Free Essay

Utopian Societies in America

In: Other Topics

Submitted By khelmers
Words 2320
Pages 10
Utopian Societies in America
Utopian societies while not abundant were far from rare in the nineteenth century. One such version of utopianism, Fourierism, attracted at some point numbers in the range of 100,000 members during the 1840’s alone. Nathaniel Hawthorne: A Letter from Brook Farm is just one of many primary documents preserving firsthand accounts of life in these communities. There are enough primary sources in enough detail such that Sterling F. Delano was able to create a secondary source, providing some evaluation and analysis in what has been referred to as a standard for a starting point when researching these societies in the book Brook Farm: The Dark Side of Utopia. Brook Farm was actually far from singular as a utopia experiment. In The Americanization of Utopia: Fourierism and the Dilemmma of Utopian Dissent in the United States an article by Carl J. Guarneri. Guarneri points out many such communities and experiments took place in the 1800’s. The Harmonys in Pennsylvania and New Harmony in Indianna, Onieda in New York, the list goes on although daily life Brook Farm, as was experienced by one of the community members, Nathanial Hawthorne, being the subject of the primary source of this paper. Brook Farm is seen as a trivial contribution by some writers, Guarneri’s article states the contrary that while Brook Farm is one of many experiments it was an important part of the utopian experiments of the time. Other secondary sources, reviews of Brook Farm: The Dark Side of Utopia from Leigh E. Schmidt, Alison Easton and Carl J. Guarneri also indicate that Brook Farm was more than just a minor contributor to the utopian experiments of the 1800’s.
The Brook Farm experiment was designed by George Ripley in effort to create utopian society or as otherwise put Heaven on earth. The site chosen may or may not have been influenced by it being a favorite vacation spot for the Ripley’s; regardless for the reasons used in choosing the location it was ultimately a poor choice for the success of the experiment. Enough primary sources from participants regarding daily live, management and daily operations allow for a more in-depth analysis of the situation by secondary sources. While the location of the farm seemed an idealistic location based on the vistas and seclusions and protection afforded from incidental passers due to the surrounding countryside and its distance from a main road it remained less than ideal; It was inconvenient for industrious endeavors, the soil was not even marginal for farming, in fact it was of a poor grade. The efforts of Ripley to address soil quality issues appear well documented. While farmers are listed in the manifest of onsite personnel it could be questioned as to Ripley’s qualifications or the presence and participation of qualified personnel to determine effective soil remediation even if the necessary technology did exist at the time. The poor quality of the soil was a contributing factor in the decline and failure of the experiment as it caused the participant to seek other industrious efforts to maintain the community. The residents at Brook Farm still managed to maintain a somewhat festive jovial atmosphere regardless of hardship. Although they still purchased milk from local sources while located on a dairy farm; even though their meals were scaled back during times of financial difficulty to include little to no meat, coffee and or tea they only balked mildly and still enjoyed simpler pleasures. The seemingly well documented pillow fight between Hawthorne and other residents supports their continued ability to find happiness in rough times. There were other key events that lead to the eventual failing of the farm. The community was striving to find means of employment for its members through industry that eventual failed, pewter ware, foot wear among others. These efforts failed partly due to remoteness of the site being ill suited for production efforts of this type and possibly also inadequate management. Mounting expenses and debt from failed efforts continued to grow. The accounting practices appear well documented, however well documented failures are not self correcting problems and did nothing to improve the finances of the community. There are also others events that contributed to the failure. An outbreak of smallpox in the community in 1845 followed by the fire that destroyed the nearly completed Phalanstery in 1846 were heavy blows to the community and are seen as some of the larger and last events leading to the failure of Brook Farm. The number of visitors in a year at times nearing 1000 must have been an additional burden on the farms inhabitants on top of what were already less than ideal conditions. Eventually even Nathaniel Hawthorne became dissatisfied with the community, suing for five hundred and twenty four dollars and five cents to recover his investment in the experiment. The farms eventual failure from poor management, un rectified poor soil conditions, failed industrious attempts, fire and plague left creditors out on a limb in their attempts to salvage and recover what they could of their investments.
