Free Essay

What Matters More to My Kids’ Future:

In: Social Issues

Submitted By trelawney
Words 1280
Pages 6
What matters more to my kids’ future: Their school or quality time with their parents?

1] On countless mornings over the past year, I stood with my 3-year-old son, James, in our driveway, watching our next-door neighbor trudge off to fifth grade. As she’d disappear around the corner, I’d think ahead to the kind of school James might attend when he starts kindergarten in two years.

2] My wife and I are in our early 30s, living in Ann Arbor, Mich., where she is finishing her training as a demographer. Over the next year we’ll figure out where we’re going to live for the long haul. Where we choose will depend to some extent on the job market, but it will also depend heavily on where we want James and his brother, Oscar, 1, to go to school.

3] We can’t afford private-school tuition, so living in a city would probably mean chancing it on a subpar public school system. And although I loved growing up on the coast of Maine, the limits of my public high school education became clear when I got to college and immediately felt like I was behind. I would like my boys to be better prepared for college.

4] But if my wife and I wanted to do everything we could to give James and Oscar the best possible K-12 education, we’d have to make some big changes. We’d have to choose more lucrative careers than hers in academia and mine as a writer so we could afford urban private schools or a house in an affluent suburb where the public schools are better. But between the longer hours and the longer commutes such changes would entail, we’d see much less of our kids. James and Oscar might be in the best schools, but we’d rarely be home before bedtime to hear what they’d learned all day.

5] Would this trade-off be worth it? When I look at the research on child development, I think it might not. Where our kids go to kindergarten or high school might matter a lot less than most parents think.

6] Social scientists have long tried to determine why some children grow up to be successful adults and others don’t. The causes are hard to untangle. High school dropouts tend to attend underperforming public schools and to come from poor families with unmarried, undereducated parents. Ivy League graduates more often attend good K-12 schools and come from well-educated, affluent, two-parent families. Because these characteristics cluster together so frequently, it’s hard to determine which attributes drive success or failure — and which are just along for the ride.

7] In a 2001 study, Greg Duncan, now a professor of education at the University of California at Irvine, measured the impact that the people in a child’s life — siblings, neighbors, classmates, best friends — have on how well the child does in school. Duncan and his team found almost no relationship between how students did on the test and whom they sat beside in class, whom they hung out with after school and who lived on their block. The only meaningful link they found was between siblings, and identical twins in particular.

8] “Schools and neighborhoods might have some effect,” Duncan says, “but I think it’s pretty clear that a lot more of the action around child development takes place at home.”

What is it about home that matters?

9] For a long time, scholars and policymakers thought that a family’s income heavily affected how well kids did in life. This is why decades of federal welfare policy were based on transferring cash to poor parents. Data from “Expenditures on Children by Families,” an annual report by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, show that as families get richer, a lot of that extra money goes into their kids. Low-income and middle-income families spend similar amounts — about $9,000 and $13,000 per child, respectively, per year. But families making more than $100,000 spend about $22,000 per kid per year. (I assume most of the increase goes to private-school tuition.) Given that the children of higher-income families typically do better in school and earn more as adults, it would be reasonable to conclude that the more my wife and I spend on our kids, the brighter their futures will be.

10] But that might not be the case. When Susan Mayer at the University of Chicago looked at the relationship between family income and lifetime achievement, she saw that many of the character traits that allow some adults to make a lot of money — a strong work ethic, honesty, reliability, good health — also make them good parents. Mayer wondered whether it is those traits, rather than the money that results from them, that really counts.

11] That makes sense to me. It seems that my impact on my kids has much more to do with who I am and how much time I spend with them than how much I earn.

12] In an influential book, "What Money Can't Buy: Family Income and Children's Life Chances," Mayer put her hypothesis to the test. She ran a series of experiments that measured the relationship between family income and a range of life outcomes, such as a child's likelihood of dropping out of high school or getting pregnant as a teenager. In one study after another, she found that such outcomes weren't caused by income.

13] Mayer's study was based primarily on low-income families, but her results apply even more powerfully to middle- and high-income families. If money doesn't make a big difference in the lives of poor children, its impact is even smaller for kids who are already well provided for.

14] Mayer found that the things that make a difference are relatively inexpensive: the number of books a kid has or how often his family goes to museums. She argues that all the other stuff — summer camps, tutors, trips to Paris — are like upgrades on a Lexus. They're nice to have but immaterial when it comes to getting from one place to another.

15] If private tutors or the right address is unlikely to change a child’s life, the relationships kids have with their parents just might. This is the argument that University of Pennsylvania professor Annette Lareau advances in her groundbreaking ethnography “Unequal Childhoods: Class, Race, and Family Life.”

