Premium Essay

Three Ethical Approaches Based on Virtue, Duty and Consequence

In: Business and Management

Submitted By THANHTRA
Words 2724
Pages 11
THREE ETHICAL APPROACHES BASED ON VIRTUE, DUTY AND CONSEQUENCE

Three ethical approaches have evolved as the focus of those who study moral philosophy: virtue ethics, duty ethics and consequential ethics. Virtue ethics, associating ethics with personal habits, is associated with Aristotle. Duty ethics is associated with religious beliefs, although Kant tried to create a system of duties independent of belief in God. Consequential ethics is associated with the quest for rationalism during the Enlightenment, and especially with the Utilitarians.

Virtue Ethics

Plato and especially later Aristotle described moral behavior as “what the moral or virtuous person does.” The virtuous person develops a sense of right and wrong. This idea endures. We look to people we think of as ethical to give us advice on an ethical issue because such people have a sense of right and wrong.

Aristotle tried to take the idea further, with less success. He thought that virtuous behavior meant people realizing their potential. He suggested that virtue was tied to moderation, a middle way between excess and deficiency. This idea is in practice not proven so helpful because where the midpoint is depends on where we put the extremes.[2] For example if an extreme drinker is someone who drinks six liters a day of vodka, then is three liters a day a moderate drinker?
Markets operate without depending on the virtue of the business people who trade in them. But in practice ethical behavior is admired. Political campaigners like to focus on the ethical shortcomings of business, while businesses poke fun at the ethical shortcomings of political leaders.

Business Example: A company has a certain DNA. If it has a permissive cultural code that that loses sight of who the customer is, it can lose the confidence of investors, workers and customers. Why should anyone invest in a fund or…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

The Three Strategic Approaches

...Week 2 Liesl Kern CSU-Global Campus Operations Management – OPS400 Paul Gioia 01/22/13 The Three Strategic Approaches The three strategic approaches to competitive advantage are differentiation, cost leadership, and response. All of these make a company competitive. Each company is different and chooses how they stay competitive. The three approaches come across all differently but each is an excellent outlet to stay competitive. Differentiation “Boston Market Corporation, headquartered in Golden, Colorado, has been giving time back to busy people since 1985”(“Boston Market”, 2013, para.1). Boston Market uses the differentiation approach when competing with their large market of competitors. The fast food market is large and it takes a strong company to be successful. Boston market thrives because they want you get fast service but quality food. “For the price of a sub sandwich and chips at other restaurants, Boston Market puts quality, flavor and wholesomeness on the center of the plate” (“Boston Market”,2013, Para.3). The atmosphere Boston Market creates is made to feel like someone is eating a good home cooked meal. Boston Market is a big go-to for the thanksgiving meals. Thanksgiving is the most sought after home cooked meal and people flock to Boston Market for it. “From a full, catered dinner where orders must be placed in advance to Heat & Serve and A La Carte options, the company that does Thanksgiving all-year-long has easy options for guests who’d......

Words: 624 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Evaluating Philosophical Approaches for Ethical Decision Making

...Running Head: EVALUATING PHILOSOPHICAL APPOACHES FOR ETHICAL DECISION MAKING Evaluating Philosophical Approaches for Ethical Decision Making Wayne Lambeth ACC 260 Donna Adams November 4, 2012 My classmates as well as I were required to evaluate philosophical methods that were used in Appendix B. Evaluating these methods would consist of whether or not a course of action that was taken made sense. I will discuss the philosophical approaches and determine whether or not that the course of action were ethical decisions and was it the best decision for the correct reasons in addition to determining the reasons are ethical. There are three key factors to evaluating philosophical approaches and they consist of consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics. Consequentialism is the theory of the value especially the moral value that would be judged by its consequences. Deontology is slightly different due to focusing on moral responsibility as well as the obligation of motivating the decisions that are made or the actions of the consequence. Virtue ethics has to deal with moral within a community as well as the integrity of an individual. The following scenarios has an ethics dilemma that be addressed. Scenario 1 The mayor is faced with building a new development that will create new jobs and economic stability to a community that really needs it and the dilemma is that it has to be built where the community center for the elderly is located and......