The primary document Nathaniel Hawthorne, A Letter From Brook Farm is a wonderful document in that it provides a fairly well painted image of his experience at the farm from his arrival to the writing of the letter. It’s possible that the letter was written Sophia Peabody but that is not defined beyond uncertainty in the document as she is not named. The weather from his time of arrival was quite inclement and prevented the attendance to many of the outdoor labors until the arrival of more suitable and permitting weather. In the letter he more than alludes to hard work. Describing in detail the means of manual labor involved in his daily assignments. The loading of twenty to thirty cartloads at the time of writing with an estimated three hundred additional cartloads remaining. The manure is not specified as begin used in soil remediation however given knowledge of the poor soil conditions it is likely that it was used in that endeavor. Hawthorne also describes the labors of plowing and planting and providing for livestock through the cutting of hay for feed. Hawthorne’s remarks of many other tasks requiring a great amount of effort is certainly indicative of one involved in starting or running a farm however is somewhat less descriptive other information gleaned from the document. The others present on the farm are described in ways such that they are perceived as pleasant natured and having specific roles to fill within the community. Life outside of their labors is described as pleasant regardless of the long hours necessary to achieve their goals. Little details down to eating arrangements, dress for daily activities all the way down to the construction of his shoes are given in sufficient detail to allow one to envision. A particularly interesting detail that shows the technology of the time regarding a portrait sent to replace one that is considered outdated and to be discarded.
Primary and secondary source documents have their benefits when analyzing historical events. This primary document being a very subjective one provides us with some intimate details that may have gone unrecorded had they not been in this letter and other documents as a result of Brook Farm. The document paints a nice picture of community with beautiful views and somewhat secluded location regardless of the hard work discussed. It also gives us some insight to other aspects of conditions on the farm such as their clothing. From the description their clothing including jackets and boots were probably made on location. This comes from Hawthorne’s description of the thin frock sent by the recipient of his letter as being a wonderful item, enough so that it was complimented and alluded to that it was of such quality that it could be made part of their uniform for fairer weather. Duplication of articles of clothing in this way tends to indicate that it would be produced onsite with their own efforts. The description of his boots appear that they were also most probably made on the farm, two inches of leather sole and being unique enough to say that he would wear them on his next visit seems to support this idea. While Hawthornes document contains lots of detail it is narrow in scope and vision and lacks the analysis available from hindsight. The analysis primary documents as provided by secondary sources provide a much wider view and at times details otherwise missed by primary sources. In this case the details of the fire, smallpox, financial hardships had yet occurred when Hawthorne wrote the letter however the soil quality was most likely known at that time and was not included in the letter. The secondary sources give us this information as well as other. The financial disposition of the community, information about the health and well being of the residents, the smallpox outbreak, the scale of daily work including baking upwards of ninety pound of bread, the now over mentioned pillow fight among household members.
