Premium Essay

Walnut Venture Asociates Deal Terms

In: Business and Management

Submitted By lalomon
Words 5092
Pages 21
Harvard Business School

Rev. November 19, 1998

Walnut Venture Associates (D): RBS Deal Terms
It was Friday, June 5, 1998, and Bob O’Connor was headed home for the weekend. He knew it would be a busy one, for he had many decisions to make. He had been trying to raise capital for his Company – the RBS Group, a software firm – for almost a year. He felt like he was finally nearing the end of this process, but now more issues had arisen. First, his prospective investors wanted to increase the amount of their investment. While he would be happy to have the extra money, he felt that the valuation on RBS was already lower than he had hoped, and he was reluctant to take more money at this price. Second, he had received a draft term sheet the day before. He’d only had a few minutes to scan it, but it seemed a long way from the simple deal they’d discussed weeks before. O’Connor knew he would be spending a lot of time with this document over the coming weekend.

Wagner and other “angels” from the Walnut group had successfully gotten over several of the issues that had arisen during their due diligence process. (See Walnut Ventures Associates (A), (B) and (C) Nos.899-062, 063 and 064) Wagner described those issues and the due diligence process: The customer feedback was all quite good. O’Connor was a great salesman. The issue was: Is he a one man band? And we decided – yes, he was a one man band, but more by necessity than by choice. After watching him in action with his organization, we were comfortable that he could grow the organization and remain an effective leader. On the market size issue, we fundamentally decided that it was not a market with “home run” potential, but that – at the right valuation – we could still make an investment that offered attractive returns. By late January, Wagner felt that he had a “soft” commitment from the…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Walnut Ventures a group to not only participate in larger deals but also to diversify risk. They invest in exchange for ownership equity or convertible debt. Angels are interested in start-ups in rapidly developing markets (or later stages if they have a proven product) where they can influence the strategy and the management team formation. An angel is financially incentivized (i.e. get more bang for the buck) for getting in deals early. Entrepreneurs seek financing from an angel for their added value to a company and their unique characteristics that are not found with VCs. Typically, VC funds are not as prevalent as angel funds since angels are more geographically dispersed and have a riskier appetite although their funding volumes are much smaller Others reasons include more informal investment criteria and more flexible business arrangements as compared to VCs. Particularly around investing in deals less than $1MM (“capital chasm”) since VCs weren’t available to fund in this category and funded >$1MM. Angels are typically affluent individuals that have made it big as a direct result of prior experience in the industry so their vast knowledge and industry experience is of tremendous value to startups. Some angels are more socially minded rather than financially motivated which becomes another reason for entrepreneurs to seek financing from them. Walnut was impressed with the CEO Bob O’Connor and his business focus. Also, Walnut was happy with the fact that the company......

Words: 1534 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Term Paper of Venture Capital

...Strictly private and confidential Not to be disclosed or distributed to third parties Draft ● Indicative Term Sheet [For use on Series A round] We are pleased to present our proposal for an investment in ● (the "Company"). Investment 1 You have told us that the proposed business plan calls for an equity injection of £● . Of this amount, funds managed by us (the "Funds") will provide £● alongside investment by other venture capital funds or financial institutions (together the "Investors"). We will act as lead equity investor. 2 The investment will be at a fully diluted pre-money valuation of £● , including employee share options (both granted or committed) equal to ●% of the fully diluted equity. The investment will represent a ●% shareholding for the Investors on a fully diluted basis, following an expansion of the share option pool as detailed in paragraph 2.4. The current capitalisation of the Company is set out in Part I of Appendix 1 and the capitalisation of the Company after this proposed funding is set out in Part 2 of Appendix 1. 3 The investment will be made in the form of convertible participating [redeemable] preferred shares ("Preferred Shares") at a price of £● per Preferred Share (the "Original Issue Price") the terms of which are set out in Appendix 2. 4 [The investment will be made in full at completion.]/ [The investment will be staged with ●% being invested at completion (the "First Tranche") and ●%......

