by national legislature. The Virginia Plan generated a counter-proposal by William Paterson of New Jersey called the New Jersey Plan. The New Jersey Plan called for a modest change in the Articles of the Confederation, keep the state governments......

Words: 498 - Pages: 2

Of Mice and Men Loneliness Essay | 10*PAPILLON FARFALLA SETA RASO CRAVATTINO Uomo Donna Papion Rosso Blu Nero rosa | Realm Defense: Hero Legends TD APK