16] In the mid-1990s, Lareau began one of the most in-depth observations of American parenting ever conducted. She spent a month each with 12 families (six middle- and upper-middle-class and six poor or working-class) and observed how these parents interacted with their children. Lareau concluded that middle-class parents convey substantial advantages to their children in three ways: by cultivating their interests, enriching their thinking and speaking skills through informal conversations, and teaching them how to navigate institutions such as colleges and workplaces that serve as de facto gatekeepers for success in America. Success in those areas is much more related to the amount of time parents spend with their children than where they send them to school.

17] “I think it’s very reasonable for parents to choose to work less in order to have more face time with their children, even if that means their children attend a school where they’re not challenged as much as the parents might like,” Lareau told me. She added: “Many parents I interview are anxious about their children’s economic futures. But I think they have an exaggerated sense of the risks involved if they don’t give their children ‘the best’ of everything.”…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

What Leaded Me to My Future

...essay I will be discussing how the events in my life, made me to what I am today, and how It made me into becoming a successful student. Ever since I was a little girl, my grandfather has had severe heart problems. I remember seeing him in the hospital before his surgeries. After these surgeries I used to watch him and help take care of him at home, because he was in so much pain. I hated seeing him like this, and It made me wonder, "would I hate seeing anyone like this ? Around age twelve, I went to visit my grandparents for the summer, and I was outside with my grandfather one evening. Our neighbor stopped by my grandparents house to see me, since they knew I was up their to visit. She told my grandfather that I looked fairly sick and that I have lost a lot of weight. After a few days, I began feeling exhausted, irritated, thirsty, and frequent urination. My grandparents and mother took me to the hospital to get some blood work done because these symptoms were occurring for weeks. The results of the blood test returned, and they sent me off to a major hospital because they assumed I was diagnosed with diabetes. When I arrived to the hospital I remember being rushed into the ER because I almost passed out into a diabetic coma because my blood sugar was very high. A day later I woke up, and looked around and their were iv's all through my arm. I hated this feeling, and knew this was a disease that I was going to have for the rest of my life. But the nurses I had were......

Words: 707 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

My Future

...My Future Goals What are my future goals? Well, let me say that I am dreaming big. I do not wish to become the President or even a CEO of a big business. I just want to be able to make a difference in the life of another. I will be attending my college in the fall and studying to become a pharmacist. After three years there, I will transfer to the actual pharmacy school for another two years. There, I will complete my Pharm D degree, also known as a Doctorate of Pharmacy. I would like to start my career in a pharmacy getting to work with and talk to patients one on one. This will help me better understand how some diseases affect people and which diseases are top priorities to eliminate. It would also be very enjoyable to work with the pharmacy technicians as well. Eventually, I want to obtain a PhD in Pharmacy. By receiving my PhD, I am able to participate in lab research. It is a dream of mine to be able to partake in finding cures for diseases like AIDS and even cancers. I would love to travel the world and assist those in need and provide medicines for those whom cannot acquire it on their own. By being a recipient of this scholarship I am able to go to school for the necessary amount of years and achieve my goals in life. Not only would this award benefit my studies, but also those whom I hope to help in the future. Thank you for your time and considering me for this scholarship....

Words: 271 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

My Past vs My Future los angles, California and with only one older sibling and my mother we had a lot of hardships. We moved a lot, never stayed in one place for more than a few months, my mom and my brother would always get into fights, my dad was on drugs and my mom kept me home-schooled and sheltered, causing me not to have a social life, or have any kind of friends for that matter. I grew up in an environment where my mom did business a lot because she had her own business and even as I child I would have to help with the family business. I learned about business and technology at a young age along with business. I know so much about business now because of my mother. And yeah at the time it was beneficial but then as time went on I became further behind in learning because I was not in school and the tutors I had were not certified in teaching, they would just be people that we knew. So every year it would get harder and harder for us. It even seems like we became homeless more and more each year. I’ve slept so many places and have been evicted out of the nicest house to the most raggedy motels. My brother and I have such a big age difference, so because of that he was mostly never around, he is 11 older than I, but he was always there for me. Eventually, when we realized there was nothing left for us in California my mother and I just got in our car and left California never to return again. So now were on our way to Georgia. My mom promised we were going to go back to California, she......