Words: 942 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Individual: Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making

...Week 4 Individual Paper Angela Tai ACC 260 May 10, 2013 Douglas Kildsig Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making Three philosophical approaches are taken when ethical decisions are being made. These approaches include consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics. Consequentialism focus on the consequences associated with the decision that was made. When an individual uses this approach, that individual should ensure that they are fully knowledgeable of the problem in order to make an ethical decision. It is crucial that the person has the ability to examine the affects both negative and positive that will occur because of the decision. When using the deontology approach, one focuses on if it was a right decision or not instead of focusing on the consequences. With this method, all of the questions about ethics and principles arise. The last method is called the virtue ethic approach. This method strives on keeping the morals and integrity of both the community and the individuals. By keeping the morals and integrity of a community when making decisions, it ensures that the decision will be made using the personality traits of the individual. These traits include honest, generosity, wisdom, intuition, and common sense. Is the course of action really the most ethical choice? Scenario One The mayor made the most ethical choice by refusing the proposal and scarifying the development of hundred jobs and million dollars to be able to......

Words: 1097 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making Matrix

...Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making Matrix Determine the ethical course of action for the following three scenarios from the perspective of each of the three philosophical approaches: consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics. Then, complete the matrix below by writing a few sentences stating the ethical course of action and the reasoning from that approach’s perspective. Clearly differentiate the reasons for each of the three approaches. Keep in mind that, although rationale might differ, the ethical course of action for a given scenario might be the same for each philosophical approach. Be sure to state the ethical course of action as well as the rationale behind it, according to the philosophical approach. Scenario 1 The mayor of a small seaside town faces a tough decision. A prominent developer has submitted a proposal to build a large mall and resort in the town. This development is estimated to bring $150 million in tourism each year and several hundred new jobs to the community, which badly needs the economic boost. The proposed location of the new development, however, is a site that now houses the only nursing home and senior citizens’ recreation center in the area. Both the nursing home and recreation center would have to be demolished, affecting 100 seniors and 30 employees. There is no other location in town where the new development can be built. How should the mayor decide: in favor of economic prosperity or in defense of his......

Words: 1008 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Approaches to Ethical Delimas

...Approaches to Ethical Dilemmas Evanya S. Perry 335 January 20th, 2014 Dr. Tami Frye Approaches to Ethical Dilemmas When trying to apply different approaches to ethical dilemmas there are several different steps that need to be taken. Understanding the case study, providing answers to difficult questions, determining an approach to take that would best suit the ethical dilemma, and identifying the ethical issues encountered along with providing an approach method will be the first few steps taken. These steps are important to recognize before proceeding in any way. In case number five we are introduced to a woman named Janet Lewis who is a registered nurse. The case study describes her as a motivated worker that has a child with special needs that she raises on her own. Other important information about Janet is the fact that she volunteers to pick up extra shifts to help her employer cover available hours. The case study describes the hours leading up to the situation that happens one day with Janet. On one particular day Janet had covered so many hours that she worked without getting any sleep and was exhausted. Later in her shift because of her exhaustion she misreads a label of medication and proceeds to give the wrong medication to the doctor to be administered. This mistake proves to be fatal and the patient dies. Janet tells the doctor about her mistake and is overheard by the patient’s family. An incident report is filed shortly after and...