The limits between the primary source document and the secondary sources used are large to say the least. The primary document is such that it only covers four to six weeks of the authors experience on the farm at the beginning of residency in the community. The primary document also does not provide some of the other information that may have accounted for the rosy and almost overly optimistic viewpoint in the letter. The intended recipient and perhaps ulterior motives for such an optimistic writing. Certainly he was newly arrived however secondary documents show that Hawthorne was also an investor in the experiment, could these have been partially responsible for the outlook given? The secondary sources also have shortcomings. The title of the book Brook Farm: The Dark Side of Utopia alludes to perhaps something sinister or subversive however it too has shortcomings in that the analysis provided and information derived from that do not really turn up anything other than an unfortunate series of bad events combined with poor management. As the secondary sources are based on information from primary sources, in tis case most all of the primary sources used the analysis given by the book is still lacking in that there do not appear to be many negative reports from residents or other primary sources of information regarding Brook Farm. The really interesting result regarding the book as a secondary source is that while a large number of primary sources are available for use in creating this secondary source it appears limited in the information presentation. There is a great deal of minute detail such as the pillow fight between residents and of the appearance of only mild discomforts from financial setbacks large enough to trouble the community. There is a lack of a bigger picture of the experiment.
I won’t comment on readability as at times what I would find interesting enough to read need not be considered “a nice read” to be worth reading. I am not surprised to have learned something new and perhaps even different from my original ideas on the subject; to not have would have been a suprise. Admittedly, my ideas on utopian communities, experiments etc… were somewhat of a concoction built around the communes I had heard of growing up and the concept of creating a society that appeals to the originators coming from the saying, if you don’t like something do something else. Prior to this paper I had not applied all of the considerations I would apply to locating and building a town or farm and thus severely underestimated the scope and scale of those projects. Creating a town or neighborhood of any kind has enough challenges; designing and implementing utilities, building houses and buildings while allowing for growth. It also entails all of the support infrastructure required to provide for the inhabitants, provisions for employment, education, access to goods and services. Creating a society based around shared ideal views adds a whole new level of complexity to the task. The Woodlands Texas was where I lived for more than 20 years prior to moving to Georgia. The relevance of this is that The Woodlands was also an experiment, undertaken by George Mitchell to build a real community where there had been none. Not just a neighborhood or subdivision but a town complete with multiple levels of income, employment opportunities, education, churches, stores etc… Having watched the evolution of the town from almost the beginning gives me some insight to how badly I’ve misperceived utopian experiments. I had erroneously grouped them into a category somewhere near the “free love communes” and Woodstock and completely overlooked something I enjoy; the amount and detail of civil engineering and planning, successful or not that had taken place. Undertakings of that scale in the 1800s had to require massive planning, possibly beyond those required in planning The Woodlands when the differences in time and the amount of knowledge available to the involved parties are factored into the equation. Works Cited
Primary Document:
"Nathaniel Hawthorne, A Letter from Brook Farm (1841),” Stable URL: http://occawlonline.pearsoned.com/bookbind/pubbooks/divine5e/medialib/timeline/docs/sources/theme_primarysources_Reform_3.html, Date Accessed: February 21, 2013.
Book and Three Required Reviews:
Delano, Sterling F. Brook Farm: The Dark Side of Utopia. Cambridge, Mass: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2004.
Easton, Alison. 2005. Review of Brook Farm: The Dark Side of Utopia. Journal Of American Studies 39, no. 3 (2005): 551-552.
Guarneri, Carl J. Review of Brook Farm: The Dark Side of Utopia. American Historical Review 110, no. 2 (2005): 477-478.
Schmidt, Leigh E. Review of Brook Farm: The Dark Side of Utopia. Journal Of American History 92, no. 1 (2005): 213-214.
Articles:
Guarneri, Carl J. “The Americanization of Utopia: Fourierism and the Dilemma of Utopian Dissent in the United States.” Utopian Studies, Vol. 5 Issue 1 (1994), p72.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Divorce in America