Words: 620 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

My Hoarder Kid

...aren't exactly known for teaching their kids how to break a task into smaller, accomplishable pieces). That, plus my mother's voice in my head ("Everybody else knows how to do it. You're just really lazy") have made figuring out this home maintenance thing an uphill climb. Here's the thing, though. As my personal life completely imploded over the last year or so, I began to realize how much living in chaos affects my outlook and stress level. Even if I have a well-developed case of hoarder's child clutter blindness, at some level I do register the mess and feel stressed by it. And so, fifteen years after leaving my mother's home, I set about really figuring out how to address this issue once and for all. Here are some of the highlights of what I've learned. 1. Cut yourself some slack. As a culture, we view people who don't keep their houses clean in a truly negative light. I really struggled to let go of viewing my messiness as a deep, personal flaw. What worked for me was to take a deep breath and replace my mother's voice ("What's wrong with you?") with something I would say to a friend in the same situation (usually, "Do you realize how much you've already gotten done today? No wonder you're tired"). Repeat about a million times, and you'll be on your way. 2. Have less stuff. Some children of hoarders go the stark minimalist route. Some, like me, just struggle with having a bit too much clutter. I now keep a Goodwill bag in my closet. When I come across something......

Words: 914 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

What Matter to You?

...What Matters to you? Education is something that every person has a right towards. Standing up for these rights is a brave and courageous act to do. In every part of the world there are different educational rights for men and women. In mostly Asian countries, education is not a priority for women, even though women do want to have an education. But some women are actually strong enough to stand up for these rights. Malala Yousafzai is a Pakistani teenager who was brave enough to campaign for girls’ education when it was not allowed. Where she is from, the Taliban had banned girls from attending school. Her thoughts on education gave the idea that education is very powerful and that every girl has a right to it. With her father also being an education activist, she had the support she needed to keep on going on the path she had made. Yousafzai is one of the most popular teenagers we know today, and for such a great reason. Before she was shot by the Taliban for standing up for girls’ educational rights, she was also a blogger. She would blog on a BBC website about her life under the Taliban’s restrictions and orders. It was way to tell the world about the influence of the Taliban on their lives. In one of the blogs she reported that she was still studying for her annual exams but because of the ban for girls from school she was uncertain if she was even going to be able to take her exams and if all the studying she was doing was even worth it. These blogs were written......

Words: 655 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

My Veiled Future

...dreams since they were young. And they are sure that they want those dreams to be their future. However, some people find their dreams after they have grown up. Most of the teenagers are still having numerous dream jobs in their mind. Most of them not sure of what they want to be but they knew where they want to be. They want to live without worries , and live happily in the future. For me, as a 17-years-old student, my only aim for now is to pass my O'level with good grades so that i can get into the course that i want. Even though my mind has been wavering with a lot of thoughts and people's 'suggestion'. It is really hard for me to stick on one dream as i am easily influenced by other people. I wanted to be a business woman when i was young because i saw a movie about a successful business woman and i thought she was cool. After a while, i wanted to be an engineer like my father, a hotel owner after i visited to a grand hotel as i thought it would be awesome and a ballet dancer when i saw a Hong Kong movie about a beautiful ballet dancer. As i grew up i had more and more dreams. I wanted to be spy, detective, singer, and lastly architecture. And now i had realized, no matter how many dreams i had, there are some common factors about the dreams that i want. I wanted those career because i thought it would be cool, famous and mostly money. The fact that i like money does not change. My last dream was to be an architecture because i thought it is a respectable job and......

Words: 558 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

My Future

...SPEECH ABOUT “MY FUTURE” STUDENT NAME- becky MODULE TITLE- ACADEMIC WRITING MODULE CODE- PF013 WORD COUNT- 750-1000 THE SUBJECT OF MY SPEECH IS “MY FUTURE” Hello ladies and gentlemen. My name is Bukky Dada. I am a student of Greenwich School of Management, and I’m studying Business Management. I am honoured to stand here before you to give a short speech about “MY FUTURE”. I can recollect the day l received my letter of admission to Greenwich School of Management, l was so excited because l was one step closer to my dreams. I had worked with “Compass Group” for 6years as a chef, so l knew a lot about catering. Before coming to this country, back home in Nigeria l used to work in the hotel as an assistant manager. I have come up with three plans for my future, which is to own a big restaurant, give my children better a future, so it will be easier for them to concentrate more in school,( because without education, there is really no future for anyone) and lastly, set up an orphanage to help the poor in my country. My perfectly laid plan for myself is unavoidably. I had always wanted to be a business woman, own two to three big restaurants with lots of staff working for me, and being my own boss. This is something l had wanted since l was a child. I understand and believe that l have to upgrade myself to achieve some certain goals in life. Some of these goals are personal to me while the others are professional. Now l have come to a cross road in my......