Words: 4236 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Walnut Venture Associates

...Stephen Choi MF602 March 12, 2013 Walnut Venture Associates (A): RBS Group Investment Memorandum The RBS Group’s business seems promising and I suggest investing $1 million in the business, exiting in three years, that is, at the end of fiscal year 2000-2001. Milestones While the business seems quite promising, there are certain milestones RBS will need to achieve in the following three years. First, within the next month RBS will have to hire a vice president who will focus on sales since its second phase will focus on increasing sales to secure market share. While the current executives of RBS have done a great job, they will need additional expertise since the sales role will switch over to newly hired sales personnel of their regional offices. Also, RBS will need to find another $1million for its next round. Since Walnut Venture Associates can only raise $1million, it is imperative that RBS find another source of funding to power through its second phase of business. Considering the prospect of RBS and its well-established relationship with big technology firms, this should not be too much of a problem. Next, RBS will have to enter the third phase of expanding its business in foreign countries should begin in the beginning of fiscal year 2000-2001. Two years after phase two, its revenue flow is projected to become more stable and cash flow turns to profit. Therefore, this seems to be the right time to enter phase three and boost up its value one last......

Words: 847 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Deal

...Leon Ball Creative Writing Final The Deal The sound of shoes walking on the tile floor was echoing throughout the entire mall. The heels clicking, sneakers were squeaking, and the flip flops smacking the floor as the people of the Colorado Springs mall, the south end location, were walking around with their family and friends trying to enjoy the day. Sarah Tolsen was spending the day at the mall with her friends trying to just enjoy the day. Sarah is new to this town and she has been trying to fit in with a clique of girls at her school. The girls that Sarah was trying to fit into were plotting on how they could initiate her into their little group. They all finally decided that they were going to make her steal something to prove she belonged in their group. Once Sarah heard what she had to do she hesitated at first and knew that these girls wouldn't truly be her friends if they didn't care if she got in trouble or not. She decided that if she had to spend another four years in her high school that she was going to need friends, even if they weren't really her friends for life. Sarah took a deep breath and started to walk towards the entrance of a store that sold accessories for young women. There were handbags of all colors and shapes, hair clips with feathers attached, and a wall with nothing but jewelry that glistened under the lights in the store. Sarah tried not to draw attention to herself as she scoped out the store and determine what would be the easiest......

Words: 1022 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

What Was the Short Term Significance of the New Deal?

...What was the short term significance of the New Deal? To discuss the short term significance of the New Deal, it is imperative to define significance. Significance is defined by the number of people’s lives affected by an event; therefore the most significant of the short term effects of the New Deal was FDR’s implementation of radical legislative reforms. It led to a number of positive economic and social changes in a very short space of time, which contrasted greatly with the inaction of the previous Hoover regime. This opinion is supported by well-known New Deal historian Anthony Badger, who stated that "When Roosevelt took power on March 4, 1933; many influential Americans doubted the capacity of a democratic government to act decisively enough to save the country".The creation of public work schemes and relief programmes provided Americans with improved social stability giving them the confidence to support their government’s initiatives, thus enabling Roosevelt to restore elements of the pre-depression economy. Agriculture was also supported to create more jobs and allow business to grow again as opposed to declining as it had during the depression. These changes were all reinforced by the modernisation policies brought in by Roosevelt in the ‘100 days’. Page 1 Word Count: 291 Page 1 Word Count: 291 This cartoon was published in 1933 by the Pittsburgh Press by Harold Talburt. The use of this cartoon of Uncle Sam ‘holding all the Aces’ shows how the new policies......