...Destruction of the Family Throughout history, societies that valued traditional marriage and sexual abstinence were able to remain fundamentally strong and have flourished. Once a society decides to abandon these simple principles, destruction inevitably follows. J. Unwin (1934) wrote, “In human records, there is no instance of a society retaining its energy after a complete new generation has inherited a tradition which does not insist on prenuptial and postnuptial continence” (Unwin, 1934, p. 174). In today’s society, family and marriage are not defined by the traditional definition handed down through several millennia of history; rather the definition has been warped, and a new unstable version of the family has been accepted by our society. Traditional marriage is by its nature, the foundation of the family. The family is the building block of society, and marriage is the basis of the family. The devaluation of the conventional family, and more specifically, the destruction of traditional marriage by divorce, can have no other outcome but the destruction of our society. There are many reasons to evaluate why we have arrived at this state in our society: the growth of consumerism and commercialism, influence of Hollywood over our lives, the decline of religiosity in the United States, the decline of the social order and neighborhood relationships. All of these reasons are legitimate causes for the decay of our society. However, only one cause has wielded its......

Words: 3540 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

America: a Multinational Society

...June 2013 America: A Multinational Society The American author Ishmael Reed has written numerous novels, poems, and essays. In his essay, “America: A Multinational Society” Reed argues that America is viewed as a monocultural society, yet we cannot be monocultural because we are a nation of immigrants. Reed provides many arguments and examples from past and present-day America that prove America is a melting pot of cultures, and therefore is already a multinational society. Reed states that in any major city in America you can see evidence of this mixing of nationalities and cultures. For example, you can find Islamic mosques and hear airport commands in both English and Spanish. The mixing of nationalities and cultures is a growing movement that if or when it continues, will affect the majority of our country in just a few years. Already in Texas the largest minority, population is Mexican American. Reed goes on to talk about how, in Milwaukee, he heard a professor speak to a crowd about the African cultures’ influence in America, in an African language (instead of their native tongue of English). In this same city, another example of the mixing of cultures comes at a most unexpected place, the local McDonald’s. At this restaurant, the manager has hung paintings that depict African symbols and images. Even with all of this evidence of a mixing of cultures, Reed asserts that the “cultural Elect” of our country still holds on to the idea that America is a......

Words: 1189 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Epidemics in America

...Epidemics in America Since the proclamation by John Winthrop, the first governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, that America should view herself as a "city upon a hill", Americans have strived to create a utopian society (Brinkley, 40). Winthrop viewed America as God's country, a place where the troubles of Europe and the rest of the world would not be repeated. This ideal is still valued by American society, yet it has prevented Americans from accepting the notion that an epidemic could strike their own country. Epidemics in the Modern World by Joann P. Krieg examines American society's reaction to the outbreak of epidemics in this country. Krieg threads the theme of American Romanticism throughout her work, as she explores the reactions of politicians, literary figures, and society in general to the outbreak of disease. Krieg also gives some biological information on the diseases that have haunted the American utopia. While this potpourri of information creates a valuable source for one studying the social effects of disease, its extensive discussion on literary topics becomes long-winded and irrelevant. Krieg explores the outbreak of five American epidemics: smallpox, cholera, yellow fever, TB, and AIDS. While reactions to each were different, Krieg shows that American Romanticism, the notion that "it couldn't happen to us", was prevalent in each of society's reactions to these epidemics. American Romanticism limited the swiftness to which the government, as well...

Words: 830 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Utopian and Cyberpunk Societies

...America: On the Path to Utopia or Cyberpunk? As I sat and listened to multiple political science essays in the last few weeks of my Honors Colloquium class, some essential concepts really stuck out to me and resonated in my mind. The idea of a utopian society that was brought forth in class got me thinking of how our world would be like today if we adopted some utopian methods of living. In America we are very blessed to live in the land of opportunity yet we are always focused on what is the next and best opportunity for us to seize. The American people have grown accustomed to a fast paced living, never stopping to look around at the beauty of nature that surrounds them or share a smile with a stranger. We are always on to the next best thing and we forget to appreciate the aspects of human life that really matter. If we as a people decided to change our patterns of everyday living we could make America more than the land of the free and opportunity. If we connected with a utopian lifestyle, we might find ourselves actually enjoying life or maybe we will discover utopia isn’t the right choice for the direction of our country’s future. Either way in this paper, I am going to introduce the key elements of a utopian society and also another society that I think represents where America is heading today and into the future. A utopia is a community or society possessing highly desirable or perfect qualities. Utopia can be seen as an imaginary society of sorts because it......

Words: 1003 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Epidemics in America

...Epidemics in America Since the proclamation by John Winthrop, the first governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, that America should view herself as a "city upon a hill", Americans have strived to create a utopian society (Brinkley, 40). Winthrop viewed America as God's country, a place where the troubles of Europe and the rest of the world would not be repeated. This ideal is still valued by American society, yet it has prevented Americans from accepting the notion that an epidemic could strike their own country. Epidemics in the Modern World by Joann P. Krieg examines American society's reaction to the outbreak of epidemics in this country. Krieg threads the theme of American Romanticism throughout her work, as she explores the reactions of politicians, literary figures, and society in general to the outbreak of disease. Krieg also gives some biological information on the diseases that have haunted the American utopia. While this potpourri of information creates a valuable source for one studying the social effects of disease, its extensive discussion on literary topics becomes long-winded and irrelevant. Krieg explores the outbreak of five American epidemics: smallpox, cholera, yellow fever, TB, and AIDS. While reactions to each were different, Krieg shows that American Romanticism, the notion that "it couldn't happen to us", was prevalent in each of society's reactions to these epidemics. American Romanticism limited the swiftness to which the government, as......