Words: 1315 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Approaches to Ethical Dilemmas

...Approaches to Ethical Dilemmas Michelle Silvas BSHS/335 August 11, 2014 Alma Carpio Protecting a friend In the case study 18, protecting a Friend, it describes Dr. Adam Marshall, a well-known, much respected physician that works at Uptown General Hospital. He has done many things for the community, such as charities and missionary work. He has worked at the hospital for 20 years with a spotless record. He goes at least twice a year with a group of other physicians to Zambia to provide medical care and much needed medical supplies for the Zambian people. HIV is very prevalent in Zambia and most of the people there are infected. While in Zambia, Dr. Marshall decides to go sightseeing and while out he collapses due to dehydration and suffers a significant laceration on his arm. A woman comes to his aid and because Dr. Marshall was so worried about his injury, he fails to notice that this woman is HIV positive and has wounds on her arms that are oozing and she helps Dr. Marshall with his open wound. After returning to where his fellow physicians are, he decides to confide in his friend Dr. Singh, he tells him that he is afraid he may have been exposed to HIV because of the woman who help clean up his wound. Dr. Singh runs HIV testing on Dr. Marshall and it comes back positive. Dr. Marshall does not want Dr. Singh to share this information with anyone back at home because he is afraid of his reputation and since they are out of the country, they did not document......

Words: 1040 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Three Most Important Virtues

...The Three Most Important Virtues The most important virtues might be different from people to people because we are raised in different culture and family and are influenced a lot from the whole society. Some people might think show mercy is a good virtue, while some peope might feel that it’s ordinary and it cannot be called a “virtue”. The three most important virtues that I appreciate are honest, empathy and thinking in other people’s view. This article might only reflect my plain point of view, which is influenced mostly by Chinese culture. Honest, might be everyone’s number one valued virtue, is the hardest virtue that people can actually obey or accept it sometimes. There is an old saying goes in China, “Good advice is harsh to the ear”. This saying tell us that in ancient China, the king loves to hear good news, which is reflecting his good administration, and feels angry and ashamed when he hear brave officers report bad new or provide useful advice. This story is just like the Chinese version ofThe Emperor's New Clothes. Not everyone is brave enough to speak the truth. People choose to say the sweet words that makes other people glad, or at lease not angry. Mostly people prefer other people to speak frankly and sincerely. Take one thing happened when I was an undergraduate student for example. One of my roommate owed the other roommate few money, not a big amount of one, but she forgot to pay back. In the next period of time, there was a weird tension between...

Words: 1343 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Legal and Ethical Duties

...Week#7 MSAC 601 Legal and Ethical Duties of Care Due: Monday, April 20th, 2014 CPMR   Abstract This paper addresses the duty of care, duty of loyalty, and ethics of care issues that arise in the workplace. It outlines the nature and scope of care that employers are ethically obligated to give their employees. Characteristics of duty, and how it can be implemented are provided, along with how to deal with issues that arise.   Duty of care is the principle that directors and officers of a corporation have in making all decisions in their capacities as corporate fiduciaries, who must act in the same manner as a reasonably prudent person in their position would (Cornell, 2015). Duty of care is considered a business judgment rule which is met as long as the fiduciary executed a reasonably informed, rational judgment in good faith, that didn’t occur with a conflict of interest. A court needs to be able to agree with the business judgment or the plaintiff needs to be able to adequately prove that the standard was not met. Even if the plaintiff can show that the standard was not met, as long as the defendant fiduciary can prove that a fair process was used and a fair outcome resulted from the decision then they can still meet their duty of care. Duty of loyalty is the principle that directors and officers of a corporation take in making all decisions in their capacities as corporate fiduciaries and must act without personal economic conflict (Cornell, 2015). This......

Words: 1576 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Acc 260 Week 4 Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making

...Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making Get Tutorial by Clicking on the link below or Copy Paste Link in Your Browser http://hwguiders.com/downloads/acc-260-week-4-critiquing-philosophical-approaches-to-ethical-decision-making/ For More Courses and Exams use this form ( http://hwguiders.com/contact-us/ ) Feel Free to Search your Class through Our Product Categories or From Our Search Bar (http://hwguiders.com/ ) As a student we are required to evaluate the philosophical approaches for each scenario from Appendix B. Evaluating whether or not the reasoning for the course of action listed makes sense. While working on the evaluation of the philosophical approaches we will discuss if the course of action is the most ethical, the best reasons for making the choices, and the reasons for believing this alternative is ethical. Consequentialism is the intent to maximize the usefulness of a decision. For this the relevance of this act depends on its consequences. For this approach it is essential to have a good ethical decisions and perception of it. With this it is important for students to analyze a decision in how the harmful and/or the benefits. This many philosophers’ debate ht consequences should count Deontology is different because it focuses on the obligation or duty in motivating the decision or the actions of the consequences. This depends on the respect, rights, and fairness. This approach brings up issues related to duty, rights,......