Words: 822 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

What Excites Me About My Future in Technology

...Ibukunoluwa Sobayo Lee University April 10, 2015 What Excites Me About The Future Of Technology? It is not news that we are at the peak of technological advancements that will change our lives. Nothing has made more impact on how we live our lives today or carry the potential to so seriously improve the human condition, as the technologies each one of us now has at our disposal, and the wonders yet to come. The inter-connectedness we have, the vast amounts of information accessible to us in less than a minute, the way in which anyone with basic knowledge can communicate with their friends and family, or even the entire world is quite impressive. The ease and convenience with which we can access almost any resource on the internet using anything from a mere personal computer to a small smart device in the pocket is highly impressive. I am encouraged and grateful to be part of such a great global innovation. I truly believe that personal and individually accessible technologies, will become an important part of humanity’s next stage of growth in the general quality of life and even survival. There is such a great potential to empower any individual to interact with people all over the world – from family and friends to new people on the other side of the planet. Nothing the human race has seen to date has the potential to empower the individual to make as much of a difference, to make as much of a connection, to make as much of himself as the technologies we have now and......

Words: 636 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

My Future

...Title: Where do I see myself in 10 years. Where do I see myself in 10 years time? Well, I’m sure majority of the people would have already plan their future though some of them can be ignorant about this. Nevertheless, it is a noteworthy subject to talk on. According to my working plan in 10 years time, I would see myself as a senior software engineer working for IBM,Korea. I had planned that I would start off working internship for IBM,Malaysia. I will gain trust of company and join the business trip for extra experience. In a way I can also travel around the glob,well at least some parts of the world and learn about the culture there while working. Then, I would apply for transfer to IBM,Korea and work there permenantly. By the age of 25 or 26, I want to get married and have a dreamy honeymoon holiday in Sanctuary Villa, Parrot Cay, Turks and Caicos Island. This villa is one of the most private resorts where there is private beach and the best getaway that anyone can ever hope for. After a year later, I hope get a baby. I don’t mind the gender. Last but not least, I want to be able to create and master all potato recipies. It might sound absurd but potato is one of them main cooking ingrediant I want to work with. In conclusion, not everything goes according to plan but there’s no harm thinking of it right?...

Words: 253 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

My Future

...| Spending time visualizing one’s future is a powerful strategy for accomplishing our goals. As you begin creating your resume, think about where you are headed in your future healthcare career. In this week’s activity, you will have the opportunity to write a letter to your future self while envisioning what your future holds! | Background | Imagine yourself after graduation and upon landing your first job to launch your career as a healthcare professional. This letter will help you focus on who you want to become as you prepare your resume and put your very best foot forward. Use this opportunity to celebrate your successes and envision your future. Watch this video as you prepare your letter to your future self. | Part 1: Letter to My Future Self | Write a letter to your future self and include the following in 3 to 5 sentences for each section: * Introduction: Remind yourself why you started this journey * Paragraph 1: Celebrate your academic successes during your journey * Paragraph 2: Recall what you have accomplished personally throughout your journey * Paragraph 3: Share where you are in your career and the next steps on your journey * Conclusion: Close with some words of wisdom to yourself as you continue your journey | 7/1/2015Dear AngelicaAs I sit here and think to myself its been one lengthy journey these last couple of months. I’ve had my ups and downs and have struggled a bit to stay committed to my education but when I think......

Words: 516 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

My Future

...assistance to get me started with my education. Without a doubt, college preparation is new to me. So, there is a lot that I will have to learn. If I receive this $1,000 scholarship, it will be of immense help to me. I could use it towards my books for my classes and towards tuition. It would relieve some of the stress knowing I have gratefully been given $1,000 that is not coming out of my parent’s pockets. At a young age, I have always had a passion for animals. All I ever dreamed of was having a puppy to grow up with. By the time I reached high school, I had two English Springer Spaniels named Shayla and Shiloh. When I was younger, my mind was set on going to Auburn University to become a veterinarian because it was the only school I ever heard of. For as long as I could remember, that was all I inspired to be. But, as I got older, I realized I also loved being in the presence of kids. My career goal automatically changed into wanting to become a teacher. I had the desire to want to be an inspiration to the kids in my community and to be a factor for why they are successful in life. It would touch my heart if one of my students ever looked up to me and said “because of you, I didn’t give up”. Those are the moments that I would long for. The greatest gift of all will be watching my students thrive. By the time my sophomore year rolled around, I became more intrigued with kids. So, I decided to go into the Early Childhood Program that my school had to offer. I knew in......