Words: 2449 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Walnut Venture Associates Case Study

...Walnut Venture Associates are a group of angel investors. In 1997 the club had around a dozen individual investors, forming an “angel group”. Their primary targets are investments ranging from $250,000 to $1,000,000. This is due to the gap of capital funds initiated by the VC’s from not considering investments bellow $1 million. Also, angel investors can acquire significant equity at low cost, and help the growth of the company with their knowledge and expertise. By selecting only the most exceptional people and ideas, investments in startups can lead to massive returns on relatively small investments. As unexperienced entrepreneurs, they are a key resource to have in order to achieve quick growth, and secure the company’s early stages. RBS began product development in 1992, and first launched to the software industry in 1994. By the end of 1997, their annual revenue rate was close to $5 million. RBS now seeks a 2 million dollar investment, to be used for sales expansion, global marketing, and product development. So why would Walnut even consider investing if the company is past startup status? Since their primal motive is to maximize earnings, they may allow going over their common investment range if the opportunity seems truly worth it. RBS does seem to have the essentials to a great company with a strong management team, a proven product, and a solid execution of their plans. The market they are in, the software industry, is growing at 5 times the rate of the rest......

Words: 650 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Walnut Venture Associates Questions

...Walnut Venture Associates: Case Questions (HAND-IN) (1)Angel investors are affluent individuals who provide capital(money) for a business start-up. Angel investors usually receive convertible debt or ownership equity in return for their investment. Angel investors are different from venture capitalists since angels typically invest their own funds meanwhile venture capitalists manage pooled money of others in a professionally-managed fund. There are 2 forces exacerbating the trend towards the prominence of angel investing which include the fact that a generation of entreprenuers had “cashed out” and were looking to utilize their wealth and expertise by investing in start-ups, and that venture capitalists usually deployed capital in larger amounts that $1 million or below. An entrepreneur would seek financing from an Angel because Angels not only have the money to help finance the company, but they also have knowledge and experience that is very helpful to start-ups. The experience and track record of Angels (who usually have started their own company, served as a CEO, etc) is an asset that can’t be matched by a venture capitalist. Part of the reason of this again is because the Angel investor is investing his or her own money, something that will truly incentivize the Angel do to everything in his or her power to make the company succeed. 1) What is your first impression about the RBS opportunity based on the business plan? My first impression about the RBS......

Words: 482 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Case Write-Up for Walnut Venture Associates (a)

...Angel investors are wealthy individuals who usually have an entrepreneurial background of their own. These individuals look for an outlet to share, recycle and increase their wealth and expertise by investing in start-ups. The reasons why they invest in start-ups vary. One of these is to put their wealth and experience to use, the other is to fill the void created by VC’s in the investment space of $1million or less. For entrepreneurs Angel investment is an attractive way to raise equity capital. Angels will provide capital up to a couple of million dollars making it an attractive option for a second round financing run where friends and family would probably fall short and the company is not yet attractive for VC’s. For a Walnut investor there are a several issues that raise questions that must be answered. Some of these questions are about RBS’s market penetration and growth projections. Why will the customer choose to switch to RBS, and how easy is it? The answer to this question would reveal the markets resistance to RBS’s penetration. Is RBS adding real value to the customers that switch? Based on the answers to these questions is the 100% annual sales growth realistic? Is opening local field offices really a good strategy? Can new field offices duplicate the success of the California office which had access to a huge software company market? We can also question assumptions about the competition. What is the barrier of entry for the competition? Does...

Words: 305 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Walnut Venture

...potential investors willing to offer a seed investment. Having just received a term sheet from Waltham Partners, a well-known East Coast venture capital firm, Aravind and Kartik were now forced to weigh their options and determine which of the four potential investors currently interested in their venture would be most appropriate for NatuRi’s future growth. Their funding decision for this stage would also impact options for later rounds of funding. The duo had to decide on NatuRi’s valuation and how much equity they would relinquish in exchange for the capital they needed. Waltham Partners had given Aravind and Kartik 24 hours to accept or reject their offer. They needed to make a decision quickly. Background Having met in 1988 as undergraduates at India’s Birla Institute of Technology in Pilani, Rajasthan, Aravind, and Kartik became fast friends. Aravind hailed from Hyderabad; Kartik from Chennai. Aravind and his parents—both scientists in Hyderabad—moved to the United States in the mid-1990s and settled in California. Aravind received a master’s degree in Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering from Boston University in 1996. He subsequently worked as a senior product manager at i2 Technologies, a supply chain company based in Dallas, TX. He kept in touch with Kartik, who had also moved to the U.S. and earned an MBA from Yale University in 1998. After business school, Kartik worked in the venture capital (VC) arena and as a consultant to early-stage biotech......