Words: 830 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

My Utopian Society

...My Utopian Society In my Utopian Society there would be many differences from the society we live in today. All people would have equal opportunities when it comes to work and relationships. There would be no judging a person because they are of a different religion, race or sex. Unlike the society we currently live in there would be no wage difference because the person happened to be a female. Wages would be based on the person’s ability and education level. I would encourage all businesses to be family oriented giving their employees ample time to spend with the loved ones by having a four-day workweek and a living wage that would support this. If employees are happy with their place of employment they will certainly be more productive. There would be no racism or bullying, people would be free to do as they see fit for themselves and their family as long as they stay within the boundaries of the law. Also, in order to teach young people the importance of working and supporting family they would start doing community service projects in high school so they can learn the value of their education and it would also help to keep young people out of trouble. The economic structure would be based mostly on natural resources and balancing between the rich and the poor. There wouldn’t be low tax for the wealthy and high tax for the middle class and CEO’s would not be making millions of dollars a year while the single parent is making minimum wage and living in a shelter......

Words: 664 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Utopian World Versus Real World

...D'Andre Mickens Mr. Gamwell E Block 7 April 2014 Imperfect Perfect World Some people believe that a utopian world may be better than a less perfect world, yet the imperfections of a utopian society realistically outweighs its ultimate goal of perfection. Perfection is defined as the condition, state, or quality of being free or as free as possible from all flaws or defects. When it comes down to it, a utopian society has many rules and regulations. Yet, if a so called perfect society is so perfect, then there should be no need for any rules or regulations. However, a Utopia's goal of perfection in itself is a contradiction, because of its goal of being "more perfect and less free" (Huxley 1). As a matter of fact a utopian society would be like a heaven on earth. At the same time there is not really a unified view of utopia. All views of utopia involves change which affects human systems and institutions. How can a society aim to be perfect when by definition freedom is needed in order to be perfect. In fact that's something people still find hard to understand and today's society. Have you ever ask yourself what is freedom,it's the power or right to act, speak, or think as one wants without hindrance or restraint. Foremost this is something they didn't have at the time of the utopian society. Well by definition a utopia is a perfect world where everything is prefect and equal but you have no freedom to do what you want; Basically your life is scripted like a book.......

Words: 443 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Farming Becoming Fundamental to Ancient Societies in Central America

...As farming became fundamental to ancient societies in Central America, it had a drastic impact on the population of these societies. Identify what you believe to be the three most important effects of farming, and explain your choices thoroughly. The discovery of farming by the people of the ancient societies of Central America was undoubtedly what ensured their survival. There are many ways that farming impacted these peoples, but three affects that are arguably (do not use I or me in your writing) the most prolific were the ability to produce more food in smaller areas, population growth, and the development of civilized societies (Faragher, Buhle, Czitrom, & Armitage, 2009). Farming in Central America was a process that was developed over thousands of years, with a certain amount of creativity and ingenuity. The people of this land discovered that by gathering and replanting seeds from wild food sources, they could control the growth of the food, produce larger quantities, and condense it into a smaller space. According to Faragher and associates (2009), “…a foraging society might require 100 square miles to support 100 people, a farming society required only a single square mile.” (p. 8). This led to a great increase in food supply with a reduction in the distance to travel to collect it. This allowed people to become more settled in one area and enabled them to have larger families. As farming developed, the need for more people to work in the fields as well as the......