Words: 710 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

To My Kids

...To my kids, Tomorrow is a big day. Fourth Grade, Middle School, and High School – wow! Kids-- When I was in third grade, there was a little boy in my class named Adam. Adam looked a little different and he wore funny clothes and sometimes he even smelled a little bit. Adam didn't smile. He hung his head low and he never looked at anyone at all. Adam never did his homework. I don't think his parents reminded him like yours do. The other kids teased Adam a lot. Whenever they did, his head hung lower and lower and lower. I never teased him, but I never told the other kids to stop, either. And I never talked to Adam, not once. I never invited him to sit next to me at lunch, or to play with me at recess. Instead, he sat and played by himself. He must have been very lonely. I still think about Adam every day. I wonder if Adam remembers me? Probably not. I bet if I'd asked him to play, just once, he'd still remember me. I think that God puts people in our lives as gifts to us. The children in your class this year, they are some of God's gifts to you. So please treat each one like a gift from God. Every single one. If you see a child being left out, or hurt, or teased, a part of your heart will hurt a little. Dink and I want you to trust that heartache. Your whole life, we want you to notice and trust your heartache. That heartache is called compassion, and it is God's signal to you to do something. It is God saying, Bethany, William, Brendan! Wake up! One of my babies is......

Words: 823 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Writing About What Matters

...Writing about What Matters Martin Luther King gave the “I Have A Dream…” speech where he proclaims that it is time to cash a check that has long been due to them. It is not money that is wanted it is a demand to have the riches of freedom and the security of justice. King brings up things that should no longer be satisfied by the colored population. By listing these things King brings out the faith in people to take action and make the changes that are needed. The ending of this speech brings the message of freedom for all not just blacks. President Obama spoke on the 50th anniversary of the March on Washington sharing how much King influenced the changes that were made following his speech. Obama spoke about how through all the hatred a nonviolent path was taken in order to get this freedom. Finding courage within others and ourselves is what leads us to be able to move forward and make a difference in the future. At the end of Obama’s speech he says that the promise of tomorrow comes from the lessons of the past. A country can only change its ways because of the love from the people. The dream has changed over the past 50 years to become something even bigger. There is so much more diversity in America today and more people share the same struggles. The vision changed to become more than just a fight for equality for blacks but for everyone who is struggling for the freedom to be themselves. These visions could not be added to or changed. They represent what two......

Words: 359 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

My Future Career

...My Future as an Attorney: Junior Project Demetria Jant English IV Ms. Hill May 9, 2016 My career was an important factor to me but to see if I had a compatible match with others careers I to a test to see. I took a test on O*NET and I turned out to I scored (27 in Artistic) ( 22 in Enterprising) (20 in Investigative). thus showing with Artistic that i'm more likely to work in a place where I’d be using my hands and imagination. For the enterprising showing that I’m capable Persuading and leading people. Making important life changing decisions and Taking risks for profits. My investigative skills were a few points less than my enterprising score, my ability to search for the truth solve some complex problems career field. The second test that was administered similar but different Enterprising was my highest score which was (12) which is in Enterprising my score in Realistic was (5), Investigative I scored an (4) my score for Artistic was a (6) but in Social I received a (9), for Conventional I received the lowest of many scored (4). The jobs that had came with theses positions were: Lawyer This job was my life......

Words: 1470 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

My Past, Present and Future

...My Past, Present, and Future I never thought I would be 42 years old and writing a paper like this one. I had planned to go to college right after high school, but life does not always happen according to plan. In this paper, I will present a brief description of a few of my life experiences that have helped shape the person I am today and analyze some of these experiences using the adult development theories from this class. I will also look ahead to the goals I want to accomplish in the future. I grew up in a military family. Both my dad and my mother had enlisted in the U.S. Air Force after they graduated from high school, and they met when they were stationed at the same air base. As mom tells it, my dad asked her out on a date several times, but she always refused because she thought he was a little wild. However, Mom was an early-morning person, and Dad was a night owl. One evening, my mother was assigned to work the graveyard shift on a security detail, and she had trouble staying awake. Dad did her a favor by working her shift for her, so she thought she at least owed him one date. The rest, as they say, is history. My earliest childhood memories were of growing up on Keesler Air Force Base in Biloxi, Mississippi, as the oldest of five children. As the family grew, my mother left the Air Force, but my father continued in military service. My siblings and I are all about two years apart in age, and my childhood was fairly ordinary until I was about ten years old,......

Words: 1798 - Pages: 8

Adriana Barraza | Eerst afgelopen | Stupeň 8: Armageddon (2013)