Words: 8733 - Pages: 35

Premium Essay


...Harvard Business School 9-899-062 Rev. December 7, 1998 Walnut Venture Associates (A): RBS Group Investment Memorandum Ralph Wagner pulled his file on the RBS Group, a young company that developed and sold accounting software specifically targeted to software companies. Wagner was a private investor—an “angel”—and a member of an informal group of other investors known as Walnut Venture Associates. (See Exhibit 1 for background information on Walnut) RBS was seeking to raise $2 million in equity capital to fund its growth. Wagner had agreed to take the lead role in evaluating RBS as an investment opportunity for Walnut. While Wagner would spearhead the process, each individual would make his own decision about whether to invest in the company. It was December 26, 1997 and Bob O’Connor, RBS’s founder and CEO, had presented to the Walnut group one week ago. The group had been impressed with O’Connor, with RBS’s business focus, and with the fact that the company had a product, sales and even earnings. Based on this positive first impression, the group had decided to take the next step and begin a more in-depth investigation of the company and its prospects. Half a dozen or so “Walnuters” had indicated an interest in possibly investing, and it was up to Wagner to come up with a due diligence agenda for these individuals. He pulled out RBS’s plan (See Exhibit 2) and began to sort through the issues the group should investigate during this phase, as well as an...

Words: 11914 - Pages: 48

Premium Essay


...Caso Walnut Venture Profesor : Claudio Dufeu A. Preguntas para el análisis del negocio. 1) ¿Por qué un emprendedor debiera buscar financiamiento de un inversionista ángel? RBS pasó la etapa de I+D, su software SOFTRAX funciona y es recomendado por sus clientes actuales, por tanto se encuentra en una etapa de crecimiento, para lo cual requiere financiamiento. En este caso, más que un inversionista ángel se trata de una red de inversionistas ángeles, Walnut, grupo de emprendedores norteamericanos con experiencia en todos los estamentos de una empresa, muchos de ellos con éxito probado en la industria de la tecnología – software, lo que sin duda abre oportunidades de colaboración conjunta para empresas como RBS, aprovechando el expertise y las redes podría traer una expansión de la mano de un grupo como Walnut. Las principales ventajas de trabajar con una red de inversionista como este caso son: ▪ Inversión fragmentada: hay 3 grupos de inversionistas (Walnut, EVS, Mid-Atlantic) y además dentro de Walnut, conviven más de 10 inversionistas, por lo tanto el poder efectivo de negociación es menor que cuando se trata de un solo inversionista. ▪ Redes profesionales, lo que abre oportunidades de colaboración con todos sus miembros, aprovechando su expertise y contactos en la industria del software. ▪ Walnut cree en RBS y le atrae la oportunidad de inversión, de hecho ellos mismos se ponen la meta de atraer los US$ 2......

Words: 2641 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Venture Capital

...PRIMER ON VENTURE CAPITAL IN MAINE . Charles J. Spies III Chief Executive Officer Timothy P. Agnew Principal Author The Finance Authority of Maine and Masthead Venture Partners would like to acknowledge and thank Governor John E. Baldacci, former Governor Angus S. King, Jr. and the Maine Legislature, who have consistently supported the efforts of Maine entrepreneurs, and the programs and services of the Finance Authority of Maine. Through their determination and support, Maine has developed perhaps the best array of programs and services for financing fledgling technology-based businesses of any state in the nation Copyright  2003 Finance Authority of Maine. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form by any electronic or mechanical means without the prior written permission of the Finance Authority of Maine. Finance Authority of Maine, 5 Community Drive, P.O. Box 949, Augusta, ME 04332-0949 Tel: (207) 623-3263 or (800) 228-3734 TYY: (207) 626-2717 Web Site: April 2003 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE CHAPTER 1: CHAPTER 2: CHAPTER 3: CHAPTER 4: CHAPTER 5: CHAPTER 6: CHAPTER 7: APPENDIX A: APPENDIX B: INTRODUCTION .................................................................................. 1 WHAT VENTURE CAPITAL IS (AND IS NOT)...................................... 3 HOW VENTURE CAPITAL INVESTORS WORK ................................... 6 HOW TO APPROACH VENTURE......