Words: 6500 - Pages: 26

Premium Essay

Three Leadership Approaches

...Three Leadership Approaches Leadership approaches are behaviors are traits that leaders use. All leaders have something in common. What style of leadership is mostly effective depends on a particular situation. There are three kinds of leadership approaches. The trait approach is about identifying different personality traits and characteristics that are connected to successful leadership in so many different situations. This approach is based on belief that ability to lead was something that people were simply born with. Trait approach focuses on the personal attributes of leaders, such as physical, personal characteristics; competencies and values. This approach gives more credit to the qualities a person was born with rather than what they develop in a relationship with followers. This style is characteristic of ones who others see as “born leaders”. This theory believes that if you can identify people with right traits, you can identify leaders. Research was done, and it was found that traits can be learned as well. Traits are strongly associated with person’s perception of leadership. One doesn’t become a leader based on traits, but working relationship between leader and group members, and changing situations. Trait leadership approach works well for organizations with managers in leadership position that have specific traits. School is a good example of an organization in this position. Behavioral leadership approach focuses on the study of specific behavior of...

Words: 471 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ethical Approaches

...CASE 1 Incidental Finding Janet Lewis was a registered nurse at Hillside Community Hospital. She had been working numerous extra shifts to cover hours from vacant positions. On top of that, she was a single mother of a child with developmental disabilities, which frequently left her exhausted. Janet had no family to assist her, and she was new in town. Her work schedule did not allow time for socializing, so she had not yet established any close friends to help in times of need. Saturday afternoon, Janet was looking forward to going home after working 72 hours that week; she had just three more hours until she could go to bed. Next thing she knew, two of the second shift nurses called sick, and Janet agreed to cover for one of them. The shift was relatively quiet and uneventful until one of Janet's patients was found unresponsive in his room: a code blue at the end of her shift. Janet normally reacted very well in these situations, but she was barely coherent from lack of sleep. The patient had developed severe bradycardia. The physician attending the call requested atropine. Janet was having trouble focusing, so she asked the physician to clarify; again, atropine was requested. She grabbed a vial from the crash cart, inadvertently reading the label from the vial next to the one she grabbed: lidocaine. She drew up the ordered amount and handed it off to the doctor. The patient's condition worsened. The physician demanded more atropine. Janet was still holding the......

Words: 777 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Duty Based

...Duty-Based and Outcome-Based Ethics Ethical reasoning is the process by which an individual examines a situation according to his or her moral convictions or ethical standards. Fundamental ethical reasoning approaches include: Duty-based ethics and Outcome-based ethics. Duty-based ethics weigh the end of an action against the means used to attain the end. Duty based ethics are based upon an underlying concept of duty regardless of the consequences of action taken or forsworn in keeping with duty. It generally arises from religious belief of philosophy reasoning. Ethical standards based on duty may also be derived from philosophical principles such as the Kantian philosophy. A central postulate in kantian ethics is that it should evaluate their actions in light of the consequences that follows if everyone in society acted in the same way. In duty-based ethics the categorical imperative can be applied to any action when deciding whether an action is ethical. To determine whether an action is ethical one should consider what the effect would be if everyone similarly situated acted in the same way. Categorical imperative ethics maintains that a decision should be made without trying to predict whether an action will create the greatest balance of good over evil. Ethics in the categorical imperative sense is a function of moral rules and principles and does not involve any calculation of the consequences. Although a duty cannot exist without a corresponding right,......