Words: 609 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Censorship in America

...Censorship in America Welcome to America. The land of the free and the home of those all too willing to use that right to its fullest extent. The first nation truly founded on the right to speak one’s mind without consequence, America is now the most prosperous nation in the world, largely due to that very fact. We as Americans are blessed to live in a nation that is thriving both politically and socially, both as innovator and steady power, both as a community and as a collection of individuals. The marks of American society have spread far beyond the nation’s borders, with everything from the Big Mac to Steven Spielberg movies to democracy itself making it’s impact felt on this modern world. The name America has become synonymous with freedom, and through this freedom, great wealth, power, and success. And yet history has shown, through the example of democracies like Athens and Rome, that even the greatest of civilizations eventually swerve off course. After reading Patrick Garry’s “An American Paradox: Censorship in a Nation of Free Speech”, Marjorie Heins’ “Not In Front Of The Children”, and various statements from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), I have come to believe that the unstoppable juggernaut that is America may too be in danger of losing its way. The principles of freedom and human rights that this country was founded and subsequently prospered on are often quickly abandoned in the effort to protect the general public from anything deemed even slightly...

Words: 2328 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

19th Century America

...| Unit 3 Research Paper | | Mid nineteenth century America was marked by a period of social reforms. The northern economy began to turn toward industrialization and the southern economy still grew cotton as a major cash crop and the boundaries were expanding more westward. During this time people began to question some the ways their society had accepted. Many wanted to change their political views or change certain things due to their religion. Many people blamed alcohol for the way things were so they tried the temperance movement. Education became an important issue to the colonies. So they set up private schools, had high schools, provided more teachers for higher education. Abolition of slavery was a huge topic among these times. Many people, slave owners and non slave owner spoke against slavery. This was a huge and active time for the Underground Railroad. An underground route that helped free slave from captivity ran by an escaped slaved called Harriet Tubman. One of the most significant reforms was for women’s rights. I feel this had the biggest effect of the times. They fought for economic and social equality. This became very significant because now women had the right to help make choices which is had a huge effect for today. There were also many people that left and reformed to create utopian communities. One of these communities was Brook Farm. Brook Farm was based on the principles of transcendentalism. Organized and reformed by......

Words: 412 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Is America a Just Society

...H2-41 Daniel Shteinbuk Hw#25 4/20/15 1) Kublai Khan- Genghuz Khan’s grandson. Completed the conquer of China at 1279. From his capital at Cambulac, he ruled all of China as well as Korea, TIbet and Vietnam. Marco Polo- Italian merchant. In 1271 left Venice with father and uncle. In Chinna spent 17 years working. Wrote about China and how they are. Zheng He- commanded the first of seven expeditions. The goal was to promote trade and collect tribute from lesser powers in western seas. In 1433 he died. Stopped oversea exploration. 2) Since once Mongols conquests a land they still allowed some freedom and trade. This encouraged trade between the captured cities, Mongol and Europe. 3)  Moved his capital from Mongolia to N. China (modern Beijing) "Adopted China's administrative system, adapted to urban life, and spared China from devastation if they accepted his rule." Encouraged commerce, promoted paper money, expanded highways, and fostered merchant corporations. Extended Grand Canal from Yellow River north to his capital. (transport of grain and goods) 4) The Ming Emperors tried to restore Chinese culture by restoring the Civil Service System, which was ultimately the key to success. After that, Ming China saw a revival of arts and literature. 5) The purpose of the overseas expeditions was to promote trade and collect tributes from the lesser powers in the western seas. 6) The differences were that in Europe the richer cities were......

Words: 287 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Influences of Asia, Africa and the Americas Toward Contemporary Society

...Human World Views The Influences of Asia, Africa and the Americas toward Contemporary Society September 13, 2015 The progression of morality as it relates to the influence of family, religion and society varies between Asia, Africa, and the Americas. Our contemporary society has been influenced tremendously in many different areas by these different societies. Social order in Asia was established by Hammurabi’s Code of Laws. Hammurabi himself was an Amorite king of Babylon, he set these laws to place order in Babylon. Hammurabi’s lex talionus explains that the punishment of a crime should be equal to what crime has been done, these laws are described as “an eye for an eye” and “a tooth for a tooth” (Levack, B., Muir, E., & Veldman, M. (2004).). Hammurabi’s laws were set up for various issues including civil and criminal issues. Though due to one’s social status, laws for free people and laws for slaves were different, but they still held on to the same concept. Hammurabi code of laws helped to mostly shape our justice system. His laws were clear to understand the offenses being committed and consequences that were to be issued. This is present in our society because when one commits a crime or murder they suffer from the consequences in the jail and prison systems. Most of the time when a murder is committed the initial punishment is life in prison or retaliated with death by lethal injection, an eye for an eye. Our current law system is heavily influenced by......