Words: 19304 - Pages: 78

Premium Essay

Venture Capital

...e-Journal    VENTURE CAPITAL IN INDIA D. P. WARNE*; PINKI INSAN** *Chaudhary Devi Lal University, Sirsa, Haryana-125055. **Shah Satnam Ji P.G. Girls College, Sirsa, Haryana- 125055.  ABSTRACT India is the largest democracy on the planet and second most populous country in the world. Its extraordinary history is intimately tied to its geography. A meeting ground between the East and the West, it has been invader’s paradise. In the last one and half decades, India has proved itself as a destination for Information Technology (IT) and Business Process Outsourcing (BPO). India is also fast emerging as a major center for cutting-edge research and development (R&D) projects for global multinational companies. Lot of activities are happening in India in various sectors such as IT, BPO, Knowledge Process Outsourcing (KPO), Semiconductors, Biotechnology, Textiles, Manufacturing, and Engineering recently. This study is an attempt to explore the trends and developments in Venture Capital financing in India through an in‐depth analysis of these investments over the last 5 years (2005‐2009). INTRODUCTION The Venture capital sector is the most vibrant industry in the financial market today. Venture capital is money provided by professionals who invest alongside management in young, rapidly growing companies that have the potential to develop into significant economic contributors. Venture capital is an important source of equity for start-up companies. Venture capital can be......

Words: 4814 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Walnut Case

...Walnut Venture Associates RBS Group is a complete accounting application solution provider targeting its products to software companies. Their product, SOFTRAX, provides software companies with a full-package of solutions spanning in financials, sales & marketing, customer support and software operations. Robert O’Connor, RBS’s founder and CEO was seeking a $2 million second round venture capital financing to support their regional sales offices growth and recruit personnel in sales, implementation & customer support. Though RBS is still a young company, it indicates to position itself in a unique niche market within a solid market. They have seasoned management team and have allied with several key clients and partnerships. What’s more important, RBS had positive earnings since starting the business. Walnut Venture Associates, a group of Angel investors seeking early-stage type investment opportunities in the New England market, is among parties interested in providing capital to RBS. It is definitely a right decision for them to make investment in such promising company. However, this angel group has an investment policy capping the investment commitment ranging for $250 thousand to $1 million in a single round of financing. In addition, taken into consideration of RBS’ aggressive expansion risk, it is viable for Walnut to persuade management team in RBS Group to reduce financing amount to $1 million. Before investment, Ralph B. Wagner, the leader of this......

Words: 1056 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...Venture Capitalist ENGL106-Week 2 IP American Intercontinental University Kendrick Little April 22, 2012 Abstract This is a paper to define and explain what venture capitalism is as well as what venture capitalists do in their business. Venture Capitalist An venture capitalist a person who provides capital is for the financing of growing, a new upstarting or struggling businesses. Venture capitalists are the general partners in the venture capitalist process. The capital itself provides long term finances to help companies that are not as lucrative as other large companies and it just simply keeps the company from failing. Venture capital can primarily help with a lot of things such as buying out a company, save a struggling one, upstart a new or expand an existing one. The venture capitalist profit is dependent solely on the company they have invested in, if the company is showing good signs of turnaround or having a good amount of success then the venture capitalist has made a good investment and will benefit from the success financially. Venture capitalist usually works very closely with the partner in the venture capital firm which develops a partnership. The general partners of the company role serves as the managers of the firm and will also in some cases take on the role as advisor to the vc’s to which the funds are made. In the Unites States of America venture capital firms can be set up or structured as limitied liability companies, by doing so......

Words: 825 - Pages: 4

Days of Our Lives | 下载 APK | Mon.Oliwa Z Ol.Ex.V.Rozmaryn 250 Monini 250Ml 15 ,28 zł