Words: 474 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Duties & Consequences

...Duties and Consequences Tenesha Williams Capella University November, 2015 Author Note This paper was written for Philosophy - Ethics, taught by Instructor Mulberry. Duties and Consequences The motion picture Casablanca from 1942, is a romantic drama movie that portrays people and scenarios in the midst of World War II background in Casablanca, Morocco. The lead protagonist, an American expatriate Rick Blaine, owns a nightclub Café Americian in Casablanca and in the movie must choose between his love interest or helping his love interest’s husband, a renowned leader of Czech Resistance movement, in fighting against the Nazi occupation in the Czech Republic. While Rick appears politically neutral, he is shown in the movie as having helped Ethiopians fight against fascist Italia hence his neutrality is only a cover. The thematic concepts that run through the course of the movie show that Rick must choose between his own individual happiness of reuniting with his love interest who is now married to the Resistance leader, or helping her and her husband in their fight for a greater common good that is the liberation of Czech Republic from the horrors of the Nazi regime that is taking over Europe. This paper examines the ideas that intersect between the characters and scenarios from the motion picture Casablanca, and philosopher Immanuel Kant’s Categorical Imperative, as well as how the motion picture supports the claims of Immanuel Kant and of philosopher John Stuart......

Words: 1359 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Virtue Based Ethics

...Chapter 9 – Virtue theory o Virtues – trained behavioral dispositions that result in habitual acts of moral goodness. o Vice – The opposite of virtue, trained behavioral dispositions that result in habitual acts of moral wrongness. o Virtue theory: based on the central theme of which is that morality involves producing excellent persons, who act well out of spontaneous goodness and serve as examples o inspire others. o Virtue-based concept of theology – focuses on the goal of life: living well and achieving excellence. - Main virtues: wisdom, temperance, courage and justice → cardinal virtues. - Another one is: faith, hope, and charity → theological virtues The nature of virtue ethics - It is not only important to do the right thing, but also to have the proper dispositions, motivations, and emotions in being good and doing right. - Not only about actions, but also about emotions, character and moral habit. It calls us to aspire to be an ideal person. Two types: o Moral virtues: honesty, benevolence, no malevolence, fairness, kindness, conscientiousness, and gratitude. o Nonmoral virtues: courage, optimism, rationality, self-control, patience, endurance, industry, music talent, and cleanliness, wit. The ideal type: Aristotle’s Nicomachean ethics - Nicomachean ethics: he identified the virtues as simply those characteristics that enable individuals to live well in communities. To achieve a state of well being (happiness or human...

Words: 1022 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Is Ehics Based on a Virtue

...Is Ethics based on a virtue? La virtud es el resultado de convertir los valores en hábitos de comportamiento. Esta aseveración corresponde al concepto de ethos comúnmente aceptado en la lengua castellana: rasgos y modos de comportamiento que forman el carácter o identidad de la persona. Si la ética se desprende del ethos, entonces muy posiblemente corresponde a la virtud. Sin embargo, el término virtud en si mismo implica una connotación moralmente elevada e incorrompible. La ética no necesariamente es así. Se pudiera decir que el sentido de ética personal puede no corresponder a la conducta del individuo ya que puede quedarse en ideas e ideales abstractos en tanto que la virtud sólo es observable a partir del comportamiento de la persona. De aquí que, una persona “virtuosa” demostrará un comportamiento moralmente o aceptablemente “ético”. No es garantía que una persona con alto sentido ético lo transforme en acciones o modos de interacción con su entorno. La ética virtuosa es el movimiento donde el carácter manda a la ética en vez de los hechos. Se da de forma natural. Alguna de las teorías proponer pensar en la vida como un todo, es decir, no solo pensar en uno mismo, sino en las emociones, en el compromiso con los demás, en las responsabilidades sociales, etc… El valor de la vida humana se gana sabiendo nuestra propia naturaleza y todo lo que se necesita para actuar de acuerdo a nuestras responsabilidades y naturaleza. La felicidad la describen como una actividad......

Words: 400 - Pages: 2

Camera Scanner To Pdf - TapScanner v1.0.1116 modded apk | Hunter X Hunter 69 | Movies 4 Free - Free HD Movies v7.0.0 APK Cracked