Words: 809 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

History of America

... Name Institution Course Tutor Date HISTORY OF THE UNITED STATES Introduction The current America we know today is not comparable to the America which existed after the civil war. Great things such as urbanization, equal rights for citizens and the two major wars have made us understand the current United States. Since the time United States ended slavery, a lot of great things have happened. Some of the major ones being the period of reconstruction, Civil Rights Movement, the great depression and the World wars I and II. The aim of this paper is to compare the views of America a Narrative History 9th edition by George Brown Tindall and those of America Compared 2nd edition by Carl J. Guarneri. According to the two authors the history of United States since 1965 somehow differs. According to (Tindall, George Brown, and David, 196), the period of reconstruction, lasting from 1865 to 1876 was a period when the nation tried to restructure itself and incorporate the southern states which became part of the union. The freed men from the South had found themselves with no system to control them in their lives. So they had to look for a way to incorporate them in a still society that was biased against them. The reconstruction dealt with the transformation of southern states. During this period, a little social or political agreement was available on issues such as who was supposed to vote and how the southern states were going to rebuild themselves after......

Words: 2069 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Society

...MY IDEAL SOCIETY Free will is a property of human nature that depends solely on the individual. Every individual in a free society has the ability to make any decision that impacts his or her own life. This means that any one person can use their own free will to alter or hamper the ideals possessed by another individual within the society. This notion goes against the grains of the idea of an ideal society. An ideal society would have to provide the ideal conditions for all those who lived within it. The principles and standards of the inhabitants within the society would determine these ideal conditions. If an individual within this model society could alter the life of another individual within the society, the ideals of the second individual may be broken; this consequently undermines and destroys the concept of an absolute ideal society. Thomas More’s Utopia carries the premise that everyone within the utopian society does what is necessary for the good of the society, and that one’s free will would consist of only what is beneficial to the culture. This, in itself, is limiting free will by excluding the possibility of freely doing what is not beneficial to the culture. More said, the citizens, “(do) not waste their time in idleness or self-indulgence,” but who’s to say that they cannot? Absolute free will gives each citizen the ability to do whatever they feel inclined to do, even perhaps, idle or self-indulge. In Dr. King’s “I Have a Dream” speech, the idea of free......

Words: 1238 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Utopian Society

...Running head: GENETIC ENGINEERING Building a Utopian Society Society, Ethics and Technology HUMN432 ACC_U January 20, 2012 How does Genetic Engineering affect society? This is a hard question, and I’m not sure that there is any one correct answer. The selection of individual traits and the enhancements in embryos has raised several moral issues that involve both individuals and society as a whole. The first thing to consider is that when selecting a particular trait does it actually pose any health issues that may not have been that may not have been of concern before? There isn’t any concrete data that could be utilized as an acceptable form of preclinical stats for human studies. Human data may present significant practical and ethical problems. Since the safety of these procedures is fairly new and is currently under investigation, there are no long-term clinical and accurate numbers of research subjects. Even with all these unanswered questions, there are still questions regarding the safety concern involving the results that the majority of genes may have multiple effects. For example, “In the late 1990s, scientists discovered a gene that is linked to memory.” (Tang et al., 1999). “Modifying this gene in mice greatly improved learning and memory, but it also caused increased sensitivity to pain.”(Wei et al., 2001) By altering genes we can’t assume that it will only affect one function, when in actuality it may turn out to disrupt other functions. ......

Words: 755 - Pages: 4

Strategy | The Girl in the Spiders Web 2018 WEB-DL x264-FGT | Advance (68)